Introduction
Bronchial Thermoplasty (BT) is an endoscopic treatment for patients with severe asthma. It uses radiofrequency energy delivered to the medium and larger airways to reduce airway smooth muscle (ASM) mass [
1‐
5]. Several studies have shown an improvement in asthma quality of life, asthma control, and a reduction in exacerbations after BT [
6‐
8]. The exact mechanism of action however is still incompletely understood and patient responder profile remains under debate.
Pulmonary function measurements before and after BT have shown various results and correlations with treatment response have not been explored comprehensively. The large clinical trials and long term follow up studies thereafter showed a stable one-second forced expiratory volume (FEV
1) up to 5 years after BT with only the RISA trial showing an improvement in FEV
1 6 months after BT [
6‐
8].
Forced Oscillation Technique (FOT) is an effort-independent technique using various pressure oscillations to assess the relation between flow and pressure in the respiratory system [
9]. It has been postulated that FOT is more accurate in detecting small airways disease than conventional tests such as spirometry [
10,
11]. Additionally, while with bodyplethysmography the airway resistance is calculated by combining the flow with alveolar pressure, FOT measures the resistance of the entire respiratory system including the surrounding tissue and small airways [
12].
This study hypothesized that the BT-induced reduction of ASM in the larger airways influences the mechanical properties of the asthmatic airways. The aims of this trial are (1) to assess the effect of BT on pulmonary function parameters as assessed by spirometry, bodyplethysmography-determined airway resistance and FOT; (2) to evaluate whether pulmonary function parameters are related to BT response.
Methods
Subjects
Patients fulfilling the World Health Organization (WHO) and Innovative Medicine Initiative (IMI) criteria for severe refractory asthma and scheduled for BT and pulmonary function tests including FOT between December 2014 and September 2018 were included (Clinical
trials.gov NCT02225392) [
13,
14]. Ethical approval was provided by the Medical Ethics Committee of the Academic Medical Center Amsterdam (NL45394.018.13) and written informed consent was obtained. Asthma medication remained stable during the study period.
Bronchial thermoplasty
Patients were treated with BT according to current guidelines using the Alair System (Boston Scientific, USA) [
15‐
17] and under conscious sedation (remifentanil/propofol) [
18] or general anesthesia. Prednisolone 50 mg was started 3 days before treatment, on the day itself and 1 day thereafter.
Methods of measurement
All pulmonary function tests were performed in the morning and conducted by experienced staff according to ERS/ATS standards using Jaeger Masterlab software (Erich Jaeger GmbH, Wurtzburg, Germany). The measurements were performed during two visits: one visit before and one visit 6 months after treatment. During the visits, short acting bronchodilators were stopped for at least 6 hours. Long acting beta agonists (LABA) were continued. Spirometry, bodyplethysmography and FOT measurements were performed both before and after administration of 400 μg salbutamol. FOT was performed in an upright position with the Resmon Pro device using a pseudorandom noise signal (Restech, Italy). The subjects received a nose-clip and patients were instructed to support their cheeks with their hands while breathing tidal for 3 min. This measurement was performed twice and the average was used in the analysis.
Outcome parameters
The main outcome parameter of this study was the change in pulmonary function assessed by spirometry, bodyplethysmography and FOT. Other outcome parameters were the correlations between baseline and change in pulmonary function parameters and baseline and change in asthma quality of life questionnaires (AQLQ) and asthma control (ACQ-6) [
19,
20]. Changes in pulmonary function parameters or asthma questionnaires were defined as post-BT minus pre-BT values. A decrease of 0.5 points on AQLQ and an increase of 0.5 points on ACQ-6 is designated as clinically relevant.
Statistical analysis
GraphPad Prism version 5.01 (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego, CA, USA) was used for the analysis. Grouped data were reported as mean with standard deviation or median with interquartile ranges, as appropriate. Within group analyses were performed with paired t-tests or Wilcoxon signed rank tests. Correlation analyses were performed with Spearman’s rho coefficient. P-values were two sided and a statistical significance was set at p < 0.05.
Discussion
This study aimed to investigate the effect of BT on pulmonary function and to explore whether these pulmonary function parameters were associated with BT response. An improvement in asthma control and quality of life was found while overall pulmonary function parameters remained stable. More importantly, this is the first study showing that a low respiratory resistance, measured with FOT, correlated to BT-response. These results can contribute to improved patient selection for BT.
Comparable to previously published larger trials [
8,
21], spirometry parameters overall remained stable. A slight increase in pre-bronchodilator FVC (% predicted) and decrease in post-bronchodilator FEV
1/FVC after BT were found, although significantly different, the clinical relevance of these small differences is questionable. For the first time however, correlations were found between asthma questionnaire (AQLQ and ACQ) changes and FEV
1 change. Although the differences were small, these data suggest that spirometry might improve after BT as previously shown in the RISA trial [
7]. In our study, this improvement in FEV
1 was only visible in the patients that responded well to BT. This correlation was also explored, but not found in an Australian cohort of severe asthma patients [
22]. An explanation can be the difference in baseline characteristics between both cohorts, with a more obstructive asthma phenotype in the Australian cohort compared to the present study (FEV
1 (% predicted) of 55% compared to 88%).
When taking all patient data into account a significant increase was found after BT in post-bronchodilator bodyplethysmography airway resistance. This increase is mainly caused by one patient, who gained 7 kg during follow-up, which could explain this outcome. Similar to Langton et al. [
23] no significant differences in FOT measurements were found after BT in our study. However, a positive correlation was found between airway and respiratory resistance measured with both bodyplethysmography and FOT and AQLQ questionnaires at baseline. For ACQ this correlation was not present. The mechanism underlying this result needs to be further explored.
An important finding of this study is the correlation between improvements on AQLQ and ACQ and respiratory resistance measured with FOT. In this study, patients with a higher respiratory resistance at baseline showed less improvements on both questionnaires after BT compared to patients with a lower resistance. Conventional spirometry and bodyplethysmography-determined airway resistance did not show this correlation. A possible explanation for this difference might be that FOT measures the respiratory resistance of the entire respiratory system, including smaller airways and surrounding tissue. Non-responding patients might be the patients with a higher resistance in surrounding tissue, potentially in the smaller distal airways which are not reached by the BT catheter. Consequently, patients with lower respiratory resistance at baseline might be the patients to select for BT treatment.
An improvement in the respiratory resistance was not observed. Other recently published studies however did show an improvement of ventilation homogeneity after BT [
24] and effects of BT on airtrapping parameters with pulmonary function tests [
22] and Computed Tomography [
25‐
27] indicating a BT-effect in the peripheral parts of the airways. To measure the resistance in the smaller airways, FOT alone is probably not sufficient. The assessment of small airways disease and/or the effect on the smaller airways of BT might be more accurate when combining multiple techniques together such as CT, FOT and/or impulse oscillometry (IOS) as currently investigated by the Atlantis study group [
28].
There are limitations to this study that need to be addressed. The results in this study are part of the TASMA study, a multicenter study, however FOT measurements were only performed in one center. Therefore the present study included patients from one center only. Although single center results, the included group was clinically heterogeneous with allergic, eosinophilic and non-allergic/non-eosinophilic patients included. Additionally, patients were referred to this center from all parts of the Netherlands, thereby decreasing the effect of environmental factors on the outcome. Another limitation is the relatively small number of included patients. Although results need to be confirmed in larger trials, this study does offer important insights that may help to improve patient selection in the future. Strong points of this study are using not only conventional methods to assess lung function parameters but also use FOT, a method known to give a more reliable result on peripheral airway resistance. Also by keeping the medication use stable during follow up, and not start tapering down, which could influence the results, strengthens the observed measurements.
Conclusion
Pulmonary function parameters, including FOT, remained stable after BT. Correlations were found between FEV1 improvement and asthma questionnaires improvement including AQLQ. Additionally, a lower respiratory resistance at baseline, measured with FOT, was associated with a favorable BT-response, which might reflect the main targeting of BT on the larger airways. These results add to understanding the mechanism of action of BT and might contribute to improved patient selection for this treatment.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.