Why carry out the study?
|
Increasing antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in hospital-acquired infections (HAIs) with limited treatment options (LTO) represents an important challenge for the healthcare system in Greece; rates of HAIs are 50% higher in Greece, with a significantly higher burden of multidrug-resistant infections than the rest of Europe. |
To combat HAIs with LTO there is a need to both preserve the effectiveness of current treatments by decreasing AMR emergence and spread, and to improve access to new effective treatments. |
This study aimed to assess the current burden of HAIs with LTO and to estimate the clinical and economic value of introducing a new antibacterial agent in Greece. |
What was learned from the study?
|
The analysis showed that introduction of a new antibacterial agent in the management of HAIs with LTO in Greece could generate considerable clinical and economic benefits, representing a monetary benefit to healthcare providers of up to €6.8 billion, over 10 years; the greatest benefits were recognised when the new antibacterial agent was introduced to the treatment sequence as the first line. |
This analysis can support decision makers on implementing an effective AMR national action plan to alleviate AMR burden and encourage access to new treatments in Greece. |
Introduction
Methods
Overview
Hospital-acquired infections (HAI) | Antibiotic-resistance causing pathogens |
---|---|
Complicated urinary tract infections (cUTIs) | E. coli Klebsiella spp. P. aeruginosa |
Complicated intra-abdominal infections (cIAIs) | |
Hospital-acquired pneumonia including ventilator-associated pneumonia (HAP/VAP) | |
Other HAI: bloodstream infections, digestive tract infections, skin and soft tissue infections and other less frequent infections |
Model Structure
Strategy | Treatment pathway |
---|---|
Current | No diversification Meropenem → Colistin |
New antibacterial in third line | |
Alternative 1 | No diversification Meropenem → Colistin → New antibacterial |
Alternative 2 | Diversification 33% of patients receive: Meropenem → Colistin → New antibacterial 33% of patients receive Colistin → Meropenem → New antibacterial 33% of patients receive New antibacterial → Meropenem → Colistin |
New antibacterial in second line | |
Alternative 3 | No diversification Meropenem → New antibacterial → Colistin |
Alternative 4 | Diversification 33% of patients receive: Meropenem → New antibacterial → Colistin 33% of patients receive: New antibacterial → Meropenem → Colistin 33% of patients receive: Colistin → Meropenem → New antibacterial |
New antibacterial in first line | |
Alternative 5 | No diversification New antibacterial → Meropenem → Colistin |
Alternative 6 | Diversification 33% of patients receive: New antibacterial → Meropenem → Colistin 33% of patients receive: Meropenem → New antibacterial → Colistin 33% of patients receive: Colistin → New antibacterial → Meropenem |
Model Inputs
Pathogen | Total | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
E. coli | Klebsiella spp. | P. aeruginosa | ||
Infections (n)a | 3066 | 4772 | 3454 | 11,292 |
Infections (%)b | 27.15% | 42.26% | 30.59% | 100.00% |
Baseline resistance | ||||
Meropenemc | 3.00% | 75.00% | 46.00% | NA |
Colistinc | 2.00% | 40.00% | 3.700% | NA |
New antimicrobial | 0.00% | 0.00% | 0.00% | NA |
Model input | Description | Value | Source |
---|---|---|---|
Life expectancy post treatment success | Life expectancy of a successfully treated patient | 20.12 yearsa | |
Treatment duration with a successful treatment | Length of stay (per therapy line) of a patient when a line of treatment is successful (days) | 10 days | Expert opinion |
Treatment duration with an unsuccessful treatment | Length of stay (per therapy line) of a patient when a line of treatment is unsuccessful (days) | 5 days | Expert opinion |
Length of stay accounting for mortality | Additional length of stay associated with patients who die in hospital (days) | 4 days | Expert opinion |
Utility (resolution of infection) | Health state utility for patients whose infection has been resolved | 0.79 | Szende et al. [29] |
Utility (infected) | Health state utility of an infected patient | 0.62b | See Supplementary Table 3 |
Daily hospitalisation cost | Cost associated with each day a patient spends in the general ward | €267.25 | See Supplementary Table 3 |
Treatment efficacy of meropenem (when no resistance) | Probability of treatment success in patients with no resistance to treatment | 85.00% | Expert opinion |
Treatment efficacy of colistin (when no resistance) | 90.00% | Expert opinion | |
Treatment efficacy of the new antibacterial (when no resistance) | 92.00% | Expert opinion |
Analysis
Sensitivity Analyses
Ethics Approval
Results
Pathogen | Current treatment strategy | Alternative treatment strategies | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
New antibacterial third line | New antibacterial second line | New antibacterial first line | ||||||||||||||
No diversification (Alternative 1) | Diversification (Alternative 2) | No diversification (Alternative 3) | Diversification (Alternative 4) | No diversification (Alternative 5) | Diversification (Alternative 6) | |||||||||||
Hospitalisation LOS | ||||||||||||||||
E. coli | 336,738 | 345,077 (− 8339 bed days saved) | 341,021 (− 4283 bed days saved) | 344,899 (− 8162 bed days saved) | 340,843 (− 4105 bed days saved) | 342,605 (− 5867 bed days saved) | 338,549 (− 1811 bed days saved) | |||||||||
Klebsiella spp. | 672,680 | 637,340 (35,340 bed days saved) | 630,426 (42,254 bed days saved) | 613,279 (59,400 bed days saved) | 606,365 (66,314 bed days saved) | 582,220 (90,459 bed days saved) | 575,306 (97,373 bed days saved) | |||||||||
P. aeruginosa | 391,713 | 412,168 (− 20,455 bed days saved) | 408,994 (− 17,282 bed days saved) | 409,107 (− 17,394 bed days saved) | 405,933 (− 14,221 bed days saved) | 397,492 (− 5779 bed days saved) | 394,318 (− 2606 bed days saved) | |||||||||
Total | 1,401,130 | 1,394,584 (6545 bed days saved) | 1,380,441 (20,689 bed days saved) | 1,367,285 (33,844 bed days saved) | 1,353,142 (47,988 bed days saved) | 1,322,317 (78,813 bed days saved) | 1,308,173 (92,957 bed days saved) | |||||||||
Hospitalisation cost | ||||||||||||||||
E. coli | €77,008,674 | €78,817,424 (− €1,808,750 costs saved) | €77,918,481 (− €909,807 costs saved) | €78,778,192 (− €1,769,517 costs saved) | €77,879,249 (− €870,574 costs saved) | €78,252,124 (− €1,243,449 costs saved) | €77,353,181 (− €344,506 costs saved) | |||||||||
Klebsiella spp. | €153,662,094 | €145,486,952 (€8,175,141 costs saved) | €143,964,798 (€9,697,296 costs saved) | €139,984,611 (€13,677,482 costs saved) | €138,462,457 (€15,199,637 costs saved) | €132,851,043 (€20,811,050 costs saved) | €131,328,889 (€22,333,205 costs saved) | |||||||||
P. aeruginosa | €89,692,792 | €94,195,868 (− €4,503,076 costs saved) | €93,482,637 (− €3,789,845 costs saved) | €93,490,730 (− €3,797,938 costs saved) | €92,777,499 (− €3,084,707 costs saved) | €90,824,944 (− €1,132,151 costs saved) | €90,111,713 (− €418,920 costs saved) | |||||||||
Total | €320,363,560 | €318,500,245 (€1,863,315 costs saved) | €315,365,916 (€4,997,644 costs saved) | €312,253,533 (€8,110,027 costs saved) | €309,119,204 (€11,244,356 costs saved) | €301,928,111 (€18,435,450 costs saved) | €298,793,782 (€21,569,778 costs saved) | |||||||||
Total days on treatment | ||||||||||||||||
E. coli | 327,943 | 339,533 (11,590 TDT gained) | 335,781 (7839 TDT gained) | 339,370 (11,427 TDT gained) | 335,618 (7675 TDT gained) | 337,374 (9431 TDT gained) | 333,622 (5680 TDT gained) | |||||||||
Klebsiella spp. | 571,991 | 604,553 (32,562 TDT gained) | 597,976 (25,985 TDT gained) | 583,564 (11,573 TDT gained) | 576,987 (4996 TDT gained) | 556,915 (− 15,076 TDT gained) | 550,338 (− 21,654 TDT gained) | |||||||||
P. aeruginosa | 370,432 | 401,217 (30,785 TDT gained) | 398,165 (27,734 TDT gained) | 398,586 (28,154 TDT gained) | 395,535 (25,103 TDT gained) | 388,797 (18,365 TDT gained) | 385,745 (15,314 TDT gained) | |||||||||
Total | 1,270,366 | 1,345,303 (74,937 TDT gained) | 1,331,923 (61,557 TDT gained) | 1,321,520 (51,154 TDT gained) | 1,308,140 (37,774 TDT gained) | 1,283,085 (12,720 TDT gained) | 1,269,705 (− 660 TDT gained) | |||||||||
LYs lost | ||||||||||||||||
E. coli | 26,954 | 17,034 (9920 LYs gained) | 16,113 (10,841 LYs gained) | 16,992 (9962 LYs gained) | 16,071 (10,883 LYs gained) | 16,065 (10,888 LYs gained) | 15,144 (11,809 LYs gained) | |||||||||
Klebsiella spp. | 310,264 | 100,363 (209,901 LYs gained) | 99,344 (210,920 LYs gained) | 90,862 (219,402 LYs gained) | 89,843 (220,421 LYs gained) | 77,188 (233,076 LYs gained) | 76,169 (234,095 LYs gained) | |||||||||
P. aeruginosa | 66,271 | 33,972 (32,300 LYs gained) | 33,595 (32,676 LYs gained) | 32,633 (33,638 LYs gained) | 32,257 (34,015 LYs gained) | 26,955 (39,316 LYs gained) | 26,579 (39,693 LYs gained) | |||||||||
Total | 403,489 | 151,368 (252,121 LYs gained) | 149,051 (254,438 LYs gained) | 140,487 (263,002 LYs gained) | 138,170 (265,319 LYs gained) | 120,208 (283,281 LYs gained) | 117,892 (285,597 LYs gained) | |||||||||
QALYs lost | ||||||||||||||||
E. coli | 21,321 | 13,485 (7836 QALYs gained) | 12,757 (8564 QALYs gained) | 13,452 (7869 QALYs gained) | 12,724 (8597 QALYs gained) | 12,720 (8601 QALYs gained) | 11,992 (9329 QALYs gained) | |||||||||
Klebsiella spp. | 245,165 | 79,340 (165,825 QALYs gained) | 78,534 (166,631 QALYs gained) | 71,832 (173,332 QALYs gained) | 71,027 (174,138 QALYs gained) | 61,027 (184,138 QALYs gained) | 60,221 (184,943 QALYs gained) | |||||||||
P. aeruginosa | 52,387 | 26,872 (25,515 QALYs gained) | 26,574 (25,813 QALYs gained) | 25,814 (26,573 QALYs gained) | 25,517 (26,871 QALYs gained) | 21,328 (31,060 QALYs gained) | 21,030 (31,357 QALYs gained) | |||||||||
Total | 318,873 | 119,697 (199,176 QALYs gained) | 117,866 (201,007 QALYs gained) | 111,099 (207,775 QALYs gained) | 109,267 (209,606 QALYs gained) | 95,075 (223,798 QALYs gained) | 93,244 (225,630 QALYs gained) | |||||||||
Monetary benefit (WTP = €30,000) | ||||||||||||||||
E. coli | NA | €233,271,729 | €256,010,681 | €234,306,965 | €257,045,917 | €256,791,837 | €279,530,789 | |||||||||
Klebsiella spp. | €4,982,922,672 | €5,008,613,653 | €5,213,652,078 | €5,239,343,059 | €5,544,941,960 | €5,570,632,941 | ||||||||||
P. aeruginosa | €760,954,563 | €770,597,028 | €793,388,986 | €803,031,451 | €930,653,045 | €940,295,510 | ||||||||||
Total | €5,977,148,964 | €6,035,221,362 | €6,241,348,029 | €6,299,420,427 | €6,732,386,842 | €6,790,459,240 |