We previously achieved a microarray analysis of the sex difference in fetal mouse lungs at GD15.5, GD16.5, and GD17.5 by using overnight mating [
6]. This protocol revealed only 83 genes presenting a sex difference at one or more of the studied time points. The much more larger number of genes showing a sex difference we report here could be explained by the mating window which was reduced to 1 h for the current study. The mouse gestational period is very short (term GD19). Therefore, because the sex difference results from a delay in modulation, the gestation period corresponding to this delay should be very short. As a consequence, overnight mating window previously used may have restrained the amount of genes showing a sex difference. Moreover, in the current study, we also performed microarray analysis of male fetal lungs following flutamide or vehicle (negative control) administration in order to identify genes in the male fetal lung that were directly or indirectly under the control of androgens.
Androgen receptor interacting genes
The AR, which mediates androgen effects, is a nuclear transcription factor that binds to androgen-responsive elements as well as to co-activators and general transcription factors to control transcription of androgen-regulated genes [
22]. As a ligand-dependent transcription factor, the AR is activated by binding to one androgen molecule: testosterone or DHT. AR is present in both male and female lungs [
23]. Moreover, in the developing lung, there is active androgen metabolism where androgen synthesis and inactivation take place [
23,
24] making the lung a candidate organ for direct androgen control. The lack of a functional AR in tissues of the testicular feminized mice (Tfm) is well-documented and no difference was observed in the phosphatidyl choline/sphingomyelin ratio between Tfm males and normal females [
8]. In Tfm males, this ratio was not altered by exogenous androgen while it is lowered in the female. This finding strongly indicates that androgen acts to alter fetal lung development via the AR. The formation of AR transcriptional complex requires its functional and structural interaction with several co-regulators [
25]. Our results show that, during the period overlapping the surge of surfactant synthesis, there is an obvious difference in AR signalling regulation between male and female lungs. Indeed, the higher androgen concentration occurring in male lungs is accompanied by a notably higher expression level of many co-factors/co-regulators of AR. Moreover, many of them are androgen-regulated, as testify their flutamide-sensitive expression. One of those cofactors, Pten, is particularly interesting while it is able to regulate AR signalling in both direct and indirect manner. Pten interacts directly with AR to suppress androgen-induced AR nuclear translocation and it also regulates AR activity via a PI3K/Akt-dependent pathway [
26]. In Drosophila, PTEN was demonstrated to suppress cell growth and G1/S progression by down-regulating the PI3K/Akt pathway and to inhibit the G2/M transition through an alternative mechanism, perhaps involving regulation of the cytoarchitecture [
27]. Thus, Pten appears to be an important regulator in the timing of cell proliferation and maturation.
Lung development regulators
During embryonic and pseudoglandular stages of lung development, sonic hedgehog (Shh) plays an important positive role. Indeed, lack of Shh signalling leads to severe pulmonary hypoplasia [
28]. The output of hedgehog signalling is mediated by the modulation of the Gli transcriptional activators and their repressors. The mammalian Gli gene family consists of three members, Gli1, Gli2, and Gli3 [
29], which are expressed in the lung mesenchyme during the pseudoglandular stage of development [
30]. While Gli1 and Gli2 are transcriptional activators of Shh signalling, Gli3 is a bipotential transcription factor, and the repressor form of Gli3, generated as a result of proteolytic cleavage, is activated in the absence of Shh signalling [
31]. As a consequence, we do not know whether the higher expression of Gli3 observed for males in our study tend to increase Shh activation. In contrast, the fact that Gli1expression is also higher in males clearly suggests that Shh signalling should be higher in male than in female developing lungs.
Some of the signalling components of pulmonary epithelial-mesenchymal interaction, essential for branching morphogenesis, are also more expressed in male than in female lungs, such as Fgf10 and Bmpr2 genes. Members of the fibroblast growth factor (FGF) family and in particular Fgf10 are potent chemotactic signalling molecules. Fgf10 elicits lung budding and branching morphogenesis [
32]. Disruption of Fgf10 results in a complete lack of lung parenchyma distal to the trachea [
33] and,
in vitro, Fgf10 alone is both necessary and sufficient for morphogenesis in mesenchyme-free endodermal explants [
32]. Fgf10 shows a sex-dependent expression at GD17 with higher levels in males, suggesting that the FGF10-dependent growth is still continuing in the male lung at this time of gestation. In contrast to FGFs, the role of TGF-β is thought to be inhibitory for embryonic lung branching morphogenesis. Tgfbr3, a TGF-β receptor participating in TGF-β-mediated negative regulation of lung organogenesis [
34], is strongly expressed in male lung at GD17. Another TGF-β-dependent protein involved in differentiation process is Tsc-22. This protein enhances TGF-β-dependent erythroid cell differentiation [
35] and modulates Smad activity, which may influence cell differentiation in many different tissues, including the lung. Like Tgfbr3, Tsc-22 is more highly expressed in male lungs on GD17. One of TGF-β isoforms, TGF-β2 (coded by mouse Tgfb2 gene) is transcriptionally induced by flutamide treatment at GD17. Lungs of the Tgfb2 null mice revealed no gross morphological defects prenatally, but display collapsed conducting airways postnatally [
36], so Tgfb2 seems to be essential for the development and maintenance of the respiratory function.
Contrary to Fgf10 and Gli which are expressed in the mesenchyme, Bmp proteins (bone morphogenetic proteins) are expressed in the adjacent pulmonary epithelium. Bmps constitute the largest group of cytokines belonging to the TGF-β superfamily. Originally, they were identified as molecules regulating growth and differentiation of bone and cartilage. However, they also control growth, differentiation, and apoptosis in a diverse number of cell lines, including mesenchymal and epithelial cells, regulating embryogenesis and contributing to the maintenance and repair of adult tissues [
37]. Bmp proteins signal through two subtypes of receptors: Bmpr1 and Bmpr2. Bmpr2 is distinguished from other TGF-β superfamily members in that it initiates intracellular signalling in response to the specific ligands Bmp-2, Bmp-4, Bmp-6, Bmp-7, growth and differentiation factor 5 (Gdf-5), and Gdf-6 [
38]. We report that Bmpr2 gene is highly expressed in male lungs compared to female lungs at GD17, and compared to flutamide-treated males at GD18. None of the mentioned Bmp or Gdf ligands is regulated according to sex, but Gdf10 and Gdf15 show androgen-responsive expression, being respectively down- and up-regulated by flutamide treatment at GD17. Gdf15 is an important determinant of collecting duct lengthening in mouse, and evidences suggest that it is also involved in development [
39]. It was also shown to be regulated during keratinocyte differentiation [
40] while Gdf15 mRNA and protein expression patterns correlate with proliferative activity and cellular differentiation during the various stages of normal prostate development [
41]. Gdf10 was localized to areas of programmed cell death in the limb where it mediates retinoic receptor signalling [
42]. This gene has also putative tumor suppressor functions, being hypermethylated and down-regulated in lung cancers [
43]. Therefore, these two Gdf genes seem to be involved in the promotion (Gdf15) or the inhibition (Gdf10) of proliferation and differentiation in fetal lung development.
Other signalling proteins that regulate cell-cell interactions in many embryonic tissues belong to the Wnt (wingless-related) family. Wnts signal through multiple pathways, the most well-characterized being the canonical β-catenin/TCF pathway [
44]. In this pathway, secreted Wnt proteins bind to Frizzled receptors on cell membranes, activating Disheveled protein, which in turn inactivates Gsk3. Giving that Gsk3 phosphorylates β-catenin leading to the subsequent degradation of this molecule, its inactivation inhibits phosphorylation of β-catenin. Hypophosphorylation stabilizes β-catenin, which is then transported to the nucleus where it heterodimerizes with members of the TCF family of transcription factors and Creb binding protein (Crebbp) to activate downstream target genes. β-catenin, a central molecule of canonical Wnt signalling, has been shown to localize in the undifferentiated primordial epithelium, differentiating alveolar epithelium, and adjacent mesenchyme [
45]. In mouse, β-catenin dependent signalling is essential to the formation of the peripheral airways of the lungs. According to our results, genes encoding for Gsk3, β-catenin, Tcf4, and Crebbp are all more highly expressed in male at GD17, suggesting involvement of these genes in some differentiating processes presenting a temporal delay for one sex.
Five decades ago, it was already suggested that surfactant deficiency could cause hyaline membrane disease, currently called RDS. This disease of prematurely born infants is due to a lack of surfactant [
46]. The surfactant complex is composed by lipids (90%) and proteins (10%) [
47]. Among the surfactant lipids, the most abundant (70%) is phosphatidylcholine (PC), principally as dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC). Among the enzymes involved in PC synthesis, we report that lipin 2 (Lpin2) and choline kinase α (Chka) are more highly expressed in male than female lungs. In addition, Chka is more highly expressed in male than in flutamide-treated male. The Cds2 gene encoding for the enzyme responsible for CDP-diacylglycerol synthesis does not show a sex difference in expression, while it is up-regulated by flutamide at GD18. The main gene responsible for DPPC synthesis, Aytl2, is up-regulated by flutamide at GD17. Thus, the main pathway leading to PC and DPPC synthesis seems to be regulated by an androgen-sensitive mechanism. A pathway susceptible to be more active in female than in male lungs on GD17 is sphingolipids synthesis for which genes Mgll, Aldh9a1, Pnliprp2, Sgpp1, Dusp11, Crls1, and Gba are all more strongly expressed in female than in male lungs.
The surfactant proteins play crucial roles in the structure, function, and metabolism of surfactant. Four proteins enter in the composition of surfactant: Sftpa1, Sftpb, Sftpc, and Sftpd (also known as SP-A, SP-B, SP-C, and SP-D, respectively). According to our microarray results, the expression of the four surfactant protein genes increases over time in both male and female lungs, but does not show any significant sexual difference. Compared to male lungs, Sftpa1 expression was augmented in flutamide-treated males at GD17, while Sftpc mRNA levels were higher in males than in flutamide-treated males at GD18. Thus, our results cannot totally exclude the participation of androgens in the control of expression of these genes.
Some factors involved in lung morphogenesis are also involved in surfactant synthesis regulation. Kruppel-like factor 5 (Klf5) gene is involved in lamellar body formation, in the stability of DPPC and Sftpb levels in late gestation in mouse, and in lung maturation during the saccular stage of development [
48]. Klf5 is regulated by androgens since its expression is higher in flutamide-treated male than in male and female at GD17. Klf5 influences paracrine signalling between lung epithelium and mesenchyme, including TGF-β pathway. TGF-β was shown to inhibit expression of Sftpa1, Sftpb, and Sftpc surfactant proteins [
49]. TGF-β is produced as a latent complex, which must be activated by cleavage [
50]. The latent transforming growth factor-β-binding protein (Ltbp1) has been shown to facilitate secretion of latent TGF-β [
51] and to target latent TGF-β to the extracellular matrix for storage [
52]. Ltbp1 protein cleavage may provide a mechanism for release of the latent TGF-β from ECM [
53]. The fact that Ltbp1 is more highly expressed in males suggests that TGF-β pathway activation could be more pronounced in males compared to females. As alleged by others, TGF-β-induced inhibition of endodermal morphogenesis is associated with inhibition of cell proliferation, which is in large part due to increased expression of Pten [
54]. Control males expressed Pten at higher levels than females and flutamide-treated males at GD17. However, at GD18, flutamide caused an increase in Pten expression in males, suggesting a switch in the Pten expression peak from male to female at GD18. Pten binds the scaffolding protein Magi-1 [
55] which shows a sexual difference with a male prevalence at GD17. Magi-1/2/3 proteins are implicated in recruiting Pten to intercellular junctions [
56,
57] and may play a crucial role in organizing thymoma viral proto-oncogene (AKT) and phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) signalling complexes that control cell growth, differentiation, and dissemination [
55,
58].
Several members of insulin-like growth factor (IGF) family show flutamide-responsive expression. Indeed, genes coding for Igf binding proteins Igfbp2 and Igfbp5, as well as Igf1 and Igf receptor 2 (Igfr2) are more highly expressed in males when compared to flutamide-treated males. Among them, only the Igfr2 gene exhibits a sexual difference, being more highly expressed in males than in females. Another factor involved in surfactant regulation is prostaglangin E2 (Ptges2), which increases surfactant secretion in rat [
59]. In our study, Ptges2 is more highly expressed in females at GD17, suggesting that surfactant secretion could be up-regulated as a consequence of Ptges2 expression.