Background
Axonal damage and loss are the key structural features in multiple sclerosis patients and the most important correlates of persistent disability [
1‐
3]. Also, the insidious clinical worsening in later stages of the disease, often independent of newly formed lesions and largely non-responsive to immunomodulatory treatments, but reflected in important brain and cervical spinal atrophy, is considered due to cumulative axonal loss [
4‐
7]. Reports on axonal loss in the normal-appearing white matter (NAWM) and spinal cord range from ∼20 to 55%, whereas in chronic multiple sclerosis lesions, axonal reduction of up to 70% has been reported [
8]. Axonal degeneration can occur via several mechanisms, the most prominent being anterograde (or Wallerian) and retrograde (“dying back”) degeneration [
9]. Inflammation-associated axonal transport disturbances, so-called “focal axonal degeneration,” may precede axonal transection and ensuing axonal self-destruction by Wallerian degeneration [
10].
Axonal transport disturbances, as visualized by the accumulation of anterogradely transported proteins such as amyloid precursor protein (APP) and synaptophysin, are often used as indicators of “acute axonal damage,” and the density of APP-positive axonal profiles is highest in the earliest stages of multiple sclerosis lesion formation [
2,
11,
12]. Axons with transport disturbance are also present at relatively high density in the rims of chronic active, smoldering lesions and may be found in the NAWM [
2,
13,
14]. Whether and to which extent axonal transport disturbances are reversible or lead to definite, irreversible axonal transection, is not yet clear. Correlations of APP-positive axonal profiles with the density of macrophages have been repeatedly shown for early lesions; however, in chronic disease, also a correlation with T cells was observed [
2,
14‐
16].
In experimental models of inflammatory demyelination, the accumulation of organelles and proteins in axons corresponds to “focal axonal degeneration,” i.e., localized axonal swelling. Importantly, a proportion of axons showing focal axonal degeneration finally undergo transection and degenerate [
10]. In experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), the progression to axonal transection is largely prevented by treatment with ROS/NOS scavengers, and axonal morphology is restored in the majority of treated axons studied [
17]. Demyelination is not a prerequisite for focal axonal degeneration, supporting the contribution of highly lipid-soluble reactive species to axonal damage [
10,
17‐
19]. Of note, however, chronic axonal transport disturbances may lead to distal axonal “malnutrition” and dying back, highlighting the importance of early therapeutic intervention [
17].
Axons proceeding from focally disturbed axonal transport to axonal transection undergo a series of orderly events, namely, an acute retraction process, both proximally and distally, termed acute axonal degeneration, followed by classical Wallerian degeneration of the distal axon part [
20]. Both processes are, at least in part, mediated by similar molecular mechanisms and contribute to the important physical “gap” between the proximal and distal axon stump rendering regenerative attempts challenging. As of yet, it is not well understood when the majority of Wallerian degeneration, the final process of axonal self-destruction, takes place in multiple sclerosis. In particular, it has not been explored whether Wallerian degeneration is abundant in the chronic disease stage of the disease.
Thus, to better understand the dynamics of axonal loss in patients with multiple sclerosis, we set out to study the timing and extent of Wallerian degeneration in patients with short- and long-standing disease harboring early- and late-stage lesions. Furthermore, experimentally, we strived to determine whether delaying Wallerian degeneration helps to decrease inflammatory axonal damage in a model of multiple sclerosis. Our data indicate that axonal transection and ensuing axonal self-destruction is most pronounced in the periplaque white matter of patients with early demyelinating lesions. Of note, however, also the presence of chronic active lesions associates with a high density of neuropeptide Y-Y1 receptor (NPY-Y1R)-positive axonal profiles, underlining the notion that focal demyelinated lesions are the key contributors to axonal demise in the periplaque and normal-appearing white matter. Experimentally, we find that neither acute axonal damage nor persistent axonal loss is ameliorated in focal EAE lesions in Wallerian degeneration slow (
Wld
S
) compared to wild-type (WT) mice, indicating limited sharing of molecular mechanisms between acute axonal transport disturbance and Wallerian degeneration [
21]. Our study underlines the role of focal white matter lesions for axonal loss in the NAWM of patients with multiple sclerosis and supports the concept of early pharmacological interventions to prevent highly vulnerable, transport-deficient axons showing signs of focal axonal degeneration from transection.
Methods
Brain tissue from patients with multiple sclerosis
We investigated paraffin-embedded archival brain tissue from 17 autopsied multiple sclerosis patients and 14 biopsied patients diagnosed with inflammatory demyelination consistent with multiple sclerosis. A total of 34 [
16] tissue specimens, which included non-demyelinated white matter regions, were used for the study. All biopsy samples analyzed contained non-demyelinated periplaque white matter (PPWM) areas contiguous with early/late active (
n = 6) or inactive (
n = 9) lesions. For direct comparison, non-demyelinated white matter tissue adjacent to 5 active lesions, 7 chronic active, and 7 chronic inactive lesions was analyzed in multiple sclerosis autopsy tissue. All lesions fulfilled the criteria for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis [
22]. Lesional activity was determined using previously described criteria [
23]. The biopsies were performed in different neurosurgical centers to exclude neoplastic or infectious diseases. Specimens were sent to the Department of Neuropathology in Göttingen, Germany, for a second opinion. The patients’ clinical characteristics are summarized in Table
1.
Table 1
Characteristics of multiple sclerosis patients included in the study
Sex; female n = 16, male n = 15 | |
Age; 47 years (median), 19–76 (range) | |
Clinical diagnosisa
| |
Clinically isolated syndrome suggestive of multiple sclerosis; n = 9 (9 biopsies) | |
Primary progressive multiple sclerosis; n = 6 (6 autopsies) | |
Relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis; n = 4 (4 biopsies) | |
Secondary progressive multiple sclerosis; n = 9 (1 biopsy, 8 autopsies) | |
Disease duration of biopsied patientsb; 42 days (median), 9–540 days (range) | |
Disease duration of autopsied patientsb; 19 years (median), 6–34 years (range) | |
Brain tissue from stroke patients
Axonal transport disturbances and Wallerian degeneration are typical and abundant after brain ischemia. To study the spatial relation of the two phenomena in a prototypic human disease, we analyzed archival paraffin-embedded brain biopsy tissue from four patients (three females, one male; median age = 54 years; range 49–63 years) with ischemic stroke lesions. Lesions were characterized by tissue necrosis as evidenced by massive axonal loss and dense macrophage infiltration. Axonal swellings in a typical ischemic pattern were abundant at the lesion borders.
Mice
Female 8–10-week-old Wld
S
(C57BL/6 OlaHsd) and C57BL/6 mice were obtained from the Harlan Laboratories, UK. The Wld
S
mouse strain is characterized by an 85-kb tandem triplication on chromosome four that occurred as a spontaneous mutation in the B6 strain in the 1940s, leading to the expression of an Ube4b/Nmnat chimeric protein. Mutant mice do not show a spontaneous phenotype. All mice had free access to water and chow and were included in the experiments after at least 5 days of acclimatization.
EAE induction and clinical evaluation
EAE was induced by subcutaneous injection of 200 μg myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG)-peptide35–55 emulsified in complete Freund’s adjuvant (CFA) containing 1 mg/ml inactivated Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Control mice were injected with CFA alone. Three hundred nanogram pertussis toxin was injected i.p. at day 0 and day 2 after immunization. Clinical deficits were assessed daily by a blinded observer using the following scoring system: 0=no symptoms, 0.5=partial tail paresis, 1.0=complete tail paralysis, 1.5=slight hind limb paresis, 2.0=distinct hind limb paresis, 2.5=severe hind limb paresis, 3.0=complete hind limb paralysis, 3.5=slight forelimb paresis, 4.0=tetraparesis, 4.5=moribund, and 5.0=death. Mice were euthanized when reaching a score of 3.5.
Histopathology
At the end of the EAE experiments, animals were deeply anesthetized and perfused with phosphate buffered saline (PBS) (pH 7.4) followed by 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA) in PBS. The spinal cords (SC) were dissected, and at least eight transverse sections were embedded in paraffin. One to three micrometer-thick sections were stained with hematoxylin-eosin (HE), Luxol Fast Blue/periodic acid Schiff’s reagent (LFB/PAS), and Bielschowsky silver impregnation to determine inflammation, demyelination, and axonal loss. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) was performed using the primary antibodies listed in Table
2. For antigen retrieval, tissue slices were microwaved in 10 mM citrate buffer (pH 6.0) 3 × 5 min. Bound antibodies were visualized using an appropriate biotinylated secondary antibody and an avidin-peroxidase-DAB technique. Negative control sections were incubated without primary antibodies or with irrelevant primary antibodies of the respective isotypes. Slices were counterstained with hemalaun and cover-slipped. Double fluorescence labeling with two mouse monoclonal primary antibodies was carried out as described previously [
24].
Table 2
Antibodies used for immunohistochemistry
Amyloid precursor protein (APP) | Mouse mAb
(22C11) | 1:2000 | Citrate MW | Chemicon International, USA |
Neuropeptide Y receptor Y1 (NPY-Y1R) | Rabbit polyAb #96106 | 1:1000 | Tris-EDTA MW | CURE/UCLA, USA |
Myelin basic protein (MBP) | Rabbit polyAb | 1:1000 | None | DakoCytomation, Denmark |
MBP peptic fragment 70–89 | Mouse mAb (SMI94) | 1:5000 | Steam | Covance Inc., USA |
Myelin proteolipid protein (PLP) | Mouse mAb (Plpc 1) | 1:500 | Citrate MW | Biozol, Germany |
Myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) | Rat polyAb | 1:1000 | Citrate MW | |
Myelin-associated glycoprotein (MAG) | Rabbit polyAb | 1:10 | Citrate MW | |
2′,3′-Cyclic-nucleotide 3′-phosphodiesterase (CNPase) | Mouse mAb (SMI91) | 1:200 | Citrate MW | Covance Inc., USA |
Monocytes, activated microglia | Mouse mAb (KiM1P) | 1:5000 | Citrate MW | |
Early-activated macrophages (S100A9) | Rabbit polyAb | 1:500 | Citrate MW | |
Phosphorylated NFs | Mouse mAb (SMI31) | 1:10000 | Citrate MW | Covance Inc., USA |
Non-phosphorylated NFs | Mouse mAb (SMI32) | 1:1000 | Citrate MW | Covance Inc., USA |
Hypo-phosphorylated NFs | Mouse mAb (SMI35) | 1:10000 | Citrate MW | Covance Inc., USA |
NF-low-molecular-weight (NF68) | Mouse mAb (NR4) | 1:100 | Citrate MW | Sigma Chemical Company, USA |
NF-high-molecular-weight (NF200) | Mouse mAb (N52) | 1:400 | Citrate MW | Sigma Chemical Company, USA |
Growth-associated protein 43 (GAP43) | Mouse mAb (9-1E12) | 1:4000 | Citrate MW | Chemicon International, USA |
Synaptophysin (protein p38) | Mouse mAb (SY38) | 1:10 | Citrate MW | DakoCytomation, Denmark |
Mouse sciatic nerve transection
Four female C57BL/6 mice were used to study sciatic nerve axotomy. They were deeply anesthetized by intraperitoneal injection of ketamine hydrochloride (“Ketanest Inresa,” 50 mg/ml, Inresa, Freiburg, Germany) mixed with xylazine hydrochloride (“Rompun” 2%, Bayer, Leverkusen, Germany) in a ratio of 2:1 (0.4 mg Ketanest and 2 mg Rompun for each mouse). Skin and muscles above the right femur were opened by fine scissors, and the sciatic nerve was completely transected. Subsequently, muscle and skin were closed by suture (Ethicon). The mice were kept for 6 days under a 12-h dark-light cycle and given food and water ad libitum. The animals were perfused transcardially with PBS and 4% PFA, and the sciatic nerves dissected. The contralateral nerves and a sciatic nerve from an animal without axotomy served as controls. Sciatic nerves were post-fixed in 4% PFA overnight and embedded in paraffin. Microtome sections of 1–3 μm thickness were de-paraffinized, pre-treated by cooking in citrate buffer (pH 6) for 10 min, and subjected to IHC.
Data acquisition and analysis
Tissue sections were analyzed using an Olympus BX51 fluorescence microscope equipped with a DP71 CCD camera (Olympus Optical Co, Ltd., Hamburg, Germany), a Zeiss Cell Observer microscope with an AxioCam ICc 3 CCD camera (Carl Zeiss MicroImaging, Ltd., Göttingen, Germany), or by confocal laser scanning microscopy with a Fluoview 1000 Olympus microscope. Transverse spinal cord (SC) sections at the cervical, thoracic, lumbar, and sacral levels were used for quantitative analysis. The extent of acute axonal damage of axons undergoing Wallerian degeneration and the density of healthy phosphorylated axons was calculated by counting APP
+, NPY-Y1R
+, or SMI31
+ profiles in spinal cross sections within at least five white matter lesions per mouse at ×400 magnification using an ocular counting grid. Counts are given as immunopositive axonal profiles per square millimeter. Relative axonal densities within lesions were determined in sections stained with Bielschowsky’s silver impregnation by using an axonal counting grid with 25 cross-points [
25]. The number of axons intersecting with the crossing points was determined as a fraction of the total number of cross-points at a magnification of ×1000, under oil immersion. The value obtained in control animals was set to 100%. The degree of axon reduction in the lesion is given as the percentage of axon density compared with the control animals. To determine the extent of demyelination, digital images of LFB/PAS-stained SC cross sections were recorded through an Olympus light microscope with a CCD DP71 camera at ×100 magnification. Using the computer program Cell^F (Soft Imaging Systems
®), demyelinated white matter areas were measured, and the percentage with respect to total white matter was calculated. The inflammatory index was defined as the mean number of perivascular infiltrates within the SC parenchyma of 8–10 spinal cross sections per animal. All the images were prepared in Adobe Photoshop CS4 Version 11.0.2.
Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses were carried out using Microsoft Office Excel 2007 and GraphPad Prism (GraphPad Software, La Jolla, USA). After normality testing, an unpaired t test was applied to determine potential differences in the mean clinical severity scores of WT and Wld
S
mice at day 20 and day 40 after disease onset. Histological data were analyzed by the non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test; animals in two groups (i.e., Wld
S
and WT) were compared on the basis of closely matched clinical scores. The influence of genotype and disease stage on inflammation and demyelination was determined using a two-way-ANOVA. Statistical significance was defined as p < 0.05. All quantitative morphological data are expressed as mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM) in the EAE studies.
Discussion
The extent of axonal loss is the most important predictor of permanent clinical deficits in multiple sclerosis [
39‐
41]. Wallerian degeneration of axons transected in focal inflammatory demyelinated lesions contributes to the loss of neural structures. Here, we demonstrate a clear relationship between lesion demyelinating activity and Wallerian degeneration in non-demyelinated multiple sclerosis white matter. Furthermore, we find that the extent of Wallerian degeneration is most extensive in early disease stages supporting the interrelation between inflammation and neurodegeneration in multiple sclerosis [
24,
42,
43]. In addition, in the present study, we hypothesized that
Wld
S
mutant mice would present with less axonal damage and reduced disability in MOG
35–55 EAE compared to WT mice. However, surprisingly,
Wld
S
and WT mice showed a similar disease course, and the degree of inflammation, demyelination, and acute axonal damage was comparable in the early as well as in the more advanced disease stage. Immunohistochemical staining with the anti-NPY-Y1R antibody demonstrated abundant Wallerian degeneration in WT mice in the early and chronic disease stage but identified only very few axons undergoing Wallerian degeneration in
Wld
S
mice in the acute disease stage. Furthermore, the net axonal loss was comparable in the chronic disease stage in both genotypes. Our data thus indicate that the
Wld
S
gene markedly delays Wallerian degeneration after inflammatory axonal damage but does not ameliorate disability resulting from EAE or cumulative axon loss.
Previous studies investigating axotomy-induced CNS Wallerian degeneration proposed three distinct phases: first, the sudden fragmentation (after 10–20 min) of both the distal and proximal axon close to the site of injury; second, the slow axonal retraction resulting in bulb formation at the axon ends with the distal stump remaining anatomically integrated and functional, and third, a proximal stable fragment while the distal fragment undergoes secondary degeneration, i.e., swelling, connection thinning, and rapid granularization [
20,
44‐
47]. Convincing evidence for the distinct molecular basis of these processes was recently obtained in studies performed in
Wld
S
mutant mice. Kerschensteiner and colleagues could show that the
Wld
S
mutation prevented the onset of sudden fragmentation in transected CNS axons [
20]. Also, expression of the
Wld
S
gene remarkably protracted the slow retraction phase in which the axon distal to the transection site remains morphologically intact and retains its physiologic function [
34,
38,
48,
49].
Modulation of ion channels expressed in axons under inflammatory demyelinating conditions was shown to amend axonal degeneration [
50‐
52]. Interestingly, it has been demonstrated that Wallerian degeneration of the distal stump is a Ca
2+-mediated process [
53,
54]. The rise in intra-axonal ROS production in the distal stump after transection is diminished in the
Wld
S
mutation, which thus may entail preserved mitochondrial function and energy supply [
55]. Hence, the fast fragmentation and slow retraction, but not the late rapid granularization, are ROS dependent. This is in agreement with the notion that the delay in axonal degeneration observed in
Wld
S
axons is only transient. Mitochondrial dysfunction, energy failure, and ensuing Ca
2+ overload have been implicated as the final common pathways in inflammatory axonal damage, leading to the activation of intra-axonal proteases, cytoskeletal degradation, and axonal degeneration and loss [
56,
57]. Therefore, the
Wld
S
mutation might be well suited to protect axons in an inflammatory demyelinating milieu, even beyond its well-described effect on the classical axonal self-destruction after transection. In our study, however, the densities of acutely damaged axons in inflammatory lesions were similar in
Wld
S
and WT mice, in both the acute and chronic disease stages, suggesting that the inflammatory insult surpassed the axonoprotective capacities of the
Wld
S
phenotype.
Our data show that the occurrence of Wallerian degeneration in multiple sclerosis is related to the density of axons with transport deficits observed in the tissue: Wallerian degeneration is most abundant in the periplaque white matter of patients early in the disease course harboring macrophage-rich focal lesions with ongoing myelin degradation. To the contrary, only few axons undergoing Wallerian degeneration were observed in late-stage patients with predominantly chronic inactive lesions. Noteworthy and as reported previously, chronic active lesions represent an area of ongoing demyelination and focal axonal degeneration [
2,
14,
58]. In line, elevated levels of axons undergoing Wallerian degeneration were detected in the corresponding periplaque and normal-appearing white matter. Although our work cannot definitely exclude the presence of focal axonal degeneration in non-lesional areas, it clearly shows that the extent of Wallerian degeneration is related to focal demyelinating pathology. Furthermore, our work highlights the relevance of axonoprotective treatments, also in patients with more advanced disease, where smoldering lesions are most common.
Coleman and colleagues [
59,
60] observed that the
Wld
S
mutation also inhibits degenerative axonal swellings in gracile axonal dystrophy (
gad) mice, a mutant mouse strain characterized by a “dying-back” type axonal degeneration and the formation of axonal spheroids. In contrast, we studied axonal pathology under inflammatory demyelinating conditions. NOS and ROS released by activated macrophages have been implicated in acute axonal transport disturbance, even in myelinated axons, and may contribute to mitochondrial damage and Ca
2+ overload, leading to a vicious cycle of energy failure and cytoskeletal degradation [
10]. Our results suggest that the intra-axonal protective mechanisms operating in
Wld
S
mice, e.g., antioxidation and increased Ca
2+ buffering capacity, are not sufficient to prevent or diminish axonal swellings during a myelin-specific T cell-mediated autoimmune attack. Prior studies showed that the
Wld
S
protection mechanism is intrinsic to the axon [
47,
61,
62]. However, recently, an upregulation of CD200 was observed in
Wld
S
mice, which may play a critical role in reducing microglia-mediated neuroaxonal damage in the CNS [
63‐
65]. Taken together, our results indicate that in inflammatory demyelination, axonal transport deficits and cumulative loss of axons are not restrained in
Wld
S
mice.
Irrespective of disease-related or mechanical transection of axons, the common downstream mechanisms of axonal degeneration include energy failure, increased Ca
2+ influx and activation of calpains, resulting in the degradation of axon components [
66‐
68]. As early as in the 1980s, it has been shown that NPY along with its Y1 receptor modulates increased Ca
2+ concentrations in cultured dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons [
69,
70]. NPY is widely distributed in the CNS and PNS, albeit NPY and its receptor Y1 are not expressed in the same population of neurons. However, both are upregulated in axonal processes of DRG neurons after nerve injury in rodents [
71‐
74]. It seems therefore possible that NPY-Y1R plays a role in limiting the early destructive processes in damaged axons. In this study, we observed an important delay in NPY-Y1R expression in axons of
Wld
S
mice with EAE, which is in line with the reduced Ca
2+ influx in transected
Wld
S
axons. Intriguingly, the increased Ca
2+ buffering capacity of
Wld
S
mitochondria shows a gradual decrease over time in the distal stump [
53]. Hence, the intra-axonal protective mechanisms appear to decrease with time after transection in
Wld
S
axons. Indeed, we observed substantially decreased immunoreactivity of NPY-Y1R in inflammatory SC lesions of
Wld
S
mice in the acute stage as compared to the chronic stage. Our results thus support the use of anti-NPY-Y1R antibodies as a bona fide marker for Wallerian degeneration.
Acknowledgements
We thank Katja Schulz for expert technical assistance and Cynthia Bunker for language editing.