Findings from preclinical studies
Psychedelics such as psilocybin primarily act on the 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) 5-HT
2A receptors in the brain, leading to alterations in perception, thought, and mood [
80]. Head-twitch response (HTR) is a rapid, rotational head movement observed in rodents after administration of 5-HT
2A receptor agonists such as psilocybin and LSD. The potency of psychedelics determined via mouse HTR is highly correlated with potencies to elicit hallucinations in humans [
81]. Furthermore, HTR induced by psychedelics in mice could be blocked by potent 5-HT
2A receptor antagonists or deletion of the 5-HT
2A receptor gene [
82‐
85]. Thus, it is likely that 5-HT
2A receptor could play a role in HTR induced after administration of psychedelics. A recent study showed that the 5-HT
1A receptor agonist 8-OH DPAT attenuated psilocybin-induced HTR in mice [
86], suggesting inhibitory effects of 5-HT
1A receptor for the HTR caused by psychedelics. Furthermore, unlike esketamine and the selective NMDAR antagonist dizocilpine, psilocybin did not induce HSP-70 expression in the rat retrosplenial cortex [
87], indicating that psilocybin could be a safer option for clinical applications in comparison to esketamine.
In terms of potential antidepressant-like effects of psilocybin, the data are mixed regarding the role of 5-HT
2A receptor activation. This uncertainty arises in part from research utilizing rodents that lack depression-like behaviors, potentially limiting accurate predictions about the clinical effectiveness of antidepressant candidates [
88‐
90]. One study showed that 5-HT
2A receptor antagonist ketanserin did not block antidepressant-like effects of psilocybin in chronically stressed male mice with depression-like behaviors [
91], suggesting that altered perception may not be necessary for its antidepressant actions.
It is currently unclear if 5-HT
2A receptor can mediate antidepressant effects of psychedelics such as psilocybin, because several non-hallucinogenic analogs of psychedelics with antidepressant-like properties have been developed [
92‐
94]. In 2023, Qu and colleagues [
95] compared the effects of DOI (2,5-dimethoxy-4-iodoamphetamine: a hallucinogenic psychedelic drug with potent 5-HT
2A receptor agonism), lisuride (non-hallucinogenic psychedelic analog with 5-HT
2A and 5-HT
1A receptor agonisms), and arketamine on depression-like behavior and the decreased dendritic spine density in the brain of lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-treated mice. Both lisuride and arketamine ameliorated the increased immobility time of forced swimming test (FST), and the decreased dendritic spine density in the medial prefrontal cortex (PFC) and hippocampus of LPS-treated mice. In contrast, DOI did not improve these changes of LPS-treated mice. This study suggests that 5-HT
2A receptor may not play a major role in rapid-acting antidepressant actions of psychedelics although further detailed studies is needed. In addition, it is likely that potent 5-HT
1A receptor agonism of lisuride plays a role in a lack of HTR in rodents [
86,
95]. Unfortunately, the effects of psilocybin with antidepressant effects in depressed patients were not investigated in this study [
95].
Subsequently, Liu and colleagues [
96] reported that pretreatment (6 days before LPS) with arketamine, but not DOI and lisuride, ameliorated body weight loss, splenomegaly, the increased immobility time of FST, and the decreased expression of synaptic protein in the PFC of LPS-treated mice. Furthermore, pretreatment with arketamine, but not DOI and lisuride, significantly ameliorated the increased FST immobility time, the reduced sucrose preference in the sucrose preference test, and the decreased expression of synaptic protein in the PFC of CRS (chronic restrain stress)-exposed mice. Unlike to arketamine, both DOI and lisuride do not exhibit long-lasting prophylactic effects in mouse models of depression.
A recent study demonstrated that LSD and psilocin, the primary metabolite of psilocybin, bind directly to TrkB (a receptor for brain-derived neurotrophic factor [BDNF]), exhibiting affinities that are 1,000-fold higher than those of other antidepressants [
97]. Furthermore, the study revealed that psychedelics and antidepressants bind to distinct, yet partially overlapping, sites within the transmembrane domain of TrkB dimers [
97]. Given the established importance of BDNF–TrkB signaling in the rapid and sustained antidepressant-like effects observed with ketamine and arketamine [
44,
46,
49,
98‐
101], these findings are particularly intriguing. They suggest that high-affinity TrkB positive allosteric modulators, which do not activate the 5-HT
2A receptor, may maintain the antidepressant potential of psychedelics without inducing hallucinogenic effects [
102]. Consequently, there is an ongoing debate over the role of 5-HT
2A receptor in the antidepressant actions of psychedelics such as psilocybin.
Findings from clinical studies
The unique subjective experiences induced by psychedelics like psilocybin are characterized by phenomena such as ego dissolution (loss of self-awareness), indescribable insights, and a profound sense of unity and connection with others (Fig.
2) [
36,
103‐
105]. Psilocybin, upon ingestion, is converted by the body into psilocin (4-hydroxy-
N,N-dimethyltryptamine: 4-hydroxy DMT), the pharmacologically active compound, which predominantly binds to the 5-HT
2A receptor (Fig.
2).
The hallucinogenic effects of psychedelics like psilocybin and LSD in health volunteers are known to be mediated by the 5-HT
2A receptor, as evidenced by the fact that these effects can be inhibited by the 5-HT
2A receptor antagonist ketanserin [
106‐
108]. A study employing positron emission tomography (PET) revealed a strong correlation between the intensity of psychedelic experiences, 5-HT
2A receptor occupancy, and plasma psilocin levels [
109]. Thus, activation of the 5-HT
2A receptor is likely a contributing factor to the hallucinogenic effects of psychedelics in humans. Research showed that a strong of oceanic boundlessness, akin to mystical-type experiences, under psilocybin was predictive of an antidepressant response in TRD patients (
n = 20) [
110]. This suggests that the nature of the acute mystical experiences plays a crucial role in mediating the long-term antidepressant effects. However, it remains uncertain whether 5-HT
2A receptor activation also plays a role in the potential antidepressant actions of psychedelics.
In 2022, Gukasyan and colleagues [
111] conducted a 12-month prospective follow-up study examining the effectiveness and safety of psilocybin-assisted therapy for patients with severe MDD (
n = 24). Significant reductions from baseline in HAMD scores were noted at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months. At the 12-month mark, the treatment response (defined as a greater than 50% reduction in HAMD score from baseline) was 75%, and remission rate was 58%. Notably, participants’ reports of personal meaning, spiritual experiences, and mystical experiences following sessions were linked to enhanced well-being at 12 months, yet these did not correlate with improvement in depression. In a comprehensive naturalistic study, involving individuals (
n = 302) who planned to undergo a psychedelic experience, several factors were found to significantly influence changes in depressive symptoms [
112]. These factors included the individuals’ medicinal motivations, their history of previous psychedelic use, the dosage of the drug, and the nature of the acute psychedelic experience, particularly the occurrence of an emotional breakthrough [
112]. Moreover, a placebo-controlled, double-blind, randomized trial revealed that the subjective effects experienced from a single dose of psilocybin in MDD patients (n = 52) were not associated with a reduction in depressive symptoms two weeks after treatment [
113].
In a 2023 exploratory placebo-controlled study involving moderate to severe patients (
N = 19) with MDD, improvements in depression and anxiety were observed following both placebo and psilocybin treatments, with no significant differences between the two groups [
114]. The psilocybin treatment showed high response (66.7%) and remission rates (46.7%). However, the intensity of mystical experiences during psilocybin administration did not correlate with subsequent antidepressant effects [
114]. Therefore, it appears unlikely that psilocybin-induced mystical experiences contribute to its antidepressant effects in MDD patients, although it is important to note the sample sizes of these studies.
In 2023, Rosenblat and colleagues [
115] reported a groundbreaking case: an adult with TRD who received psilocybin therapy following premedication with trazodone, a potent 5-HT
2A receptor antagonist. This case raises the possibility that the antidepressant effects of psilocybin may not solely depend on 5-HT
2A receptor activation or its psychedelic properties. However, further research is necessary to fully understand the role of 5-HT
2A receptor activation and its psychedelic impact in antidepressant mechanism of psychedelics like psilocybin.
To delve deeper into the role of the 5-HT
2A receptor in psilocybin’s antidepressant effects, a comprehensive study design is proposed: a double-blind, randomized controlled trial comparing the effects of psilocybin with and without the 5-HT
2A receptor antagonists such as ketanserin and volinanserin (MDL 100,907). Additionally, a similar ongoing study (NCT05710327) is examining the effects of psilocybin (25 mg) combined with risperidone (1 mg), which blocks dopamine D
2 and 5-HT
2A receptors, in TRD patients [
116].
There are currently a limited number of studies indicating the antidepressant effects of LSD and DMT in patients with MDD. A randomized, placebo-controlled crossover study found that LSD treatment (200 μg across two sessions) significantly alleviated anxiety and depressive symptoms in patients (
n = 42), some of whom had a life-threatening illness [
117]. Notably, positive acute subjective drug effects and mystical-type experiences in the first session correlated with long-term reductions in anxiety symptoms [
117]. Another randomized, placebo-controlled crossover study revealed that a low dose of LSD (26 μg) decreased depressive scores in depressed patients, albeit with various subjective effects [
118]. Additionally, an open-label study reported that a single dose of ayahuasca produced rapid antidepressant effects in six inpatients with depression [
119]. More recently, an open-label study demonstrated that DMT treatment (initially 0.1 mg/kg, followed by 0.3 mg/kg) lowered depressive scores in seven MDD patients, though it increased blood pressure, heart rate, anxiety, psychedelic, and psychotomimetic effects [
120]. Given the scarcity of research, the extent to which mystical experiences induced by LSD or DMT contribute to their antidepressant effects in depressed patients remains uncertain.
Furthermore, recent studies have highlighted non-hallucinogenic compound lisuride, which shows antidepressant-like effects in preclinical models [
95,
121]. A notable study from Japan demonstrated that lisuride maleate (0.075 mg/day over 12 weeks) improved depressive symptoms in patients suffering from post-stroke depression [
122]. This study demonstrated that the antidepressant effects of lisuride in these patients do not have a rapid onset. Given lisuride’s established use in treating Parkinson’s disease, it is intriguing to consider its potential in treating MDD patients.