Background
The mammalian oviduct plays important roles in reproduction. After an oocyte cumulus complex (OCC) is ovulated from the ovary into the peritoneal or bursal cavity, it is "picked-up" by the infundibular portion of the oviduct [
1,
2]. As the OCC adheres to the ciliated outer surface of the infundibulum [
3], cilia beat in the direction of the ostium. Both adhesion and ciliary beating are needed to move the OCC into the ampulla, where fertilization occurs [
4‐
6]. Failure of the OCC to be properly picked-up by the oviduct can result in ectopic pregnancy [
7]. Ciliated epithelial cells also line the lumen of the oviduct, where they function in transport of preimplantation embryos through the oviduct [
2,
8]. Oviductal smooth muscle contraction also plays a role in transporting the embryo towards the uterus [
2,
9‐
16].
There is both
in vivo and
in vitro evidence that the mammalian oviduct is a target of cigarette smoke. Oviducts can be exposed either directly to mainstream (MS) smoke, which is the smoke inhaled by active smokers, or indirectly to sidestream (SS) smoke, which burns off the end of cigarettes. Inhalation of MS and SS cigarette smoke by hamsters was correlated with blebbing of ciliated epithelial cells and a decreased ratio of ciliated to secretory cells in the ampulla of the oviduct [
17]. MS and SS smoke inhalation by hamsters also slowed oviductal smooth muscle contraction and embryo transport [
18]. These effects were seen when the inhaled doses of MS and SS smoke were similar to those received by active and passive smokers as measured by serum cotinine levels [
17,
18]. In humans, inhalation of cigarette smoke also inhibited oviductal muscle contraction [
19].
Intravenous administration of nicotine, a major component of cigarette smoke, retarded rat embryo cleavage, reduced embryo cell number, and reduced oviductal blood flow [
20], which may be related to reduced smooth muscle contraction [
21]. Intravenous nicotine also inhibited oviductal motility in Rhesus monkeys [
22].
A newly developed
in vitro assay has been useful in studying the effects of smoke exposure on hamster oviductal functioning [
4,
5,
8,
16,
23‐
25]. MS and SS cigarette smoke solutions significantly decreased ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and oviductal smooth muscle contraction in hamster oviducts
in vitro; however, in the presence of albumin, SS smoke solutions stimulated ciliary beat frequency [
5,
8,
16,
23,
25]. Individual MS and SS smoke constituents (potassium cyanide, acrolein, phenol, acetaldehyde, and formaldehyde), which are ciliotoxic in other models, inhibited oocyte pickup rate and ciliary beat frequency [
26]. However, only cyanide was present in cigarette smoke solutions in a high enough concentration to account for the effect seen
in vitro [
26].
To test the hypothesis that additional ciliotoxic chemicals are present in smoke, we fractionated MS smoke solutions using solid phase extraction cartridges. Twelve pyridine and seven pyrazine compounds were then identified in the active fractions using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) [
16]. We previously showed that several of the pyridines inhibited the ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and infundibular smooth muscle contraction rate at picomolar doses [
16]. The purpose of the present study was to test the hypothesis that the pyrazine derivatives identified in active smoke fractions also inhibited oviductal functioning. Dose-response experiments were used to determine the lowest observable adverse effect level (LOAEL) and efficacy of each pyrazine derivative on ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and infundibular smooth muscle contraction. Our data show that the pyrazine derivatives, some of which are widely used in consumer products, inhibit oviductal functioning in the picomolar to nanomolar range.
Discussion
Six pyrazine derivatives containing hydrocarbon substitutions were identified in the active fractions of MS smoke solutions that were known to inhibit oviductal functioning. In the current study, pyrazine and the identified pyrazine derivatives inhibited ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and smooth muscle contraction in hamster oviductal explants. The LOAELs and efficacies for each compound tested in this study are compared in Table
2 for each of the oviductal assays. The finding that these pyrazine compounds are inhibitory at very low doses is significant because of their widespread use as additives in food and tobacco [
28].
The hierarchies of potency of the pyrazine compounds as determined by the LOAELs in this study for the ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and infundibular smooth muscle contraction rate assays are summarized in Table
3. In all the assays, pyrazine derivatives showed an equal or greater potency than pyrazine. A previous study that looked at the effect of pyridine derivatives on ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and infundibular smooth muscle contraction found that pyridine derivatives with a single ethyl substitution and several with a single methyl substitution were also effective in picomolar doses and were ten million times more inhibitory than pyridine alone [
16]. The pyrazine ring differs from the pyridine ring only by the presence of a second nitrogen atom in the fourth position of the ring, yet pyrazine was at least 1 million-fold more inhibitory than pyridine in all three bioassays.
Table 3
Hierarchies of Potency Based on LOAELs for the Oviductal Assays
Ciliary Beat Frequency | pyrazine = 2-methylpyrazine = 2-ethylpyrazine > 2-methoxy-3-methylpyrazine = 2,3,5-trimethylpyrazine > 2,5-dimethylpyrazine > 2,6-dimethylpyrazine |
Oocyte Pickup Rate
| 2-methoxy-3-methylpyrazine > 2-methylpyrazine = 2-ethylpyrazine = pyrazine = 2,5-dimethylpyrazine > 2,3,5-trimethylpyrazine > 2,6-dimethylpyrazine |
Infundibular Smooth Muscle Contraction Rate
| 2-methoxy-3-methylpyrazine = 2-ethylpyrazine > 2-methylpyrazine > 2,3,5-trimethylpyrazine = 2,5-dimethylpyrazine = pyrazine > 2,6-dimethylpyrazine |
The efficacy of each pyrazine derivative identified in the cigarette smoke solutions was calculated for ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup rate, and infundibular smooth muscle contraction rate (Table
2). In all three assays, the pyrazines with single ethyl or methyl substitutions were among the most inhibitory at the LOAEL dose. Single methyl and ethyl substituted pyrazines were always in the number one or number two position in the hierarchy of potency (Table
3) for each bioassay irrespective of water solubility or lipophilicity. In general, pyrazine and its derivatives were more effective at inhibiting oocyte pickup rate and infundibular smooth muscle contraction rate than ciliary beat frequency. A similar pattern was observed for the pyridine compounds tested previously on oviductal functioning [
16].
We have now discovered two classes of smoke constituents, pyridines [
16] and pyrazines, that are ciliotoxic at very low doses
in vitro. In this study, pyrazine and its derivatives inhibited ciliary beat frequency at doses much lower than previously shown with cyanide. However, ciliary beat frequency was only modestly affected by pyrazine derivatives compared to oocyte pickup rate. Therefore, it is probable that pyrazine derivatives inhibited oocyte pickup rate by affecting another factor(s) in addition to ciliary beat frequency. We have previously shown that adhesion of the OCC matrix to the tips of the cilia is also needed for successful OCC pickup [
5]. It is possible that pyrazine and its derivatives had a stronger effect on adhesion than on ciliary beat frequency, which could account for the stronger inhibition of oocyte pickup rate that we observed. Although our results cannot be extrapolated to humans, epidemiological studies show that women who smoke are at increased risk for ectopic pregnancies and spontaneous abortions [
7,
12,
15,
29‐
31] [40], two conditions that could be caused by inhibition of oocyte pickup.
In this study, pyrazine derivatives found in cigarette smoke also adversely affected smooth muscle contraction of the infundibular portion of the hamster oviduct
in vitro at nanomolar and picomolar doses. Previously, pyridine compounds were also shown to inhibit infundibular smooth muscle contraction at similarly low doses [
16]. The pyridine and pyrazine data suggest that the inhibition of infundibular smooth muscle contraction observed
in vitro using MS smoke solutions [
16] is due to the pyridine and pyrazine derivatives found in the smoke solutions. These individual smoke constituents may also be responsible for the inhibition of smooth muscle contraction that was observed in the hamster oviduct after
in vivo inhalation of MS cigarette smoke [
18].
In addition to effects on oviductal functioning, the pyrazine and pyridine derivatives found in cigarette smoke impair other biological processes. Six pyrazine and twelve pyridine derivatives along with their parent compounds inhibited growth of the chick chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) [
32,
33]. Pyrazine was the most potent chemical tested and inhibited both CAM and embryo growth at picomolar doses due to inhibition of DNA synthesis [
32]. Several pyrazine [
32] and pyridine (unpublished data) derivatives also perturbed pattern formation of blood vessels, migration of mesodermal blood vessels to the ectoderm, and differentiation of the capillary plexus in CAMs. Several pyrazine and pyridine derivatives with single ethyl or methyl substitutions (3-ethylpyridine, 2-ethylpyridine, 2-methylpyridine, and 2-ethylpyrazine) inhibited CAM and/or embryo growth [
32,
33] and oviductal functioning [
16] at picomolar or nanomolar doses. Taken together, these observations suggest that pyridine and pyrazine derivatives impair diverse biological processes either by affecting different mechanisms that control these different processes or by acting through one common mechanism that is fundamental to multiple processes.
The concentrations of several pyrazine derivatives in MS and SS cigarette smoke were determined by Brunnemann et al. for a single brand commercial U.S. non-filtered cigarette [
34]. For this particular cigarette type, 2-methylpyrazine was present in the gas phase of MS smoke at 2.2 ppm and in gas phase of SS smoke at 55 ppm [
34]. The combined concentration of 2,3-dimethylpyrazine, 2,5-dimethylpyrazine, and 2,6-dimethylpyrazine was 3.9 ppm in the gas phase of MS and 61 ppm in gas phase of SS smoke. Quantitative analysis of cigarette smoke has shown that both pyridine and pyrazine compounds are more concentrated in SS than MS smoke [
34]. 2-Methylpyrazine was one of the most potent pyrazine derivatives in this study, with a LOAEL in several of the bioassays of 10
-12 M. The concentrations of pyrazine derivatives in the serum or tissues of smokers are unknown. However, since the pyrazine compounds are inhibitory at such low doses, it is likely that these pyrazine derivatives are present
in vivo at high enough concentrations to adversely affect processes such as ciliary beat frequency, oocyte pickup, and smooth muscle contraction.
Pyrazine and the six pyrazine derivatives examined in this study appear on the FEMA GRAS list of chemicals [
28]. This is a list of chemicals published by the
F lavor and
E xtract
M anufacturers'
A ssociation (FEMA) that are
g enerally
r egarded
a s
s afe (GRAS) and are therefore added directly to food, drinks, tobacco, cosmetics, and fragrances. Pyrazines with alkyl and alkoxy substitutions may also be produced from condensation of hexoses and amino acids at elevated temperatures. Their precursors are the amine and carbonyl compounds found in uncooked foods [
28]. Pyrazine derivatives are absorbed optimally at intestinal pH [
28]. The metabolism of pyrazine derivatives involves oxidation of side-chain alkyl or oxygenated functional groups and hydroxylation of the pyrazine ring [
28].
Pyrazines are responsible for roasted or smoky flavors and are widely distributed in food products [
35]. The range for the average usual and average maximum concentrations of pyrazine added to various types of food are (0.3–1.0 ppm) and (1.5–5.0 ppm) respectively [
28]. The LOAEL doses for pyrazine in our study were (0.4 ppb) for the ciliary beat frequency assay, (4 ppb) for the oocyte pickup rate assay, and (400 ppb) for the infundibular smooth muscle contraction assay, which are all less than the concentrations of pyrazine added to food. However, the dose eaten is probably not equivalent to the dose at the oviduct.
Recently, the safety of pyrazine compounds was re-evaluated for FEMA, and it was concluded that pyrazine compounds are safe for use in human consumer products [
28]. Although many of the biological processes, for example, acute toxicity, sub-chronic toxicity, histopathology, hematology, organ weights, clinical chemistry, genotoxicity, hepatotoxicity, and carcinogenicity, were reviewed and were not significantly affected by pyrazine compounds, there were reproductive effects shown in several of the papers reviewed by Adams et al., [
28]. For example, 2,5-dimethylpyrazine delayed the onset of puberty in female mice due to effects on adrenal function [
36] and caused a decrease in uterine weight in rats in a dose-dependent manner, possibly by inhibition of uterine uptake of estradiol [
37]. In male rats, 3,6-dimethylpyrazine-2-thiol caused a decrease in prostate and seminal vesicle weights [
38], and 2,5-dimethylpyrazine decreased levels of plasma testosterone, polyamines, and acid phosphatase in the prostate [
39]. Our data show that very low doses of pyrazine and six of its derivatives adversely affect various cell processes important in oviductal functioning. When combined with prior reproductive studies, our results raise questions about the safety of these compounds in consumer products even at very low doses.
Authors' contributions
KR carried out the dose-response experiments, data collection and analysis, and the solid phase extraction and GC-MS experiments and analysis. RR carried out the analysis of the raw ciliary beat frequency data. JA provided equipment and technical support for GC-MS. PT provided project supervision and assistance with writing the manuscript.