The use of hysteroscopic metroplasty with diode laser to increase endometrial volume in women with septate uterus: preliminary results

Mullerian ducts anomalies (MDA) stem from a defect in Mullerian ducts fusion on the median line or from an incomplete reabsorption of the septum originated from their fusion.

Prevalence has been estimated between 16% and 10% [1, 2], while incidence involves 1% of general population and 3% of women having multiple abortions or infertility [2].

The discovery of a genital organ malformation may be random, but these patients show a wide span of symptoms, such as sterility, primary amenorrhea, multiple abortions, severe dysmenorrhea, abdominal pain, and dyspareunia.

One third of anomalies are characterized by septate uterus, one third by bicornuate uterus, 10% by arcuate uterus, a 10% by didelphys and unicornuate uterus, and less than 5% by uterine aplasia according to the American Fertility Society Classification [3].

The most commonly used classifications of Mullerian anomalies in clinical practice include the American Fertility Society Classification and the ESHRE-ESGE Classification developed in 2013 [4, 5]. Nowadays, MDA are diagnosed by non-invasive techniques such as magnetic resonance or 3D transvaginal ultrasound (3D-TV US) [6]. 3D-TV US allows the creation of three-dimensional images useful to study the uterine surface and the cavity and to calculate endometrial volume. In particular, rotational measurement of volume has become possible thanks to the introduction of virtual organ computer-aided analysis (VOCALª), which is an extension of 3D-VIEWª software (Kretz Technik, Zipf, Austria). Using this new imaging program, the dataset can be rotated around a fixed axis through a number of rotation steps determined by the observer. There are four rotation angles to choose from: 30°, 15°, 9°, and 6°, and because the entire dataset is rotated about 180°, it results that we can observe respectively 6, 12, 20, and 30 planes.

3D-TV US and magnetic resonance are the gold standard for the diagnosis of MDA, but ultrasound is the more cost-effective technique [7].

The most common MDA is the septate uterus, V-a type according to the American Fertility Society classifications and U2b class according to the ESHRE-ESGE classification. These septa are usually repaired by performing a metroplasty with various hysteroscopic techniques. Today hysteroscopic metroplasty is considered the first therapeutic option for septate uterus because it offers several advantages: reduced hospitalization, decreased intra- and post-surgical morbidity, less surgical pelvic adhesions risk, and increased amount of vaginal deliveries [8]. Several tools have been successfully used for hysteroscopic metroplasty: scissor, forceps, operative hysteroscopy, unipolar or bipolar cauterization, laser energy [9‐15], but no RCTs have shown that a technique is better than another [6, 16]. The aim of our study was to evaluate the efficacy of hysteroscopic office technique using a diode laser and its efficacy to increase endometrial volume by comparing transvaginal 3D ultrasound endometrial volume of patients affected by septate uterus before and 3 months after metroplasty.

This pilot study was performed and conducted in compliance with the Helsinki Declaration. Informed consent was obtained from all the patients included in the study. We recruited 10 women diagnosed with primary infertility and septate uterus in the Endoscopic Centres of the Universities of Cagliari and Foggia between February and November 2019. Exclusion criteria included infertility due to other explained factors.

Patients’ characteristics are summarized in Table 1. The median age was 29.4 years old and the median BMI was 24.2 kg/m². All the patients were diagnosed with primary infertility (no other factor was identified as a cause for their infertility). Only one patient experienced a miscarriage at 7 weeks of gestation. The uterine morphology assessed by 3D-TV US revealed a MDA U2a in 9 patients and U2b in 1 patient according to the ESHRE-ESGE classification. The surgical procedure was successful in all patients. There were no early complications and the patients were discharged the same day of the procedure with no discomfort or pain. The pathological examination of the septa removed during the procedure revealed the presence of smooth muscle tissue (leiomyoma). 3D-TV US endometrial volume before and 3 months after metroplasty is shown in Table 2.

Median endometrial volume was significantly lower preoperatively [4.4 (range 2.5–5.5) vs 6.5 (range 4.4–7.6) cm³, p 0.019] and the median increase before and after surgery was 1.9 cm³ (range 1.7–2.1) (Table 3). At the moment of the current study, a 12-month follow-up has been performed in all the patients. None of the patients has reported adverse effect, and one patient is currently spontaneously pregnant 9 months after the surgical procedure.

Mullerian ducts anomalies (MDA) have been historically connected to bad obstetric prognosis characterized by a recurrent miscarriage, preterm delivery, abnormal fetal presentation and fetal or perinatal complications [3]. There are several techniques available for uterine malformations evaluation, office hysteroscopy is particularly useful to evaluate uterine cavity, while transvaginal ultrasound with 3D technique and the use of contrast can evaluate the uterine external morphology, the cavity and the tubes [6]. Ultrasound is easily reproducible and less expensive than magnetic resonance and it can be considered as the gold standard. The development of both the hysteroscopic technique in an outpatient setting and the 3D ultrasound, has increased the knowledge on MDA and has allowed development of new strategies in the treatment of MDA. The calculation of endometrial volume has not been previously studied as a diagnostic factor able to evaluate the success of the hysteroscopic procedure, but can easily and objectively measure the increase in the volume after removing the septa. According to ASRM guidelines, there are no sufficient proofs to recommend any specific method for hysteroscopic septum removal, and there are no randomized studies that showed which surgical technique can be preferred to improve the outcomes [6, 19]. However, some studies have shown that the metroplasty can improve the pregnancy outcomes in women with a history of infertility and miscarriages [20]. Our surgical technique consists in the surgical removal of the septum, and not in the simple opening of the septum as the traditional technique. These techniques have already shown good clinical outcomes in our previous experience with laser [12, 21]. In addition, recently, Haimovich et al. confirmed our preliminary results on hysteroscopic metroplasty with a diode laser. Tissue vaporization and coagulation with low power diode laser energy allow the quick elimination of the uterine septum without affecting the underlying myometrium [22]. The septum should be considered as a solid foreign body in the uterine cavity, surrounded by healthy myometrium, as confirmed in the most recent literature [23]. Because of its anatomopathological nature of leiomuscular tissue, a septum should be potentially treated as a myoma. In conclusion, diode laser is a feasible and safe alternative to the scissor, bipolar twizzle, and bipolar or monopolar resectoscope techniques. It allows the vaporization of the uterine septum demonstrating extreme precision of cutting, precise control of tissue vaporization, controlled power of penetration, a high capacity of hemostasis, the absence of electrical interferences, high safety, and good compliance of patients due to office setting without the need for cervical dilatation [24‐26]. Among the limitations of our study we can include the relatively small number of the sample and the lack of a control group. A potential side effect of our technique could be the weakening of the uterine walls because of the removal of the septum, that might potentially have a negative effect on the pregnancy and a spontaneous delivery; therefore, further larger randomized studies are necessary to correlate our positive first clinical data to obstetric outcomes.

Office hysteroscopic metroplasty for septate uterus with diode laser confirms to be a feasible and safe alternative to other available techniques and it could increase endometrial volume after the procedure. A randomized clinical study is currently ongoing at our department in order to better evaluate the laser metroplasty technique and to assess if the increase in endometrial volume by 3D-TV US can be used as a prognostic factor for the reproductive outcomes.