Introduction
Early clinical observations
Twentieth-century clinical reports
Author(s), year | N | Age, sex | NPs onset | DD | Bulbar signs | EPD | Cognitive deficits | Behavioral alterations | Post-mortem histological findings | In vivo exams | Familial elements |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Oppenheim and Siemerling 1886 [80] | 5 | NA | – | NA | All: + | – | All: cognitive efficiency | All: PBA | All: widespread atrophy | NA | – |
Marie 1887 [66] | 1 | 31, M | – | 23 mo | + | – | Cognitive efficiency | PBA | NA | NA | – |
Tranquilli 1890 [105] | 1 | 45, M | – | 3 y | + | – | Memory | PBA | NA | – | |
Marie 1892 [65] | 2 | NA | + | P1: 10 y. P2: 13 y | NA | NA | P1 and P2: cognitive efficiency | P1 and P2: psychosis | NA | NA | – |
Watanabe 1893 [115] | 1 | 41, M | – | NA | + | – | Language | Disinhibition | NA | NA | – |
Sarbó 1898 [95] | 1 | 55, M | + | 2 y | + | – | Cognitive efficiency | PBA | Widespread atrophy | NA | – |
Franceschi 1902 [39] | 1 | 56, M | + | 1 y | + | – | – | Depression Anosognosia Disinhibition PBA | F | NA | – |
Haenel 1903 [49] | 1 | 45, F | – | 5 mo | + | – | – | Disinhibition | Widespread atrophy | NA | – |
Mass 1904 [68] | 2 | P1: 29, M P2: 26, F | – | NA | + | + | P2: cognitive efficiency | P1 and P2: disinhibition | NA | NA | + |
Raymond and Cestan 1905 [91] | 1 | 36, M | NA | 28 mo | + | – | – | Depression Anosognosia | NA | NA | – |
Cullerre 1906 [29] | 5 | P1: 47 M P2: 44 M P3: 50, M P4: 2 M P5: 49, M | P1, P2, P4, P5: + | P1: 1 y P2, P3, P5: NA; P4: 3 y | P1, P2, P3, P5: + | – | P1, P3: – P2: memory, cognitive efficiency P4: cognitive efficiency P5: cognitive efficiency | P1: psychosis, depression, eating behavior, anosognosia P2: depression, psychosis P3: depressionP4: psychosis, PBA P5: psychosis | NA | NA | P1: + (epilepsy) |
Resegotti 1907 [92] | 1 | 40, M | – | 2 y | + | – | Executive functioning | PBA | Widespread atrophy | NA | – |
Fragnito 1907 [37] | 3 | P1: 53, M P2: 44, M P3: 41, M | – | P1: 1 y P2: 3 y P3: NA | P1: + P2: + P3: | P1: – P2: P3: | P1: orientation, memory P2: executive functioning, memory P3: disorientation, memory, executive functioning | P1: depression, apathy P2: apathy, anosognosia P3: apathy, anosognosia, psychosis, depression | NA | NA | P2: + (epilepsy) P3: + (stroke) |
Gentile 1909 [42] | 2 | P1: 54, M P2: 20, M | – | NA | P1 and P2: + | – | P1 and P2: cognitive efficiency, executive functioning, memory | P1: depression | NA | NA | – |
Fernàndez 1908 [35] | 1 | 51, M | – | NA | + | – | Executive functioning | Depression | NA | NA | + (stroke) |
Astwazaturow 1911 [6] | 1 | 50, M | – | 12 y | – | – | – | Depression Psychosis | NA | NA | – |
Barrett 1913 [8] | 1 | 35, F | + | 5 y | + | – | Cognitive efficiency, orientation Language | Disinhibition Depression PBA | Widespread atrophy; AD | NA | – |
Marchand and Dupouy 1914 [64] | 1 | 44, M | + | NA | – | – | Cognitive efficiency, memory | Depression | NA | NA | – |
Martini 1916 [67] | 3 | P1: 26 M P2: 39 M | – | NA | – | P1 and P2: + P3: – | P1: executive functioning P2: – P3: executive functioning, cognitive efficiency | P1: PBA P2: PBA, depression P3: PBA, depression, disinhibition | NA | NA | – |
Fragola 1918 [38] | 1 | 57, M | + | 2 y | + | + | Memory | Psychosis Depression Anxiety PBA | F-P (L > R) | NA | – |
Büscher 1922 [19] | 1 | 42, M | + | 16 mo | + | + | Memory | Disinhibition | F | NA | – |
Gerber and Naville 1921 [44] | 1 | 43, M | – | 3 y | + | – | – | Depression, disinhibition, anosognosia | F | NA | – |
Tscherning 1921 [108] | 1 | 30, M | – | NA | – | – | – | Psychosis | NA | NA | + |
Matzdorff 1925 [69] | 1 | 38, M | – | 4 y | + | + | – | – | P1: F | NA | – |
Tretiakoff and Amorin 1924 [106] | 1 | 25, F | + | 1 y | + | – | Memory Executive functioning | Apathy | – | NA | – |
Van Bogaert 1925 [109] | 10 | P1: 47, F P2: 68, F P3: 62, F P4: 64, M P5: 34, M P6: 42, F P7: 63, F P8: 34, M P9: 57, F P10: 52, M | P3 and P4: + M P6 and P7: + | NA | P2, P3, P4, P8, P9, P19: + | – | P1: – P2: – P3: – P4: cognitive efficiency P5: memory, cognitive efficiency P6: – P7: cognitive efficiency P8: memory, cognitive efficiency P9: memory, orientation P10: – | P1: depression, disinhibition P2: depression, apathy P3: depression P4: depression, disinhibition P5: disinhibition, apathy P6: disinhibition P7: depression, apathy P8: disinhibition, psychosis P9: apathy, disinhibition P10: depression | NA | NA | – |
Westphal 1925 [118] | 2 | P1: 46, M P2: 43, M | – | NA | + | + | – | Psychosis | NA | NA | – |
Meyer 1929 [72] | 1 | 55, M | + | 9 mo | + | – | Memory | Disinhibition Apathy OCD psychosis | F; sub-cortical | NA | – |
Ottonello 1929 [81] | 5 | P1: 46, F P2: 44, M P3: 30, M P4: 40, M P5: 50, F | P2: + | P1, P2, P3: NA P4: 2 y P5: 2 ½ y | P1, P3, P4, P5: + | All: – | All: – | P1: depression, PBA P2: depression P3: PBA P4: PBA P5: disinhibition; psychosis | NA | NA | P5: + (stroke) |
Ziegler 1930 [125] | 2 | 51, M 59, F | P2: + | P1: 1 y P2: 3 y | All: + | – | P1: cognitive efficiency P2: cognitive efficiency, memory | P1: disinhibition, PBA P2: psychosis | NA | NA | – |
Munch-Petersen 1931 [77] | 3 | P1: 20, F P2: 20, F P3: 30, F | – | NA | P1: + P2 and P3: – | – | P2: cognitive efficiency | P1: disinhibition P3: psychosis | NA | NA | + |
Von Braunmùhl 1932 [113] | 1 | 40, M | + | 2 y | – | – | Executive functioning, cognitive efficiency | Disinhibition Psychosis | T; Pick’s | NA | – |
Wechsler and Davidson 1932 [116] | 1 | 38, M | + | 2.2 y | + | – | Memory Attention Language | Psychosis Depression Apathy PBA | F | NA | – |
Teichmann 1935 [103] | 1 | 43, M | + | 16 mo | – | – | – | Depression, psychosis | Sub-cortical; cerebellar | NA | – |
Gozzano 1936 [48] | 2 | P1: 42, M P1: 40, M | + – | 3 y 2 y | + – | – – | P1: + P2: memory | P1: PBA, apathy P2: anosognosia, apathy | F | NA | P2: + (psychiatric) |
Miskolczy and Csermely 1939 [76] | 1 | 64, M | + | 5 y | – | – | Language Cognitive efficiency | Eating behavior | Pick’s L > R F-T | EEG: F-T | + (psychiatric) |
Androp 1940 [5] | 1 | 55, M | – | 6 y | – | – | Cognitive efficiency | Psychosis | F-P–T | NA | – |
Friedrich 1940 [41] | 1 | 35, M | – | 3 y | – | – | Memory | Depression, disinhibition | F; Pick’s | NA | + |
Meller 1940 [71] | 1 | 59, M | + | NA | – | – | – | Psychosis, disinhibition | NA | – | |
Tirico 1940 [104] | 1 | 42, M | + | NA | + | – | Memory, language, orientation | Psychosis | NA | NA | – |
Von Bagh 1941 [112] | 30 | NA | NA | NA | NA | + | NA | NA | 6 pts.: F 11 pts: T 13 pts.: F-T 9 pts: P | NA | – |
De Caro 1941 [31] | 1 | NA, M | + | NA | + | – | Cognitive efficiency, language, visuo-spatial | PBA | F-P (L > R); sub-cortical | NA | – |
Raithel 1941 [89] | 1 | – | + | NA | – | – | – | Psychosis | – | NA | + |
Tronconi 1941 [107] | 1 | 58, M | + | NA | + | – | Orientation, memory, attention, language | PBA | F; T (L); sub-cortical; Pick’s | NA | – |
Van Reeth et al. 1961 [110] | 1 | 52, M | + | 6 y | – | – | Executive functioning, memory Praxis | Eating behavior, disinhibition | F-T (+ T); CC; OFC | PEG: F | – |
Bartoloni and D’Angelo 1947 [9] | 4 | P1: 53, F P2: 52, M P3: 50, M P4: 44, F | P4: + | P1: 3 y P2: NA P3: 6 y P4: 4 y | P1: – P2: + P3: + P4: – | – | P1: – P2: attention P3: attention P4: attention | P1: depression P2: disinhibition P3: depression, anxiety P4: disinhibition; psychosis | P1: F; sub-cortical P2: F-T; sub-cortical P3: F-P; sub-cortical P4: F; sub-cortical | NA | – |
Friedlander and Kesert 1948 [40] | 1 | 50, M | + | 3 y | + | – | Language, cognitive efficiency, executive functioning | Disinhibition, psychosis | NA | NA | – |
Bartoloni 1950 [10] | 1 | 58, M | + | 11 y | + | – | Executive functioning, memory | Disinhibition, apathy, anosognosia | NA | NA | – |
Robertson 1953 [94] | 1 | 69, F | – | 13 mo | + | – | Memory, language, orientation, executive functioning, attention | Disinhibition, apathy, psychosis | F-T | NA | + |
Léchelle et al. 1954 [61] | 1 | 44, M | + M | 3 y | + | – | Memory, language | Disinhibition | Pick’s; F | NA | – |
Michaux et al. 1955 [73] | 2 | P1 and P2: 58 | All: + M | P1 and P2: 2 y | P1 and P2: + | – | P1: cognitive efficiency, language, praxis, visuo-spatial P2: language; praxis; visuo-spatial; memory | P1: disinhibition | P1: F-P–T (L > R) | P1: EEG and CSF: negative | – |
Corsino and Lugaresi 1956 [28] | 2 | P1: 49, M P2: 53, M | P1: + | P1 and P2: NA | P1 and P2: + | – | – | P1: psychosis, depression P2: apathy, depression, PBA | NA | NA | – |
Levi 1958 [62] | 1 | 53, F | – | 2 | + | – | Cognitive efficiency, attention, memory, executive functioning | Disinhibition, depression, anxiety, psychosis | Widespread atrophy; sub-cortical | CSF: negative | – |
Bonaretti 1959 [12] | 2 | P1: 67, M P2: 66, M | All: + | P1: 3 y P2: NA | P1: + | P1: attention, executive functioning, calculation, orientation, memory, cognitive efficiency P2: memory, orientation, cognitive efficiency | P1: disinhibition, PBA, depression P2: apathy, PBA, depression | NA | NA | – | |
Campanella and Bigi 1959 [21] | 1 | 60, M | – | 20 y | – | – | Attention, executive functioning, memory, cognitive efficiency, praxis | Apathy, anosognosia, disinhibition | NA | NA | + |
Delay et al. 1959 [33] | 2 | P1: 57, F P2: 61, M | – | P1: 2 y P2: 3 y | All: + | – | P1: cognitive efficiency, attention, executive functioning, orientation P2: language | P1: psychosis, disinhibition, PBA P2: psychosis | P1: F-T P2: F, T, P, O | NA | – |
Gentili and Volterra 1960 [43] | 4 | P1: 51, F P2: 63, F P3: 56, F P4: 48, F | All: + | P1, P3: 18 mo P2: 1 y P4: 4 ½ y | All: + | – | P1: attention, language, cognitive efficiency P2: attention, language, orientation, cognitive efficiency P3: cognitive efficiency P4: language, memory, calculation | P1: apathy, disinhibition P2: apathy, disinhibition P3: apathy P4: depression | NA | P1: CSF: negative EEG: widespread abnormalities PEG: widespread atrophy P2: CSF: negative EEG: widespread abnormalities PEG: F P3: EEG: widespread abnormalities PEG: widespread atrophy | – |
Hanau 1960 [51] | 1 | 45, M | + | NA | + | – | Memory, attention, cognitive efficiency | Apathy | NA | PEG: F EEG: negative | – |
Smith 1960 [98] | 7 | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA | All: F-P; subcortical | NA | – |
Vella and Mariani 1960 [111] | 1 | 43, M | M + | + | PBA, disinhibition, anxiety, depression, apathy | NA | NA | – | |||
Myrianthopoulos and Smith 1960 [78] | 1 | 66, M | + | 5 y | + | – | Memory, cognitive efficiency | Depression | P | NA | – |
Parnitzke and Seidel 1961 [82] | 2 | P1: 16, M P2: 18, M | – | NA | – | – | – | Psychosis, depression | NA | NA | + |
Alliez and Roger 1963 [4] | 1 | 60, M | + | 2 y | + | + | Cognitive efficiency | – | NA | EEG: widespread | – |
Poppe and Tennstedt 1963 [87] | 2 | P1: 50, M P2: 65, F | All: + | NA | – | – | P1 and P2: memory, cognitive efficiency, orientation, language | P1 and P2: depression, psychosis | P1 and P2: widespread atrophy; AD + Pick’s | NA | – |
Pisseri 1963 [86] | 1 | 70, M | + | NA | – | – | Cognitive efficiency, language | Apathy, disinhibition, psychosis | NA | NA | + (psychosis) |
Beau 1964 [11] | 1 | 22, M | + | NA | – | + | Language | Depression, psychosis | NA | EEG and CSF: negative | – |
Von Matt 1964 [114] | 1 | 57, F | + M | 6 mo | + | – | Memory, language, cognitive efficiency | Disinhibition, apathy | Widespread atrophy | NA | + (psychosis) |
de Morsier 1967 [32] | 1 | 52, M | + | 7 y | + | – | Attention, memory, language | Depression, anxiety, OCD, psychosis | F-T (T +); Pick’s; subcortical | NA | – |
Caidas 1966 [20] | 1 | 60, M | + M | 1 y | + | + | Cognitive efficiency, memory | Psychosis | F; sub-cortical | NA | – |
Chateau et al. 1966 [24] | 1 | 57, F | – | 3 y | – | Memory, orientation | – | F-T atrophy | EEG: widespread abnormalities CFS: negative PEG: widespread atrophy | – | |
Boudouresques et al. 1967 [14] | 1 | 54, M | + | 40 m | + | + | Attention, memory | – | F-T (F +); sub-cortical | PEG: positive (F, subcortical) EEG and CSF: negative | + |
Bonduelle 1975 [13] | 2 | P1: 65, M P2: 59, F | – | P1: 2 y P2: 3 y | All: + | All: + | P1: memory, cognitive efficiency P2: orientation, memory, calculation | P1: disinhibition P2: disinhibition, apathy | P1: F, sub-cortical P2: F-T (F > T), subcortical; AD | P1: EEG and CSF: negative; normal P2: EEG: widespread abnormalities; CSF: negative | |
Dazzi and Finizio 1969 [30] | 3 | P1: NA, F P2: 53, M P3: 47, F | P1: + M | P1: NA P2: 1 y P3: 1 y | All: + | – | P1: cognitive efficiency P2: orientation, memory, attention, language, cognitive efficiency P3: – | P1: psychosis, disinhibition P2: – P3: PBA | NA | P1: NA P2: CT and CSF: negative P3: CT, EEG and CSF: negative | All: + |
Minauf and Jellinger 1969 [74] | 1 | 64, F | – | 2 y | + | – | – | – | Pick’s; T | NA | – |
Yuasa 1970 [122] | 1 | 54, F | + | 2 y | + | – | Cognitive efficiency | – | Pick’s F | EEG: widespread abnormalities PEG: F | – |
Allen et al. 1971 [3] | 1 | 56, M | + M | 13 mo | + | Memory, praxis | Psychosis | F-T; subcortical; CJD-like | EEG: CJD-like | – | |
Yvonneau et al. 1971 [123] | 2 | P1: 50, M P2: 65, M | All: + | NA | P1: + | – | P1 and P2: cognitive efficiency | P1: apathy, disinhibition P2: anxiety, disinhibition, psychosis | P1: widespread atrophy; subcortical | NA | + |
Yase et al. 1972 [121] | 1 | 32, M | + | 11 y | + | + | – | Depression, psychosis, apathy, disinhibition | Widespread atrophy; sub-cortical; AD | EEG: P | – |
Finlayson et al. 1973 [36] | 2 | P1: 60, M P2: 52, M | P1: + M P3: + | P1: 30 mo P2: 3 y | P1 and P2: + | – | P1: memory P2: cognitive efficiency, attention, praxis, visuo-spatial | P1: disinhibition P2: disinhibition, PBA | P1 and P2: F-T; sub-cortical | NA | + |
Kaiya 1974 [57] | 2 | P1: 45, M P2: 61, M | All: + | P1: 20 mo P2: 3.5 y | + | – | P1 and P2: cognitive efficiency, orientation | P1 and P2: disinhibition | P1 and P2: widespread atrophy | NA | P1: + (intellectual disabilities) |
La Maida et al. 1974 [60] | 1 | 39, M | + | NA | – | + | Language, attention | Depression, Apathy | NA | NA | + (depression) |
Sherratt 1974 [97] | 1 | 53, M | + | NA | – | – | Calculation Executive functioning | Disinhibition, anxiety | NA | EEG: CJD-like | – |
Kurachi et al. 1979 [59] | 1 | 48, M | + M | 15 m | + | – | Memory, cognitive efficiency | Disinhibition, anxiety | T (R > L); cerebellar; sub-cortical; Pick’s | NA | – |
Pinsky et al. 1975 [84] | 1 | 50, F | – | 5 y | + | – | Memory, language, cognitive efficiency | Apathy | F-T (+ T); sub-cortical | NA | + |
Hart et al. 1977 [52] | 1 | 56, F | + M | 19 mo | – | – | Memory, language | Apathy | F-T | EEG: widespread | – |
Ferguson and Boller 1977 [34] | 2 | P1: 68, M P2: 66, M | – | P1: 2 y P2: 3 y | + | – | P1: calculation, language P2: language | – | P1: F-P P2: NA | P1: EEG, CT, CSF: negative P2: EEG, CT: negative | – |
Brion 1980 [15] | 1 | 59, M | + | 5 y | + | – | Cognitive efficiency, memory, executive functioning | Eating behavior, disinhibition, apathy | T (R > L) | PEG: F-T (R > L) | – |
Burnstein 1981 [17] | 1 | 55, F | – | 5 y | – | – | Memory, language, visuo-spatial | Psychosis, depression, anxiety, apathy | F-T | CSF: normal EEG: T | + |