Background
Methods
Data sources and search strategy
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Definitions, outcomes and follow up periods
The adverse cardiovascular outcomes were
Data extraction and quality assessment
Methodological quality and statistical analysis
Ethics
Results
Study selection
Baseline characteristics
Studies | Age (year) | Male (%) | Ht (%) | Ds (%) | Cs (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
IT/NIT | IT/NIT | IT/NIT | IT/NIT | IT/NIT | |
Abizaid [30] | 63.0/63.0 | 49.5/63.6 | 73.3/67.5 | 60.0/64.0 | 48.9/48.6 |
Akin [2] | 66.9/66.6 | 65.4/75.0 | 92.4/92.6 | 80.7/83.5 | 14.9/19.3 |
Antoniucci [31] | 69.0/68.0 | 65.0/73.0 | 40.0/43.0 | 30.0/30.0 | 17.0/21.0 |
Dangas [8] | 62.6/63.2 | 61.3/76.5 | 87.5/83.2 | – | 17.9/14.7 |
Hermillier [32] | 62.2/62.2 | 63.5/63.5 | 81.1/81.1 | 71.4/71.4 | – |
Jain [33] | 66.6/64.9 | 62.2/71.8 | 82.1/77.5 | 67.9/67.7 | 13.9/18.0 |
Kereiakes [34] | 63.3/63.3 | 63.3/63.3 | 87.0/87.0 | 82.5/82.5 | 18.3/18.3 |
Kirtane [3] | 63.0/63.0 | 64.7/64.7 | 82.1/82.1 | 74.0/74.0 | 18.4/18.4 |
Kirtane [16] | 64.0/64.0 | 60.4/60.4 | 90.6/90.6 | 87.1/87.1 | 54.1/54.1 |
Kuchulakanti [35] | 65.1/65.1 | 60.5/60.5 | 89.0/89.0 | 88.5/88.5 | 16.0/16.0 |
Kumar [15] | 62.0/67.0 | 62.0/67.0 | 94.0/93.0 | 89.0/92.0 | 11.0/8.0 |
Mehran [36] | 63.0/66.0 | 52.0/61.0 | 77.0/77.0 | 71.0/67.0 | 11.0/12.0 |
Mulukutla [37] | 63.5/64.0 | 50.7/61.5 | 84.8/83.1 | 79.5/77.3 | 16.9/19.4 |
Nakamura [38] | 66.2/67.2 | 66.2/75.4 | 68.1/72.0 | 58.0/60.4 | 12.1/19.5 |
Schofer [39] | 60.0/62.0 | 71.0/77.0 | 73.0/75.0 | 65.0/72.0 | 13.0/20.0 |
Stein [40] | 58.0/60.0 | 53.1/66.1 | 56.8/63.0 | – | – |
Stone [41] | 63.8/63.8 | 63.2/63.2 | 83.1/83.1 | 79.4/79.4 | 19.6/19.6 |
Tada [1] | 66.7/67.9 | 67.0/76.0 | 76.0/78.0 | – | 16.0/21.0 |
Witzenbichler [42] | 64.5/64.5 | 73.4/73.4 | 72.3/72.3 | 60.3/60.3 | 56.8/56.8 |
Kappetein [43] | 65.4/65.4 | 71.0/71.0 | 70.0/70.0 | 82.0/82.0 | 16.0/16.0 |
Included studies | Insulin-treated DM (n) | Non-insulin treated DM (n) | Follow-up period |
---|---|---|---|
Abizaid [30] | 97 | 151 | During 1 year |
Akin [2] | 581 | 1078 | During 1 year |
Antoniucci [31] | 84 | 82 | 6 months |
Dangas [8] | 325 | 631 | 1 month, 5 years |
Hermillier [32] | 105 | 213 | At 1 year |
Jain [33] | 644 | 1919 | During 1 year |
Kereiakes [34] | 314 | 826 | At 1 year |
Kirtane [3] | 265 | 562 | 4 years |
Kirtane [16] | 137 | 319 | At 1 year |
Kuchulakanti [35] | 265 | 586 | 6 months |
Kumar [15] | 115 | 182 | 9 months |
Mehran [36] | 81 | 114 | In-hospital |
Moussa [18] | 82 | 197 | 9 months |
Mulukutla [37] | 817 | 1749 | During 1 year |
Nakamura [38] | 200 | 647 | At 3 years |
Schofer [39] | 48 | 117 | 6 months |
Stein [40] | 352 | 781 | In hospital |
Stone [41] | 494 | 1375 | 2 years |
Tada [1] | 996 | 3404 | 3 years |
Witzenbichler [42] | 159 | 434 | At 1 year |
Kappetein [43] | 89 | 142 | 5 years |