What are the barriers, facilitators and interventions targeting help-seeking behaviours for common mental health problems in adolescents? A systematic review
verfasst von:
Antonia Aguirre Velasco, Ignacio Silva Santa Cruz, Jo Billings, Magdalena Jimenez, Sarah Rowe
Increasing rates of mental health problems among adolescents are of concern. Teens who are most in need of mental health attention are reluctant to seek help. A better understanding of the help-seeking in this population is needed to overcome this gap.
Methods
Five databases were searched to identify the principal barriers, facilitators and interventions targeting help-seeking for common mental health problems in adolescents aged 10–19 years. The search was performed in June 2018 and updated in April 2019. Two independent screening processes were made using the eligibility criteria. Quality assessment of each study was performed, and findings summarised using a narrative synthesis.
Results
Ninety studies meet the inclusion criteria for this review for barrier and facilitators (n = 54) and interventions (n = 36). Stigma and negative beliefs towards mental health services and professionals were the most cited barriers. Facilitators included previous positive experience with health services and mental health literacy. Most interventions were based on psychoeducation, which focused on general mental health knowledge, suicide and self-harm, stigma and depression. Other types of interventions included the use of multimedia and online tools, peer training and outreach initiatives. Overall, the quality of studies was low to medium and there was no general agreement regarding help-seeking definition and measurements.
Conclusion
Most of the interventions took place in an educational setting however, it is important to consider adolescents outside the educational system. Encouraging help-seeking should come with the increased availability of mental health support for all adolescents in need, but this is still a major challenge for Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services. There is also a need to develop shared definitions, theoretical frameworks and higher methodological standards in research regarding help-seeking behaviours in adolescents. This will allow more consistency and generalisability of findings, improving the development of help-seeking interventions and ensuring timely access to mental health treatments.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Abkürzungen
MMAT
Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool
RCT
Randomised Controlled Trial
Background
Young people present with the highest prevalence of mental health disorders compared to individuals at any other stage of the lifecycle [1], with up to 20% of adolescents likely to experience mental health disorders [2]. Mental health has been defined as “a state of wellbeing in which and individual realizes of his/her abilities, can cope with normal stresses of life ( …) and is able to make a contribution to his/her community” [3]. Around 50% of mental health conditions start before the age of 14 [4] and the onset of 75% of cases is before the age of 18 [5]. The most common diagnoses are depression and anxiety [6] and around 25% of young people experience psychological distress [7]. Depression is one of the principal causes of illness and disability in teenagers, and suicide is the third most common cause of death among older adolescents [4]. Mental health problems can significantly affect the development of children and young people [4] having an enduring impact on their health and social functioning in adulthood [8]. Adolescents experiencing mental health conditions may face several challenges such as isolation, stigma, discrimination and difficulty in accessing health services [2]. However, 75% of adolescents with mental health problems are not in contact with mental health services [9], the primary reason being reluctance to seek help [1, 10, 11].
Help-seeking for mental health problems necessitates communicating the need for personal and psychological assistance to obtain advice and support. Rickwood and Thomas’ (2012) define help-seeking for mental health problems as “an adaptive coping process that is the attempt to obtain external assistance to deal with mental health concerns” [p.180, 12]. This includes both formal (e.g., health services) and informal (e.g., friends and family) sources of help. However, adolescents most in need of psychological help are those least likely to look for it [1‐13]. One of the biggest challenges in adolescent mental health is ensuring that at-risk individuals are linked with the appropriate support [14]. Understanding barriers and facilitators to help- seeking is fundamental for the development of interventions and programmes to support adolescents with mental health problems.
Anzeige
Rickwood et al., (2005), investigated the main barriers and facilitators of help-seeking for mental health problems in young people. They found that lack of emotional competence, negative beliefs about help-seeking and stigma were the most prominent barriers. Conversely, emotional competence, previous positive experiences with health professionals and mental health literacy, were the main facilitators [15]. Gulliver et al., (2010) performed a systematic review of the available literature at that time, finding similar results; however, they stated that stigma was the most prominent barrier for seeking for help in young people [1]. Another systematic review was made by Rowe et al., (2014), focused on in help-seeking for adolescent self-harm. They found that in addition to stigma, negative reactions from others related to confidentiality breaches and being seen as an “attention seeker” were the most relevant obstacles [10]. While interesting, these previous reviews do not address the help-seeking barriers and facilitators of most common mental health troubles among adolescents, nor include interventions targeting these. Rickwood, Deane et al., (2005) only included depressive symptoms, personal emotional problems and suicidal thoughts and Rowe et al. (2014), only focused on adolescent self-harm. The most complete review published by Gulliver and colleagues (2010) is almost 10 years old and need of updating.
Adequate and effective interventions that promote help-seeking are necessary for enhancing prevention, early detection, timely treatment and recovery from mental health problems [14]. Previous systematic reviews on interventions targeting help-seeking reveal some promising results in regard to enhancing mental health literacy [16] and a significant positive overall effect of these interventions in improving help-seeking for mental health problems [17]. Nonetheless, these reviews do not focus on adolescent populations and only one includes randomised controlled trials (RCT).
The primary aim of this review is therefore to provide an update of the literature on barriers and facilitators of adolescent mental health help-seeking including formal and informal sources of help, with the inclusion of interventions targeted at improving this. We will focus on common mental health problems, including depression, anxiety, suicidal thoughts, self-harm, emotional distress, among other personal-emotional symptoms. The secondary outcome is to examine any significant differences between age and sex. Understanding the difficulties around help-seeking behaviours and facilitating access to timely and effective treatment is essential for preventing the escalation of mental health problems among adolescents.
Methods
For the purpose of this review, help-seeking was defined as the action of actively searching for help for mental health problems, including informal (family, friends) or formal (GP, mental health professionals, etc.) sources, based on interpersonal and social abilities [11]. “Adolescents” were people aged 10 to 19 years, as defined by the World Health Organisation [4]. Despite the increasing debate regarding the age of adolescence [18], this definition was considered as appropriate for our study as it is accepted by international organisation such as OMS and UNICEF. Also, we considered this age range more homogenous and comparable in terms of lifecycle experiences and challenges that would be reflected in help-seeking behaviours and intentions. This review was prospectively registered on PROSPERO (CRD42018096917) and reported in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines [19]. The search terms were developed using the PICO structure, then expanded using MeSH terms and combined using Boolean operators. Four databases were selected including MEDLINE®, Embase, PsycINFO, and Web of Science, as well as the search engine Google scholar, identified as an optimal database combination [20]. Grey literature from the mentioned databases was also included and a search was carried in Open Grey. An initial version of the proposal for this study was reviewed by the McPin Foundation. The feedback was considered in the developmental stage, in order to evaluate the relevance and reception of the protocol by Patient and Public Involvement (PPI) organisations.
Anzeige
We included studies published in English, Spanish and French and focused on identifying barriers, facilitators and interventions targeting help-seeking behaviours for mental health problems in adolescents, specifically depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, emotional distress and general symptoms of mental illness. Other mental health problems such as psychosis, anorexia, among others were excluded, because we decided to focus on most prevalent mental health problems which share a more similar help-seeking process. Regarding barriers and facilitators, we included studies published after 2010 since a previous systematic review on the topic was published then [1]. We did not include any limit regarding year of publication for help-seeking interventions. All study designs were considered, including feasibility studies and study protocols. We excluded studies that referred to young people over the age of 19 or children under 10 years old. When study populations included adolescents outside of the established age range, the paper was included if over 50% of the individuals in the sample were within the 10–19 years category or if separate outcome data was provided for the participants in this age range. Studies meeting the inclusion criteria and including parents in their sample were also considered. Finally, other exclusion criteria were articles written in other languages, or if the intervention did not explicitly target help-seeking behaviours or was not related to mental health conditions (Appendix S1) (Table 1).
Table 1
Inclusion/Exlusion criteria
Inclusion
Exclusion
- Focused on help-seeking barriers, facilitators and interventions
- Includes formal and informal sources of help
- Help-seeking for depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, emotional distress
- Age range: 10 to 19 years
- Studies published in English Spanish and French
- All study designs
- Not focused on help-seeking for mental health problems
- Help-seeking for anorexia, schizophrenia and other mental health problems not described in the inclusion criteria
- Participants above or over 10 to 19 years age range
- Published in other languages
- Published before 2010 if referring to help-seeking barriers and facilitators
The search was performed in June 2018 and updated in April 2019. The results were exported to EndNote X8 and duplicates were removed. Titles and abstracts were screened by one author (AA) at the first stage. At a second stage, two authors (AA and IS) checked the full articles using the pre-determined inclusion and exclusion criteria. A third member of the research team (MJ) was available to solve discrepancies. Disagreement on 12 studies was attributed mainly to differences concerning the definition and measurement of help-seeking and was resolved in a discussion with a third author (MJ) not involved in the process of screening. Authors were contacted when relevant information was missing or when we could not find the articles retrieved by the databases. Reference list of all included studies were screened in case we found other studies relevant to our review. Data were extracted using a predefined form, which allowed the research team to identify the main characteristics of each study. This process was executed by one author (AA) after a complete review of the included papers. For the first question, data extraction focused on identifying barriers and facilitators and for the second question, intervention and effect size when reported. We created an additional form to extract data regarding the secondary outcome (age and sex). For the quality assessment, we used the Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal Checklist [21] and the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) [22], which were appropriate due to the variety of study designs included in this review; both have been previously validated [23, 24]. The Joanna Briggs tool has a number of checklists to evaluate the main features of each study design. We used the checklist for cross-sectional studies, RCT, quasi-experimental studies and qualitative studies. Each checklist had a number of items to evaluate the most relevant aspect of the specific design (e.g: for RCT was allocation to treatment groups concealed? Were treatment groups similar at the baseline?). After completing the checklist an overall quality appraisal score was calculated to provide a measure (low, medium and high) of the quality of each study. The MMAT included a similar checklist but is specific to mixed method study reviews. Overall study quality was not used as an exclusion criterion because we opted to be overly inclusive and provide a thorough overview of help-seeking in adolescents. Results have been summarised using a narrative synthesis. We identified the most relevant features regarding help-seeking barriers, facilitators and interventions in our data. These features were grouped into themes that capture the essential aspects regarding the main outcome of this review. With this information we developed a preliminary synthesis of the results organizing the themes so that patterns regarding the main barriers, facilitators and interventions were identified. Finally, we explored previous evidence on the topic and explore the relationship between the included studies. This allowed us to explore the influence of heterogeneity and the robustness of the preliminary synthesis [25]. Due to the heterogeneous nature of the studies included, a meta-analysis was not conducted. The quality of each study was not used as an exclusion criterion or impacted the weight given to each study in the narrative synthesis. This over-inclusive criteria allowed us to have an overall picture not only regarding help-seeking barriers, facilitators and interventions, but also the methodological quality of the available evidence.
Results
Two independent searches were carried out during June 2018 and then updated in April 2019. A total of 90 studies were included in this review, combining both barriers and facilitators (n = 54) and the intervention (n = 36) questions. PRISMA diagrams displaying the number of papers retrieved and the process of selection of the included studies is available in Figs. 1 and 2. Regarding the inter-rater reliability for this review, the agreement between the researchers screening the papers was high, with a 85% accuracy and 95% precision (Kappa = 0.954). Adolescents identified a range of formal and informal help-seeking options across studies, such as GPS, psychologists, psychiatrists, teachers, social workers (formal), and friends, family, sporting coaches, and online communities (informal). Regarding question 1, most of studies focused on identifying barriers and facilitators towards formal sources of help, whereas intervention studies had a wider variety of sources of help, depending on help-seeking behavior attempted to promote.
Fig. 1
Prisma 2009 Flow Diagram. Question 1: Help-seeking barriers and facilitators
Fig. 2
Prisma 2009 Flow Diagram. Question 2: Help seeking interventions
×
×
Question 1: help-seeking barriers and facilitators
Fifty-four studies that reported barriers and/or facilitators including a total of 56,821 participants were considered in the narrative synthesis (Table 2). Most of the studies (n = 18) were conducted in Australia, followed by the United States (n = 12) and the United Kingdom (n = 5). The majority of the studies were cross sectional (n = 36) [26‐61], thirteen studies were qualitative [62‐74] and six used a mixed-method design [75‐80]. Three PhD dissertations and one conference abstract were included in the grey literature. The age ranged from 8 to 26 years old. Three articles included adolescents and their parents, while one article included just adolescents’ mothers.
Table 2
Barriers and facilitators
1st author, year, country
Study design
Sample size
(n=)
Age and setting
Barriers
Facilitators
Quality
Bates, 2012, Canada
Cross sectional survey
n = 193 students
110 parents
11 to 15 years old high school students
Students: “nothing will help”, stigma, self-sufficiency, fear of coercion.
Parents: fear of coercion, money constraints, self-sufficiency, perceived impact of adolescent problems and not understanding the child problem.
Both: Prior professional help-seeking
Medium
Boyd, 2011, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 201
11 to 18 years old students in rural high school
Perceived limited service availability, social proximity and gossip, travel and cost of service, limited knowledge of sources of help, fears confidentiality
Not assessed
Medium
Buttigieg, 2016, Malta
Mixed Methods
n = 494
14–15-year-old high school students
Need for autonomy, embarrassment, poor mental health literacy, stigma, higher levels of depressive symptoms
Not assessed
Low
Charman, 2010, Australia
Qualitative
n = 20
16–26 (mean 17.7 years) members of community groups
Confidentiality concerns and stigma
Not assessed
Medium
Chen, 2017, Malasya
Cross sectional
n = 277
13–20-year-old high school students
Stigma, fear, lack of courage, doubt about counsellor competency
Not assessed
Medium
Cheng, 2013, United Kingdom
Cross sectional
n = 67
Parents of Chinese students in language school living in England.
Knowledge about help-seeking, language barriers
Not assessed
Low
Cramer, 2017, United States
Cross sectional
n = 396
14–17-year-old high school students
Stigma, higher levels of emotional difficulties, personnel and service availability
Prior help-seeking behaviours
Medium
Curtis, 2010, New Zealand
Mixed Methods
n = 1896
18–24 years old (60.2% under 20) university students
Stigma and a perceived need for self-reliance
Not assessed
Low
Czyz, 2013, United States
Cross sectional
n = 157
18–22-year-old (77.1% under 20) college students at elevated suicide risk
Perception that treatment is no needed, lack of time, self-management and stigma
Not assessed
Low
Dardas, 2017, Jordania
Cross sectional
N = 2349
12–17 year-old high school students
Higher depressive symptoms, higher levels of stigma
Not assessed
Medium
De Anstiss, 2010, Australia
Qualitative
n = 85
13–17 years old, refugee adolescents living in Australia
Low priority of mental health, poor mental health literacy, distrust in services, stigma associated with psychological problems and help-seeking
Not assessed
Medium
Doyle, 2017, Ireland
Mixed methods
n = 856
15–17-year-old students in post-primary school
Dislike of dual role of counsellor/teacher, confidentiality concerns.
Not assessed
Medium
Fukuda, 2016, Brazil
Cross sectional
n = 1030
8–21-year-old school students receiving mental health treatment
Fear of stigmatisation and problem denial
Not assessed
Low
Flink, 2013a, The Netherlands
Qualitative
n = 41
Mother of teen daughters (aged 12–20) from different ethnic backgrounds
Negative attitudes to GP, inaccessible mental health services, denial by daughters.
Minority ethnic groups: fear of negative judgements and gossiping.
Good and trustful bond with daughters, good contact with school
Medium
Flink, 2013b, The Netherlands
Qualitative
n = 50
12–20-year-old female adolescents from different ethnic backgrounds
Negative attitudes towards health professionals and school services.
Minority groups: fear to parental and fear reactions
Not assessed
Medium
Gonzlaves, 2012, Portugal
Qualitative
n = 39
12–17 years old immigrant attending to school, parents, teachers and health professional.
Adolescents: reliance on self-support, shyness, fear and language gap
Family: fees, language, legal issues
Professionals: non-recognition of the problem
All: stigma
All: strong link with community, mainly teachers and health professionals
Medium
Gulliver, 2012, Australia
Qualitative
n = 15
16–23-year-old elite athletes (66.7% aged under 19).
Stigma, lack of mental health literacy, negative past experiences of help-seeking
Encouragement from others, stablished relationship with provider, previous positive experiences with mental health services, positive attitudes of others, access to internet.
Medium
Haavik, 2017, Norway
Cross sectional
n = 1249
Adolescents from Norwegian upper schools (mean = 17.6)
Mental health literacy, delay in making contact, stigma.
Increased mental health literacy, awareness of service availability
Medium
Hasset, 2017, United Kingdom
Qualitative
n = 8
16–18-year-old males who entered CAMHS following self-harm or suicidal ideation and where engaged in therapy
14 to 16 years old high school students from rural and metropolitan towns
Personal factors related with communication with mental health professionals, problem recognition, shame, confidentiality breach. Logistical factors (transport, money, travel distances, etc.).
Not assessed
Low
Ijadi-Maghsoodi, 2018, United States
Qualitative
N = 76
11–18 years old school students
Embarrassment, fear of judgement, confidentiality, mental health literacy
17–21 years old student (53,8% aged 17–18) undergoing a preventive medical visit at University centre
Confidentiality, embarrassment, doubt about the professionals’ ability to act, knowledge of services, and logistical factors (money, transport, contact).
Not assessed
Low
Labouliere, 2015, United States
Cross sectional
n = 2145
14–18-year-old high school students
Extreme self-reliance
Not assessed
Low
Linsdey, 2010, United States
Mixed-method
n = 69
13 to 18 years old African American boys with high levels of depressive symptoms
Shame and distrust of mental health professionals
Not assessed
Medium
Lubman, 2017, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 2456
14–15-year-old high school students
Self-reliance, embarrassment, time and money
Not assessed
Medium
Lynn, 2014, United Kingdom
Cross sectional
n = 175 adolescents
n = 95 parents
14–18-year-old adolescent
Adolescents: desire of being independent, reduced mental health literacy in parents.
Adolescents: Higher perception of problem severityBoth: prior professional help-seeking.
Low
Maioulo, 2019, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 1582
16–18 years high school students
Not assessed
Positive parenting
Medium
Mariu, 2012, New Zealand
Cross sectional
n = 9699
12–18 years old secondary students (years 9 and 10).
Not assessed
Living with a single parent, living in an over-crowed house, being well known by a teacher
Medium
Maritnez-Hernaes, 2014, Spain
Cross sectional
n = 105
17–21 year old (84.3% aged under 19) participating in longitudinal survey
Normalisation of problem, stigma, reliance on self, beliefs of no need of professional help
Positive perception of mental health professionals
Medium
McLean, 2013, United Kingdom
Qualitative
n = 90
10–15-year-old secondary school students
Stigma
Not assessed
Medium
Murry, 2011, United States
Mixed Methods
n = 163
African American mothers of adolescents (mean = 14) living in rural Georgia
Community stigma towards family, cultural mistrust, cost
Welcoming environment of mental health services
Medium
Nearchou, 2018, Ireland
Cross sectional
N = 722
12–16 years old school student
Perceived public stigma
Not assessed
Medium
O’Connor, 2014, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 180
17–25-year-old (74.16% aged 18–19) college students
Not assessed
Extraversion, increased perceived benefits of help-seek, low social support and high perceived benefit
Low
Pisani, 2012, United States
Cross sectional
n = 2737
14–17 years old high school students in rural communities
Not assessed
Positive attitudes about help-seeking, perceptions responsiveness from adults, school support
Medium
Recto, 2018, United States
Qualitative
n = 20
15–19 years adolescents with perinatal depression
Fear of judgement, normalisation of symptoms, lack of trust
Not assessed
Medium
Rughani, 2011, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 778
13–18 years old high school students (years 9 to 12) in rural towns
Mistrust and do not believe professional help is beneficial
Perceived benefits of mental health treatments
Medium
Samuel, 2014, United States
Qualitative
n = 54
15–17-year-old African American males who received mental health treatment services after detention
Stigma, ineffective treatment, fear and shame from peers, mistrust of mental health providers
Not assessed
Medium
Sawyer, 2011, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 5362
12–14 years old school students
Higher depressive symptoms
None found
Medium
Seamark, 2018, United Kingdom
Qualitative
n = 6
17–18-year-old college psychology students
Gender roles, cultural expectations, lack of awareness of sources of help, fear of stigma and rejection
Not assessed
High
Sharma, 2017, India
Cross sectional
n = 354
13–17-year-old school students
Feeling ashamed, uncomfortable
Not assessed
Low
Shechtman, 2018, Israel
Cross sectional
n = 238
14–18-year-old school students
Self-stigma
Not assessed
Low
Sylwestrzak, 2015, United States
Cross sectional
n = 10,123
13–18-year-old adolescents
Self-reliance, mental health literacy, fear of stigma, usefulness of treatment
Not assessed
Low
Tharaldsen, 2017, Norway
Qualitative
n = 8
17–18-year-old students
Limited knowledge, stigma
Not assessed
Medium
Thomas, 2013, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 289
18–25-year-old (59.9% aged 18–19) students enrolled in first year psychology classes
Not assessed
Good symptom recognition, identification of benefits of professional help, openness to treatment for emotional problems
Medium
Wang, 2018, United States
Mixed methods
n = 19
Asian immigrants parents
Mental health literacy, structural barriers, cultural barriers (stigma, lack of cultural sensitivity of services)
Not assessed
Medium
Watsford, 2014, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 102
12–18-year-old presenting mild to moderate mental health concerns
Not assessed
Previous experience in mental health services
Medium
Wilson, 2010a, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 109
18–25 years old (78% age 18–19) college students*
Higher levels of psychological distress, negative beliefs about treatment
Not assessed
Medium
Wilson, 2010b, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 302
18–25 years old (78% age 18–19) university students*
Higher level of suicidal ideation and higher depressive symptoms
Not assessed
Medium
Wilson, 2010c, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 590
13–18 years old high school students
Higher levels of suicidal ideation and general psychological distress.
Not assessed
Medium
Wilson, 2011, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 562
18–25 years old (87,7% aged 17–21) students
Need for autonomy and independence
Not assessed
Medium
Wilson, 2012, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 1037
13–21-year-old adolescents (79% under 19)
Need for autonomy
Helpfulness of prior mental health care
Low
Yap, 2011, Australia
Cross sectional
n = 3746 teens
n = 2005 parents
12–25 years old student (separated data)
Stigma and beliefs about helpfulness of mental health care
Not assessed
Low
Yoshioika, 2015, Japan
Cross sectional
n = 311
15–19 high school students
Concerns about what other people may think
Not assessed
Low
Zhao, 2015, Canada
Cross sectional
N = 115
15–16-year-old students
Not assessed
Secure attachment style, strong relation with peers
Medium
The majority of studies were conducted in educational settings, such as schools (n = 24) and tertiary education (n = 11) focusing in non-clinical samples. Sixteen studies included participants from other community settings and two studies were conducted in mental health care facilities. Among the studies that include actual help-seekers (n = 7), the most common reason for seeking help was suicidal ideation, self-harm, depressive symptoms, and general mental health concerns (e.g., anxiety/nervousness/fear). Therefore, the conclusions drawn by the majority of the articles were based on help-seeking intentions rather than actual behaviours, since the participants were not experiencing mental health problems and focused on hypothetical scenarios.
Help-seeking barriers
Stigma
Stigma is defined as the fear of being socially sanctioned or disgraced leading to hiding or preventing certain actions or behaviours, including the misreporting of mental health problems [81]. More than half of the included studies (n = 30) made reference to this and other negative attitudes towards mental health problems as the main obstacle to help-seeking behaviours in adolescents. Of these, twenty-five studies referred to stigma as the primary obstacle, describing it through different concepts such as, “stigma”, “fear of stigmatisation”, “community stigma”, “perceived stigma” and “self-stigma”. Other negative attitudes towards mental health problems included shame, fear, and embarrassment.
Family beliefs
The second most mentioned barrier was associated to adolescents’ family beliefs toward mental health services and treatment (n = 15). Barriers related to problem with communication and distrust towards health professionals, negative past experiences with mental health services, and believing that the treatment is not going to be helpful. This was especially true for studies including immigrant and refugee populations, which referred to cultural barriers including mistrust of mental health diagnosis and practitioners, and lack of cultural sensitivity in services as a significant barrier.
Mental health literacy
Mental health literacy refers to the ability to use mental health information to recognise, manage and prevent mental health disorders and make informed decisions about help-seeking and professional support [82]. Almost one-third of the articles (n = 14) referred to problems related to mental health literacy as a significant barrier including poor recognition of mental health conditions (self and others) and lack of awareness of available sources of help.
Autonomy
Adolescents’ attitudes towards help-seeking revealed a perceived need of self-sufficiency and autonomy which were recognised as a relevant barrier in twelve studies, as well as fears of confidentiality breaches.
Other help-seeking barriers
To a lesser extent, problems regarding service and personnel availability and other structural factors (such as cost, transportation and waiting times) were mentioned as obstacles to help-seeking (n = 8). This was a significant barrier for studies including rural and immigrant populations, and in studies that included parents in their sample. Six studies focused on the relationship between symptomatology and help-seeking. These found that higher levels of psychological distress, suicidal ideation and depressive symptoms were linked to lower help-seeking behaviours.
Help-seeking facilitators
Of the 56 included studies, 19 also referred to facilitators of help-seeking behaviours. Mental health literacy and prior mental health care were the most cited facilitators for help-seeking for mental health problems (n = 10). Specifically, timely access to mental health was facilitated by having a previous positive experience with mental health services or help-seeking, being familiar with the sources of help, and good symptom and problem recognition. Higher engagement with the community and having a trusting and committed relationship with relevant adults such as parents, schoolteachers and counsellors also facilitated seeking help among adolescents. Further details of the included articles are available in Table 2.
Secondary outcomes
Few studies identified a significant difference when comparing younger and older adolescents in relation to barriers and facilitators to help-seeking, with no conclusive findings being reached. Some findings suggested that older adolescents tended to establish to feel more comfortable with people with mental health issues [83] and had less help-seeking fears [40]. In contrast, younger adolescents had greater knowledge about professional sources of help [34]. Only one study found a significant difference between ages regarding help-seeking, with younger adolescents reporting higher intentions of seeking help [60].
Twenty-four studies examined possible gender differences in help-seeking barriers and facilitators. Seven studies did not find significant differences between genders [28, 39, 40, 42, 46, 51, 69]. One study reported higher help-seeking intentions in males experiencing suicidal intentions [60] and two studies found that females perceived more overall barriers [26‐58]. However, this may be related to higher rates of females seeking help for mental health problems compared to males [31, 33, 37, 42, 48, 53, 58, 61, 76]. Studies reviewed did not evidence convincing differences between gender in relation to help-seeking.
Anzeige
Question 2: help-seeking interventions
Thirty-six studies on interventions targeting help-seeking behaviour, including a total of 28,608 participants, were summarised in the review (Table 3). Most of intervention studies were conducted in Australia (14) and the United States (14), followed by Canada (4) and United Kingdom (3). All studies were conducted in educational setting including high school (n = 35) and college (n = 1). The majority of studies developed interventions for non-clinical samples, and their focus was the prevention of mental health problems and the promotion of healthy coping strategies via help-seeking behaviours. Outcomes varied between help-seeking intentions, attitudes and behaviours. Almost half of the studies focused on the effectiveness of the interventions, while sixteen were feasibility or pilot trials and study protocols. Most of the studies used a quasi-experimental design (n = 21) followed by randomised controlled trials (n = 15). The age of participants ranged from 11 to 19 years old, although one study that included participants under 29 years old was incorporated as more than half of the sample were adolescents. Interventions were delivered using four main methods: psychoeducation, outreach interventions, multimedia tools and peer leader training.
Table 3
Help-seeking interventions
1st Author, year, country
Sample size
Inclusion criteria
Design
Setting and intervention
Comparison group
Primary outcome
Measures
Results and effect size
Quality
Psychoeducation-mental health
Berridge, 2011, Australia
182
10th grade students (aged 14–16)
Post-test design
Feasibility trial
MAKINGthe LINK. School-based. Five
class room activities provided by teachers who received specialised training.
No control group
Acceptability and feasibility of the programme
A 16-item programme
satisfaction survey.
-Not relevant
n/a1
Casañas, 2019, Spain
.
13–14 year old high school student
Clustered RCT2. Study protocol
EspaiJOVE, 14 h of psychoeducation and activities with the scholar community.
Waiting list
Help seeking behaviours
General Help-Seeking Questionnaire
(GHSQ)
-Not relevant
n/a
Lubman, 2016, Australia
–
year-9 students (aged 14–15)
Cluster RCT
Study protocol
MAKINGthe LINK. Five class room activities provided by teachers who received a training.
Waiting list
Help seeking behaviours
General
Help Seeking Questionnaire (GSHQ-V)
-Not assessed
n/a
Perry, 2014, Australia
208
9th or 10th grade students (aged 13–16)
Cluster RCT.
Feasibility trial
HeadStrong, school based intervention with educational practical modules during 5 to 8 weeks.
Regular Health and Physical Education classes
Attitudes towards help-seeking
Inventory of Attitudes towards Seeking Mental Health Services (IASMHS)
-Not relevant
Medium
Sharpe, 2016, United Kingdom
6551
Year 7 school student (aged 11–12)
Hierarchical cluster RCT.
Student booklet designed fomenting help-seeking and self-management support.
Waiting list
Help-seeking behaviour
Four-point scale developed by authors
There was no difference in help-seeking behaviour
Odds ratio (95% C.I)
1.01 (0.95–1.07)
Medium
Psychoeducation-depression
Joyce, 2011, Australia
32
Secondary students (aged 14–16)
Post-intervention design.
Pilot study
School based. Information sheet based on evolutionary perspective
Informative sheet about depression
Piloting the sheet.
Linkert scale (5 points)
-Not relevant
n/a
King, 2011, United States.
416
9th to 12th grade high school students
Quasi experimental design
Surviving the Teens is school based programme. Four 50 min session focused on psychoeducation.
No control group
Help seeking attitudes and behaviour
Instrument developed for the study evaluating self-efficacy and help-seeking behaviours.
Increased help-seeking behaviours after intervention and maintained in follow-up (3 months).
(t = 4.634/ p < .001)
Medium
Robinson, 2010, Australia
246
Boys school students
(aged 14–16)
Pre-test, post-test design
School-based developed in one-off, 2-h workshop
focused on depression definition, coping skills and help-seeking.
Waiting list
Help-seeking behaviours
Evaluation of Mental Health First Aid training
Intervention group was more likely to seek for help Adjusted odds
ratio (95% C.I.)=
3.48 (1.93, 6.29)
p < 0.0001
Medium
Ruble, 2013, United States
593
High school students
Pre-test and post-test design
School-based, 3 h curriculum designed to educate students, teachers, and parents about depression and help-seeking.
School based, interactive presentation by former mental health patients.
No intervention
Help-seeking intentions
General Intentions to Seek Help Questionnaire
Significant effect of the intervention Wilks’ Λ = .942
F (4,417) = 6.428p < 0.001
Medium
Saporito, 2013, United States
156
Adolescents from Public High School
RCT.
School based
Interactive 1 h session, providing basic mental health and video with case example.
Educational presentation with content
unrelated to mental health.
Reduction of
Stigma towards help-seeking
Short for of
Attitudes toward Seeking Professional Psychological Help (ATSPPH)
Increased willingness to seek for help in students with past treatment history F(1, 146) =6.64, p = .01ηp2 = .04
Medium
12. Yang, 2018, United States
14
High school students “at risk” of mental health conditions.
Quasi-experimental
Pilot study
InSciEd-oOut. School based, 20-day anti-stigma classroom activities
No control group
Help-seeking behavioural intentions
General Help-Seeking Questionnaire Vignette Version.
Not assessed
n/a
30. Young, 2013, Canada
254
High school students (aged 14–18)
Pre and Post intervention survey design
School based, combining classroom sessions and talk with person with schizophrenia
No control group
Self-stigma in help-seeking
Self-Stigma of Seeking Help scale
Significant reduction in self-stigma to seeking help after the intervention (p < 0.05)
Medium
Psychoeducation- suicide + self-harm
Aseltine, 2004, United States
2100
Students
in high schools
Cluster RCT
SOS programme, school based interactive intervention based on teaching materials and discussion guide, plus a screening instrument.
Health and social studies classes
Help-seeking behaviour
Questionnaire developed by the authors
Not significant effect of the program in help-seeking β = 0.255
p > 0.05
Medium
Aseltine, 2007, United States
3837
Students
in high schools in Hartford and
in Columbus.
Cluster RCT
SOS programme, school based interactive intervention based on teaching materials and discussion guide, plus a screening instrument.
Health and social studies classes
Help-seeking behaviour
Questionnaire developed by the authors
Not significant effect of the program in help-seeking β = −0.01
p > 0.05
Medium
Freedenthal, 2010, United States.
142 staff
146 student
Staff and students in High school in Denver area.
Pre and Post intervention survey
Pilot study
Yellow-ribbon. School based, 25 min training, card with hotline numbers and t-shirt with mental health messages.
No intervention
Help seeking behaviours
Self-reported survey developed by authors
Not relevant
n/a
Kalafat, 1994, United States
253
10th grade high school students
Solomon four-group design
School based suicide awareness program. 3 psychoeducation sessions.
Physical education classes
Help seeking attitudes
Likert scale developed by the authors.
Significant effect of the intervention F (14,225) =1.87
p < .03
Medium
Schimidt, 2015, United States
5949
High school students (aged 10–18)
Pre and Post intervention design.
Feasibility trial
Yellow-ribbon. School based, 25 min training, card with hotline numbers and t-shirt with mental health messages.
No control group
Help Seeking
9 item scale developed for the study
-Not relevant
n/a
Outreach interventions
Deane, 2007, Australia
506
9th and 10th grade high school students
Post-test design
The Building Bridges to General Practice, school based. GP deliver one session to improve students perception.
No intervention
Help seeking intentions
Adapted version from the General Help Seeking Questionnaire (GHSQ)
Increased help-seeking intentions at follow-up F(2,217) = 3.04/ p < 0.05.
Medium
Rughani, 2011, Australia
260
Year 11 high school students
RCT
Promoting Access to support seeking. School based, two 50 min sessions for building relationships with mental health professionals.
Alternative presentation
Help-seeking intentions
Items adapted from the General Help-Seeking questionnaire (GHSQ)
Short term improvement of help-seeking intentions
F (14,225) =1.87
p < .03
Medium
Wilson, 2008, Australia
291
Year 11 students from 3 high schools in New South Wales
Quasi-experimental
Nested design
The Building Bridges to General Practice, school based. GP deliver one session to improve students perception.
No intervention (year 10 students)
Help-seeking intentions
General Help Seeking Questionnaire
(GHSQ)
Increased help-seeking intentions for psychological problems after the intervention F(2,598) = 4.31p < 0.01
High
Multimedia/Online interventions
Conrad, 2014, Germany
532
High school Students without history of mental health care
Quasi-experimental
Film festival aiming to give a podium to the topic mental health.
No control group
Help seeking attitudes
Seven items Linkert scale developed by authors
Not significant change in help-seeking
t = 0.414
Medium
Nicholas, 2004, Australia
243
High school students aged 13 to 18.
Post-test design
Feasibility trial
School based, classroom presentations of ReachOUT! Website.
No control group
Help-seeking behavioursintentions and the use if the website.
Questionnaire developed by authors
Not relevant
n/a
Rowe, 2018, United Kingdom
23
Teens (aged 12–18) who had self-armed (last 12 months) and basic English speaker.
Two group parallel arm, single blind RCT.Feasibility trial.
My self-help tool. School based, web-personalised decision aid intervention designed to help identify help-seeking alternatives for self-harm.
General information
about mood and feelings.
Help seeking intentions
General Help-Seeking Questionnaire (GHSQ).
Not relevant
n/a
Santor, 2007a, Canada
388
Grade 8th high school students
Pre-post test design
School based help seeking workshop + Information website called “YooMagazine”
No intervention
Help-seeking attitudes
The Help Seeking Attitude Questionnaire
Positive effect of the intervention
β = 0.108, F(1,1037) = 3.85 p < 0.04.
Medium
Santor, 2007b, Canada
455
Grade 7th to 12th students
Pre and Post intervention survey design
Feasibility trial
Information website called “YooMagazine”
No control group
Help-seeking behaviours
Help-seeking indicators (e.g: visits to school
mental health)
Not relevant
n/a
Wiljer, 2016, Canada.
–
Youth (16–29) college students
Two arm RCT.Study protocol
Thought Spot. College based, web and mobile platform
Usual care
Self-efficacy for mental health
help-seeking
General Help-Seeking Questionnaire
(GHSQ)
Not assessed
n/a
Peer leader training interventions
Calear, 2016, Australia
–
7 to 10 grade students (aged 12–15)
Two arm cluster RCT.
Study protocol
The sources of Strength. School based, during 1 year (approx.) includes staff and peer leaders training and school messaging.
Waiting list (24 months).
Help seeking intentions
An adapted version of General Help -Seeking Questionnaire(GHSQ)
Not relevant
n/a
O’reilly, 2016, Ireland
30
Teens aged 15–17 with interest in mental health, speaking skills.
Pre and Post intervention survey design
Feasibility trial
School based, four 3 h workshop training peer leaders.
No control group
Stigma for help-seeking behaviours
Perception of Stigmatisation by Others FOR Seeking Help Scale (PSOSH)
Not relevant
n/a
Parihk, 2018, United States
878
High school students
Quasi-experiment
P2P. School based, peer leaders develop a school public awareness campaign
No control group
Help seeking intentions
Adapted version of the P2P Depression Awareness
Questionnaire
78% of students will seek for help after the intervention p < 0.001
Medium
Wyman, 2010, United States
2675
High school students (aged 14 to 18)
RCT.
The sources of Strength. School based, during 1 year (approx.) includes staff and peer leaders training and school awareness campaign.
Waiting list
Acceptability of seeking help
Help Seeking from Adults scale created by authors
Positive effects on help-seeking from adults
Mean differences (95%CI)
=0.58 (0.24, 0.91).
p = 0.04
Medium
1 n/a: Not applicable
Types of intervention
Psychoeducation
Most of studies (n = 23) used psychoeducation and classroom-based interventions. Although all the interventions focused on encouraging help-seeking behaviours, the emphasis and content differed among them, including general mental health topics, suicide and depression awareness and stigma.
Five studies developed programmes based on the notion that promoting mental health awareness could enhance mental health literacy and promote help-seeking [84‐88]. Four interventions targeting help-seeking for suicide were identified within five studies [89‐93]. Five interventions explicitly targeted help-seeking for depression in school-based settings their focus being to educate the school population about adolescent depression and thereby encourage help-seeking [94‐98]. Two studies evaluated the effectiveness of an intervention combining depression awareness and a suicide prevention programme promoting early identification and self-referral [99, 100]. Six classroom-based interventions addressing stigma were identified, two of which used psychoeducation to overcome myths regarding mental illness [101, 102] and four focused on providing interpersonal contact with people with mental health conditions in order to improve acceptance and increase help-seeking intentions [103‐106].
Outreach interventions
Three studies used outreach interventions to target mental health help-seeking [107‐109]. These aim to establish contact with adolescents who may be experiencing psychological and emotional distress in order to help them get the attention they need and increase their access to health services. They were based on the Building the Bridges to General Practice (BBGP) programme, developed by Wilson et al. (2005), a programme that aims to target help-seeking obstacles for physical and psychological problems by promoting contact between high school students and general practitioners [110].
Multimedia interventions
Six types of multimedia interventions have been developed to address some of the difficulties of reaching an adolescent population, such as fear of confidentiality breaches, stigma and self-reliance [111‐115]. The interventions included interactive films to engage students with mental health related topic and online platforms providing personalised information regarding the decision-aids process.
Peer training interventions
Peer training interventions are focused on the training of peers who act as active agents of change and social interactions incorporated into the daily activities within the school environment [116]. All three programmes followed similar principles concerning improving the climate around mental health problems, promoting social connectedness, and challenging norms and behaviours associated with help-seeking [117‐120]. “Peer leaders” acted as a link between the student population and mental health literacy, promoting the acceptability of seeking for help for mental health problems.
Further details of the included articles are available in Table 3.
Secondary outcomes
No studies referred to significant differences concerning the effectiveness of help-seeking interventions when comparing ages. No significant gender differences were identified regarding the effectiveness of the help-seeking interventions [89, 101, 103, 111]. However, before the intervention¸ females tended to have higher mental health literacy and more adaptive attitudes regarding mental health problems [90, 111], including greater help-seeking knowledge and intentions [107, 112, 113].
Effectiveness
The main goal of this review was to describe the interventions targeting help-seeking in adolescents and therefore did not include an analysis of their effectiveness. Almost half of the included studies were study protocols and feasibility studies, so effect sizes were not reported. However, some findings are worth mentioning.
Four studies which looked at effectiveness of the interventions focused on psychoeducation about depression found a significant effect in increasing help-seeking. King et al., [99] identified that there was an increase in future help-seeking behaviours after the interventions and that this was maintained at 3 months’ follow-up (t = 4.634/ p < .001). Strunk et al., [100] found a significant increase of help-seeking (p < 0.0005); however, this was not sustained at follow-up (p = 0.014). Robinson et al., [95] found that the intervention group was more likely to seek help at post-test (Odds ratio (95% C.I) =3.48 (1.93, 6.29), p < 0.0001) and Ruble et al., [96] found increased intention of help-seeking from others after the intervention (t = 13.658/ p < 0.0001.).
Anzeige
The three studies that looked at the effectiveness of stigma reduction identified positive effects of the intervention on help-seeking. Two studies [101, 104] found a significant reduction in self-stigma surrounding seeking help after the intervention (p < 0.05) and one study [103] found a significant effect of the intervention in help-seeking intentions (Wilks’ Λ = .942, F (4,417) = 6.428, p < 0.001).
Finally, all the studies that focused on outreach found a significant effect of the intervention in help-seeking intentions. One detected an increase in intentions at 3 months follow-up (F (2,217) = 3.04/ p < 0.05) [108], Rughani [107] found short terms improvements in help-seeking intentions (F (14,225) =1.87 p < .03) and Wilson [109] found a significant effect in the intention of seeking help for psychological problems after the intervention (F (2,598) = 4.31 p < 0.01).
Quality assessment
The majority of the studies were low to medium quality with moderate to high risk of bias. Most of the cross-sectional studies did not state a clear inclusion and exclusion criteria and did not consider possible confounders affecting the interpretation of the outcome. Regarding qualitative research, the most common problem was linked to sample size and the difficulty of providing a clear strategy to address the subjectivity of the authors in the interpretations of the data. Mixed method studies presented some inconsistencies in addressing specific components of both quantitative and qualitative traditions, and in the process of integrating both approaches. Regarding intervention studies, it was difficult to identify to what extent the groups were similar at baseline. Although some studies included baseline measures of demographic information, most of them did not consider confounders or other factors influencing effectiveness, and some studies did not have any baseline measures. Also, few studies included follow-up and the ones that did, had high attrition rates and short follow-up periods (up to 6 months); therefore, it is not possible to attribute a long-lasting effect to the interventions. Quasi-experimental studies acknowledge possible selection and sample bias. Randomised controlled trials presented difficulties in terms of the blinding of the research team and participants at different stages of the process.
Overall there was inconsistency regarding the measurements of help-seeking, with most of the studies focusing on help-seeking intentions, which is not necessarily related to future behaviours. Moreover, many studies did not use valid and reliable instruments for measuring help-seeking. This is especially true for the experimental studies since most of them developed tools focused on their intervention rather than standardised help-seeking measures. Finally, most of the studies only used self-report measures, increasing the risk of bias of the findings. We did not assess the quality of study protocol, feasibility studies and pilot studies.
Anzeige
Discussion
Question 1: barriers and facilitators
This review focused on identifying barriers, facilitators and interventions targeting help-seeking behaviours in adolescents. Consistent with previous findings [1], the most prominent barrier identified was stigma. Negative attitudes and beliefs about mental health services and professionals was the second most prominent barrier. Trusted and strong relationships with possible gatekeepers (teachers, parents, GPs, health professionals, etc.) and prior positive help-seeking experience were the most cited facilitators.
Few studies related symptom severity with help-seeking. Of those that did, higher symptomatology was associated with lower help-seeking intentions and behaviours. This is in line with previous studies suggesting that teens who are most in need are less likely to seek help [1, 11, 15]. It is possible that the nature of mental health symptoms such as self-blame, emotional distress, difficulty in speaking to others and diminished cognitive ability contribute to lower help-seeking behaviours. Adolescents with higher symptom severity may be even more vulnerable experiencing difficulties with the help-seeking process in areas such as identifying the need for professional assistance or fear of stigmatisation. This could be due to higher rates of isolation and exclusion from their peers. Increasing mental health literacy among this population may provide a way of improving social support between peers [121].
There are structural barriers affecting the help-seeking process that go beyond attitudes, for example, costs, waiting times and transportation. These barriers were not among the most prominent reasons cited in the research review; however, this may be related to the limited amount of studies that included parents’ perceptions. A previous review, which focused on the parents of children and adolescents, concluded that structural barriers were the most relevant [122]. This suggests that adolescents are less worried about the practical implications of accessing help for mental health problems and are more affected by being attitudinal barriers, but that structural barriers may be more relevant to parents.
Key facilitators to help-seeking should be considered when creating new interventions such as trusted relationships with gatekeepers, and familiarisation with the help-seeking process. However, the lack of studies focusing on facilitators precludes many conclusions being drawn. The majority of studies used sub-clinical samples and/or hypothetical help-seeking scenarios rather than asking genuine help-seeker with mental health problems who could refer to the real circumstances leading them to ask for help. More research including young people who have sought help from services would be useful in understanding the idiosyncrasies of this process.
These findings provide a useful overall picture of the relevant factors influencing the help-seeking process in adolescents. However, the included studies did not share a clear definition and framework regarding help-seeking. A wide range of tools were used to measure help-seeking, varying in their validity and reliability, and also in the constructs they measured. This limits the generalisability of the findings and our understanding of the help-seeking process. Rickwood & Thomas (2012) have proposed a framework regarding help-seeking, identifying the different parts of the process, sources of help, types of help and main concerns [15]. In the future, sharing such a framework could be a useful means to reach a general agreement regarding the definition of help-seeking and its components.
Question 2: interventions
The types of interventions varied considerably and included classroom-based psychoeducation, outreach interventions, multimedia and online-based interventions and peer training. Among classroom-based psychoeducation interventions, the most effective ones were those focused on prompting help-seeking through addressing depression and stigma. All peer outreach interventions had a significant effect in improving help-seeking intentions, thus showing promising results. In sum, addressing stigma, mental health literacy, and attitudes towards mental health services could be beneficial in terms of promoting help-seeking.
Most of the intervention studies included in this review did not investigate mechanisms of change with regards to help-seeking behaviour. The relevance of studying underlying mechanisms and practical requirements related to the functionality of interventions has been previously discussed [123], and most of the interventions included in this review did not refer to these processes. Identifying such mechanisms could help understand how interventions work, enlightening and optimising the process of decision-making and design [93]. Adolescence is a period essentially characterised by emotional, behavioural, hormonal, and neuronal changes [124, 125]. Interventions congruent with the developmental stages may be useful to target age-appropriate factors.
It is important to mention that few intervention studies referred in detail to the implementation process and the main issues they encountered; however, the studies which did refer to this, found significant barriers. School administration issues, the difficulty of obtaining parental consent and attrition rates for the follow-up measures were one of the main difficulties regarding the implementation [93, 97, 102, 115]. Teacher’s support and engagement with the intervention were also described as a barrier in the implementation process for some studies [85, 93, 114]. Most of studies concluded that implementation strategies should consider the reality and challenges of each school. For this the theme of contextualization is fundamental and the specificities of the process of implementation (planning, engaging, executing, reflecting and evaluating) [126, 127].
All interventions were conducted within an educational setting. Special attention should also be paid to young people outside of the educational system, who are particularly vulnerable in terms of economic and social deprivation [128]. Around one in five children and adolescents are out of school according to the UNESCO [129], with psychosocial factors appearing to obstruct traditional educational trajectories [130]. Health and mental health conditions have a relevant role in terms of absenteeism and truancy [131]. Adolescents experiencing symptoms of depression and anxiety or in charge of a chronically sick relative can be more prone to avoid school and stay at home. These children can be even more vulnerable and harder to reach, and there is a lack of collaborative effort attempting to overcome this situation. Encouraging partnerships between the health and educational systems, community settings, youth detention centres, among other institutions providing social care, should be promoted with the purpose of supporting mental healthcare and provision for young people [132].
Encouraging adolescents to seek help for mental health problems is a key priority however, this does not resolve the discrepancy between needs and resources worldwide [132, 133]. “Mental health services for children and adolescents have internationally been poorly understood, underfunded and even neglected by governments” [p.92, 134]. This may be associated with the lack of a general understanding of this population’s needs (including developmental issues), and the “implementation gap”, referring to the challenges of translating evidence to health service development and practice [134]. Simultaneously, focusing on increasing help-seeking and service availability for children and adolescents is necessary to reduce the global burden of disease and protect the future health of this population [125, 135].
Limitations
This review has a number of limitations. First, only one author performed the data extraction and critical appraisal of papers therefore the data analysis is at risk of some subjectivity. Second, there is an increasing debate regarding the age that adolescence comprises, with some suggesting the age should be extended to 10 to 24 years old [17]. However, we decided to follow the definition of ´adolescent´ established by international organisations including the OMS and UNICEF. A significant number of papers were excluded considering our age range (n = 104). Defining adolescence as a period between 10 to 19 years old could be a limitation to our study. Thirdly, this review focused on common mental health problems such as depression, anxiety and emotional distress and excluded psychiatric conditions such as anorexia, schizophrenia and substance misuse, mainly due to the particular nature of the help-seeking processes. However, the exclusion of substance misuse problems could be seen as a limitation of this study due to its high prevalence in adolescence, making it a particularly sensitive issue during this period of life [136]. Finally, this review prioritised the overinclusion of studies to have an overall picture of the existing evidence regarding help-seeking for mental health problems in adolescents. As a result, low quality studies were included in the analysis and may affect the interpretation of the findings. There were some notable strengths in this review. This is the first systematic review studying help-seeking barriers, facilitators and interventions in order to give a comprehensive review of the topic. The search strategy developed was over-inclusive, using an optimal database combination, including multiple languages and PPI involvement in the development of the topic.
Conclusion
In conclusion, stigma and negative beliefs about mental health services appear as the most significant barriers to help-seeking for adolescents, whereas previous positive experiences with services and good mental health literacy are the most relevant facilitators. There are a number of interventions being developed to promote help-seeking for mental health problems in adolescents, and most of them take place in high education settings. They include a range of delivery methods including psychoeducation, stigma and depression awareness campaigns, online tools and peer training. Since such initiatives are relatively new, there is a need for more trials, with longer follow-up periods and the use of reliable and validated tools focused in future help-seeking behaviour. Despite school seeming to be the ideal setting for deploying these interventions, it is important to consider adolescents outside the school system who may be in more need of attention for psychosocial and mental health problems.
The completion of this systematic review would not have been possible without the support of The National Commission of Scientific and Technological Research (CONICYT-Beca Chile) under the Ministry of Education of the Chilean Government.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This is a systematic review including studies based on human participants. All the included papers had ethical approval, consent to participate and consent for publication authorised by the participants.
Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
What are the barriers, facilitators and interventions targeting help-seeking behaviours for common mental health problems in adolescents? A systematic review
verfasst von
Antonia Aguirre Velasco Ignacio Silva Santa Cruz Jo Billings Magdalena Jimenez Sarah Rowe
Erwachsene, die Medikamente gegen das Aufmerksamkeitsdefizit-Hyperaktivitätssyndrom einnehmen, laufen offenbar erhöhte Gefahr, an Herzschwäche zu erkranken oder einen Schlaganfall zu erleiden. Es scheint eine Dosis-Wirkungs-Beziehung zu bestehen.
Menschen mit Typ-2-Diabetes sind überdurchschnittlich gefährdet, in den nächsten Jahren auch noch eine Depression zu entwickeln – und umgekehrt. Besonders ausgeprägt ist die Wechselbeziehung laut GKV-Daten bei jüngeren Erwachsenen.
In einer Leseranfrage in der Zeitschrift Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology möchte ein anonymer Dermatologe bzw. eine anonyme Dermatologin wissen, ob er oder sie einen Patienten behandeln muss, der eine rassistische Tätowierung trägt.
Sportliche Betätigung hilft nicht nur bei Depression, sondern auch in Gruppen von Patientinnen und Patienten mit unterschiedlichen psychischen Erkrankungen, wie Insomnie, Panikattacken, Agoraphobie und posttraumatischem Belastungssyndrom. Sie alle profitieren längerfristig.
