Background
The two regions of the brain most intensively scrutinized in recent years for their reparative or cell replacement potential are the subventricular zone (SVZ) which lines the lateral ventricles and the subgranular zone (SGZ) of the hippocampal dentate gyrus [
1,
2]. Both regions daily generate thousands of interneurons that integrate into synaptic circuitry. SVZ neuroblasts migrate long distances from their birthplaces near the lateral ventricles to the olfactory bulbs via the rostral migratory stream (RMS) [
3]. The SVZ, including human SVZ, contains cells that self-renew and are multipotential when exposed to appropriate growth factors in vitro; they are stem cells [
4]. As such, they may provide a source for cell replacement, and many experiments have shown they attempt repair of damaged or diseased tissue [
1].
Hipppocampal microglia dampen neurogenesis during inflammation [
5,
6]. Hematopoietic lineage cells comprise approximately five percent of cells in the SVZ [
7‐
9], yet the constitutive and pathological role of these cells within the SVZ is poorly understood. SVZ microglia are distinctive: they express relatively high levels of CD45, a tyrosine phosphatase, they proliferate more than microglia in non-neurogenic regions, and are resistant to traumatic brain injury that causes microglial activation in adjacent nuclei [
7]. Macrophages migrate into the brain during late development in certain foci, including the lateral ventricles and SVZ [
10] and then become resident microglia. Interestingly, neural macroglia (astrocytes and oligodendrocytes) are generated in the SVZ during late development and migrate throughout the forebrain. Thus although microglial and macroglial lineages are different [
11], their emigration routes from the SVZ into the postnatal forebrain are very similar. These same migratory routes, fanning out into the forebrain from the SVZ, are followed by SVZ neuronal cells after a variety of injuries and diseases [
12,
13].
CD45 exhibits multiple splicing isoforms and modulates microglial and T cell activation [
14‐
16]. Upon activation, resident microglia undergo morphological changes consistent with their function: amoeboid for migrating to areas of injury and round for phagocytosis. FACsorting of immunofluorescent cells is used to distinguish resident microglia (CD45
low) from infiltrating macrophages (CD45
high) [
17]. We have shown that immunolabelling sections with anti-CD45 antibodies also reveals CD45
low (the majority of cells under normal conditions) versus CD45
high cells [
7]. Levels of CD45 expression correlate with levels of microglial activation, CD45
high expression indicating significant activation. Interestingly, CD45 mutations have been observed in some multiple sclerosis (MS) patients suggesting that it is not merely a "marker" but may contribute to the etiology of the disease [
18].
MS is a demyelinating disease mediated by inflammation. In addition to loss of oligodendrocytes and myelin, neuronal apoptosis occurs in the forebrain and other regions [
19‐
21]. The etiology of the disease is still elusive; possibilities range from spontaneous autoimmunity to a primary CNS insult such as infection. Because of the variability and uncertain etiology of MS, a variety of preclinical models are used to replicate specific features of the disease. The sclerotic lesions evident in the CNS are sites of CD45+ microglial, macrophage, dendritic cell, and T-cell accumulation indicative of an inflammatory response. Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) infection of susceptible SJL mice is a model used to study this response [
22‐
24]. The TMEV model is consistent with chronic, progressive inflammatory demyelination rather than the relapsing/remitting disease profile of the experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) model [
25]. In addition, TMEV results in the direct infection of microglia, whereas in EAE, microglia are activated secondary to the autoimmune response [
25].
Interestingly the two co-receptors used by different Theiler's virus strains, sialic acid and heparan sulfate [
26] are expressed at high levels in the SVZ. In fact, polysialic acid residues attached to the neural cell adhesion molecule (PSA-NCAM) are required for SVZ neuroblast migration [
27]. The SVZ augments new oligodendrocyte production in EAE [
28,
29], and syngeneic SVZ neurospheres ameliorated EAE pathology in mice, pointing to the potential for SVZ repair of MS [
30]. The clinical MRI and pathological description of "Dawson's fingers", lesions extending from the lateral ventricles to surrounding regions [
31,
32] suggest that the SVZ and periventricular regions are particularly sensitive to MS. Despite these tantalizing data, whether TMEV induces inflammation in the SVZ, and the effects of TMEV on SVZ neurogenesis and migration have remained unstudied until now. If SVZ inflammation is prominent in MS and this reduces neurogenesis, it may reduce autologous repair. Also, though there is an extensive literature on TMEV, a within-study comprehensive characterization of the time-course and anterior to posterior spread of viral induced CD45+ cell activation has not been carried out. Therefore, in these experiments we examined CD45+ cell activation and studied its spatio-temporal relationship to SVZ neurogenesis and emigration after TMEV. We show here with an antibody that recognizes all isoforms of CD45, that forebrain CD45+ cell activation precedes spinal cord activation and that the SVZ is the area with the most consistent CD45+ cell activation. We also document SVZ neuroblast emigration into inflamed periventricular regions and a delayed decrease in neurogenesis.
Methods
Mice
Eighty 6–7 week old female wild type SJL/J mice (Taconic Labs) were used in the TMEV studies. All mice were housed in the Northwestern University animal care containment facility and were provided with unlimited access to standard laboratory food and water. Easier access to food and water was provided for TMEV injected animals exhibiting neurological impairment.
TMEV disease induction
Three groups of mice were used: TMEV, sham, and naïve. Together, sham and naïve mice constituted "controls". TMEV and sham mice were anesthetized with 4% isoflurane. 3 × 106 PFU BeAN 8386 virus, suspended in sterile 0.03 ml BSS, was injected into the right cerebellar cortex through a 27 gauge needle fitted with a needle guard to prevent penetration beyond 3.5 mm ventral to skull. Injections were localized to a point half-way to midline at ear level. Sham mice received injections of 0.03 ml BSS. Naïve mice were not anesthetized or injected. All mice were monitored for changes in neurological status two to three times per week. Mice were assigned numerical scores as follows: 0 = asymptomatic; 1 = mild waddling gait; 2 = moderate waddling gait without spastic paralysis; 3 = severe waddling gait with mild spastic paralysis; 4 = severe waddling gait with moderate to severe spastic paralysis; 5 = total hind limb paralysis; 6 = moribund. Mice were further divided into three groups according to clinical scores or time point match for sham and naive: preclinical = prior to onset of any symptoms but after initial inflammatory/increased stress due to injections (D 14–24); early onset = clinical score of 1 or more for 2 consecutive days (D 42–47); chronic = increased clinical score (2 or 3) for minimum of 5 consecutive days (D 90). Each group had its respective control mice. Preclinical sham N = 4, Preclinical naïve N = 1, Preclinical TMEV N = 27; early onset sham N = 5, early onset naïve N = 1, early onset TMEV N = 25; chronic sham N = 4, chronic naïve N = 1, chronic TMEV N = 4.
Cuprizone induced demyelination
Chow containing 0.2% cuprizone (Harlan Teklad) was fed to C57Bl mice (N = 7) ad libitum for 3 weeks. Control mice (N = 7) received the same chow minus cuprizone.
Tissue preparation and immunohistochemistry
Mice were perfused with 4% paraformaldehyde, brains post-fixed overnight, and cryoprotected in 30% sucrose overnight at 4°C before sectioning. Free-floating coronal sections, 30 μm thick, were cut on a sliding microtome and stored in cryoprotectant at -20°C. Antibodies used: rat anti-CD45 (clone IBL-5/25; 1:500, Chemicon, Temeluca, CA); goat anti-doublecortin (C-terminus; 1:200, Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Santa Cruz California), rabbit anti-BeAn (1:600, Miller Lab, Northwestern University), mouse anti-PSA-NCAM (1:500, Chemicon), rabbit anti-phosphohistone3 (1:500, Upstate Biotechnology). Sections were washed and blocked with 50 mM glycine in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) to reduce autofluorescence of paraformaldehyde-fixed tissue. Sections were washed, blocked in PBS containing 0.1% Triton X-100 and 10% Donkey Serum, DS (Sigma), (PBS+), incubated overnight at 4°C in primary antibodies, washed, incubated one hr at RT in Cy2 (1:200) or Cy3 (1:500) conjugated anti-primary secondaries, and rinsed in phosphate buffer (PB). Sections were mounted and slides were coverslipped with FluorSave mounting medium (Chemicon) in PBS. Ommission of primary antibody was used as controls in all immunohistochemistry experiments.
Microscopy, quantification, and data analysis
A comprehensive anterior to posterior set of brain sections were examined at the following anatomical coordinates [
33]. Olfactory bulb (4.0 to 3.0 mm anterior to bregma), anterior cortex (3.0 to 2.0 mm anterior to bregma), striatum (1.7 to -0.5 mm from Bregma), hippocampus (-1.0 to -2.5 mm posterior to bregma), cerebellum (-5.6 to -7.0 mm from bregma). In addition, we collected sections from cervical, thoracic, and lumbar spinal cord. Immunohistochemistry was examined and recorded on a Leica DMIRB microscope using Openlab software and on a Zeiss Meta confocal microscope, and analyzed in 3-D with Zeiss and Volocity Software. Images were composed in Adobe Photoshop.
Doublecortin SVZ neurogenesis quantification. Doublecortin Cell Counts. Images of doublecortin and DAPI labeled sections of the dl SVZ were taken at 63× on a Zeiss Meta confocal microscope with a single scan of both channels. The images were saved and exported as tiff images into Openlab Image software (Improvision). In Openlab Dcx+ cells and DAPI+ cell nuclei in the dl SVZ were counted.
Dcx immunofluorescence surface area measurements. We used these measurements to confirm Dcx+ cell counts. Images of doublecortin labeled sections were taken at identical camera settings and positive Dcx immunofluorescence intensity threshold levels pre-determined. We used these levels to calculate the percent of the SVZ surface area occupied by positive Dcx immunofluorescence in the dorsolateral SVZ (dl SVZ).
Hippocampal Dcx+ cell counts. All Dcx+ cells were counted in the subgranular zone of the dentate gyrus unilaterally.
Emigrated Dcx+ cell quantification. The large majority of cells that emigrated in controls and after TMEV did not move more then a few hundred microns from the SVZ. Therefore the large majority of cells were within the distances sampled. Doublecortin labeled striatal sections were viewed at 40× on a Leica DMIRB upright microscope. Emigrated Dcx+ cells were counted unilaterally. With the SVZ to the left margin of the field of view at 40×, Dcx+ cells in the striatum were counted, with the SVZ to the right margin of the field of view, septal Dcx+ cells were counted, with the SVZ in the middle of the field showing the full extent of the CC thickness, Dcx+ cells in the CC were counted, with the ventral 3rd of the SVZ in the middle of the field, emigrated Dcx+ cells in the ventral 3rd septum, striatum and surrounding ventral SVZ were counted.
Phosphohistone3 cell counts. Images of phosphohistone3 labelled sections of the dorsolateral, medial septal and ventral-medial SVZ and were taken at 40× on a Leica DMRIB microscope. The images were saved and exported as tiff images into Volocity (Improvision). The number of phosphohistone H3+ cells were counted and averaged for 6 consecutive sections per animal ranging from ~bregma 0.9 to 0.0. Only cells that had bright, complete labelling in the nuclei were included, cells that showed fragmented staining were excluded. All measurements were taken by staggering controls and treated mice to avoid quantification drift bias. Satistics were performed in Microsoft Excel; Student's T-tests (two tailed, equal variance) with p values < 0.05 were considered to be significant.
Discussion
We showed that in TMEV-induced inflammation, CD45+ cell activation within the forebrain is most consistently found in the SVZ and periventricular regions. Interestingly, neuroblast emigration from the SVZ increased at the same time as CD45+ cell activation. At later time points, when SVZ inflammation had subsided, neurogenesis decreased. We also showed that the forebrain is affected before the cerebellum and spinal cord. In contrast to the spinal cord, where extensive CD45+ cell infiltration was observed in white matter tracts, forebrain white matter was relatively spared at all time points.
A wide variety of preclinical models of injury and disease increase neurogenesis and induce neuroblast emigration from the SVZ [
1,
12,
13,
49]. We showed that TMEV induced SVZ neuroblasts to emigrate, to our knowledge, the first example of neuronal emigration from the SVZ in a model of brain inflammation. Since maximal emigration occurred at the same time as maximal CD45+ cell activation in the forebrain, it is very likely that CD45+ activated cells secrete molecules contributing to SVZ neuroblast emigration. Future mechanistic studies may identify molecular interactions between CD45+ cells and SVZ neuroblasts and thereby lead to molecular approaches designed to augment neural repair.
Although neuroblast emigration was augmented at early time points after TMEV inoculation, the number of neuroblasts was unchanged. Other studies have shown that inflammation rapidly reduces adult neurogenesis [
5,
6], however we did not observe decreases in Dcx+ neuroblasts during the time of maximal inflammation. Decreased numbers of Dcx+ neuroblasts were only found in "chronic mice", well after major inflammation had subsided. Surprisingly, Dcx+ cell numbers decreased in both the SVZ and dentate gyrus, even though only the former exhibited focal inflammation. Our results suggest that even though SVZ neuroblasts emigrate relatively soon after TMEV inoculation, any autologous repair may be attenuated by delayed decreases in neurogenesis.
One of the most novel and unpredictable findings of our study was that although forebrain activation of CD45+ cells was stochastic from section to section, and from mouse to mouse, it was remarkably consistent in the SVZ. Our results suggest that this is not a general response to demyelination since cuprizone induced demyelination did not activate CD45 expression in the SVZ. We favor two main possible mechanisms for our finding after TMEV infection: viral SVZ macrophage tropism or viral spread through the ventricular system. CD45+ cells are constitutively semi-activated in the SVZ [
7] and CD45+ cells were consistently activated in the SVZ and in the RMS. Since TMEV preferentially infects activated microglia [
50,
51], the relatively high levels of constitutive macrophage activation in the SVZ [
7] may predispose them to infection. Another interpretation of our study is that the ventricular system is a conduit for viral spread. CD45 activation was high in the preclinical group near the ventricular system: lateral ventricle, 3
rd ventricle, periventricular hippocampus, and 4
th ventricle. Immunodetectable virus was associated with SVZ neuroblasts and Theiler's virus exhibits tropism for sialic acid residues [
26], thus it also possible that PSA-NCAM+ neuroblasts may be preferentially infected.
We found vigorous CD45+ cell activation throughout the forebrain already at two weeks after viral induction, suggesting that it commenced earlier. Microglial activation can occur quite rapidly, within hours to days after insults. By the time clinical symptomatology appeared in TMEV mice, CD45+ cell activation in the forebrain had diminished. In contrast to the forebrain, the major CD45+ cell activation in the cerebellum occurred three months after TMEV infection, which is surprising since TMEV was injected into the cerebellum. Similar to the cerebellum, the major spinal cord response was in the chronic group. Based on our results with this model, subtle forebrain inflammation mediated symptomatology may precede the severe spinal cord mediated motor defects in MS.
Whereas the large majority of newborn cells in the adult SVZ are young neurons, a few oligodendrocytes are also generated constitutively [
12,
52]. EAE induces increased numbers of oligodendrocyte genesis and emigration out of the SVZ [
28,
29,
53]. Interestingly postmortem human studies suggest that SVZ cells, probably glioblasts, emigrate into adjacent regions in MS [
54]. The effects of preclinical models of MS on neurogenesis and neuroblast emigration were less clear, especially with regards to TMEV. This was important to address since, in addition to glial loss, a significant amount of neuronal loss occurs in MS [
19]. Our results show that even though neurons are lost in MS, neurogenic regions of the brain do not increase the production of newborn neurons. This is unlike multiple other models of neuronal loss such as stroke which generally increase neurogenesis [
1,
13].
An interesting clinical observation is that MS is frequently associated with periventricular lesions; "Dawson's fingers" [
31]. As seen with MRI, these lesions extend from the ependyma into the corpus callosum and other brain regions [
32]. The lesions course along subventricular zone (subependymal) blood vessels, suggesting they are routes of entry for destructive immune cells. As in Dawson's fingers, CD45+ cell activation was frequently associated with SVZ blood vessels and it may be that these were infiltrating macrophages. Recent studies have documented increased cell density and proliferation in the SVZ of MS patients [
54]. These observations are compatible with the massive CD45+ cell activation we consistently observed around the lateral ventricles. High numbers of CD45+ inflammatory cells concentrate in the circumventricular organs, during EAE [
55] and MS cerebral hemisphere lesions are primarily perivascular [
56,
57]. Regardless of the mechanism, an increasing body of evidence suggests that periventricular regions, including the neurogenic SVZ, are particularly affected in preclinical models and human MS.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
GEG. Sectioned brains, performed the majority of immunohistochemistry, analyzed sections, and wrote the manuscript. AG sectioned brains, performed immunohistochemistry, and analyzed sections. REJ performed immunohistochemsitry and analyzed sections. LKFA examined the cuprizone model. WSB performed TMEV inoculations. SDM provided expertise on the TMEV model and advised on experimental design and the manuscript. FGS provided expertise on the subventricular zone and wrote the manuscript.