Background
Methods
Eligibility Criteria
Information Sources
“global surgery”[Title/Abstract] |
AND |
(((“General Surgery/education”[Mesh]) OR (“Education”[Mesh])) OR (“Global Health/education”[Mesh])) OR (educat*[Title/Abstract] OR training [Title/Abstract]) |
AND |
((“global surgery”[Title/Abstract]) AND ((((“General Surgery/education”[Mesh]) OR (“Education”[Mesh])) OR (“Global Health/education”[Mesh])) OR (educat*[Title/Abstract] OR training[Title/Abstract]))) AND ((((partnership[Title/Abstract]) OR (“International Cooperation”[Mesh])) OR (“Developing Countries”[Mesh])) OR (low middle income[Title/Abstract] OR lmic[Title/Abstract])) |
Selection of Sources of Evidence
Results
No | Authors | Year | Publication type | HIC partner institution country | LMIC partner institution country | Taxonomy category | Taxonomy sub-category |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Coleman JR, Lin Y, Shaw B, Kuwayama D | 2019 | Journal Article | United States | N/A | Qualified HIC surgeons | Skills before LMIC travel |
2 | Haji FA, Lepard JR, Davis MC, Lien ND, Can DDT, Hung CV, Thang LN, Rocque BG, Johnston JM | 2021 | Journal Article | United States | Vietnam | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC LMIC to HIC |
3 | Deckelbaum D.L., Gosselin-Tardif A., Ntakiyiruta G., Liberman S., Vassiliou M., Rwamasirabo E., Gasakure E., Fata P., Khwaja K., Razek T., Kyamanywa P | 2014 | Journal Article | Canada | Rwanda | LMIC training | Additional to formal training |
4 | Hayton RA, Garba LT, Teferi AN, O'Neill LR, Namm JP, Reeves ME | 2019 | Journal Article | United States | Malawi | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
5 | Cintolo-Gonzalez JA, Bedada AG, Morris J, Azzie G | 2016 | Journal Article | United States | Botswana | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
6 | Wong K, Bhama PK, d'Amour Mazimpaka J, Dusabimana R, Lee LN, Shaye DA | 2018 | Journal Article | United States | Rwanda | LMIC training | Additional to formal training |
7 | Fuller A., Tran T., Muhumuza M., Haglund M.M | 2016 | Journal Article | United States | Uganda | LMIC training | Supporting formal training |
8 | Graf J, Cook M, Schecter S, Deveney K, Hofmann P, Grey D, Akoko L, Mwanga A, Salum K, Schecter W | 2018 | Journal Article | Various | Tanzania | LMIC training | Supporting formal training |
Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC | ||||||
9 | Behar BJ, Danso OO, Farhat B, Ativor V, Abzug J, Lalonde DH | 2019 | Journal Article | United States/Canada | Ghana | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
10 | Miller C., Haber K., Panarelli E., Samuelson R., Shahabi S | 2015 | Journal Article | United States | Uganda | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
11 | Merchant A.I., Walters C.B., Valenzuela J., McQueen K.A., May A.K | 2017 | Journal Article | United States | Not specified | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
12 | Anderson G.A., Albutt K., Holmer H., Muguti G., Mbuwayesango B., Muchuweti D., Gidiri M.F., Mugapathyay S., Iverson K., Roa L., Sharma S., Jeppson B., Jönsson K., Lantz A., Saluja S., Lin Y., Citron I., Meara J.G., Hagander L | 2019 | Journal Article | United States/Sweden | Zimbabwe | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
13 | Tarpley M., Hansen E., Tarpley J.L | 2013 | Journal Article | United States | Kenya | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
14 | Love TP, Martin BM, Tubasiime R, Srinivasan J, Pollock JD, Delman KA | 2015 | Journal Article | United States | Haiti | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
LMIC training | Supporting formal training | ||||||
15 | Harvey L., Curlin H., Grimm B., Lovett B., Ulysse J.-C., Sizemore C | 2020 | Journal Article | United States | Haiti | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
16 | Jooste R, Roberts F, Mndolo S, Mabedi D, Chikumbanje S, Whitaker DK, O'Sullivan EP | 2019 | Journal Article | Various | Malawi | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
17 | Inchauste S.M., Deptula P.L., Zelones J.T., Nazerali R.S., Nguyen D.H., Lee G.K | 2020 | Journal Article | United States | Cuba/Vietnam | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
18 | Aarabi S, Smithers C, Fils MM, Godson JL, Pierre JH, Mukherjee J, Meara J, Farmer P | 2015 | Journal Article | United States | Haiti | Qualified HIC surgeons | LMIC Teaching placement |
19 | Hill K.A., Johnson E.D., Lutomia M., Puyana J.C., Lee K.K., Oduor P.R., MacLeod J.B | 2018 | Journal Article | United States | Kenya | LMIC training | Additional to formal training |
20 | Global Surgery Student Alliance—Global Surgery Curriculum | 2021 | Website | Various | Various | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
21 | LeCompte M.T., Goldman C., Tarpley J.L., Tarpley M., Hansen E.N., Nthumba P.M., Terhune K.P., Kauffmann R.M | 2018 | Journal Article | United States | Kenya | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
22 | Harvard Medical School—Programme in Global Surgery and Social Change | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
23 | Ullrich S., Kisa P., Ruzgar N., Okello I., Oyania F., Kayima P., Kakembo N., Sekabira J., Situma M., Ozgediz D | 2020 | Journal Article | United States | Uganda | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
24 | Leeds IL, Hugar LA, Pettitt BJ, Srinivasan J, Master VA | 2013 | Journal Article | United States | Haiti | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
25 | Ellis R, Izzuddin Mohamad Nor A, Pimentil I, Bitew Z, Moore J | 2017 | Journal Article | United Kingdom | Ethiopia | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
26 | Lin Y., Scott J.W., Yi S., Taylor K.K., Ntakiyiruta G., Ntirenganya F., Banguti P., Yule S., Riviello R | 2018 | Journal Article | United States | Rwanda | LMIC training | Additional to formal training |
27 | Hendra L, Kibaja J, Kibula E, Szymankiewicz M | 2020 | Journal Article | United Kingdom | Tanzania | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
28 | Dyer GSM | 2019 | Journal Article | Various | Haiti | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
LMIC training | Supporting formal training | ||||||
29 | King’s College London—Global Health MSc | 2021 | Website | United Kingdom | N/A | ||
30 | Kassam A.-F., Park C., Lungu D., Wise P.E., Mammen J.M., Benns M.V., Sussman J.J., Logan J.M | 2019 | Journal Article | United States | Malawi | Trainee mobility | HIC to LMIC |
31 | Nataraja R.M., Oo Y.M., Ljuhar D., Webb N.R., Pacilli M., Win N.N., Aye A | 2020 | Journal Article | Australia | Myanmar | LMIC training | HIC to LMIC |
32 | Davis RW, Sherif YA, Vu MT, Shilstone H, Scott B, Olutoye OO, Hollier L Jr, Nuchtern J, Rosengart TK | 2021 | Journal Article | United States | Ecuador/Egypt/Guatemala/Malawi /Mongolia/Tanzania/Uganda/Vietnam | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | Outside formal training |
33 | Wu H.-H., Patel K.R., Caldwell A.M., Coughlin R.R., Hansen S.L., Carey J.N | 2016 | Journal Article | United States | Various | LMIC training | |
34 | Bakhshi S.K., Jooma R | 2019 | Journal Article | United Kingdom | Pakistan | LMIC training | Outside formal training |
35 | ReSurge International and COSECSA—RESURGE—COSECSA Short Term Exchange Programme | 2021 | Website | United States | Various – East, Central and Southern Africa | Trainee mobility | Outside formal training |
36 | Riviello R, Ozgediz D, Hsia RY, Azzie G, Newton M, Tarpley J | 2010 | Journal Article | United States | Uganda/Nigeria/Botswana/Kenya | Various | HIC to LMIC |
37 | Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland - Master of Surgery (by module) | 2021 | Website | Ireland | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
38 | The Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland’s collaboration with COSECSA | 2021 | Journal Article | Ireland | Various – Sub-Saharan Africa | LMIC Training | |
39 | Royal College of Surgeons in England - Surgical Training for Austere Environments (STAE) | 2021 | Website | United Kingdom | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
40 | Lwin AT, Lwin T, Naing P, Oo Y, Kidd D, Cerullo M, Posen J, Hlaing K, Yenokyan G, Thinn KK, Soe ZW, Stevens KA | 2018 | Journal Article | United States | Myanmar | LMIC training | |
41 | Guest GD, Scott DF, Xavier JP, Martins N, Vreede E, Chennal A, Moss D, Watters DA | 2017 | Journal Article | Australia | Indonesia | LMIC training | Additional to formal training |
42 | Mitchell KB, Giiti G, Kotecha V, Chandika A, Pryor KO, Härtl R, Gilyoma J | 2013 | Journal Article | United States | Tanzania | LMIC training | Supporting formal training |
43 | Jones CM, Campbell CA, Magee WP, Ayala R, Mackay DR | 2016 | Journal Article | United States | Various | LMIC training | Supporting formal training |
44 | McNee M.A., DeUgarte D.A., Gerstle J.T., Butler M.W., Petroze R., Holterman A.-X., Velcek F., Cleary M., Krishnaswami S., Fitzgerald T.N | 2020 | Journal Article | United States | Various | Trainee mobility | Supporting formal training |
45 | Hayton R.A., Donley D.K., Fekadu A., Woods B.K., Graybill C.K., Fitzgerald T.N | 2017 | Journal Article | United States | Malawi | LMIC training | LMIC to HIC |
46 | Butler MW, Ozgediz D, Poenaru D, Ameh E, Andrawes S, Azzie G, Borgstein E, DeUgarte DA, Elhalaby E, Ganey ME, Gerstle JT, Hansen EN, Hesse A, Lakhoo K, Krishnaswami S, Langer M, Levitt M, Meier D, Minocha A, Nwomeh BC, Abdur-Rahman LO, Rothstein D, Sekabira J | 2015 | Journal Article | Various | Various | Qualified HIC surgeons | Additional to formal training |
47 | Taro T., Yao C., Ly S., Wipfli H., Magee K., Vanderburg R., Magee W | 2016 | Journal Article | United States | China/Vietnam/Mexico/India | Trainee mobility | Skills before LMIC travel |
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |||||||
48 | Sue G.R., Covington W.C., Chang J | 2018 | Journal Article | United States | Vietnam/Ecuador/Nepal/Zimbabwe | Trainee mobility | LMIC to HIC |
49 | Haider M., Jalloh M., Yin J., Diallo A., Puttkammer N., Gueye S., Niang L., Wessells H., McCammon K | 2020 | Journal Article | United States | Senegal | LMIC training | HIC to LMIC |
50 | University of British Columbia—Master of Global Surgical Care (MGSC) | 2021 | Website | Canada | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | Supporting formal training |
51 | University of Florida - Global Surgery and Health Equity Program | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
52 | University of Oxford – Global Surgery | 2021 | Website | United Kingdom | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
53 | Johns Hopkins University – Global Surgery Training Program | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
54 | University of Utah – Public Health Certificates | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
55 | University of Wisconsin-Madison – Global Education Opportunities | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
56 | Columbia University – Global Health Opportunities | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
57 | University of Toronto—PGME Global Health Education Initiative—Global Surgical Scholar Program | 2021 | Website | Canada | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
58 | Global Surgery Amsterdam – Training Programmes | 2021 | Website | The Netherlands | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
59 | University of Michigan – Global Health Research Certificate Program | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
60 | North-western University Feinberg School of Medicine – Institute for Global Health | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
61 | Baylor College of Medicine – Global Surgery Track | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
62 | Stanford University – Global Surgery | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
63 | Duke-NUS Medical School – Global Surgery Programme | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
64 | Yale School of Medicine – Yale Global Surgery Division | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
65 | Virginia Commonwealth University – VCU Program for Global Surgery | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
66 | McGill University—Master of Science (M.Sc.) Experimental Surgery (Thesis): Global Surgery | 2021 | Website | Canada | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | |
67 | University of California San Francisco – Global Surgery and Public Health Pathway | 2021 | Website | United States | N/A | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training |
The Meaning of Global Surgery Education and Training in Practice
Taxonomy of Global Surgery Education and Training Programmes
Category | Sub-category | Sources | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | HIC academic institution global surgery education and training | 1 | 25 | |
2 | Trainee mobility | 2 | HIC to LMIC | 12 |
3 | LMIC to HIC | 2 | ||
4 | Bi-directional | 2 | ||
5 | LMIC to LMIC | 1 | ||
3 | Qualified HIC surgeons | 6 | LMIC Teaching placement | 7 |
7 | Skills before LMIC travel | 2 | ||
4 | LMIC training | 8 | Supporting formal training | 11 |
9 | Additional to formal training | 6 | ||
10 | Outside formal training | 11 |