Skip to main content
Erschienen in: Indian Journal of Surgery 1/2022

Open Access 25.08.2021 | Original Article

Global Surgery Education and Training Programmes—a Scoping Review and Taxonomy

verfasst von: Eric O’Flynn, Arbab Danial, Jakub Gajewski

Erschienen in: Indian Journal of Surgery | Sonderheft 1/2022

Abstract

Global surgery is an emerging field of study and practice, aiming to respond to the worldwide unmet need for surgical care. As a relatively new concept, it is not clear that there is a common understanding of what constitutes “global surgery education and training”. This study examines the forms that global surgery education and training programmes and interventions take in practice, and proposes a classification scheme for such activities. A scoping review of published journal articles and internet websites was performed according to the PRISMA Extension for Scoping Review guidelines. PubMed MEDLINE, EMBASE and Google were searched for sources that described global surgery education and training programme. Only sources that explicitly referenced a named education programme, were surgical in nature, were international in nature, were self-described as “global surgery” and presented new information were included. Three hundred twenty-seven records were identified and 67 were ultimately included in the review. “Global surgery education and training” interventions described in the literature most commonly involved both a High-Income Country (HIC) institution and a Low- and Middle-Income Country (LMIC) institution. The literature suggests that significant current effort is directed towards academic global surgery programmes in HIC institutions and HIC surgical trainee placements in LMICs. Four categories and ten subcategories of global surgery education and training were identified. This paper provides a framework from which to study global surgery education and training. A clearer understanding of the forms that such interventions take may allow for more strategic decision making by actors in this field.
Hinweise

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Background

Five billion people lack access to safe, affordable, timely surgical care and 143 million extra operations per year are required in Low- and Middle- Income Countries (LMICs) to meet current surgical need [1]. Communicable diseases are declining as a percentage of the global burden of disease but conditions which could be treated by surgery are increasing, indeed an estimated 28% of the global burden of disease is surgical [2]. The term “Global surgery” has recently entered the lexicon. A commonly cited definition of the field states that global surgery “places priority on improving health outcomes and achieving health equity for all people worldwide who are affected by surgical conditions or have a need for surgical care” [3]. Another definition notes that in practice, the term is used “often with an explicit focus on LMICs” [4]. There remains, however, a lack of conceptual clarity and understanding. Abraham et al. find that the term ‘global surgery’ is not well-understood among health professionals. There is no clear consensus on what it means to be a global surgeon” [5].
Global surgery interventions take many different forms [2]. Education and training of surgical practitioners and allied healthcare workers is a key focus of national efforts to expand access to surgical care [6, 7]. It is also a key focus of international surgical partnerships. In a systematic review of global surgery partnerships between North American and LMIC institutions, Jedrzejko et al. [8] find that 81% of partnerships contain a surgical education or training component.
As we look at the nature of global surgery education and training, it is helpful here to distinguish between the academic, predominantly classroom-based acquisition of broad subject knowledge — referred to in this study as “education” and the learning-by-doing, predominantly hospital-based acquisition of knowledge, skills and attitudes intended to lead to specific, concrete results — referred to in this study as “training.” The overlapping concepts of education and training are discussed in detail elsewhere [9]. Although “[t]he last ten years have seen the rise of global surgery as an academic pursuit” [10], in global surgery partnerships, clinical training continues to predominate over academic education [11]. Looking specifically at North–South surgical training partnerships Greive-Price et al. found mostly “educational exchanges between HICs and LMICs” which, in general “flowed North to South… typically at the resident level, with most originating from North America and travelling to sub-Saharan Africa” [12].
It is not clear that there is a shared conception of what constitutes, and what does not constitute, education and training in global surgery. Aiming to clarify what global surgery education and training means in practice, we undertook a scoping review of available literature. A scoping review approach was chosen as such reviews “are an ideal tool to determine the scope or coverage of a body of literature on a given topic… Scoping reviews provide a useful alternative to literature reviews when clarification around a concept or theory is required” [13].
From this scoping review, we then look to categorise self-described global surgery education and training programmes and interventions. This review and taxonomy together clarify the scope of such education and training, who is being taught, and how these programmes and interventions are structured. It is hoped that this study will contribute to thoughtful global surgery education programme design.

Methods

The study protocol was developed following the PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews guidelines [14].

Eligibility Criteria

Only published journal articles and websites in the English language were included. No time limit was placed on the search; however, as the term “global surgery” is a relatively new “emerging terminology” [4], the oldest source returned in the search is from 2010 [15].

Information Sources

PubMed MEDLINE and EMBASE databases were searched on 13/05/2021. The PubMed MEDLINE search strategy is shown in Table 1. The electronic database search was supplemented by an internet search for relevant grey literature performed on 15/06/2021. This involved searching the term “global surgery” on Google and screening all results within the first 10 search engine result pages for education and training interventions, as well as identifying webpages from personal knowledge. At each stage of screening, EO’F and AD reviewed sources separately. Where reviewers differed, JG adjudicated.
Table 1
PubMed MEDLINE search strategy
“global surgery”[Title/Abstract]
AND
(((“General Surgery/education”[Mesh]) OR (“Education”[Mesh])) OR (“Global Health/education”[Mesh])) OR (educat*[Title/Abstract] OR training [Title/Abstract])
AND
((“global surgery”[Title/Abstract]) AND ((((“General Surgery/education”[Mesh]) OR (“Education”[Mesh])) OR (“Global Health/education”[Mesh])) OR (educat*[Title/Abstract] OR training[Title/Abstract]))) AND ((((partnership[Title/Abstract]) OR (“International Cooperation”[Mesh])) OR (“Developing Countries”[Mesh])) OR (low middle income[Title/Abstract] OR lmic[Title/Abstract]))
This search strategy (with appropriate language) was also used for EmBASE

Selection of Sources of Evidence

Sources were included if:
1.
They explicitly and directly reference a named education or training intervention or programme.
 
2.
The subject of the educational programme is surgical practice, education or policy.
 
3.
The educational programme is “global” or “international” in nature — and at least one of the sites is in a low- or middle-income country.
 
4.
The educational programme is described by the authors as a “global surgery” intervention – or any surgical (sub-)specialty variation on this, e.g. “global urology.”
 
5.
The source presents new information, not previously or elsewhere published. Opinion, correspondence and systematic and scoping review articles were excluded.
 

Results

Three hundred twenty-seven records were identified. Two hundred fifty-nine were excluded and 67 studies included in the review, as shown in Fig. 1. Table 2 illustrates the characteristics of the included sources. No critical appraisal of sources of evidence was undertaken.
Table 2
Characteristics of the included studies
No
Authors
Year
Publication type
HIC partner institution country
LMIC partner institution country
Taxonomy category
Taxonomy sub-category
1
Coleman JR, Lin Y, Shaw B, Kuwayama D
2019
Journal Article
United States
N/A
Qualified HIC surgeons
Skills before LMIC travel
2
Haji FA, Lepard JR, Davis MC, Lien ND, Can DDT, Hung CV, Thang LN, Rocque BG, Johnston JM
2021
Journal Article
United States
Vietnam
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
LMIC to HIC
3
Deckelbaum D.L., Gosselin-Tardif A., Ntakiyiruta G., Liberman S., Vassiliou M., Rwamasirabo E., Gasakure E., Fata P., Khwaja K., Razek T., Kyamanywa P
2014
Journal Article
Canada
Rwanda
LMIC training
Additional to formal training
4
Hayton RA, Garba LT, Teferi AN, O'Neill LR, Namm JP, Reeves ME
2019
Journal Article
United States
Malawi
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
5
Cintolo-Gonzalez JA, Bedada AG, Morris J, Azzie G
2016
Journal Article
United States
Botswana
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
6
Wong K, Bhama PK, d'Amour Mazimpaka J, Dusabimana R, Lee LN, Shaye DA
2018
Journal Article
United States
Rwanda
LMIC training
Additional to formal training
7
Fuller A., Tran T., Muhumuza M., Haglund M.M
2016
Journal Article
United States
Uganda
LMIC training
Supporting formal training
8
Graf J, Cook M, Schecter S, Deveney K, Hofmann P, Grey D, Akoko L, Mwanga A, Salum K, Schecter W
2018
Journal Article
Various
Tanzania
LMIC training
Supporting formal training
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
9
Behar BJ, Danso OO, Farhat B, Ativor V, Abzug J, Lalonde DH
2019
Journal Article
United States/Canada
Ghana
LMIC training
Outside formal training
10
Miller C., Haber K., Panarelli E., Samuelson R., Shahabi S
2015
Journal Article
United States
Uganda
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
11
Merchant A.I., Walters C.B., Valenzuela J., McQueen K.A., May A.K
2017
Journal Article
United States
Not specified
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
12
Anderson G.A., Albutt K., Holmer H., Muguti G., Mbuwayesango B., Muchuweti D., Gidiri M.F., Mugapathyay S., Iverson K., Roa L., Sharma S., Jeppson B., Jönsson K., Lantz A., Saluja S., Lin Y., Citron I., Meara J.G., Hagander L
2019
Journal Article
United States/Sweden
Zimbabwe
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
13
Tarpley M., Hansen E., Tarpley J.L
2013
Journal Article
United States
Kenya
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
14
Love TP, Martin BM, Tubasiime R, Srinivasan J, Pollock JD, Delman KA
2015
Journal Article
United States
Haiti
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
LMIC training
Supporting formal training
15
Harvey L., Curlin H., Grimm B., Lovett B., Ulysse J.-C., Sizemore C
2020
Journal Article
United States
Haiti
LMIC training
Outside formal training
16
Jooste R, Roberts F, Mndolo S, Mabedi D, Chikumbanje S, Whitaker DK, O'Sullivan EP
2019
Journal Article
Various
Malawi
LMIC training
Outside formal training
17
Inchauste S.M., Deptula P.L., Zelones J.T., Nazerali R.S., Nguyen D.H., Lee G.K
2020
Journal Article
United States
Cuba/Vietnam
LMIC training
Outside formal training
18
Aarabi S, Smithers C, Fils MM, Godson JL, Pierre JH, Mukherjee J, Meara J, Farmer P
2015
Journal Article
United States
Haiti
Qualified HIC surgeons
LMIC Teaching placement
19
Hill K.A., Johnson E.D., Lutomia M., Puyana J.C., Lee K.K., Oduor P.R., MacLeod J.B
2018
Journal Article
United States
Kenya
LMIC training
Additional to formal training
20
Global Surgery Student Alliance—Global Surgery Curriculum
2021
Website
Various
Various
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
21
LeCompte M.T., Goldman C., Tarpley J.L., Tarpley M., Hansen E.N., Nthumba P.M., Terhune K.P., Kauffmann R.M
2018
Journal Article
United States
Kenya
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
22
Harvard Medical School—Programme in Global Surgery and Social Change
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
23
Ullrich S., Kisa P., Ruzgar N., Okello I., Oyania F., Kayima P., Kakembo N., Sekabira J., Situma M., Ozgediz D
2020
Journal Article
United States
Uganda
LMIC training
Outside formal training
24
Leeds IL, Hugar LA, Pettitt BJ, Srinivasan J, Master VA
2013
Journal Article
United States
Haiti
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
25
Ellis R, Izzuddin Mohamad Nor A, Pimentil I, Bitew Z, Moore J
2017
Journal Article
United Kingdom
Ethiopia
LMIC training
Outside formal training
26
Lin Y., Scott J.W., Yi S., Taylor K.K., Ntakiyiruta G., Ntirenganya F., Banguti P., Yule S., Riviello R
2018
Journal Article
United States
Rwanda
LMIC training
Additional to formal training
27
Hendra L, Kibaja J, Kibula E, Szymankiewicz M
2020
Journal Article
United Kingdom
Tanzania
LMIC training
Outside formal training
28
Dyer GSM
2019
Journal Article
Various
Haiti
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
LMIC training
Supporting formal training
29
King’s College London—Global Health MSc
2021
Website
United Kingdom
N/A
  
30
Kassam A.-F., Park C., Lungu D., Wise P.E., Mammen J.M., Benns M.V., Sussman J.J., Logan J.M
2019
Journal Article
United States
Malawi
Trainee mobility
HIC to LMIC
31
Nataraja R.M., Oo Y.M., Ljuhar D., Webb N.R., Pacilli M., Win N.N., Aye A
2020
Journal Article
Australia
Myanmar
LMIC training
HIC to LMIC
32
Davis RW, Sherif YA, Vu MT, Shilstone H, Scott B, Olutoye OO, Hollier L Jr, Nuchtern J, Rosengart TK
2021
Journal Article
United States
Ecuador/Egypt/Guatemala/Malawi
/Mongolia/Tanzania/Uganda/Vietnam
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
Outside formal training
33
Wu H.-H., Patel K.R., Caldwell A.M., Coughlin R.R., Hansen S.L., Carey J.N
2016
Journal Article
United States
Various
LMIC training
 
34
Bakhshi S.K., Jooma R
2019
Journal Article
United Kingdom
Pakistan
LMIC training
Outside formal training
35
ReSurge International and COSECSA—RESURGE—COSECSA Short Term Exchange Programme
2021
Website
United States
Various – East, Central and Southern Africa
Trainee mobility
Outside formal training
36
Riviello R, Ozgediz D, Hsia RY, Azzie G, Newton M, Tarpley J
2010
Journal Article
United States
Uganda/Nigeria/Botswana/Kenya
Various
HIC to LMIC
37
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland -
Master of Surgery (by module)
2021
Website
Ireland
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
38
The Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland’s collaboration with COSECSA
2021
Journal Article
Ireland
Various – Sub-Saharan Africa
LMIC Training
 
39
Royal College of Surgeons in England -
Surgical Training for Austere Environments (STAE)
2021
Website
United Kingdom
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
40
Lwin AT, Lwin T, Naing P, Oo Y, Kidd D, Cerullo M, Posen J, Hlaing K, Yenokyan G, Thinn KK, Soe ZW, Stevens KA
2018
Journal Article
United States
Myanmar
LMIC training
 
41
Guest GD, Scott DF, Xavier JP, Martins N, Vreede E, Chennal A, Moss D, Watters DA
2017
Journal Article
Australia
Indonesia
LMIC training
Additional to formal training
42
Mitchell KB, Giiti G, Kotecha V, Chandika A, Pryor KO, Härtl R, Gilyoma J
2013
Journal Article
United States
Tanzania
LMIC training
Supporting formal training
43
Jones CM, Campbell CA, Magee WP, Ayala R, Mackay DR
2016
Journal Article
United States
Various
LMIC training
Supporting formal training
44
McNee M.A., DeUgarte D.A., Gerstle J.T., Butler M.W., Petroze R., Holterman A.-X., Velcek F., Cleary M., Krishnaswami S., Fitzgerald T.N
2020
Journal Article
United States
Various
Trainee mobility
Supporting formal training
45
Hayton R.A., Donley D.K., Fekadu A., Woods B.K., Graybill C.K., Fitzgerald T.N
2017
Journal Article
United States
Malawi
LMIC training
LMIC to HIC
46
Butler MW, Ozgediz D, Poenaru D, Ameh E, Andrawes S, Azzie G, Borgstein E, DeUgarte DA, Elhalaby E, Ganey ME, Gerstle JT, Hansen EN, Hesse A, Lakhoo K, Krishnaswami S, Langer M, Levitt M, Meier D, Minocha A, Nwomeh BC, Abdur-Rahman LO, Rothstein D, Sekabira J
2015
Journal Article
Various
Various
Qualified HIC surgeons
Additional to formal training
47
Taro T., Yao C., Ly S., Wipfli H., Magee K., Vanderburg R., Magee W
2016
Journal Article
United States
China/Vietnam/Mexico/India
Trainee mobility
Skills before LMIC travel
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
48
Sue G.R., Covington W.C., Chang J
2018
Journal Article
United States
Vietnam/Ecuador/Nepal/Zimbabwe
Trainee mobility
LMIC to HIC
49
Haider M., Jalloh M., Yin J., Diallo A., Puttkammer N., Gueye S., Niang L., Wessells H., McCammon K
2020
Journal Article
United States
Senegal
LMIC training
HIC to LMIC
50
University of British Columbia—Master of Global Surgical Care (MGSC)
2021
Website
Canada
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
Supporting formal training
51
University of Florida -
Global Surgery and Health Equity Program
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
52
University of Oxford – Global Surgery
2021
Website
United Kingdom
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
53
Johns Hopkins University – Global Surgery Training Program
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
54
University of Utah – Public Health Certificates
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
55
University of Wisconsin-Madison – Global Education Opportunities
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
56
Columbia University – Global Health Opportunities
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
57
University of Toronto—PGME Global Health Education Initiative—Global Surgical Scholar Program
2021
Website
Canada
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
58
Global Surgery Amsterdam – Training Programmes
2021
Website
The Netherlands
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
59
University of Michigan – Global Health Research Certificate Program
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
60
North-western University Feinberg School of Medicine – Institute for Global Health
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
61
Baylor College of Medicine – Global Surgery Track
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
62
Stanford University – Global Surgery
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
63
Duke-NUS Medical School – Global Surgery Programme
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
64
Yale School of Medicine – Yale Global Surgery Division
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
65
Virginia Commonwealth University – VCU Program for Global Surgery
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
66
McGill University—Master of Science (M.Sc.) Experimental Surgery (Thesis): Global Surgery
2021
Website
Canada
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 
67
University of California San Francisco – Global Surgery and Public Health Pathway
2021
Website
United States
N/A
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
 

The Meaning of Global Surgery Education and Training in Practice

This review shows that language of global surgery education and training is used to represent a narrower range of activity than definitions of global surgery aspire to [3, 4]. While de jure global surgery may be considered to be a “worldwide” field of study and practise in some definitions [3], de facto all programmes and interventions included in this review involve interaction between HIC and LMIC institutions, or interaction between HIC institutions and the LMIC surgical care context as the area of study and discussion.
The majority of training interventions found in our review concerned the training of surgeons. One study concerned the training of anaesthetists [16], another the surgical training of medical students [17] and two studies concerned training of different cadres of the surgical team together [18, 19]. Non-specialist cadres of surgical care provider were trained in two studies [20, 21]. Global surgery education programmes were less explicit in the cadres targeted.
Institutions from the USA were the HIC partner in 67% (n = 45/67) of studies. Where a single LMIC partner country was reported, East and Southern African institutions accounted for 63% (n = 20/32) of LMIC partners.

Taxonomy of Global Surgery Education and Training Programmes

Our analysis of programmes which are described using the language of global surgery revealed the existence of four main categories of surgical education and training programmes and ten subcategories as shown in Table 3. Some sources reviewed describe multiple, or multi-faceted, programmes and interventions, and are thus recorded in multiple categories. The categories are as follows:
1.
The academic education of surgical care providers, trainees, students, researchers and policy makers on the broad global issues related to the lack of access to safe surgical care [2246]. A number of HIC universities and training bodies list global surgery education, training and research offerings — which take a wide variety of different forms. Among these are standalone global surgery academic courses, ranging from certificate [24, 26, 29] to master’s degree level [45], and fellowship [34]. Global surgery education may also form part of other qualifications [40, 42] or be a dedicated track in a surgical training residency [37, 39, 41, 44]. In most cases, these academic programme form part of a surgical training programme, or are targeted at surgical trainees, but in other cases open to “students and trainees” [23], “surgeons, anaesthetists and obstetricians/gynaecologists… those in training including senior medical students…[and] allied health care professions” [24], “graduate students, postgraduate trainees, surgical faculty, or surgery-related allied health care workers” [45].
 
2.
The provision of opportunities for surgical practitioners, students and trainees to train and practice abroad. This surgical trainee mobility most commonly involved HIC surgical trainees spending time in LMIC hospitals [4758]. Less commonly, exchanges involved LMIC surgical trainees travelling to HIC hospitals [43, 59] or bi-directional exchanges [60, 61], and in just one case a LMIC-LMIC trainee mobility programme [62].
 
3.
HIC institutional support for surgical training in LMICS — either through support for the delivery an existing formal training programme [15, 53, 56, 58, 6368], or additional training delivered to trainees enrolled in a formal training programme [17, 18, 48, 6971], or delivered outside of a formal training programme [16, 1921, 61, 7277].
 
4.
Provision of qualified HIC surgical care providers as trainers in LMICs [15, 61, 78], or the training of such HIC providers to work successfully in low resource environments [79, 80].
 
Table 3
Taxonomy of self-described global surgery education and training programmes and interventions
Category
Sub-category
Sources
1
HIC academic institution global surgery education and training
1
 
25
2
Trainee mobility
2
HIC to LMIC
12
3
LMIC to HIC
2
4
Bi-directional
2
5
LMIC to LMIC
1
3
Qualified HIC surgeons
6
LMIC Teaching placement
7
7
Skills before LMIC travel
2
4
LMIC training
8
Supporting formal training
11
9
Additional to formal training
6
10
Outside formal training
11

Discussion

Global Surgery Education and Training — a Collaborative Endeavour

All programmes and interventions included in this review involve both HIC institutions and LMIC institutions or contexts as we have described. Acknowledging that our search strategy and eligibility criteria is likely to have favoured studies that described programmes and interventions undertaken in international partnerships, nevertheless, our review of the literature suggests that surgical training and education programmes, in both HICs and LMICs, are not commonly termed as “global surgery” programmes unless they involve both HIC institutions and LMIC institutions or contexts.

Global Surgery Education in HIC Academic Institutions

All global surgery academic education programmes identified were in HICs, aimed primarily, but not exclusively, at surgical trainees. It seems likely that these programmes are to some degree a result of HIC student and trainee demand. Patel et al. note that demand for increased global surgery training reflects the enthusiasm by the current generation of HIC surgical trainees” [81]. This may be expected to benefit the well-intentioned HIC trainee; we support Patel et al.’s assertion that “Training is incomplete for any HIC surgical trainee … [who does not] have knowledge of the global context of surgical care and burden of disease.” It also seems plausible that these trainees will have a positive impact in lower resource settings than that in which they trained.
However, if we consider “knowledge of the global context of surgical care and burden of disease” [81] to be of value to LMIC students and trainees, as well as their HIC counterparts, then we must question whether such academic programmes are accessible to LMIC trainees and students, and whether there is a need or demand for such programmes in LMIC contexts. A comparison with the longer established field of global health academic education may be informative in this regard. Svadzian et al. ask “even if HIC universities made their [global health] degrees more accessible, we should still ask why an African trainee must go to London or Boston to learn [about global health].” The question may be equally pertinent when applied to academic global surgery.

Surgical Trainee Mobility — a Two-Way Street?

Our review identified many more programmes sending HIC surgical trainees to LMICs, than bi-directional, LMIC to HIC or LMIC to LMIC programmes. This is consistent with the findings of other studies [12]. The presence of HIC surgical trainees may undoubtedly in some circumstances provide significant benefit to the LMIC host institution [48, 82]. However this apparent lack of reciprocity in travel, as similarly identified elsewhere [83], may also give us cause for concern. It is incumbent upon us as practitioners in a field dedicated to “achieving health equity for all people worldwide who are affected by surgical conditions” [3], to consider how much satisfying HIC demand for LMIC surgical placements should be a priority for the global surgical community.

Expanding the Focus of Global Surgery Education and Training in the Literature

Global surgery may be conceived of as involving “surgeons, anaesthetists, nurses and allied healthcare professionals working together with non-clinicians, including policy makers, epidemiologists and economists” [4] but this multidisciplinarity is not currently reflected in the global surgery education and training literature. Similarly, the predominance of the USA and East and Southern Africa in the literature does not seem to reflect the global nature that the field aspires to.

COVID 19 — an Opportunity for a Rethink

We believe the greatest surgical return on educational investment is in low-resource settings, and thus support for local training programme is likely to be highly impactful. Surgeons trained locally, stay locally [84]. Many of the models of international cooperation described in this study rely heavily on travel, which has been dramatically curtailed due to the pandemic. While hugely disruptive, this may also be “an opportunity to rethink global cooperation in higher education and research” [85]. Innovative approaches to the delivery of global surgery education and training at a distance may prove more efficient than models based on trainees and surgeons flying across the world [86]. Notable in this regard is the launch of the US$5million Global Surgical Training Challenge Prize [87], which represents a new approach to supporting LMIC surgical training innovation, leveraging expertise across the world, without any in-person meeting.

South-South Cooperation

Trainee rotations in other low-resource environments may offer more contextually appropriate learning opportunities than rotations in high-resource environments. HIC institutions can facilitate such rotations as ReSurge is doing for plastic surgery trainees of the College of Surgeons of East, Central and Southern Africa (COSECSA) [62]. Similarly, local LMIC developed training content may be more appropriate than content developed elsewhere. HIC institutions may play a useful role here also in facilitating the creation of such resources such as the pan-African paediatric surgery e-learning platform developed by the West African College of Surgeons and COSECSA, facilitated by RCSI and KidsOR [88].

Limitations

As the study aims to understand what it is meant by global surgery education and training through analysis of programmes using that language, it necessarily does not include studies which may be conceived of as global surgical in nature, yet which do not use the term. As an “emerging terminology” [4], the use of the term “global surgery” in relation to education and training is still evolving.
The search returned little information about programmes related to the education and training of anaesthetists, nurses, non-specialist surgical providers and allied professionals. Use of terms referring to other members of the surgical team — such as “global anaesthesia” — may produce different results.
The taxonomy produced is by necessity reductive, many global surgery education programmes may recognise their work in a number of these conceptions. Many programmes which enable HIC country trainees to spend time in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs) also provide training for such HIC trainees pre-departure, and provide reciprocal opportunities for LMIC trainees to spend time in a high-resource environment. The authors’ own institution supports formal surgical and anaesthesiology training programmes in LMICs [89], supports in-service training and capacity development outside of formal training programmes [90], and delivers academic and clinical global surgery education to students and trainees in Ireland.

Conclusion

The growth of the global surgery paradigm presents an opportunity to leverage international cooperation to expand and enhance education and training programmes which ultimately benefit the surgical patient, worldwide. This paper provides a framework from which to further study global surgery education and training. Our review suggests that significant effort has been directed towards global surgery programmes in HIC academic institutions and HIC surgical trainee placements in LMICs. The ultimate impact of the identified categories on the surgical patient remains to be determined; however, a clearer understanding of the forms that global surgery education and training interventions take may allow for more strategic decision making by all partners.

Declarations

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare no competing interests.
Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​4.​0/​.

Publisher's Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Unsere Produktempfehlungen

Die Chirurgie

Print-Titel

Das Abo mit mehr Tiefe

Mit der Zeitschrift Die Chirurgie erhalten Sie zusätzlich Online-Zugriff auf weitere 43 chirurgische Fachzeitschriften, CME-Fortbildungen, Webinare, Vorbereitungskursen zur Facharztprüfung und die digitale Enzyklopädie e.Medpedia.

Bis 30. April 2024 bestellen und im ersten Jahr nur 199 € zahlen!

e.Med Interdisziplinär

Kombi-Abonnement

Für Ihren Erfolg in Klinik und Praxis - Die beste Hilfe in Ihrem Arbeitsalltag

Mit e.Med Interdisziplinär erhalten Sie Zugang zu allen CME-Fortbildungen und Fachzeitschriften auf SpringerMedizin.de.

Literatur
9.
Zurück zum Zitat Masadeh M (2012) Training, education, development and learning: what is the difference? Eur Sci J 8:62–68 Masadeh M (2012) Training, education, development and learning: what is the difference? Eur Sci J 8:62–68
10.
Zurück zum Zitat Martin AN, Petroze RT (2020) Academic global surgery and COVID-19: turning impediments into opportunities. Am J Surg 220:53–54CrossRef Martin AN, Petroze RT (2020) Academic global surgery and COVID-19: turning impediments into opportunities. Am J Surg 220:53–54CrossRef
18.
Zurück zum Zitat Lin Y, Scott JW, Yi S et al (2018) Improving surgical safety and nontechnical skills in variable-resource contexts: a novel educational curriculum. J Surg Educ 75:1014–1021CrossRef Lin Y, Scott JW, Yi S et al (2018) Improving surgical safety and nontechnical skills in variable-resource contexts: a novel educational curriculum. J Surg Educ 75:1014–1021CrossRef
20.
Zurück zum Zitat Bakhshi SK, Jooma R (2019) Primary trauma care: a training course for healthcare providers in developing countries. J Pak Med Assoc 69(1):S82–S85PubMed Bakhshi SK, Jooma R (2019) Primary trauma care: a training course for healthcare providers in developing countries. J Pak Med Assoc 69(1):S82–S85PubMed
22.
Zurück zum Zitat Merchant AI, Walters CB, Valenzuela J et al (2017) Creating a global acute care surgery fellowship to meet international need. J Surg Educ 74:780–786CrossRef Merchant AI, Walters CB, Valenzuela J et al (2017) Creating a global acute care surgery fellowship to meet international need. J Surg Educ 74:780–786CrossRef
43.
Zurück zum Zitat Taro T, Yao C, Ly S et al (2016) The global surgery partnership: an innovative partnership for education, research, and service. Acad Med 91:75–78CrossRef Taro T, Yao C, Ly S et al (2016) The global surgery partnership: an innovative partnership for education, research, and service. Acad Med 91:75–78CrossRef
49.
Zurück zum Zitat Kassam A-F, Park C, Lungu D et al (2019) Multi-Institutional Approach to Establishing a Sustainable Academic Global Surgery Program. J Am Coll Surg 229:S134–S135CrossRef Kassam A-F, Park C, Lungu D et al (2019) Multi-Institutional Approach to Establishing a Sustainable Academic Global Surgery Program. J Am Coll Surg 229:S134–S135CrossRef
50.
Zurück zum Zitat Sue GR, Covington WC, Chang J (2018) The ReSurge Global Training Program: a model for surgical training and capacity building in global reconstructive surgery. Ann Plast Surg 81:250–256CrossRef Sue GR, Covington WC, Chang J (2018) The ReSurge Global Training Program: a model for surgical training and capacity building in global reconstructive surgery. Ann Plast Surg 81:250–256CrossRef
51.
Zurück zum Zitat LeCompte MT, Goldman C, Tarpley JL et al (2018) Incorporation of a global surgery rotation into an academic general surgery residency program: impact and perceptions. World J Surg 42:2715–2724CrossRef LeCompte MT, Goldman C, Tarpley JL et al (2018) Incorporation of a global surgery rotation into an academic general surgery residency program: impact and perceptions. World J Surg 42:2715–2724CrossRef
54.
Zurück zum Zitat Miller C, Haber K, Panarelli E et al (2015) Collaborative resident education at a large teaching hospital in Kampala, Uganda. Ann Glob Heal 81:41–42CrossRef Miller C, Haber K, Panarelli E et al (2015) Collaborative resident education at a large teaching hospital in Kampala, Uganda. Ann Glob Heal 81:41–42CrossRef
55.
Zurück zum Zitat Anderson GA, Albutt K, Holmer H et al (2019) Development of a Novel Global Surgery Course for Medical Schools. J Surg Educ 76:469–479CrossRef Anderson GA, Albutt K, Holmer H et al (2019) Development of a Novel Global Surgery Course for Medical Schools. J Surg Educ 76:469–479CrossRef
59.
Zurück zum Zitat McNee MA, DeUgarte DA, Gerstle JT et al (2021) The first six years of the APSA travel fellowship program: impact and lessons learned. J Pediatr Surg 56:862–867 McNee MA, DeUgarte DA, Gerstle JT et al (2021) The first six years of the APSA travel fellowship program: impact and lessons learned. J Pediatr Surg 56:862–867
61.
Zurück zum Zitat Butler MW, Ozgediz D, Poenaru D et al (2015) The Global Paediatric Surgery Network: a model of subspecialty collaboration within global surgery. World J Surg 39:335–342CrossRef Butler MW, Ozgediz D, Poenaru D et al (2015) The Global Paediatric Surgery Network: a model of subspecialty collaboration within global surgery. World J Surg 39:335–342CrossRef
63.
Zurück zum Zitat Haider M, Jalloh M, Yin J et al (2020) The role of international partnerships in improving urethral reconstruction in low- and middle-income countries. World J Urol 38:3003–3011CrossRef Haider M, Jalloh M, Yin J et al (2020) The role of international partnerships in improving urethral reconstruction in low- and middle-income countries. World J Urol 38:3003–3011CrossRef
66.
Zurück zum Zitat Fuller A, Tran T, Muhumuza M, Haglund MM (2016) Building neurosurgical capacity in low and middle income countries. eNeurologicalSci 3:1–6CrossRef Fuller A, Tran T, Muhumuza M, Haglund MM (2016) Building neurosurgical capacity in low and middle income countries. eNeurologicalSci 3:1–6CrossRef
67.
Zurück zum Zitat Tierney S, O’Flynn E (2014) The Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland’s Collaboration with COSECSA. J Assoc Surg Gt Britain Irel 43(42):43 Tierney S, O’Flynn E (2014) The Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland’s Collaboration with COSECSA. J Assoc Surg Gt Britain Irel 43(42):43
70.
Zurück zum Zitat Deckelbaum DL, Gosselin-Tardif A, Ntakiyiruta G et al (2014) An innovative paradigm for surgical education programs in resource-limited settings. Can J Surg 57:298–299CrossRef Deckelbaum DL, Gosselin-Tardif A, Ntakiyiruta G et al (2014) An innovative paradigm for surgical education programs in resource-limited settings. Can J Surg 57:298–299CrossRef
72.
Zurück zum Zitat Wu H-H, Patel KR, Caldwell AM et al (2016) Surgical management and reconstruction training (SMART) course for orthopaedic surgeons: a 1-year prospective analysis. Lancet Glob Heal 4:11CrossRef Wu H-H, Patel KR, Caldwell AM et al (2016) Surgical management and reconstruction training (SMART) course for orthopaedic surgeons: a 1-year prospective analysis. Lancet Glob Heal 4:11CrossRef
74.
Zurück zum Zitat Harvey L, Curlin H, Grimm B et al (2020) Experience with a novel laparoscopic gynecologic curriculum in Haiti: lessons in implementation. Surg Endosc 34:2035–2039CrossRef Harvey L, Curlin H, Grimm B et al (2020) Experience with a novel laparoscopic gynecologic curriculum in Haiti: lessons in implementation. Surg Endosc 34:2035–2039CrossRef
75.
Zurück zum Zitat Inchauste SM, Deptula PL, Zelones JT et al (2020) Global health microsurgery training with cell phones. Ann Plast Surg 84:S273–S277CrossRef Inchauste SM, Deptula PL, Zelones JT et al (2020) Global health microsurgery training with cell phones. Ann Plast Surg 84:S273–S277CrossRef
76.
Zurück zum Zitat Ullrich S, Kisa P, Ruzgar N et al (2021) Implementation of a contextually appropriate pediatric emergency surgical care course in Uganda. J Pediatr Surg 56:811–815 Ullrich S, Kisa P, Ruzgar N et al (2021) Implementation of a contextually appropriate pediatric emergency surgical care course in Uganda. J Pediatr Surg 56:811–815
77.
Zurück zum Zitat Nataraja RM, Oo YM, Ljuhar D et al (2020) Overview of a novel paediatric surgical simulation-based medical education programme in Myanmar. ANZ J Surg 90:1925–1932CrossRef Nataraja RM, Oo YM, Ljuhar D et al (2020) Overview of a novel paediatric surgical simulation-based medical education programme in Myanmar. ANZ J Surg 90:1925–1932CrossRef
81.
Zurück zum Zitat Patel R, Khundkar R, Peter N et al (2019) Improving global surgery education for trainees. IJS Glob Health 2:7 Patel R, Khundkar R, Peter N et al (2019) Improving global surgery education for trainees. IJS Glob Health 2:7
89.
Zurück zum Zitat O’Flynn E, Erzingatsian K, Magee D (2019) Operating together: 12 years of collaboration between RCSI and COSECSA. Dublin O’Flynn E, Erzingatsian K, Magee D (2019) Operating together: 12 years of collaboration between RCSI and COSECSA. Dublin
Metadaten
Titel
Global Surgery Education and Training Programmes—a Scoping Review and Taxonomy
verfasst von
Eric O’Flynn
Arbab Danial
Jakub Gajewski
Publikationsdatum
25.08.2021
Verlag
Springer India
Erschienen in
Indian Journal of Surgery / Ausgabe Sonderheft 1/2022
Print ISSN: 0972-2068
Elektronische ISSN: 0973-9793
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12262-021-03081-w

Weitere Artikel der Sonderheft 1/2022

Indian Journal of Surgery 1/2022 Zur Ausgabe

Mehr Frauen im OP – weniger postoperative Komplikationen

21.05.2024 Allgemeine Chirurgie Nachrichten

Ein Frauenanteil von mindestens einem Drittel im ärztlichen Op.-Team war in einer großen retrospektiven Studie aus Kanada mit einer signifikanten Reduktion der postoperativen Morbidität assoziiert.

„Übersichtlicher Wegweiser“: Lauterbachs umstrittener Klinik-Atlas ist online

17.05.2024 Klinik aktuell Nachrichten

Sie sei „ethisch geboten“, meint Gesundheitsminister Karl Lauterbach: mehr Transparenz über die Qualität von Klinikbehandlungen. Um sie abzubilden, lässt er gegen den Widerstand vieler Länder einen virtuellen Klinik-Atlas freischalten.

Was nützt die Kraniektomie bei schwerer tiefer Hirnblutung?

17.05.2024 Hirnblutung Nachrichten

Eine Studie zum Nutzen der druckentlastenden Kraniektomie nach schwerer tiefer supratentorieller Hirnblutung deutet einen Nutzen der Operation an. Für überlebende Patienten ist das dennoch nur eine bedingt gute Nachricht.

Klinikreform soll zehntausende Menschenleben retten

15.05.2024 Klinik aktuell Nachrichten

Gesundheitsminister Lauterbach hat die vom Bundeskabinett beschlossene Klinikreform verteidigt. Kritik an den Plänen kommt vom Marburger Bund. Und in den Ländern wird über den Gang zum Vermittlungsausschuss spekuliert.

Update Chirurgie

Bestellen Sie unseren Fach-Newsletter und bleiben Sie gut informiert.

S3-Leitlinie „Diagnostik und Therapie des Karpaltunnelsyndroms“

Karpaltunnelsyndrom BDC Leitlinien Webinare
CME: 2 Punkte

Das Karpaltunnelsyndrom ist die häufigste Kompressionsneuropathie peripherer Nerven. Obwohl die Anamnese mit dem nächtlichen Einschlafen der Hand (Brachialgia parästhetica nocturna) sehr typisch ist, ist eine klinisch-neurologische Untersuchung und Elektroneurografie in manchen Fällen auch eine Neurosonografie erforderlich. Im Anfangsstadium sind konservative Maßnahmen (Handgelenksschiene, Ergotherapie) empfehlenswert. Bei nicht Ansprechen der konservativen Therapie oder Auftreten von neurologischen Ausfällen ist eine Dekompression des N. medianus am Karpaltunnel indiziert.

Prof. Dr. med. Gregor Antoniadis
Berufsverband der Deutschen Chirurgie e.V.

S2e-Leitlinie „Distale Radiusfraktur“

Radiusfraktur BDC Leitlinien Webinare
CME: 2 Punkte

Das Webinar beschäftigt sich mit Fragen und Antworten zu Diagnostik und Klassifikation sowie Möglichkeiten des Ausschlusses von Zusatzverletzungen. Die Referenten erläutern, welche Frakturen konservativ behandelt werden können und wie. Das Webinar beantwortet die Frage nach aktuellen operativen Therapiekonzepten: Welcher Zugang, welches Osteosynthesematerial? Auf was muss bei der Nachbehandlung der distalen Radiusfraktur geachtet werden?

PD Dr. med. Oliver Pieske
Dr. med. Benjamin Meyknecht
Berufsverband der Deutschen Chirurgie e.V.

S1-Leitlinie „Empfehlungen zur Therapie der akuten Appendizitis bei Erwachsenen“

Appendizitis BDC Leitlinien Webinare
CME: 2 Punkte

Inhalte des Webinars zur S1-Leitlinie „Empfehlungen zur Therapie der akuten Appendizitis bei Erwachsenen“ sind die Darstellung des Projektes und des Erstellungswegs zur S1-Leitlinie, die Erläuterung der klinischen Relevanz der Klassifikation EAES 2015, die wissenschaftliche Begründung der wichtigsten Empfehlungen und die Darstellung stadiengerechter Therapieoptionen.

Dr. med. Mihailo Andric
Berufsverband der Deutschen Chirurgie e.V.