Introduction
Methods
Study selection
-
Learners’ knowledge, post-intervention. Knowledge is defined as learners’ factual or conceptual understanding measured using change between pre- and post-test scores.
-
Learners’ skills post-intervention. Skills are defined as learners’ ability to demonstrate a procedure or technique in an educational setting.
-
Learners’ attitudes post-intervention towards new competencies, clinical practice or patients (e.g. recognition of moral and ethical responsibilities towards patients). Attitude is defined as the tendency to respond positively or negatively towards the intervention.
-
Learners’ satisfaction post-intervention with the learning intervention (e.g. retention rates, dropout rates, survey satisfaction scores). This can be defined as the level of approval when comparing the perceived performance of digital education compared with one’s expectations.
-
Change in healthcare professional’s practice or behaviour.
-
Cost and cost-effectiveness of the intervention
-
Patient-related outcomes (e.g. heaviness of smoking index, number of smoking cessation)
-
Adverse/unintended effects of the intervention
Data sources, collection, analysis and risk of bias assessment
Data synthesis and analysis
Results
Study, design, country | Learning modality | Guideline topic area | No. (type) of participants | Knowledge | Skill | Satisfaction | Behaviour | Patient outcome | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Digital education vs no intervention | |||||||||
Attin et al. [30], RCT, USA | I: Online scenario-based simulation module discussion C: No intervention | Resuscitation | 31 nursing students | – | Post-test mean score on a performance-based test SMD 0.93 [0.18, 1.68] | – | – |
–
| Skills: digital education > no intervention |
Butzlaff et al. [31], RCT, Germany | I: Online/offline learning module C: No intervention | Dementia, congestive heart failure, urinary tract infection and prevention of colorectal carcinoma | 72 primary care physicians | Post-test mean score on a 25-item MCQ SMD 0.43 [− 0.03, 0.90] | – | – | – |
–
| Knowledge: digital education = no intervention |
Kerfoot et al. [32], RCT, USA | I: Email-delivered, spaced education C: No intervention | Prostate cancer screening | 95 primary care clinicians (physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants) | Post-test mean score on a 19-item MCQ SMD 1.52 [1.06, 1.97] | – | – | Proportion of inappropriate PSA screening based on a per patient record RR 0.75 [0.69, 0.82] | – | Knowledge: digital education > no intervention Behaviour: digital education > no intervention |
Stewart et al. [33], RCT, USA | I: Online module and discussion C: No intervention | Preventive health practices for peri-menopausal patient, diabetic care | 58 primary care physicians | Post-test mean score on a 21-item questionnaire for preventive health practices for peri-menopausal women SMD 0.84 [0.30, 1.38] Post-test mean score on a 22-item questionnaire for type 2 diabetic care SMD 0.32 [− 0.30, 0.84] | – | – | Post-test mean scores from Chart audit for quality of practice on prevention for peri-menopausal patient SMD 0.35 [− 0.18, 0.87] Post-test mean scores from Chart audit for quality of practice on diabetes care SMD 0.01 [− 0.51, 0.52] Post-test mean scores assessed by undercover standardised patients for physician behaviours for prevention case SMD 0.25 [− 0.27, 0.77] Post-test mean scores assessed by undercover standardised patients for physician behaviours for diabetes case SMD 0.23 [− 0.28, 0.75] | – | Knowledge: digital education ≥ no intervention Behaviour: digital education = no intervention |
Digital education vs traditional learning | |||||||||
Bell et al. [34], RCT, USA | I: Online module C: Printed resources (including guidelines) | Care after myocardial infarction | 162 primary care and internal medicine residents | Post-test mean score on MCQ SMD 0.22 [− 0.08, 0.53] | – | Post-test mean score from a 5-item survey SMD 1.41 [1.06, 1.75] | – | – | Knowledge: digital education = traditional learning Satisfaction: digital education > traditional learning |
Fordis et al. [35], RCT, USA | I: Online module C: Small-group tutorial | Cholesterol management in adults | 103 primary care physicians | Post-test mean estimates on a 39-item MCQ and fixed choice responses | – | Proportion of participants rating the learning experience as “(very) good” RR 0.93 [0.85, 1.02] | Proportion of patients screened for dyslipidaemia as per patient record RR 1.02 [0.95, 1.10] Proportion of patients treated for dyslipidaemia as per patient record RR 1.05 [0.94, 1.16]* | – | Knowledge: digital education = traditional learning Behaviour: digital education = traditional learning Satisfaction: digital education = traditional learning |
Hemmati et al. [36], RCT, Iran | I: PowerPoint presentation C: Lecture | Resuscitation | 80 physicians | Post-test mean score on a 20-item MCQ SMD 0.43 [− 0.02, 0.87] | – | Post-test mean score from a 15-item survey SMD 3.48 [2.77, 4.18] | – | – | Knowledge: digital education = traditional learning Satisfaction: digital education > traditional learning |
Jousimaa et al. [37], cRCT, Finland | I: CD-ROM-based guidelines C: Printed guidelines | Consultation practice behaviours | 139 physicians | – | – | – | Proportion of laboratory examinations compliant with guidelines from a computer file log RR 1.01 [0.98, 1.03] Proportion of radiological examinations compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 1.01 [0.99, 1.02] Proportion of physical examinations compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 0.98 [0.96, 1.00] Proportion of other examinations compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 0.93 [0.85, 1.01] Proportion of procedures compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 0.95 [0.85, 1.05] Proportion of Physiotherapy sessions compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 0.98 [0.85, 1.12] Proportion of non-pharmacologic treatment compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 0.96 [0.87, 1.06] Proportion of pharmacological treatments compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 0.98 [0.95, 1.01] Proportion of referrals compliant with guidelines from computer file log RR 1.01 [0.99, 1.02] | – | Behaviour: digital education = traditional learning |
Nurse [38], RCT, USA | I: PowerPoint presentation C: Lecture | Pushing and positioning during labour | 10 nurses | Post-test mean score on a survey SMD − 0.79 [− 2.11, 0.53] | – | Post-test mean score on Allen’s semantic differential scale SMD 2.26 [0.49, 4.04] | – | – | Knowledge: digital education = traditional learning Satisfaction: digital education > traditional learning |
Schwid et al. [39], RCT, USA | I: Online simulation module C: Printed guidelines | Resuscitation | 45 anaesthesiology residents | – | Post-test mean score on Megacode performance checklist SMD 1.13 [0.50, 1.76] | – | – | – | Skills: digital education > traditional learning |
Shenoy [40], cRCT, USA | I: Online modules C: Printed guidelines | Physical therapy | 45 physiotherapists | Mean change score on a 38-item MCQ MD 0.04 [−1.22, 1.31] | – | – | Proportion of patients who received all interventions per guideline as per patient records RR 0.84 [0.45, 1.60] Proportion of patients who received most intervention per guideline as per patient records RR 1.01 [0.75, 1.37] Proportion of patients who received at least one intervention per guideline as per patient records RR 1.35 [0.47, 3.87] | Post-test mean score Patient Quality of life from Oswestry Disability Questionnaire MD − 1.82, [− 7.37, 3.72] | Knowledge: digital education = traditional learning Behaviour: digital education = traditional learning Patient outcomes: digital education = traditional learning |
Stephan et al. [41], RCT, Germany | I: Video demonstration C: Peer teaching | Paediatric basic life support | 88 medical students | – | Post-test mean score on OSCE examination SMD − 3.72 [− 4.42, − 3.02] | – | – | – | Skills: digital education < traditional learning |
Digital education (more interactive) vs digital education | |||||||||
Bonevski et al. [42], RCT, Australia | I: Online module with performance feedback C: Online module | Screening behaviour for cholesterol, blood pressure and cervical screening and identification of risk behaviours (smoking, alcohol consumption, benzodiazepine use) | 19 primary care physicians | – | – | – | Proportion of patients with cholesterol screening as per physician checklist RR 1.35 [1.12, 1.63] Proportion of patients accurately identified for alcohol consumption as per physician checklist RR 1.14 [1.01, 1.28] Proportion of patients with BP screening as per physician checklist RR 1.08 [0.99, 1.18] Proportion of patients accurately identified for long-term benzodiazepine use as per physician checklist RR 1.14 [0.91, 1.43] Proportion of patients accurately identified for smoking as per physician checklist RR 1.01 [0.87, 1.19] Proportion of patients accurately identified for benzodiazepine use as per physician checklist RR 1.03 [0.93, 1.15] Proportion of patients with BP screening as per physician checklist RR 1.06 [0.87, 1.30] | – | Behaviour: digital education (more interactive) ≥ digital education |
Billue et al. [43], cRCT, USA Crenshaw et al. [44], cRCT, USA Estrada [45], cRCT, USA | I: Website with performance feedback and reminders C: Online resources | Glucose, blood pressure and lipids control | 205 primary care physicians | – | – | – | Rate of medication intensification for HbA1C control as per patient records RR 1.05 [0.88, 1.24] Rate of medication intensification for BP control as per patient records RR 0.98 [0.75, 1.27] Rate of medication intensification for LDL control as per patient records RR 1.35 [0.94, 1.93] | Proportion of patients with optimal control of HbA1C (< 7%) as per patient records RR 1.10 [0.98, 1.24] Proportion of patients with optimal control of BP as per patient records RR 1.10 [0.92, 1.32] Proportion of patients with optimal control of LDL as per patient records RR 0.95 [0.86, 1.05] | Behaviour: digital education (more interactive) = digital education Patient outcome: digital education (more interactive) = digital education |
Kerfoot et al. [46], RCT, USA | I: Email-delivered, spaced education game C: Online resources | Blood pressure control | 111 primary care physicians | Post-test mean score on a 24-item MCQ SMD 0.81 [0.43, 1.20] | – | – | Rate of monthly medication intensification as per patient records RR 0.95 [0.54, 1.67] Rate of monthly lifestyle counselling as per patient records RR 0.91 [0.66, 1.26] | Duration of the hypertensive period as per as per patient records HR 1.043 [1.007, 1.081] | Knowledge: digital education (more interactive) > digital education Behaviour: digital education (more interactive) = digital education Patient outcome: digital education (more interactive) > digital education |
Leszczynski et al. [47], RCT, Poland | a) Online modules with audio-visual material, a questionnaire and feedback b) Online modules with audio-visual material c) Online modules with textual-graphical material | Resuscitation | 65 emergency medicine students | Post-test mean change score on a 30-item MCQ (a vs c) SMD 0 [− 0.60, 0.60] Post-test mean change score on a 30-item MCQ (a vs b) SMD 0.10 [− 0.5, 0.70] Post-test mean change score on a 30-item MCQ (b vs c) SMD −0.10 [− 0.72, 0.52] | – | – | – | – | Knowledge: digital education (more interactive) = digital education |
Schroter et al. [16], RCT, UK | I: Online module and knowledge-based feedback and customization C: Online resources | Diabetes management | 1054 physicians and nurses | Post-test mean score on a 19-item MCQ SMD − 0.09 [− 0.21, 0.03] | – | – | Self-reported practice change via survey RR 0.93 [0.83, 1.04] | Knowledge: digital education (more interactive) = digital education Behaviour: digital education (more interactive) = digital education |