Background
Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a procedure for alleviating end-stage osteoarthritis with significant impact on the quality of life in these patients [
1]. However, the life-in-service of joint implants is limited predominantly by aseptic loosening and periprosthetic osteolysis both causally linked to wear debris that are generated continuously by THA [
2]. Phagocytosed wear particles provoke macrophages, fibroblasts and other cells to release proinflammatory cytokines and mediators that attract other precursor cells. As a result, chronic inflammatory milieu and a foreign body granuloma develop [
3]. This, together with direct inhibition of osteoblast function by wear particles [
4], distorts homeostasis in bone in favour of excessive bone resorption, i.e. osteolysis, which can lead to aseptic loosening or periprosthetic fracture.
The concept of cytokines as initiators and perpetuators of particle disease is supported by reports on proinflammatory cytokine (IL-1, IL-6, TNF-α) up-regulation in macrophages and fibroblasts in response to wear particles [
5,
6]. These pleiotropic cytokines substantially promote the recruitment and maturation of osteoclast precursors at the bone-prosthesis interface [
7]. Particle disease/osteolysis might be also facilitated by down-regulation of immunomodulatory cytokines with anti-osteoclastogenic properties (e.g. IL-4, IL-10, IFN-γ) as has been already demonstrated in inflammatory joint conditions [
8,
9].
However, so called "particle disease" cannot sufficiently explain either the variable degrees of osteolysis found in patients with similar wear rates (and thus exposure to wear particles) or differences in THA survivorship even in the case of the same implant and similar wear rate [
10]. For this reason, the concept of individual susceptibility to osteolysis must play a role. Generally, the interaction between the prosthesis and host can be influenced by several less or well known mechanisms including the allergic hypersensitivity, non-allergic and toxic response to a material constituent of the implant [
11,
12]. Hypothetically, variation in genes for cytokines can alter gene function and/or expression which may affect the individual's resistance/susceptibility to severe osteolysis [
13]. In support of this concept, Wilkinson
et al. reported increased rate of osteolysis in patients carrying the A allele of the
TNF-238 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP), [
14]. Other studies have addressed variation in single genes for other candidate molecules in relationship with aseptic loosening [
15‐
17]. Surprisingly, only one study reported the variation in the axis of RANKL/RANK/OPG (at position
RANK+575*T) that is considered the single most influencing regulator of osteoclastogenesis [
18]. Interesting results were published by Gordon
et al. on the association of periprosthetic osteolysis and polymorphism in genes for Wnt canonical pathway (FRZB 200Trp, FRZB 200Arg: 324Arg haplotype), [
19]. Recently, the same team identified the association between carriage of
IL1RN +2018*C allele and a decreased risk of osteolysis after THA [
20]. Taken together, none of the reported findings has been replicated in independent samples thus still being considered as preliminary. Therefore, researchers in the field are strongly encouraged to perform well-organized replication studies to enable a meta-analysis [
21].
This study was conducted to investigate the contribution of genetic variation in proinflammatory/immunomodulatory cytokine genes to the risk of development of severe periprosthetic osteolysis. In addition, this study addressed the question whether there is an association between particular cytokine gene variants and risk of THA failure.
Discussion
This comprehensive study investigated the association between extent of acetabular osteolysis in THA and polymorphic variants across a wide spectrum of genes encoding for cytokines/cytokine receptors with inflammatory and/or immunomodulatory properties. In particular, the study suggests that SNPs in genes for proinflammatory cytokines TNF-α and IL-6 may play a role in the pathogenesis of osteolysis. In addition, a SNP in the gene for the Th1 cytokine IL-2 was found to be a factor associated with severity of acetabular osteolysis and risk for premature THA failure.
In this study, carriage of the
TNF-238*A allele was associated with severe acetabular osteolysis and risk for premature failure in contrast to the
TNF-238 "GG" genotype. Individuals carrying the
TNF-238*A were six times more prone to develop severe osteolysis than patients with the GG genotype. Accordingly, the striking risk for severe acetabular osteolysis associated with
TNF-238*A carriage could be detected here at statistically significant level though this variant is relatively rare (see power calculations in Additional file
1). Our study, therefore, confirms that
TNF-238 SNP plays a role in the development of osteolysis as suggested by Wilkinson
et al. [
14]. Concerning another SNP in
TNF gene promoter, our findings are concordant to those of Wilkinson
et al. and Kolundzic
et al. [
17], who found no relationship between the carriage of the
TNF-308*A allele and risk for osteolysis development or premature prosthetic failure.
To properly evaluate the contribution of SNPs in the
TNF gene to osteolysis development and prognosis of THA, it should be acknowledged that the minor
TNF-238*A allele occurs rarely in the normal population, limiting its contribution to the overall "population" risk of severe acetabular osteolysis (PAR value, 5.2%). This SNP may, however, serve as a marker for other causative polymorphism(s) in the
TNF locus or neighbouring polymorphic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes. This interpretation would be also in accordance with equivocal data from
in vitro/
ex vivo analyses of the functional influence of
TNF-238 and also
TNF-308 polymorphisms on
TNF gene transcription and subsequent cytokine expression, processes which seem to be highly cell or stimulus specific [
38,
39].
A SNP in the
IL6 gene promoter was another polymorphism implicated in the pathogenesis of OL in this study. IL-6 is a multifunctional cytokine also involved in the regulation of bone metabolism; therefore its participation in the processes occurring at the bone-prosthesis interface is plausible [
6]. Here,
IL6-174*G allele carriage was associated with the increased risk of severe osteolysis according to both the univariate and multivariate analyses. However, this SNP in gene for IL-6 did not influence the risk for cumulative hazard of THA failure. Association of
IL6-174*G with severe osteolysis could not currently be supported by straightforward "mechanistic" explanation because its functional role on IL-6 expression is controversial. The allele
IL6-174*G was originally associated with higher induced expression of IL-6
in vitro [
40], however this was not subsequently confirmed [
41]. Importantly, Terry
et al. revealed that effect of
IL6 genetic variation on IL-6 expression is tissue-specific and dependent on other environmental factors [
41,
42]. This observation may explain the opposite roles of
IL6-174 SNP observed in different clinical conditions [
40,
43,
44]. Our results, therefore, allow us to speculate that complex local response around THA provides adequate conditions/stimuli promoting "penetrance" of the
IL6-174 variant in terms of its effect on IL-6 expression. Concerning previous findings on
IL6 gene in THA outcome, Malik
et al. [
16] like us, reported no association of
IL6-174 SNP with the risk of premature failure of cemented THA. The association of the
IL6 SNP (positions -597 and -572) with the earlier prosthetic failure has been reported by Kolundzic
et al. [
17]. However, their study had a small number of patients and included both hips in the same patient into the analysis.
Based on our data the
IL2-330*G genetic variant may function protectively against severe osteolysis which could result in significantly lower cumulative hazard of THA failure. Interestingly, Campos
et al. [
45] found that polymorphism in the
IL2-330*G was not associated with premature failure of dental implants. Due to biological and mechanical similarities between THA and dental implants, both studies suggest a protective role of
IL2 SNP on the prosthetic-bone interface. IL-2 regulates both survival and death of regulatory T cells which might affect the osteoclast life cycle [
46]. However, the functional relevance of the investigated
IL2 SNP is not clear [
47,
48] and thus the role of IL-2, and therefore also Th1 lymphocytes in the pathogenesis of periprosthetic osteolysis has yet to be elucidated [
11]. Whatever the mechanism behind possible IL-2 participation in pathological processes around THA, if proven in other centres/populations, the protective effects of the
IL2-330*G would have clear implications because the G allele is carried by more than 50% of Europeans [
29,
49].
While interpreting the results of the current study, one should consider the theory of multifactorial susceptibility to complex disease and current issues of genetic association studies (GAS). Any individual genome contains many functional variants and many of these can influence the development of osteolysis in conjunction with other biological, mechanical and material factors. Furthermore, one may also conceivably argue that other genetic "elements" than those identified in this study may be involved in the complex process of particular disease via phenomenon of linkage disequilibrium [
50]. Future investigations should be directed at detailed analyses of specified candidate regions on chromosomes 4q, 6p and 7q in order to search for further genetic markers of osteolysis developing after THA. Finally, based on current experience showing that the great proportion of GAS has not been replicated in independent samples, further validation through replication studies is strictly recommended [
51]. In this regard, it should be emphasised that our study replicated the findings of Wilkinson
et al. for
TNF-238*A [
14].
Limitations and strengths of our study
We are aware that relative heterogeneity of the primary diagnoses leading to index THA may be linked to the THA outcome including osteolysis. Nevertheless, genetic variants of cytokine genes (namely
TNF-238*A and
IL6-174*G) appeared to be independent predictors of severe osteolysis after adjustment for primary diagnosis and other relevant factors in the regression analysis. Moreover, the vast majority of dysplastic hips (over 98%) were of Hartofilakidis type I which influence the THA survival only insignificantly, and the remaining ones were of type II [
52]. In addition, selection bias might have an influence on the reported findings because not all patients with the ABG 1 prosthesis could be included in the study (205 of 506). In non-revised cases the severity of bone defects was determined primarily from radiography which could have led to underestimation of the true bone defects. Despite the rigorously created design of this association study, false positive findings cannot be excluded. On the other hand, only patients with identical prosthesis were included which eliminated the influence of inter-prosthetic differences on osteolysis development and prosthetic failure. In addition, surgery was performed at the single institution by a limited number of experienced surgeons which should minimize the role for surgery-related differences on failure of the implant.
Also from the genetic epidemiology view, our study meets the recently adopted criteria for GAS [
21]. Apart from emphasis on its preliminary character, this study had adequate study power (more than 80% in 19 of 22 investigated SNPs; see Additional file
1) and adhered to quality control methods in genotyping/analytical methodologies [
29]; overall genotyping "failure" rate was very low (less than two percent). Importantly, the parameter of PAR was included to estimate the specific contribution of investigated genetic markers among other complex individual and environmental factors promoting development of severe acetabular osteolysis and premature THA failure.
All three authors are with the Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, Palacky University, Czech Republic and in parallel with the Faculty Hospital Olomouc, Czech Republic. Associated Professor Jiri Gallo, MD, PhD is the chief of Department of Orthopaedics; Assistant Professor Frantisek Mrazek, MD, PhD is at the Department of Immunology and leads the DNA section of the Tissue Typing laboratory, Faculty Hospital; Professor Martin Petrek, MD, PhD, is the acting head of the Department of Clinical Chemistry & Immunogenetics, the Principal Investigator at the Laboratory of Immunogenomics & Proteomics and the Director of the Tissue Typing Laboratory.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by Internal Grant Agency of Ministry of Health, Czech Republic (IGA MZ CR NR 9490 to Frantisek Mrazek).
Drs. V. Havranek, A. Arakelyan and Z. Kubistova assisted in the following partial works related to this report: measurements of polyethylene wear in retrieved THAs (VH), contribution to data analyses (AA) and partial genotyping of population control (ZK). Prof. S.B. Goodman has critically assessed the manuscript. Parts of this work were presented at the 20th European Histocompatibility & Immunogenetics Conference, June 6-9 2006, Oslo, Norway, 17th Annual Meeting of EORS, April 24-26 2008, Madrid, Spain and 9th EFORT Congress, May 29-June 1 2008, Nice, France, where poster by Jiri Gallo et al. was awarded the Jacques-Duparc award.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
All three authors equally contributed to this paper; the order of the authors is alphabetical. JG recruited THA patients into the study and collected clinical details, MP provided healthy population control. FM carried out the genotyping and performed statistical analyses with help of MP's and JG's ideas. Conceptualization and design of the study was joint work of JG (clinical problem of individual predisposition to osteolysis) and MP (immunogenetic approach to its solution and proposal for data analyses/presentation). All three authors contributed to drafting of the paper; the author responsible for the MS integrity is MP.