Introduction
Methods
Search strategy
Selection criteria
Data extraction and quality assessment
Statistical analysis
Results
Literature search
Study characteristics
Author (Ref) | Publication Year | Location | Study design | Age Range | Number of cases | No. Positive in cases | Number of controls | No. Positive in controls |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Oh [28] | 2003 | Germany | Cross-Sectional | 29 days to 15.5 years | 217 | 31 | ||
Phan [29] | 2004 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | 2 months to 14 years | 236 | 9 | ||
Yan [30] | 2004 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 7 years | 207 | 12 | ||
Akihara [31] | 2005 | Japan | Case-Control | 1 month to 2 years | 88 | 11 | 833 | 96 |
Logan [32] | 2006 | Ireland | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 220 | 11 | ||
Phan [33] | 2006 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | 5 months to 8 years | 125 | 1 | ||
Reither [34] | 2007 | Ghana | Case-Control | Under 12 years | 243 | 67 | 124 | 39 |
Chen [35] | 2007 | Taiwan | Cross-Sectional | 3 months to 18 years | 257 | 51 | ||
Fabiana [36] | 2007 | Italy | Cross-Sectional | 2 months to 12 years | 313 | 29 | ||
Nguyen [37] | 2007 | Vietnam | Cross-Sectional | 37 days to 9 years | 1010 | 32 | ||
Shimizu [38] | 2007 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | 3 months to 14 years | 337 | 27 | ||
Gomara [39] | 2008 | UK | Cross-Sectional | Under 6 years | 685 | 66 | ||
Jin [40] | 2008 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 1110 | 85 | ||
Silva [41] | 2008 | Ghana | Cross-Sectional | Under 11 years | 367 | 73 | ||
Verma [42] | 2008 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 439 | 34 | ||
Dey [43] | 2009 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | Under 10 years | 628 | 28 | ||
Dey [44] | 2009 | Bangladesh | Cross-Sectional | 2 months to 3.2 years | 917 | 17 | ||
Jin [45] | 2009 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 544 | 18 | ||
Kittigul [46] | 2009 | Thailand | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 131 | 4 | ||
Li [47] | 2009 | Hong Kong | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 209 | 7 | ||
Nakanishi [48] | 2009 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | Under 14 years | 877 | 33 | ||
Podkolzin [49] | 2009 | Russia | Cross-Sectional | Under 14 years | 3208 | 119 | ||
Sdiri-Loulizi [50] | 2009 | Tunisia | Cross-Sectional | Under 12 years | 788 | 18 | ||
Cunliffe [51] | 2010 | UK | Cross-Sectional | Under 16 years | 576 | 83 | ||
Rasanen [52] | 2010 | Finland | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 50 | 5 | ||
Zhang [53] | 2011 | China | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 201 | 10 | 53 | 5 |
Khamrin [54] | 2011 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 235 | 8 | ||
Rimoldi [55] | 2011 | Italy | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 273 | 4 | ||
Braun [27] | 2012 | USA | Case-Control | Under 2 years | 24 | 11 | 78 | 43 |
Chaimongkol [56] | 2012 | Thailand | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 160 | 3 | ||
Grant [57] | 2012 | USA | Cross-Sectional | Under 9 months | 247 | 3 | ||
Lee [58] | 2012 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 2064 | 113 | ||
Ouyang [59] | 2012 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 766 | 135 | ||
Rezaei [60] | 2012 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 100 | 8 | ||
Seo [61] | 2012 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | Under 10 years | 310 | 48 | ||
Chhabra [62] | 2013 | USA | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 782 | 93 | 499 | 9 |
Al-Thani [63] | 2013 | Qatar | Cross-Sectional | Under 10 years | 121 | 11 | ||
Chen [64] | 2013 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 811 | 22 | ||
Chen [65] | 2013 | Taiwan | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 755 | 69 | ||
Dey [66] | 2013 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 7185 | 565 | ||
Ren [67] | 2013 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 477 | 30 | ||
So [68] | 2013 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | 1 month to 11 years | 186 | 0 | ||
Zhu [69] | 2013 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 3 years | 749 | 6 | ||
Kabayiza [70] | 2014 | Rwanda | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 544 | 216 | 162 | 68 |
Chhabra [71] | 2014 | Soviet Union | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 495 | 20 | ||
Kabayiza [72] | 2014 | Rwanda | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 880 | 216 | ||
Liu [73] | 2014 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 6 years | 2233 | 219 | ||
Mitui [74] | 2014 | Turkey and Bangladesh | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 288 | 168 | ||
Raboni [75] | 2014 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 225 | 45 | ||
Soli [76] | 2014 | New Guinea | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 199 | 23 | ||
Amaral [77] | 2015 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 591 | 12 | ||
Chen [78] | 2015 | Taiwan | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 2810 | 105 | ||
Khoshdel [79] | 2015 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 100 | 22 | ||
La Rosa [19] | 2015 | Albania | Cross-Sectional | 2 months to 7 years | 142 | 33 | ||
Lekana-Douki [80] | 2015 | Gabon | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 317 | 62 | ||
Liu [81] | 2015 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 2171 | 150 | ||
Lu [82] | 2015 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 436 | 31 | ||
Mladenova [83] | 2015 | Bulgaria | Cross-Sectional | Under 3 years | 115 | 11 | ||
Osborne [84] | 2015 | USA | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 941 | 95 | ||
Patil [85] | 2015 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 9 years | 950 | 12 | ||
Thongprachum [86] | 2015 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 2381 | 134 | ||
Yu [87] | 2015 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 18,266 | 879 | ||
Zhang [88] | 2015 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 14 years | 1128 | 76 | ||
Li [89] | 2016 | China | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 461 | 50 | 461 | 12 |
Ouédraogo [90] | 2016 | Burkina Faso | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 263 | 82 | 50 | 25 |
Steyer [91] | 2016 | Slovenia | Case-Control | Under 6 years | 297 | 22 | 88 | 0 |
Brown [92] | 2016 | UK | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 1393 | 146 | ||
Dashti [93] | 2016 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 2682 | 132 | ||
Jin [94] | 2016 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | 1 month to 16 years | 345 | 26 | ||
Liu [95] | 2016 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 3147 | 324 | ||
Nakamura [96] | 2016 | Japan | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 1796 | 88 | ||
Reis [97] | 2016 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 12 years | 377 | 47 | ||
Shen [98] | 2016 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 137 | 3 | ||
Colak [99] | 2017 | Turkey | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 180 | 25 | ||
Cornejo-Tapia [100] | 2017 | Peru | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 117 | 17 | ||
Costa [101] | 2017 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 2 years | 172 | 74 | ||
Hawash [102] | 2017 | Saudi Arabia | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 76 | 5 | ||
Kim [103] | 2017 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | Under 16 years | 415 | 56 | ||
Lu [104] | 2017 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 674 | 32 | ||
Stockmann [105] | 2017 | USA | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 1089 | 71 | ||
Zaki [106] | 2017 | Egypt | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 100 | 20 | ||
Qiu [107] | 2018 | China | Case-Control | Under 18 years | 273 | 79 | 361 | 26 |
Adam [108] | 2018 | Sudan | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 437 | 7 | ||
Alcala [109] | 2018 | Venezuela | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 227 | 26 | ||
Biscaro [110] | 2018 | Italy | Cross-Sectional | 2 months to 15 years | 510 | 35 | ||
Primo [111] | 2018 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 10 years | 2009 | 107 | ||
Yu [112] | 2018 | Taiwan | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 837 | 13 | ||
Hassan [113] | 2019 | USA | Case-Control | Under 2 years | 330 | 75 | 272 | 44 |
Iturriza-Gomara [114] | 2019 | Malawi | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 684 | 199 | 527 | 14 |
Lima [115] | 2019 | Brazil | Case-Control | 2 months to 3 years | 588 | 19 | 573 | 5 |
Shen [116] | 2019 | China | Case-Control | Under 18 years | 273 | 24 | 361 | 16 |
Tilmanne [117] | 2019 | Belgium | Case-Control | Under 16 years | 178 | 12 | 165 | 5 |
Arashkia [118] | 2019 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 376 | 16 | ||
Arowolo [119] | 2019 | Nigeria | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 175 | 9 | ||
Elmahdy [120] | 2019 | Egypt | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 60 | 17 | ||
Gaensbauer [121] | 2019 | Guatemala | Cross-Sectional | 6 to 35 months | 316 | 41 | ||
Gelaw [13] | 2019 | Ethiopia | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 450 | 144 | ||
Goldar [122] | 2019 | India | Cross-Sectional | 6 months to 5 years | 80 | 27 | ||
Harb [123] | 2019 | Iraq | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 155 | 53 | ||
Kumthip [12] | 2019 | Thailand | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 2312 | 165 | ||
Portal [124] | 2019 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 9 years | 219 | 110 | ||
Pratte-Santos [125] | 2019 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 12 years | 134 | 81 | ||
Tatte [126] | 2019 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 185 | 5 | ||
Theamboonlers [127] | 2019 | Thailand | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 442 | 87 | ||
Farfan-Garcia [128] | 2020 | Colombia | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 431 | 14 | 430 | 1 |
Pabbaraju [129] | 2020 | Canada | Case-Control | Under 18 years | 3347 | 629 | 1355 | 97 |
Dey [130] | 2020 | Bangladesh | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 574 | 24 | ||
Kim [131] | 2020 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 740 | 7 | ||
Lambisia [132] | 2020 | Kenya | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 984 | 120 | ||
Mohammadi [133] | 2020 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 103 | 3 | ||
Mousavi Nasab [134] | 2020 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 120 | 6 | ||
Romo-Saenz [135] | 2020 | Mexico | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 57 | 8 | ||
Sharif [136] | 2020 | Bangladesh | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 387 | 22 | ||
Zhu [137] | 2020 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 1220 | 37 | ||
Alsuwaidi [138] | 2021 | UAE | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 203 | 35 | 73 | 2 |
Harrison [139] | 2021 | USA | Case-Control | Under 11 years | 660 | 51 | 624 | 9 |
Huang [140] | 2021 | China | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 383 | 21 | 327 | 13 |
Mero [141] | 2021 | Guinea-Bissau | Case-Control | Under 5 years | 228 | 40 | 201 | 32 |
Abdel-Rahman [142] | 2021 | Qatar | Cross-Sectional | 3 months and 14 years | 901 | 59 | ||
Barsoum [143] | 2021 | Ireland | Cross-Sectional | Under 3 years | 150 | 19 | ||
Chandra [144] | 2021 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 3882 | 351 | ||
Chang [145] | 2021 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 2692 | 193 | ||
De Francesco [146] | 2021 | Italy | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 476 | 34 | ||
Gopalkrishna [147] | 2021 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 308 | 25 | ||
Huang [14] | 2021 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 656 | 49 | ||
Lu [148] | 2021 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 804 | 28 | ||
Ndjangangoye [149] | 2021 | Gabon | Cross Sectional | Under 15 years | 66 | 54 | ||
Olivares [150] | 2021 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 458 | 139 | ||
Rossouw [151] | 2021 | South Africa | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 221 | 15 | ||
Souza [152] | 2021 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 1992 | 166 | ||
Souza [153] | 2021 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 14 years | 3419 | 171 | ||
Wang [26] | 2021 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 85,001 | 2284 | ||
Abbasi [154] | 2022 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 7 years | 173 | 4 | ||
Allayeh [155] | 2022 | Egypt | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 447 | 35 | ||
Al-Nasrawy [156] | 2022 | Iraq | Cross-Sectional | Under 3 years | 450 | 150 | ||
Colito [157] | 2022 | Cape Verde | Cross-Sectional | Under 12 years | 105 | 7 | ||
do Nascimento [158] | 2022 | Brazil | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 1012 | 227 | ||
Dong [159] | 2022 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 897 | 106 | ||
Gelaw [160] | 2022 | Ethiopia | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 38 | 7 | ||
Jo [161] | 2022 | South Korea | Cross-Sectional | Under 9 years | 184 | 1 | ||
Li [162] | 2022 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 14 years | 160 | 15 | ||
Mihala [163] | 2022 | Australia | Cross-Sectional | Under 2 years | 11,111 | 2171 | ||
Mitra [164] | 2022 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 3157 | 276 | ||
Othma [165] | 2022 | Egypt | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 50 | 3 | ||
Shams [166] | 2022 | Iran | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 130 | 23 | ||
Tang [20] | 2022 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 14 years | 1352 | 60 | ||
Yılmaz [167] | 2022 | Turkey | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 94 | 13 | ||
Bhat [168] | 2023 | India | Cross-Sectional | 1 month to 18 years | 109 | 0 | ||
Borkakoty [169] | 2023 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 407 | 187 | ||
Eifan [170] | 2023 | Saudi Arabia | Cross-Sectional | Under 18 years | 97 | 6 | ||
Hugho [3] | 2023 | Tanzania | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 146 | 29 | ||
Joshi [16] | 2023 | India | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 1167 | 61 | ||
Lu [171] | 2023 | China | Cross-Sectional | Under 15 years | 1048 | 97 | ||
Ndjangangoye [172] | 2023 | Gabon | Cross Sectional | Under 15 years | 284 | 75 | ||
Potgieter [173] | 2023 | South Africa | Cross-Sectional | Under 5 years | 275 | 52 |
Prevalence of HAdV infection among children with gastroenteritis
Group | Number of studies | Pooled prevalence (%) (95%CI) | Heterogeneity test I2%, p-value | Differences between subgroups; χ2 test (p-value) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Overall prevalence | - | 155 | 0.10 (0.09–0.11) | 98.63, < 0.001 | |
Study design | Cross-sectional | 134 | 0.10 (0.08–0.11) | 98.58, < 0.001 | P = 0.01 |
Case-control | 21 | 0.15 (0.11–0.20) | 97.32, < 0.001 | ||
Method | Nested PCR | 8 | 0.23 (0.12–0.37) | 98.17, < 0.001 | P < 0.001 |
Multiplex PCR | 44 | 0.05 (0.04–0.06) | 94.27, < 0.001 | ||
Real-time PCR | 29 | 0.15 (0.12–0.19) | 98.27, < 0.001 | ||
Conventional PCR | 61 | 0.09 (0.08–0.11) | 98.09, < 0.001 | ||
Multiplex Real-time PCR | 13 | 0.17 (0.10–0.26) | 97.74, < 0.001 | ||
Primer | Universal | 118 | 0.10 (0.09–0.12) | 98.84, < 0.001 | P = 0.60 |
Group F | 37 | 0.10 (0.08–0.12) | 95.87, < 0.001 | ||
Sampling time | 1996–2000 | 2 | 0.32 (0.26–0.37) | NA | P < 0.001 |
2001–2005 | 16 | 0.08 (0.04–0.12) | 97.74, < 0.001 | ||
2006–2010 | 36 | 0.08 (0.06–0.09) | 95.15, < 0.001 | ||
2011–2015 | 42 | 0.12 (0.10–0.15) | 98.88, < 0.001 | ||
2016–2020 | 51 | 0.11 (0.08–0.13) | 97.21, < 0.001 | ||
2021–2022 | 8 | 0.13 (0.06–0.21) | 99.14, < 0.001 | ||
Continent | South America | 26 | 0.16 (0.10–0.22) | 98.61, < 0.001 | P < 0.001 |
Asia | 84 | 0.07 (0.06–0.08) | 97.70, < 0.001 | ||
Europe | 18 | 0.09 (0.07–0.12) | 92.45, < 0.001 | ||
Africa | 9 | 0.20 (0.14–0.26) | 97.93, < 0.001 | ||
North America | 16 | 0.12 (0.08–0.18) | 96.96, < 0.001 | ||
Oceania | 2 | 0.19 (0.19–0.20) | NA | ||
Gender | Male | 19 | 0.08 (0.06–0.11) | 90.64, < 0.001 | P = 0.63 |
Female | 19 | 0.08 (0.06–0.10) | 87.95, < 0.001 | ||
Age (month) | 0–6 | 18 | 0.08 (0.05–0.12) | 93.26, < 0.001 | P = 0.56 |
7–12 | 17 | 0.09 (0.06–0.13) | 95.36, < 0.001 | ||
13–24 | 19 | 0.14 (0.09–0.20) | 95.31, < 0.001 | ||
25–36 | 12 | 0.11 (0.04–0.19) | 90.97, < 0.001 | ||
37–48 | 8 | 0.10 (0.02–0.22) | 86.23, < 0.001 | ||
49–60 | 8 | 0.06 (0.00-0.16) | 80.80, < 0.001 | ||
Age (year) | 0–5 | 38 | 0.11 (0.08–0.13) | 98.49, < 0.001 | P < 0.001 |
6–18 | 23 | 0.04 (0.02–0.05) | 83.87, < 0.001 | ||
Patient type | Outpatients | 27 | 0.07 (0.05–0.08) | 95.88, < 0.001 | P = 0.09 |
Inpatients | 62 | 0.09 (0.07–0.10) | 96.95, < 0.001 | ||
Species | A | 7 | 0.05 (0.01–0.11) | 71.62, < 0.001 | P < 0.001 |
B | 6 | 0.05 (0.01–0.11) | 80.03, < 0.001 | ||
C | 8 | 0.29 (0.16–0.44) | 88.67, < 0.001 | ||
D | 5 | 0.09 (0.02–0.19) | 88.08, < 0.001 | ||
E | 2 | 0.05 (0.01–0.12) | NA | ||
F | 7 | 0.57 (0.41–0.72) | 89.01, < 0.001 |