Background
Rational
Antecedent-focused and response-focused emotion regulation
Neural basis of emotion regulation
Implicit and explicit emotion regulation
Objectives
Methods
Results
Maintenance of emotions
Study | Age | Medication | Paradigm | Dependent variables | Results behavioral | Results neural |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Adults | Yes | Task: Emotional working memory task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I, remitted (n = 29) HC (n = 30) | Behavioral: Performance in the emotion working memory task | Maintaining negative emotions: BD-I < HC Maintaining positive emotions: NS | X |
Regulating emotions via distraction
Study | Age | Medication | Paradigm | Dependent variables | Results behavioral | Results neural |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ladouceur et al. (2013) | Adolescents | No | Task: N-back task with emotional distractors Valence: Negative, positive Participants: HBO (n = 15) HC (n = 16) | Behavioral: Performance in n-back task Neural: fMRI, PPI Regions of interest: Amygdala, Ventral Striatum, ventrolateral prefrontal cortex (VLPFC), DLPFC, and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) PPI seed: VLPFC PPI targets: Amygdala, DLPFC | Distraction from emotional distractors: NS | During distraction from emotional distractors: Right VLPFC: happy: Risk group > HC Right VLPFC: fearful: NS PPI during distraction from emotional distractors: VLPFC – Amygdala (positive connectivity) Fearful: HC > Risk group (right amygdala) Happy: HC > Risk group (left amygdala) Neutral: HC vs. Risk group: NS Right VLPFC – left DLPFC (positive connectivity) Fearful: HC vs. Risk group: NS Happy: HC > Risk group Neutral: HC vs. Risk group: NS |
Kanske et al. (2013) | Adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: High HPS scores (n = 22) FDR (n = 17) HC (n = 22, n = 17) | Behavioral: Performance in the distraction task Neural: fMRI | RT (mental arithmetic task): NS | During distraction: HC vs. Risk groups: NS |
Heissler et al. (2014) | Young adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: High HPS scores (n = 22) HC (n = 24) | Behavioral: Self-report (during and after the task) Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Emotions reactivity: Amygdala, subgenual ACC, VMPFC, occipital and ventral temporal cortices, thalamus Emotion regulation: OFC, DLPFC, DMPFC, dACC, parietal cortex, precuneus | Rating after the experiment: Risk group > HC Viewing condition: NS Emotion regulation: NS Performance in the mental arithmetic task: NS | Viewing: Negative vs. neutral: Right Amygdala: Risk group > HC Positive vs. neutral: NS Distraction vs. viewing: Negative: NS Positive: left inferior parietal cortex: Risk group > HC |
Kanske et al. (2015) | Adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: FDR (n = 17) HC (n = 17) | Behavioral: Self-report during and after the task Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Bilateral OFC, dorsolateral (DLPFC, middle frontal) and dorsomedial prefrontal (DMPFC, superior medial), anterior cingulate (ACC), and parietal cortex (inferior, superior) | Rating after the experiment: Risk group > HC (all pictures more positive) Viewing: Positive: Risk group < HC Negative: NS Distraction: NS | Viewing: NS Distraction vs. viewing: NS |
Study | Age | Medication | Paradigm | Dependent variables | Results behavioral | Results neural |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Caseras et al. (2015) | Adults | Yes | Task: N-back task with emotional distractors Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I, euthymic (n = 16) BD-II, euthymic (n = 19) HC (n = 20) | Behavioral: Performance in n-back task Neural: fMRI, PPI, DTI Regions of interest: DLPFC, amygdala, and accumbens PPI seed: DLPFC PPI targets: Amygdala, accumbens | RT (2-back vs. 0-back): BD-I > BD-II and HC Slowing due to distractors in 2-back task: BD-I > BD-II and HC RT in 2-back without distractors: BD-I > HC BD-II vs. HC: NS RT in the 2-back task (no distractor vs. emotional distractor): BD-I: Fear > no distractor Happy > no distractor BD-II: NS HC: Fear > no distractor Neutral > no distractor | 2-back (no distractor) vs. 0-back (no distractor): Working memory network: BD-I > BD-II and HC 2-back task (distractor vs. no distractor): DLPFC: Fear: BD-II > BD-I > HC Happy: BD-I > BD-II and HC Neutral: HC > BD-I Amygdala: Fear: BD-II > BD-I > HC Happy: BD-I > BD-II > HC Neutral: BD-I > HC Accumbens: Fear: BD-I and BD-II > HC Happy: BD-I > BD-II and HC Neutral: BD-I > HC Functional connectivity: DLPFC-Amygdala Fear: BD-II > BD-I and HC DLPFC-Accumbens NS Structural integrity: Left uncinate fasciculus: NS Right uncinate fasciculus: BD-I < BD-II and HC |
Kanske et al. (2013) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I, euthymic (n = 22) HC (n = 22) | Behavioral: Performance in the distraction task Neural: fMRI | RT in the mental arithmetic task: BD-I > HC | During distraction: Right parietal cortex: BD-I > HC |
Kanske et al. (2015) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I, euthymic (n = 22) HC (n = 22) | Behavioral: Self-report during and after the task Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Bilateral OFC, dorsolateral (DLPFC, middle frontal) and dorsomedial prefrontal (DMPFC, superior medial), anterior cingulate (ACC), and parietal cortex (inferior, superior) | Self-report: Rating after the experiment: NS Viewing: Positive: NS Negative: NS Distraction: NS | Viewing: NS Distraction vs. viewing: NS |
Distraction in people at risk for BD
Distraction in euthymic patients
Regulating emotions via reappraisal
Study | Age | Medication | Paradigm | Dependent variables | Results behavioral | Results neural |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Heissler et al. (2014) | Young adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: High HPS scores (n = 22) HC (n = 24) | Behavioral: Self-report during and after the task Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Emotions reactivity: Amygdala, subgenual ACC, VMPFC, occipital and ventral temporal cortices, thalamus; Emotion regulation: OFC, DLPFC, DMPFC, dACC, parietal cortex, precuneus | Rating after the experiment: Arousal: Risk group > HC Viewing condition: NS Reappraisal: NS | Viewing: Negative vs. neutral: Right Amygdala: Risk group > HC Positive vs. neutral: NS Reappraisal vs. viewing: Negative: Right Amygdala: Risk group > HC Positive: NS |
Kanske et al. (2015) | Adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: FDR (n = 17) HC (n = 17) | Behavioral: Self-report during and after the task Neural: fMRI, PPI Regions of interest: Bilateral OFC, dorsolateral (DLPFC, middle frontal) and dorsomedial prefrontal (DMPFC, superior medial), anterior cingulate (ACC), and parietal cortex (inferior, superior) PPI seed: Amygdala PPI targets: OFC, dorsolateral (DLPFC, middle frontal) and dorsomedial prefrontal (DMPFC, superior medial), anterior cingulate (ACC) and parietal cortex (inferior, superior) | Rating after the experiment: Risk group > HC (all pictures more positive) Viewing: Positive: Risk group < HC Negative: NS Reappraisal: Risk group < HC | Viewing: NS Reappraisal vs. viewing: Amygdala: Risk group > HC PPI: Left amygdala/bilateral OFC: HC, negative connectivity; Risk group, positive connectivity Right amygdala/right OFC: HC, negative connectivity; Risk group, positive connectivity |
Ajaya et al. (2016) | Young adults | No | Task: Videogame task Valence: Negative Participants: Undergraduates (n = 66) | Behavioral: self-reported affect, facial expressions Psychophysiology: Respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) | Higher HPS scores increased RSA during ER (only in the deliberated reappraisal condition) | X |
Study | Age | Medication use | Paradigm | Dependent variables | Results behavioral | Results neural |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rive et al. (2015) | Adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I/BD-II, currently depressed (n = 9) BD-I/BD-II, remitted (n = 26) HC (n = 36) | Behavioral: Self-report Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Amygdala, thalamus, insula, DLPFC, ACC, medial PFC, and hippocampus | ER success in depressed groups: Happy: UDd < HC BDd vs. HC: n.s. differences Happy vs. sad: BDd: happy > sad HC: happy vs. sad: NS | Depressive state: Reappraisal of happiness vs. reappraisal of sadness: rACC: BDd > UDd |
Morris et al. (2012) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative Participants: BD-I (n = 13) (six BD patients met criteria for euthymia and five met criteria for hypomania) HC (n = 15) | Behavioral: Self-report Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Amygdala, cortico-lymbic areas with activity during ER Coupling seed: Amygdala Coupling targets: Whole brain | Self-report of emotions: HC: Increase > Maintain > Decrease BD: Increase > Maintain BD: Maintain v.s. Decrease: NS | Down regulation: Right VLPFC: BD > HC Up regulation: Right VLPFC: BD > HC Rostral ACC: BD > HC Inverse coupling of left PFC (especially left IFG) and amygdala found in HC did not occur in BD |
Study | Age | Medication use | Paradigm | Dependent variables | Results behavioral | Results neural |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kanske et al. (2015) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I, euthymic (n = 22) HC (N = 22) | Behavioral: Self-report during and after the task Neural: fMRI, PPI Regions of interest: Bilateral OFC, dorsolateral (DLPFC, middle frontal) and dorsomedial prefrontal (DMPFC, superior medial), anterior cingulate (ACC), and parietal cortex (inferior, superior) PPI seed: Amygdala PPI targets: OFC, dorsolateral (DLPFC, middle frontal) and dorsomedial prefrontal (DMPFC, superior medial), anterior cingulate (ACC) and parietal cortex (inferior, superior) | Rating after the experiment: NS Viewing: NS Reappraisal: NS | Viewing: NS Reappraisal vs. viewing: Amygdala: BD-I > HC Parahippocampal: BD-I > HC PPI during reappraisal: Left amygdala/right OFC HC negative connectivity, BD-I positive connectivity Left amygdala/ventral ACC: HC negative connectivity, BD-I positive connectivity Right amygdala/right OFC HC negative connectivity, BD-I positive connectivity |
Corbalán et al. (2015) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative Participants: BD-I, euthymic (n = 19) HC (n = 17) | Behavioral: Self-report Behavioral fMRI Regions of interest: Whole brain | NS | Viewing negative: VLPFC: BD-I > HC Reappraisal negative: VLPFC: BD-I > HC Reappraisal negative vs. viewing negative: Amygdala: BD-I > HC |
Townsend et al. (2013) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative Participants: BD-I, euthymic (n = 30) HC (n = 26) | Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Bilateral amygdala PPI seed: Bilateral amygdala PPI target: Whole brain (and a priori VLPFC) | No affect related behavioral data was reported | Viewing negative vs. viewing neutral: HC vs. BD-I: NS Reappraisal Negative vs. Viewing Negative: Amygdala: HC vs. BD-I: n.s. differences Bilateral VLPFC: HC > BD-I Insula: HC > BD-I Bilateral MFG: HC > BD-I Bilateral cingulate: HC > BD-I pre-SMA: HC > BD-I PPI Seed: Left amygdala Negative Functional connectivity Left VLPFC: HC > BD-I Left occipital gyrus: HC > BD-I Right posterior cingulate: HC > BD-I PPI Seed: Right amygdala: Negative functional connectivity Right MFG: BD-I > HC |
Zhang et al. (2018) | Adults | Yes | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative Participants: BD patients,euthymic (n = 23), (2 currently depressed) HC (n = 17) | Behavioral: Self-report Neural: fMRI, DCM VOI: DLPFC, left VLPFC, and left amygdala | ER and emotion reactivity: NS | GLM contrasts: NS DCM: DLPFC to Amygdala during reappraisal: BD < HC |
Gruber et al. (2014) | Adults | Yes | Task: Film clips Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I, remitted (n = 23) HC (n = 23) | Behavioral: Self-report, analysis of facial expression Physiological measures: Skin conductivity and Respiratory sinus arrhythmia | Uninstructed vs. Reappraisal: NS | X |
Kjærstad et al. (2016) | Adults | Yes | Tasks: Social scenarios task, Picture viewing task Valence: Negative Participants: BD-I, full or partial remitted (n = 9) BD-II, full or partial remitted (n = 11) Depression, full or partial remitted (n = 20) HC (n = 20) | Behavioral: Self-report | Emotion reactivity: NS Social Scenarios/dampen: Negative: BD < HC Positive: NS Picture task/reappraisal: NS | X |
Rive et al. (2015) | Adults | No | Task: Picture viewing task Valence: Negative, positive Participants: BD-I/BD-II, remitted (n = 26) HC (n = 36) | Behavioral: Self-report Neural: fMRI Regions of interest: Amygdala, thalamus, insula, DLPFC, ACC, medial PFC, and hippocampus | ER success in remitted groups across all emotions: BDr < HC | Regulate vs. viewing across emotions: DLPFC: NS |