Background
Malaria is the most important insect-transmitted disease with half of the world's population at risk of disease and mortality. In 2008, malaria led to nearly 900,000 deaths [
1]. The high impacts on human health and on countries' economies have motivated campaigns for the eradication of the disease through methods controlling either the parasite
Plasmodium spp. or its vectors.
Anopheles arabiensis is one of the major African vectors of malaria. A feasibility study of using the sterile insect technique (SIT) for
An. arabiensis, as part of an area-wide integrated pest management project [
2] for population suppression, is currently being conducted in Northern Sudan and in Réunion [
3]. SIT is based on the release of large numbers of sexually sterile males, which would mate with wild females and transfer their sterile spermatozoids for the fertilization of the eggs. If the sterile males successfully compete for mates, the wild population size will progressively diminish. A lower probability of contact between the vector and humans is, therefore, expected, and as a result pathogen transmission and disease incidence will decrease. Sexual sterilization can be accomplished by male mosquito exposure to ionizing radiation, resulting in random dominant lethal mutations in the germinal cells that cause the death of the developing embryos after fertilization.
Part of the research work for the implementation of SIT requires mating of radio-sterilized males with virgin females so as to identify the effect of irradiation on those males. Until 2 years earlier, the sex-separation method routinely used in this laboratory for
An. arabiensis Dongola, consisted of separating females from males as adults, less than 18 h after emergence [
4,
5]. This procedure consistently ensured virginity of the females. However, recent experiments suggested the occurrence of early matings between males and females separated from one another between 12 to 16 h after their emergence.
Like many Diptera species, male mosquitoes are not immediately sexually mature after emergence: maturation includes a permanent 180° rotation of their genitalia [
6]. The male mosquito genitalia consist of the 8
th to 10
th abdominal segments. Claspers tipped with claws enable the male to grasp the female for copulation and are located on segment 10
th[
7]. When males emerge these claws are rotated dorsally, which prevents them from copulating until the rotation occurs. Rotation is driven by two sets of opposed and crossed muscles [
8] and can happen equally frequently either clockwise or counter-clockwise [
8,
9]. The time to complete this event is species-specific. Aedine species show a great variation:
Aedes iriomotensis,
Aedes albopictus,
Aedes atriisimilis were shown to rotate 180° respectively around 12, 22 and 40 hours after emergence [
10]; 18 to 24 h were required for
Aedes aegypti[
8]; 30 h for
Aedes taeniorhynchus[
11] and nearly 4 days for
Aedes provocans[
12].
Culex tritaeniorhynchus and
Culex quinquefasciatus completed the rotation in 19 h [
13,
14]. Finally, the species
Culiseta inornata needed only 6 to 12 h [
7]. The rate of genitalia rotation for anopheline mosquitoes is not yet reported. Only observations of the insemination status demonstrated that at least 24 h post-emergence are required for mating in
An. arabiensis and
Anopheles gambiae s.s.[
15] as well as for
Anopheles stephensi[
16]. Besides the requirement for male maturation, females of most mosquito species are unreceptive during the first 30-60 h after emergence; although they may allow copulation, they will not become inseminated [
17]. Mahmood and Reisen [
16] showed that females of
An. stephensi reached sexual maturity by the 2
nd night of life, though a very low proportion of females were inseminated by older males less than 12 h after their emergence.
In order to investigate the issue of sexual maturity in this laboratory colony, experiments were performed to determine the rate of sexual maturation over time in the current laboratory colony of An. arabiensis Dongola. This was compared with wild specimens collected directly in the field. The forces for laboratory selection due to the stock-keeping method and the possible consequences of this outcome on insects rearing and research are discussed.
Discussion
The establishment of disparities between reared and wild insects during colonization can result from selection, genetic drift and inbreeding [
23]. Possible methods to avoid and mitigate these in mosquitoes have been discussed but few have been empirically demonstrated to be effective [
24]. Several studies reported modifications in the sexual behaviour of long-term laboratory reared insects (house flies [
25], screw-worm flies [
26,
27], bud worms [
27] and a shortened sexual maturity period (Mediterranean fruit flies [
28]).
Between 2004 and 2009, more than one hundred generations of the Dongola strain have been reared under laboratory conditions, allowing the possibility that selective pressures would lead to purifying selection of particular traits. The present work was prompted by unexpected data obtained during irradiation experiments where the expected sterility levels were not reached. The mating of radio-sterilized males with females separated from males less than 16 h post-emergence never allowed the achievement of full sterility with the five-year-old laboratory colony. A high proportion of females were inseminated at this age as mosquitoes from the laboratory colony were shown to be already sexually competent a few hours after emergence. As early as 11 h post-emergence, males were able to copulate and females were receptive. In spite of a much higher temperature, wild males collected in the field as pupae required twice as much time as laboratory males to complete the rotation of their genitalia. This observation and comparison with previous results suggest a rearing induced selection of the males to sexually mature more rapidly.
Sexual maturity in male mosquitoes is reached after a 180° rotation of the genitalia and the maturation of sexual organs and antennal fibrillae [
29]. Approximately 20 h would be required for wild males collected in the field to become sexually mature which is in agreement with the data reported by Mahmood & Reisen [
16]. A deceleration in genitalia rotation beyond 90° has been reported for an aedine species [
11]; a similar pattern seems to exist in the Dongola wild males, but was not evident in the laboratory males. Provost
et al[
11] reported an increase of the rotation rate with temperature. As the wild males observations had to be conducted at ca 40°C, one could suppose that the completion of this process would be even slower in typical laboratory conditions e.g. 28°C.
Very few females inseminated by 11 to 19.5 h old males laid eggs though spermatheca dissection showed that 20 to 40% of them were inseminated. The low number of ovipositions would suggest that the quantity of sperm actually transferred by males may not always be sufficient to permit oviposition. Indeed, it has been shown with
An. gambiae s.s. that the oviposition behaviour is triggered by a spermatheca filled with sperm [
30], although more recent work demonstrates that the mating plug may alone be sufficient [
31]. However, during the mating experiments with sterile males irradiated at 120 Gy, in which females were separated at the adult stage, 6% of them laid fertile progeny (i.e. > 60% fertile eggs) resulting from the early insemination by same age un-irradiated males. This result indicates that those females received enough sperm before the sex-separation process to fertilize and lay viable eggs. Besides, 53% of those females laid egg-batches that were semi-sterile (i.e. >10 and <60% fertile eggs) indicating that fertile then sterile males inseminated them successively and that they used both sperm to fertilize the eggs. The high rate of semi-sterility corroborated the fact that a relatively high proportion of the young emerged males were able to transfer their sperm in the first hours after emergence. It seems likely that most of them inseminated the females only partially thus allowing a subsequent double mating by a sterile male. Mahmood and Reisen [
16] suggested that the high rate of multiple matings observed in caged
An. stephensi and
Anopheles culicifacies would be induced by an incomplete transfer of sperm, which would mostly occur when the male's reproductive system is partially depleted. They reported the depletion of the accessory glands in newly emerged males or following a mating. However once sexual maturity was reached, the accessory glands were fully filled with secretory cells and male accessory gland fluid. The observation of semi-sterility however suggests that the sperm transferred by young emerged males was already mature, as it has been used to fertilize at least some of the eggs. A possible hypothesis is that the quantity of sperm in the sperm reservoir or the quantity transferred during the mating might be low for the < 18.5 h old males. An alternative explanation could be that newly emerged males were not able to transfer a mating plug after the sperm transfer, and females would eject part of the sperm. Rogers
et al[
31] demonstrated that in anophelines the seminal secretions (mating plug) produced by the male accessory gland and transferred during insemination, promote sperm storage. They suggested that when males failed to transfer the mating plug, females would actively eject the sperm or part of it. It would be of interest to investigate whether the failure of most of the females to oviposit is due to an insufficient quantity of sperm transferred or to the non-transfer of a mating plug.
There are at least five reasons to support the hypothesis of rearing selection pressures for accelerated sexual maturation in males: (
i) variation in rotation time exists within males of the same age for a given temperature [
9]; (
ii) the observation of males attempting to mate before their genitalia had sufficiently rotated to ensure a successful copulation has been reported for
Ae. aegypti[
9]; (
iii) the small cages used in laboratory rearing might not allow males to execute a mating swarm and hence favour individual mating attempts [
16]; (
iv) the management of the stock in the laboratory consists of a situation in which there is no overlapping of generations and all males are of a similar age range of approximately three days; (
v) genetic selection on insects due to rearing pressures have already been reported [
32,
33]. Such behaviours could favour males that would complete early sexual maturation and this phenomenon would be purified over generations.
The precocious sexual maturity we observed in males may have occurred as well in females. Indeed, they both showed a reduced sexual maturity period as compared with typical values from the literature [
15,
16]. However the data presented here do not allow us to state whether males and females evolved simultaneously or if one sex was already pre-adapted for early mating. Lima
et al[
34] mentioned the evolution of male
Anopheles albitarsis mating ability after ca. 10 years of rearing under laboratory conditions, with an improvement of the mating capacity and insemination rates. They suggested that this evolution did not involve females, as the difficulties to mate in a confined space concerned males only. However, Gwadz and Craig [
35] reported that females
Ae. aegypti from four two-year-old laboratory strains showed a significantly shorter refractory period than two young colonized strains, but they did not mention male receptivity. In females
Aedes atropalpus, Gwadz [
36] showed that early receptivity was inherited as it is linked to a juvenile hormone. It is not known however if sexual maturity in males is also moderated by hormones.
Difficulties in establishing colonies of anopheline mosquitoes are often reported and attributed to the incapacity of male swarm formation in a confined space [
24]. The adaptation to rearing conditions would necessitate individual mating capacities of the males. Because
Anopheles mosquitoes' sex ratio is 1:1, it is likely that not all males have an opportunity to mate. Variation among males that may be under selection and that could affect reproductive success include size [
37] and the quality of the male accessory gland fluids and sperm [
38‐
40] and genetic factors whose phenotypic effects are unknown [
41]. This study showed that, in laboratory settings in which similarly aged males must compete for mates, maturation rate is apparently under selection. As mentioned by Howell & Knols [
29], laboratory rearing can lead to a bottleneck because of selective pressures. Negative side effects of such unintentional behavioural selections might present themselves when the reared insects are released in the field and strong differences to their wild counterparts might compromise their survival or mating capacities [
42]. Nevertheless the early capacity of mating found in males
An. arabiensis Dongola might not be a negative attribute in an SIT project, as the released males would be reproductively capable only a few hours after emergence, assuming that they are also able to join or initiate a mating swarm. As part of an SIT program, it is of primary importance that the released sterile males are able to copulate and successfully inseminate wild females as early as possible, so that predation pressures and survival capacities would not have a negative impact on their performance. Indeed, when releasing sterile insects, it is often recommended to wait until adults are sexually mature before their release so that they would be immediately effective in the field. But if a selection of males able to mate shortly after emergence can be induced by the rearing procedure, the possibility of release at the pupal stage becomes advantageous, as the handling can be easier than for adult releases.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
CFO, JG and MQB developed the design of the study. CFO carried out the experimental work, performed the statistical analysis and drafted the manuscript. JG, MQB and GL supervised manuscript preparation and contributed significantly to the final draft of the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.