Background
Methods
Search strategy and protocol registration
Inclusion criteria and study selection
Data extraction and study characteristics
Results
Study selection
Characteristics of the included studies
Author, year | Study type | Target population (n) | Country/District | Cultural values | Stigma type | Measurements |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chiu et al., 2013 [17] | Quantitative study | Caregivers (211) | China | Face concern | Affiliate stigma | The Loss of Face Scale (LOS) The Affiliate Stigma Scale (AAS) |
Mirza et al., 2019 [12] | Quantitative study | Students (173) | White British and South Asians | Supernatural beliefs | Public stigma | The Beliefs About Mental Health Problems Questionnaire The Supernatural Attitudes Questionnaire (SAQ) |
Mak et al., 2015 [18] | Quantitative study | Adults (199) | China | Face concern | Self-stigma | Loss of Face (LOF), 9-item Self- Stigma Scale |
WonPat-Borja et al., 2012 [19] | Quantitative study | Chinese Americans (42) and European American (428) | the USA | Face concern and familism | Public stigma | Three items measuring eugenic attitudes and one item measuring the importance of genetics in mental health ‘three items that describe intimate social distance |
Mak & Cheung, 2012 [20] | Quantitative study | Caregivers (108) | China | Face concern | Affiliate stigma | ASS, LOS |
Chiu et al., 2015 [21] | Quantitative study | Caregivers (211) | China | Face concern | Affiliate stigma | ASS, LOS |
Griffiths et al., 2006 [22] | Quantitative study | Adults (3998 from Australia and 2000 from Japan) | Australia and Japan | Individualism | Self-stigma and Public stigma | Perceived stigma scale; Personal stigma scale |
Boge et al., 2018 [23] | Quantitative study | Adults (924) | India | Familism | Public stigma | Link’s Perceived Discrimination and Devaluation Scale (PDDS). |
Picco et al., 2016 [24] | Quantitative study | Adults (280) | Singapore | Cultural values and beliefs affect stigmatization | Self-stigma | Internalized Stigma of Mental Illness; Rosenberg’s Self Esteem Scale; Dispositional Hope Scale (DHS) |
Ran et al., 2018 [2] | Quantitative study | Adults (153) | China | Cultural values and beliefs affect stigmatization | Self-stigma | Internalized Stigma of Mental Illness; |
Mileva, Vázquez & Milev, 2013 [25] | Quantitative study | Persons with bipolar disorder (178 from Argentina and 214 from Canada) | Argentina and Canada | Cultural values and beliefs affect stigmatization | Public stigma | Inventory of Stigmatizing Experiences (ISE) |
Marquez & Ramírez, 2013 [26] | Quantitative study | Caregivers (32) | Mexican caregivers in the USA | Familismo | Affiliate stigma | Five items scale developed by Greenberg, Greenley, McKee, Brown, and Griffin-Francell (1993) |
Lin et al., 2018 [27] | Quantitative study | Mental health professionals (665) | China and the USA | Confucianism and face concern | Professional stigma | The Clinician Associative Stigma Scale (CASS) |
Pang et al., 2017 [28] | Quantitative study | Youths (940) | Singapore | Collectivism and face concern | Public stigma | The Attitudes Towards Serious Mental Illness; Social Tolerance Scale |
Haraguchi et al., 2009 [29] | Quantitative study | Rehabilitation workers (292 from Japan and 270 from China). | China and Japan | Cultural values and beliefs affect stigmatization | Public stigma | The Social Distance Scale |
Caplan et al., 2011 [30] | Quantitative study | Adults (177) | Latino immigrant in the USA | Religion and supernatural beliefs | Public stigma | Beliefs about Causes of Depression scale; Perceived stigma contained three items |
Kurumatani et al., 2004 [31] | Quantitative study | Elementary school teachers (150 from Taiwan and 129 from Japan) | Taiwan and Japan | Cultural values and beliefs affect stigmatization | Public stigma | Angermeyer and Matschinge questionnaire |
Papadopoulos, Foster & Caldwell, 2013 [32] | Quantitative study | 4 culture groups (78 Americans, 75 White-English, 77 Greek, 75 Chinese) | White-English, American, Greek, Chinese | Individualism and Collectivism | Public stigma | Community Attitudes to Mental Illness Scale; the ‘vertical-horizontal individualism-collectivism scale |
Loya, Reddy, & Hinshaw, 2010 [33] | Quantitative study | Students (74 Caucasians and 54 South Asians) | South Asian and Caucasian in the USA | Collectivism | Public stigma; Self-stigma | Social Distance Scale; Devaluation-discrimination Scale |
Tsang et al., 2007 [34] | Qualitative study | Employees (40 from Chicago, 30 from Hong Kong, and 30 from Beijing) | China and the USA | Confucianism and religions | Public stigma | N/A |
Tanaka et al., 2018 [35] | Qualitative study | People with mental illness (39) | Philippines | Religion and supernatural beliefs | Self-stigma | N/A |
Fancher et al., 2010 [36] | Qualitative study | Adults (11) | Vietnamese American in the USA | Supernatural beliefs and familism | Self-stigma | N/A |
Luo et al., 2018 [37] | Qualitative study | Medical school graduates (20) | China | Face concern | Professional stigma | N/A |
Chen et al., 2013 [38] | Qualitative study | Persons with mental illness (53) | Chinese immigrant in the USA | Face concern and familism | Self-stigma | N/A |
Han et al., 2017 [39] | Qualitative study | Participants aged from 18 to 49 (18) | Korean Immigrants in the USA | Collectivism and face concern | Public stigma | N/A |
Ramli et al., 2017 [40] | Qualitative study | Caregivers (14) | Malaysia | Religion and familism | Affiliate stigma | N/A |
Mascayano et al., 2015 [41] | Qualitative study | Persons with mental illness (20) | Chile | Familism | Self-stigma | N/A |
Alvidrez et al., 2008 [42] | Qualitative study | Mental health consumers (34) | the USA | Familism | Public stigma Self-stigma | N/A |
Interian et al., 2007 [43] | Qualitative study | Outpatient (30) | Latin America | Collectivism and familism | Public stigma | N/A |
Caplan, 2019 [44] | Qualitative study | Persons with mental illness (177) | Latinos in the USA | Supernatural beliefs | Public stigma | N/A |
Bui et al., 2018 [45] | Qualitative study | Caregivers (21) | Vietnamese in the USA | Familism and religion | Affiliate stigma | N/A |
Yang et al., 2013 [46] | Qualitative study | Individuals with psychosis (20), their relatives (15), and community respondents (15). | Chile | Familism and religion | Public stigma; Self-stigma | Perceived Devaluation-Discrimination (PDD) Scale and Internalized Stigma of Mental Illness Scale (ISMI) |
Keller et al., 2019 [47] | Qualitative study | Students (33) | the USA | Collectivism and individualism | Public stigma; Self-stigma | N/A |
Yang, 2015 [48] | Mixed-method | Caregivers (120) | China | Face concern and familism | Affiliate stigma | ASS, LOS |
Yang et al., 2014 [49] | Mixed-method | Caregivers (11) | Chinese Immigrants in the USA | Familism | Affiliate stigma | Internalized stigma scale |
Lee et al., 2005 [50] | Mixed-method | Out-patients (480) | Hong Kong | Face concern | Public stigma | Psychiatric Stigma Experience Questionnaire (PSEQ) |
Mascayano et al., 2016 [51] | Theory study(review) | Latin Americans | Latin America | Familism, and religion | Public stigma, self-stigma, affiliate stigma, and multiple stigmas | N/A |
Yang & Kleinman, 2008 [52] | Theory study | Chinese | China | Face concern | N/A | N/A |
Yang et al., 2007 [53] | Theory study | Chinese | China | Face concern | N/A | N/A |
Hanzawa, 2012 [54] | Theory study | Japanese | Japan | Confucianism and familism | Affiliate stigma | N/A |
Abdullah & Brown, 2011 [11] | Theory study(review) | Americans (different ethnicities) | the USA | N/A | N/A |
Stigma type
Public stigma
Self-stigma
Affiliate stigma
Professional stigma
Rates of stigma of mental illness
Study | Country/District | Sample | Type of Stigma | Assessment | Rate |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ran et al., 2018 [2] | Mainland China | 453 persons with schizophrenia in rural community | Self-stigma | Internalized Stigma of Mental Illness (ISMI) | Moderate to severe: 94.7% |
Picco et al., 2016 [24] | Singapore | 280 adults with mental illness | Self-stigma | Internalized Stigma of Mental Illness (ISMI) | Moderate to severe: 43.6% |
Alvidrez et al., 2008 [42] | USA | 34 African Americans with mental illness | Self-stigma | Self-report | 15–68.0% |
Mileva, Vázquez & Milev, 2013 [25] | Argentine | 178 adults with bipolar disorder | Self-stigma | Inventory of Stigmatizing Experiences (ISE) | 36.2–61.7% |
Lee et al., 2005 [50] | Hong Kong | 320 out-patients with schizophrenia | Self-stigma | Psychiatric Stigma Experience Questionnaire | Work-related stigma: 40.2–46.8%; Interpersonal stigma 27.9–68%; Concealment and anticipated stigmatization: 28.8–69.7%; |
Griffiths et al., 2006 [22] | Australia | 3998 general adults aged over 18 years | Public Stigma | Perceived stigma scale | 35.6–85.2% |
Japan | 2000 general adults aged 20 to 69 | Public Stigma | Perceived stigma scale | 30–82% 43.5% | |
Boge et al., 2018 [23] | India | 924 general adults in cities | Public stigma | Link’s Perceived Discrimination and Devaluation Scale (PDDS) | 39.7–57.7% |
Kurumatani et al., 2004 [31] | Japan | 129 Japanese elementary school teachers | Public stigma | Angermeyer and Matschinge questionnaire | 36.3% |
Taiwan | 150 Taiwanese elementary school teachers | Public stigma | Angermeyer and Matschinge questionnaire | 25.4% | |
Pang et al., 2017 [28] | Singapore | 940 general youths from schools | Public stigma | Social Tolerance Scale | 44.5% |
Cultural factors
Author, year | Main findings |
---|---|
Tsang et al., 2007 [34] | Chinese employers were more likely to perceive that people with mental illness would exhibit a weaker work ethic and less loyalty to the company. |
Tanaka et al., 2018 [35] | Fatalism could help PMHP to remain hopeful. In addition, traditional communal unity alleviated some of the social exclusion associated with stigma. |
Chiu et al., 2013 [17] | Chinese caregiving was characterized by a lack of formal support, and such cultural concerned as loss of face and strong affiliated stigma. |
Mirza et al.,2019 [12] | South Asians reported higher beliefs in supernatural causes of psychosis than White British. |
Mak et al., 2015 [18] | Role of face concerned in affecting self-stigma and mental health among Chinese with substance use problems |
Yang et al., 2007 [53] | Stigma exerted its core effects by threatening the loss or diminution of what is most at stake, or by actually diminishing or destroying that lived value. |
Fancher et al., 2010 [36] | Four themes: (1) Stigma and face; (2) Social functioning and the role of the family; (3) Traditional healing and beliefs about medications; and (4) Language and culture. |
WonPat-Borja et al., 2012 [19] | Chinese Americans endorsed all four eugenic statements more strongly than European Americans |
Luo et al., 2018 [37] | Low levels of social acceptance of individuals with mental illness among medical students in China were largely related to fears of violence of and loss of face. |
Chen et al., 2013 [38] | Participants commonly suffered from stigma after disclosure. However, half of our participants reported situations where they experienced little discriminatory treatment and some experienced support and care as a result of cultural dynamics. |
Abdullah & Brown, 2011 [11] | Cultural values are important with regard to stigma, particularly for Asian Americans and African Americans. |
Han et al., 2017 [39] | The study findings revealed stigmatized beliefs (e.g., being dangerous, out of control, and abnormal) and behaviors (e.g., social distance) toward people with mental illness, as well as cultural values that reinforced the stigma in the Korean-immigrant community. |
Yang, 2015 [48] | Caregivers with higher face concern were more likely to internalize feelings of shame, self-blame and powerlessness and suffered poorer mental health. |
Mak & Cheung, 2012 [20] | Affiliate stigma was found to serve as a partial mediator between face concern and care- giver distress and a full mediator between face concern and subjective burden. |
Ramli et al., 2017 [40] | Most Malay caregivers experienced the stigma around mental health problems regardless of the type of mental illness. |
Chiu et al., 2015 [21] | The mediating role of affective stigma was confirmed. |
Mascayano et al., 2015 [41] | A key feature shaping stigma among females was the loss of ability to fulfill family roles (i.e. take care of children). For males, cultural value of ‘Machismo’ kept them from disclosing their psychiatric diagnosis as a means to maintain social status. This is attribute to ‘Familismo’. |
Griffiths et al., 2006 [22] | Personal stigma and social distance were considerably greater among the Japanese than the Australian public, which is connected to the perception of the attitudes and discriminatory behavior of others. |
Hanzawa, 2012 [54] | persons with mental illness had greater likelihood to isolate themselves, thus refusing contact with nonfamily members. Such kinds of behaviors increased caregivers’ burden. Japanese families did not allow others to care family members with mental illness. |
Boge et al., 2018 [23] | Gender differences in cultural and societal roles and expectations could account for higher levels of perceived stigma among female participants. A higher level of perceived stigma among female participants was attributed to cultural norms and female roles within a family or broader social system. |
Interian et al., 2007 [43] | Stigma resulted in negative social outcome and caused by cultural values. |
Alvidrez et al., 2008 [42] | Concerns about stigma caused most Black Americans initially to avoid treatment; They commonly were exposed to stigmatizing reactions from others when they accepted treatment. |
Picco et al., 2016 [24] | There was a negative association between quality of life and self-stigma, which may be expressed by cultural values and beliefs. |
Ran et al., 2018 [2] | Self-stigma among persons with mental illness was pervasive and severe in rural community in China. Ongoing evaluation and measurement of stigma in the Chinese context would play a crucial role in understanding culture-specific aspects of experiencing self-stigma. |
Yang & Kleinman, 2008 [52] | Stigma was embedded in the moral experience of participants across culture. |
Mileva, Vázquez & Milev, 2013 [25] | People with bipolar disorder experienced stigma and psychosocial effects. Canadian and Argentinean societies showed different family dynamics due to diverse cultures. |
Marquez & Ramírez, 2013 [26] | Familism, folk beliefs, and shame might result in Latinos’ lower service usage. Caregivers reported that cultural beliefs acted as barriers to mental health service use among Latinos |
Lin et al., 2018 [27] | Professional stigma was considerably lower in China than in the US, possibly indicating the cultural dominance of respect for professionals over stigma towards persons with mental illness. |
Caplan, 2019 [44] | The cultural values contributed to shaping stigma but also could be an important source to cope mental illness. |
Bui et al., 2018 [45] | Religion offered an important coping strategy to persons with mental illness. Mental health education and use of less stigmatizing language might facilitate early intervention by reducing stigma. |
Pang et al., 2017 [28] | The contexts of stigma and social tolerance were different between Asian cultures and Western cultures. Chinese youths displayed higher level of ‘physical threat’ and lower level of ‘social tolerance’ than their counterparts of other ethnicities. |
Yang et al., 2014 [49] | This study pointed out an initial but crucial approach to reduce stigma of mental illness among Asian Americans who influenced by stigma powerfully role. |
Lee et al., 2005 [50] | Stigma was common, hard to prevent and devastating to people with schizophrenia. Family support was required to be realized with the emphasis on relationship bonds in Chinese societies. |
Haraguchi et al., 2009 [29] | Social distance towards schizophrenia was widely common in both Beijing and Fukuoka, but the features of social distance was not similar between them. |
Caplan et al., 2011 [30] | Latino immigrants strongly endorsed that depression was caused by both malevolent spiritual forces and psychosocial issues, reflecting that they engage in a dual system of Western-medicine and spiritual beliefs. |
Yang et al., 2013 [46] | Stigma of mental illness endangered the males’ ability to protect their family honors, and the females’ ability to become holy and pure. What’s worse, it further threatened the family ability. Development of culture-specific stigma measures played an important role in implementation of community mental health care in Latin American contexts. |
Keller et al., 2019 [47] | Individualist orientation was more common for Caucasians, collectivist orientation was more common for Native Americans, indicating that it was necessary to address culture difference during the process of formulating programme to reduce stigma of mental illness. |
Kurumatani et al., 2004 [31] | Japanese and Taiwanese displayed similar knowledge, beliefs and attitudes with regard to schizophrenia with the general public in Western countries. |
Papadopoulos, Foster & Caldwell, 2013 [32] | Individualism contributed to more positive attitudes towards mental illness, while collectivism contributed to more stigmatizing attitudes towards mental illness. |
Loya, Reddy, & Hinshaw, 2010 [33] | The South Asian students displayed greater personal stigma towards mental illness than Caucasian students, which might be influenced by South Asians cultural values which emphasize a collectivist orientation and a hierarchical and family structure. |
Mascayano et al., 2016 [51] | Stigma was common across cultures and influenced by cultures profoundly. There was significantly local difference regarding stigma in Latin American contexts. |