Introduction
Methods
Evidence acquisition
-
Inclusion criteria:
-
Exclusion criteria:
Search strategy and study selection
Data extraction and analysis
Results
Reference/ year | Journal | Level of evidence | Number of patients | Age in years (median, range) | Initial procedure (number of patients) | Presenting symptoms | Time to presentation after surgery (months) (median, range) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wang et al. 2018 | Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms | 4a | 12 | 54, 40–66 | TVT (2), TOT (4), mini-invasive (4), Solyx (1), unspecified (1) | SUI; UI; dyspareunia; voiding LUTS; mesh-associated stones | 47, 10–161 |
Chan et al. 2016 | Journal of Endourology | 4a | 18 | 58, 50–60 | TVT (12); Burch/MMK (5); Bladder neck sling (1) | Voiding LUTS; pelvic pain; SUI; rUTIs; mesh-associated stones | 84, 24–132 |
Lee et al. 2017 | Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery | 4a | 22 | 55.4, 43–68 | TVT (2); TOT (16); transvaginal mesh repair for pelvic organ prolapse (4) | Voiding LUTS; haematuria; recurrent cystitis; dysuria; mesh-associated stones | 63.6, 9–113 |
Ogle et al. 2017 | Int Urogynecol J, Wiley | 4a | 10 | 58, 54–66 | TVT (4), other urethral slings (5), MMK (1) | Voiding LUTS; pelvic pain; haematuria; rUTI | 12, 1–72 |
Campobasso et al. 2014 | Int Urol Nephrol | 4a | 3 | 62, 57–65 | TVT | Voiding LUTS; haematuria; dysuria | Range: 60–120 |
Davis et al. 2012 | The Journal of Urology | 4a | 12 | 55, 47–73 | TVT (10), Burch (1), vesicopexy (1) | Voiding LUTS; SUI; rUTIs; haematuria | 19, 3–84 |
Jo et al. 2011 | Korean Journal of Urology | 4a | 23 | 51, 40–67 | TVT (8), TOT (11), mini-sling (1), unknown (3) | Voiding LUTS | 31, 2–247 |
Doumouchtsis et al. 2010 | BJUI International | 4a | 6 | 64, 49–79 | TVT (5), TOT (1) Burch (1) | Voiding LUTS; rUTIs | 84, 12–156 |
Sakalis et al. 2011 | Int Urogynecol J, Wiley | 4a | 7 | 58, 42–72 | TVT | Voiding LUTS; dysuria; haematuria; rUTI; dyspareunia | 25, 8–48 |
Frenkl et al. 2008 | Neurourology and Urodynamics | 4a | 11 | 51, 41–84 | Urethral sling, sacrocolpopexy, colposuspension | Voiding LUTS; dyspareunia; haematuria; SUI | 35, 3–185 |
Giiri et al. 2005 | The Journal of Urology | 4a | 3 | 50, 47–57 | TVT, Burch, vesicopexy | Voiding LUTS; haematuria; rUTIs | Range: 1–12 |
Hodroff et al. 2004 | The Journal of Urology | 4a | 3 | Unknown | TVT | SUI, haematuria | Range: 1–6 |
Goujon et al. 2018 | J Gynecol Obstet Hum Reprod | 4a | 13 | 58, 43–76 | TOT (8); TVT (5) | Voiding LUTS; UI; rUTI; dysuria; pelvic pain; persistent SUI; haematuria | 23, 0–127 |
Wijffels et al. 2008 | Int Urogynecol J, Wiley | 4a | 3 | 52, 44–59 | TVT | UI; SUI; rUTIs | Range: 6–14 |
Oh and Ryu 2009 | Journal of Endourology | 4a | 14 | 48, 41–64 | TVT (11), TOT (3) | Voiding LUTS; UI | 5, 0–36 |
Velemir et al. 2008 | Int Urogynecol J, Wiley | 4a | 4 | 54, 39–66 | TVT (1), TOT (1), retropubic tape inserted trans-abdominally (2) | Voiding LUTS; rUTI | 34, 2–180 |
Huwyler et al. 2008 | BJUI International | 4a | 5 | 68, 63–74 | TVT | Dyspareunia; rUTI; UI | Range: 1–18 |
Baracat et al. 2005 | CLINICS | 4a | 11 | Unknown | TVT | Voiding LUTS; rUTI | Unknown |
Foley et al. 2010 | BJUI International | 4a | 9 | 60, 38–75 | TVT (8), TOT (1) | Voiding LUTS, rUTI | 8, 2–18 |
Castroviejo-Royo et al. 2015 | Journal of Endourology | 4a | 9 | 61, 49–70 | TOT (3), mini-sling (6) | Voiding LUTS | 13,1–79 |
Demographics and clinical presentation
Site of mesh erosion
Outcomes with laser incision
Reference/ year | Number of patients | Location of mesh erosion | Type of endoscopic procedure | Follow-up duration (months) | Complications (number of patients) | Management of complications | Recurrence of mesh erosion (number of patients) | Repeat operations (number of patients) | Initial success rate | Final success rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wang et al. 2018 | 12 | U | Holmium laser | 14–70 | None reported | None | 6 | Multiple repeat procedures (1); vaginal surgery (5) | 50% | 58% |
Chan et al. 2016 | 18 | B (6) BN (4) U (8) | Holmium laser | 12–24 | Worsening SUI (7), new SUI (1), post-op UTI (2) | None | 4 | 1 Repeat procedure(3); 2 repeat procedures (1) | 78% | 100% |
Lee et al. 2017 | 22 | B (16) U (6) | Holmium laser | 23.2 | SUI (5) | None | 6 | 1 repeat procedure (5); 2 repeat procedures (1) | 73% | 100% |
Ogle et al. 2017 | 10 | B (6) U (4) | Holmium laser | 27 | SUI (3) | None | 3 | 1 Needed further procedure for SUI | 60% | 100% |
Campobasso et al. 2014 | 3 | B | Holmium laser ± endoscopic forceps | 15 | Unknown | None | 1 | 1 Recurrent mesh treated with repeat procedure | 67% | 100% |
Davis et al. 2012 | 12 | B (10) U (2) | Holmium laser (10), thulium laser (2) | 6–134 | SUI (2) | None | 5 | 1 Repeat procedure (4); open cystostomy (1) | 58% | 92% |
Jo et al. 2011 | 23 | B (20) U (3) | TUR with electrode loop (16); Holmium laser(7) | 2 | Vesicovaginal fistula following TUR with electrode (2); SUI (1) | Fistula repair | 6 | TURE: 1 Further procedure for mesh removal (1) TURH: transvaginal removal (3); repeat procedure (2) | 74% | 87% |
Doumouchtsis et al. 2010 | 6 | B (2) U(4) | Holmium laser | 12–36 | SUI (1), voiding difficulty(1) | None | 3 | 1 Needed partial cystectomy, repeat procedure (2) | 50% | 83% |
Sakalis et al. 2011 | 7 | B | Holmium laser | 12 | None reported | None | 0 | Nil | 100% | 100% |
Frenkl et al. 2008 | 11 | B (9) BN (7) U (6) | Holmium laser (4), scissors (4), endoscopic TUR (2) | Unknown | Unknown | None | 2 | Repeat procedure (2) | 82% | 100% |
Giiri et al. 2005 | 3 | B | Holmium laser | 3–12 | SUI (1) | None | 0 | Nil | 100% | 100% |
Hodroff et al. 2004 | 3 | B (2) BN (1) | Holmium laser | 1 | SUI (2) | None | 0 | Nil | 100% | 100% |
Goujon et al. 2018 | 13 | B (10) U (3) | Cystoscopy + suprapubic percutaneous access + laparoscopic scissors/holmium laser | 6 | Intra-peritoneal bladder perforation (1); retroperitoneal bladder perforation (1); vesicovaginal fistula (1) | Conversion to laparoscopy for diagnosed perforation (2); fistula repair (1) | 6 | 2 Repeat procedures (4); 5 procedures (1); 6 procedures (1) | 54% | 100% |
Wijffels et al. 2008 | 3 | U | Endoscopic scissors | Unknown | SUI (2) | None | 1 | Repeat procedure (1) | 67% | 100% |
Oh and Ryu 2009 | 14 | B | Endoscopic TUR | 3–12 Cystoscopy; 5–40 (clinical) | Vesicovaginal fistula (1); full-thickness perforation and haematoma (1); mild SUI (1); UUI (1) | Fistula repair; Surgical drainage of haematoma | 1 | Repeat procedure (1) | 93% | 100% |
Velemir et al. 2008 | 4 | U | Endoscopic TUR | 6–24 | SUI (3) | None | 2 | Repeat procedures (2) | 50% | 100% |
Huwyler et al. 2008 | 5 | B | TUR | 3–23 | SUI (1) | None | 0 | Nil | 100% | 100% |
Baracat et al. 2005 | 11 | B (6) U (5) | Bladder erosion-lap-assisted endoscopic excision; urethral erosion-endoscopic excision | 6 | SUI (3) | None | 1 | Repeat procedure (1) | 91% | 100% |
Foley et al. 2010 | 9 | B (6) U and B (3) | Endoscopic TUR or direct excision with nasal speculum | Unknown | SUI (9) | None | 4 | Repeat procedure (2); open surgery (2) | 56% | 78% |
Castroviejo-Royo et al. 2015 | 9 | B | TUR with electrode loop | 38 | None reported | None | 0 | Nil | 100% | 100% |