Introduction
Methods
Study design
Study setting and participants
Establishing design requirements – interviews and observations
Designing alternatives – design thinking workshops
Prototyping and evaluation
Results
Establishing design requirements – results of interviews and observations
Confusion about target audience
Saliency
Trade-off between simplicity and complexity
Method ambiguity
Personas
Persona | Description | User requirements |
---|---|---|
Julia, Internal Medicine Nurse, Age 25 | • Julia began working in the internal medicine ward at the USZ directly after finishing her nursing degree. Having freshly finished her schooling, she looks up to the more experienced nurses. • She is especially vigilant in her infection control practices, including isolation precautions, as this was a major focus of her training. • When she is not sure about which isolation precautions she should use for a patient, she (erroneously) references the sign on the housekeeping cart. | • Signage should offer multiple levels of information for frequent versus rare users. For example, recognition of the standardised signage colour may be enough for frequent users to recall the necessary precautions, whereas rare users need to be reminded of the specific precautions. • Target audience must be clearly distinguishable. |
Sarah, Nursing assistant, Age 48 | • Sarah has worked in several wards of the USZ. One of the highlights of her job is that it allows her to have a close relationship with patients. • She has a hard time bringing up isolation with her patients because she sympathises with the emotional effects this may have. For the same reason, she sometimes neglects to respect hygiene measures such as hand hygiene and wearing gowns, as she feels this puts a separation between herself and the patient. | • Signage should aim to establish social norms, increase acceptability of performing infection prevention measures. |
Paul, Emergency Ward Physician, Age 42 | • During medical school in Germany, Paul chose to specialise in emergency medicine because Dr. House was his favourite TV drama and he enjoys the challenge and rush to resolve critical situations. • Paul’s career took off quickly after he successfully published a highly cited paper in New England Journal of Medicine and he became known as an expert in fluid management in poly-trauma patients. • In the rush of acute care situations, infection control measures sometimes take a back seat, but no one dares to correct this senior physician. | • Signage must quickly communicate essential information and must not require extra time. • Barriers to performing isolation precautions (e.g. missing materials) should be removed. • Signage should aim to support psychological safety (e.g. speaking up). |
Omar, Porter, Age 55 | • Prior to moving to Switzerland with his family five years ago, Omar was an elementary school teacher in Tunisia. He came to Switzerland with no prior German knowledge but was able to begin working in the hospital while simultaneously taking German classes. • When he began working, he relied on clear photos and symbols to help him interpret written protocols. | • Signage must be able to communicate effectively with staff for whom German is not a native language, for example with self-explanatory images. |
Teresa, Housekeeping staff, Age 46 | • Teresa is specially assigned to work in the emergency ward, where they have specific cleaning and maintenance procedures from the rest of the hospital. Her native language is Portuguese, but her outgoing personality helped her to quickly learn German through chatting with her colleagues when she began working at the USZ, even picking up a Swiss German accent. • She has been working in the emergency ward for 12 years now, and although she has no medical training, she is excellent at what she does. | • Signage content may need to be adapted for specific settings. • Signage must be able to communicate effectively with staff for whom German is not a native language, for example with self-explanatory images. |
List of design requirements
Functional requirements (what the system should do) | |
Information dissemination | • Draw the attention of anyone entering the room that special precautions must be taken. • Inform any person entering the patient room what isolation status that patient has. • Inform any person entering the patient room about the isolation precautions they must employ according to the patient’s isolation status. ▪ Inform healthcare personnel about required personal protective equipment. ▪ Inform cleaning staff about required protective equipment, adapted disinfectants, and prioritised cleaning measures. ▪ Inform visitors about required personal protective equipment, or instruct them to see a staff member. • Inform any person entering the room about the order in which precautions (e.g. donning and doffing personal protective equipment, hand hygiene) should be performed. • Inform anyone transporting the patient about the transmission-based precautions that should be respected. • In addition to the three main categories of transmission-based precautions (contact, droplet, and airborne), signage should also be designed to communicate combined or “light” isolation precautions specific to the USZ. |
USZ guidelines | • Be consistent with USZ guidelines for isolation precautions. The three main isolation categories include: ▪ Contact isolation: don gown ▪ Droplet isolation: don surgical mask ▪ Airborne isolation: don FFP2 mask • Communicate combined isolation precautions: ▪ Contact + Droplet isolation: don gown and surgical mask ▪ Contact + Airborne isolation: don gown and FFP2 mask |
Non-functional requirements (constraints on the system and its development) | |
Maintenance restraints | • Must be easy to hang and remove on an as-need basis. • If printed on paper, must either be laminate so that it may be cleaned and reused, or single use. |
Accessibility and confidentiality requirements | • Should include graphics and symbols to accommodate non-native German speaking personnel. • Signage should avoid potential patient stigmatisation and should not disclose any confidential patient information. • Signage must be accessible to individuals with colour vision deficiency, for example by avoiding problematic colour combinations and employing both colours and symbols to convey messages over multiple channels. |
Physical environment requirements | • Signage must be noticeable relative to other signs in the healthcare setting (appropriate single-to-noise ratio). • Some indication of the patient’s isolation status should travel with the patient at all times so that the appropriate transmission-based precautions can be communicated at all times (e.g. when the patient is outside of the room where the sign is posted) – this could be attached to the patient herself or to the patient’s bed. • Signage for housekeeping personnel should be of a portable size (A4 or smaller) so that it can fit on the cleaning trolleys. |
Organisational environment requirements | • The signage should be able to quickly communicate the required actions, so that healthcare providers do not need to slow down (‘break the rhythm’) to interpret them. • If sign will be paper-based, it should be easily accessible to staff on the ward when an isolated patient arrives (e.g. printed copies from intranet) or purchasable. • Any posted signs must be consistent with the Corporate Design Guidelines. • Information communicated through signage must be consistent with evidence based-guidelines, such as the CDC 2007 guidance, as well as institutional infection control guidelines. |
Technical environment requirements | • Colour printer must be available if units are to print their own copies of paper-based signage. • Intranet connection must be available if units are to download the signs. • Staff must be able to post the signage either by using an adhesive material, or the signs may be printed directly onto an adhesive sheet. • Handling of signage material should be cost-effective and practical in every-day use. • It should be possible to update the signage system easily in case new hospital rules/guidelines are introduced. |