Symmetrical (SDMA) and asymmetrical dimethylarginine (ADMA) in sepsis: high plasma levels as combined risk markers for sepsis survival

Sepsis is a life-threatening dysregulated host response to infection [1]. Disease severity may be indicated by the sepsis-related organ failure assessment (SOFA) score which defines organ dysfunction by a subset of clinical findings and laboratory markers [1, 2]. Despite improvements in sepsis treatment, such as fluid resuscitation and early antibiotics, the in-hospital mortality remains high and in Germany up to 24% of patients with sepsis die [3, 4]. The high mortality rate, however, follows variable phases of sepsis severity and physicians face a diagnostic and prognostic challenge: Patients with sepsis are difficult to identify and the course of sepsis is often unpredictable [5].

Analysis of the signaling molecule nitric oxide (NO) may provide a promising approach to the identification of high-risk cases because changes in NO levels relate to both circulatory failure and infection control [6, 7]. First, endothelial-derived NO dilates blood vessels via activation of guanylate cyclase, which induces relaxation of vascular smooth muscle cells by increasing intracellular 3,5-cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP) concentration. On the one hand, excessive production of NO may cause severe hypotension with loss of systemic vascular resistance (SVR) and consequently reduced organ perfusion. On the other hand, NO is essential for maintaining microvascular function since it regulates the supply and distribution of oxygen and nutrients throughout all tissues [8]. In this context, NO maintains microvascular homeostasis by dilating and regulating vascular tone, red blood cell deformability, and leukocyte and platelet adhesion to endothelial cells [8].

Second, NO is essential to the innate immunological response to pathogens as indicated by extensive studies of innate immunity involving monocytes and macrophages [6]. NO is a free radical and has immediate antimicrobial effects including disruption of bacterial target structures and inhibition of bacterial metabolism [9‐11]. NO is generated by three tissue-specific NO synthases (NOS) termed endothelial (eNOS), neural (nNOS) and inducible NOS (iNOS), the latter being expressed in immune tissue [12]. Two non-proteinogenic amino acids inhibit NO formation via interference with the NOS substrate arginine: high concentration of symmetric dimethylarginine (SDMA) inhibits cellular arginine uptake and asymmetric dimethylarginine (ADMA) competes for catalytic substrate conversion [13]. SDMA is metabolized in the kidneys by alanine-glyoxylate aminotransferase 2 (AGXT2) and is closely associated with renal function [14]. This is one reason why SDMA may serve as a reliable marker for renal failure [15, 16]. ADMA levels are controlled by two cleaving enzymes, dimethylarginase-dimethylalaminohydrolase-1 and 2 (DDAH1 and 2), of which DDAH2 is predominantly expressed in immune cells [15, 17]. Interestingly, in studies of polymicrobial sepsis in mice, global knockout of DDAH2 is associated with 12% 120-h survival compared to 53% survival in wild-type animals, underlining the important immunosuppression effect of ADMA in sepsis [18]. Further, we have shown that plasma ADMA levels are increased whereas DDAH2 expression in peripheral blood monocytes (PBMC) is reduced in patients with sepsis [19].

With this background of plasma SDMA levels depending on renal function and plasma ADMA levels depending on DDAH2 activity in immune cells, we sought to investigate whether plasma concentrations of SDMA and ADMA are associated with sepsis survival and could be useful markers to identify patients at high risk.

Plasma SDMA and ADMA concentrations were measured in 120 patients diagnosed with sepsis and admitted to the ICU. During follow up, plasma samples from 106 patients at day 3 and from 71 patients at day 7 were obtained before discharge or death (Table 1). A total of 31 patients (26%) died within 28 days; for further analysis, the cohort was divided into 28-day survivors and non-survivors. There was no difference between groups in basic demographic data, age and gender, cause of sepsis (medical or surgical) or the species detected or gram positivity or negativity (Table 1). However, non-survivors had a higher SOFA score than survivors (Table 1, P = 0.006).

The aim of this study was to determine whether plasma SDMA and plasma ADMA concentrations are associated with sepsis survival and are useful markers to stratify risk levels. We found that elevated levels of SDMA and ADMA in non-survivors were associated with disease severity. The occurrence of high plasma SDMA together with high plasma ADMA levels identified individuals at risk of a poor outcome who might need the highest priority of care.

The most important factors affecting sepsis outcome are circulatory failure and a disturbed host response [1]. NO is an important signaling molecule with regulatory functions in both the circulatory and immune systems. We were therefore interested to determine whether plasma concentrations of SDMA and ADMA, which are direct and indirect inhibitors of NOS, are altered in sepsis and hypothesized that increased levels might contribute to lower NO bioavailability.

Physiologically, NO regulates blood pressure and is the most important vasodilatator. Reduced NO levels are responsible for progression of a variety of conditions associated with hypertension such as coronary heart disease and chronic renal failure. Reduced NO levels have been attributed to an increase in SDMA and ADMA concentrations, which are established risk markers for cardiovascular mortality [25, 26]. Furthermore, ADMA infusions in humans result in increased systemic vascular resistance (SVR) and mean arterial pressure (MAP) [27]. In contrast, one hallmark of sepsis and septic shock is loss of SVR and MAP with subsequent alterations in cardiac output (CO) and reduced tissue perfusion [28]. This leads to the hypothesis that, in sepsis, NO production is unregulated and may be responsible for vascular failure [29, 30]. We have previously shown that NO bioavailability is reduced in sepsis; this is indicated by low NOS substrate levels but high levels of the NOS inhibitor ADMA; we are now able to provide data for SDMA [19]. The theory that low NO levels pertain to sepsis severity is supported by a randomized clinical trial in which a NOS inhibitor was tested to stabilize hemodynamic derangements in septic patients. Intravenous administration of the non-selective NOS inhibitor L-NG-methyl-L-arginine hydrochloride (546C88) has been compared with placebo. The 546C88 increased SVR but other hemodynamic parameters such as CO and oxygen delivery were blunted. In the long term, administration of 546C88 was associated with higher sepsis mortality and despite macrocirculatory improvements during treatment, the drug was not associated with favorable sepsis outcomes [31, 32].

How can we explain the apparently contradictory roles of NOS? Inhibition of NOS in the macrocirculation may improve signs of hypotension and loss of SVR but inhibition in the microcirculation may impair capillary exchange resulting in organ dysfunction [12]. Thus, the effect of NO is ambivalent in sepsis. However, the protective effect of NO on the microvascular exchange seems to predominate [33‐37].

SDMA is transported efficiently by the hCAT-2B transporter into cells and exchanged against intracellular L-arginine, resulting in cellular L-arginine depletion in vitro [38]. Although we cannot exclude the possibility that SDMA concentrations, e.g. in the microcirculation, are higher than plasma concentration and may influence NO synthesis locally; this depletion mechanism requires very high SDMA concentrations, i.e. 5 mM, much higher than those observed in our study [38]. Moreover SDMA, may amplify its diagnostic role as a marker for organ function as elimination depends entirely on renal function, which is extremely sensitive to the septic assault. Acute kidney injury (AKI) occurs in over 40% of patients [39, 40]. Considering this important effect, one may argue that early detection of septic AKI is of great importance. The SOFA score includes a variety of clinical parameters among which creatinine (Crea) reflects renal function [41]. However, serum Crea as a renal marker in sepsis is questionable because of the well-known problem that serum Crea levels are influenced by various factors that are altered in critical illness and supported by experimental data in mice showing that Crea levels are reduced after induction of sepsis, which may mask early detection of AKI [42, 43]. However, SDMA is a very established and superior marker for kidney function [44]. In a meta-analysis involving over 2100 patients, the coefficient of correlation between SDMA and inulin clearance (the gold standard for measuring kidney function) was 0.85 (95% CI 0.76–0.91) [16]. In this context, one may consider that SDMA is not only a molecule cleared by the kidneys but that SDMA accumulation reflects the degree of renal failure, and high concentrations potentially may inhibit NOS to a greater extent [34]. In sepsis, this relationship may reflect sustained and disturbed microcirculatory exchange with consequent impairment of organ function. We have observed those associations and shown that SDMA concentrations correlate not only with Crea but also with liver failure (bilirubin), the collapse of coagulation as represented by platelet counts and the SOFA score (Table 3, Fig. 2). Moreover, our results are supported by those of two previous studies involving 223 and 67 patients with sepsis, respectively, in which SDMA levels were elevated and associated with higher mortality [45, 46]. The positive correlation between SDMA and PCT might be explained by the fact that PCT elimination is prolonged in patients with renal dysfunction [47]. Creating risk groups on the basis of SDMA levels seems an appropriate tool to identify patients needing early and high priority of care such as hemodialysis or intensified hemodynamic monitoring (Fig. 3).

Beside the important role of NO levels in circulation, reduced levels of NO might be deleterious for the immune response in sepsis and increased NOS inhibitor levels may contribute to this. It has long been observed that iNOS knockout (removing the predominant NOS in immune tissue) is associated with poor survival in mice with sepsis [48]. This effect is reversed by transplantation of wild-type bone marrow to iNOS knockout mice [49]. Increased release of cytokines such as TNF-α together with better survival was observed in mice with pneumonia when iNOS was restored this way [49]. Together with the discovery that mouse macrophages produce large amounts of nitrite (NO2-) and nitrate (NO3-) upon bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) stimulation, it has been suggested that decreased NO levels impair the innate immune response under septic conditions [50]. The reduced ability of monocytes to release pro-inflammatory cytokines after stimulation with LPS indicates the immunosuppressive phase of sepsis in humans and has been suggested as a standard tool to identify immunosuppressed patients [51, 52]. In summary, it seems that manipulation of NO metabolism either by knocking out iNOS or by high levels of NOS inhibitors such as ADMA is associated with sepsis severity and mortality [19]. ADMA levels were associated with mortality in two studies of 267 patients with sepsis and 255 critically ill patients, and in a small population of patients with sepsis the odds ratio for 28-day mortality in the upper quartile was 20.8 [45, 53, 54].

While SDMA levels depend on renal function, ADMA clearance is directly linked to the immune system and levels are controlled by DDAH1 and DDAH12 activity, of which DDAH2 is predominantly expressed in immune cells [15, 17]. Circulating ADMA levels are genetically determined by promoter polymorphism in a regulatory gene encoding DDAH2 polymorphism and have been investigated by other research groups. In a series of 47 patients with severe sepsis, high ADMA concentration was associated with the DDAH2 -449G polymorphism [55]. Interestingly, we have previously shown an association between decreasing DDAH2 expression in peripheral blood monocytes (PBMC) and disease severity [19]. This is in line with animal experiments in DDAH2 knockout mice in which the 120-h survival rate was only 12% compared to 53% in wild-type animals after cecal ligation and puncture [18]. The authors attributed this phenotype to impaired macrophage function as monocyte-specific deletion of DDAH2 results in a similar pattern of increased severity to that seen in animals globally deficient in DDAH2. The DDAH2 knockout in macrophages was associated with a significantly higher bacterial load in plasma and in the peritoneum. NO production in activated mouse macrophages is DDAH2-dependent with reduced intracellular NO levels within the cell, which impairs motility and phagocytosis in these cells [18].

Increased SDMA and ADMA levels directly correlate with sepsis severity and mortality. We have used this information to suggest a risk classification (Fig. 1 and Fig. 3). Among our patients, 17% died when SDMA levels were ≥ 1.34 and ADMA levels were ≤ 0.97; the highest mortality however (67%) was observed when ADMA levels were > 0.98 μmol/L (Fig. 3). One may hypothesize that NOS inhibitors reflect two essential pathophysiological steps in sepsis: vascular failure and immunosuppression. Thinking about sepsis markers it is important to combine markers for both vascular function and for immunity. Analyzing the NO metabolism is a promising approach in this context.

This was a prospective observational study and therefore had certain limitations. The study was carried out at a single center and involved relatively small numbers of patients. Future studies involving larger cohorts should eliminate potential selection bias and further statistical adjustments such as for estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) should be made possible. We observed that the two direct and indirect endogenous NOS inhibitors SDMA and ADMA were associated with mortality and disease severity, which may indicate disturbances in NO metabolism. The gold standard for analysis of NO metabolism would be its direct measurement in blood. This currently seems impossible, in particular in an ICU setting, due to the short half-life of the NO molecule. Therefore, we can only speculate that ADMA and SDMA may influence NO metabolism in septic patients. Experimental studies are required, to explain why SDMA and ADMA are increased in sepsis and how this may influence NO metabolism especially in the microcirculation. Another limitation is that we cannot exclude the possibility that dialysis may influence SDMA and ADMA levels. However, we observed high SDMA and ADMA concentration in non-survivors, which warrants follow-up studies addressing the question, e.g. as to whether patients would benefit from early SDMA-guided renal replacement therapy. To date it has not been shown that dialysis improves sepsis outcome [56, 57]. Furthermore, it would be interesting to know if increased ADMA levels are associated with other acquired changes in sepsis-induced immunosuppression such as downregulation of monocytic HLA-DR receptors. Nevertheless, we believe that our observations warrant follow-up studies with larger patient groups to confirm the power of SDMA and ADMA to indicate sepsis outcome and severity.

In patients with sepsis, the concentrations of SDMA and ADMA are increased. We suggest a risk classification according to SDMA and ADMA levels. Due to the biological elimination process of SDMA and ADMA one may speculate that SDMA accumulates with severity of renal failure and ADMA with severity of immune dysfunction and one may consider SDMA and ADMA as markers to indicate vascular failure and immune dysregulation in sepsis, respectively.