Rationale
-
Do steroids improve neurologic symptoms in patients with metastatic brain tumors compared to no treatment?
-
If steroids are given, what dose should be used?
Methods
Search strategy
Eligibility criteria
-
Published in English with a publication date of 1990 forward.
-
Patients with brain metastases.
-
Fully-published peer-reviewed primary comparative studies (all comparative study designs for primary data collection included; e.g., RCT, non-randomized trials, cohort studies or case-control studies).
-
Study comparisons include one or more of the following:
-
steroid therapy versus none.
-
comparison of different doses of steroid therapy.
-
Number of study participants with brain metastases ≥5 per study arm for at least two of the study arms.
-
Baseline information on study participants is provided by treatment group in studies evaluating interventions exclusively in patients with brain metastases. For studies with mixed populations (i.e., includes participants with conditions other than brain metastases), baseline information is provided for the intervention sub-groups of participants with brain metastases.
Study selection and quality assessment
Evidence classification and recommendation levels
Guideline development process
Scientific foundation
Studies meeting search criteria
First author (year): Vecht et al. (1994), [5] | ||
---|---|---|
Study characteristics | Study outcomes | Study quality |
Study design RCT (two trials reported)
Inclusion criteria for both RCTs
KPS < 80, histologically confirmed diagnosis of solid cancer outside nervous system, together with single or multiple BM diagnosed by CT
Exclusion criteria for both RCTs
Age > 75 years; KPS = 90 or 100; prior RT to brain; likelihood of early treatment with neurosurgery; glucocorticoid administration in the previous 3 months; BM secondary to lymphoreticular malignancy; diabetes mellitus or disability due to causes other than BM
Interventions
First RCT G1: dexamethasone 8 mg/day p.o. × 7 day (then tapered to discontinue) G2: dexamethasone 16 mg/day p.o. × 7 day (then tapered to discontinue) Second RCT After G1 versus G2 not significantly different at day 7 G3: Dexamethasone 4 mg/day p.o. × 28 day (then tapered to discontinue) G4: Dexamethasone 16 mg/day p.o. × 28 day (then tapered to discontinue) Notes: all pts scheduled for RT to started at some point after Day 7 (RT dose/schedule not reported); all pts received ranitidine 150 mg bid Median follow-up: not reported # male: G1: 14/20; G2: 14/22; G3: 12/24; G4: 7/23 Median age (range): median not reported; mean age ± SD: G1: 61 ± 7.6 years G2: 61 ± 11.5 years G3: 60 ± 9.9 years G4: 56 ± 10.9 years Predominant tumor types: G1: lung 11/20, breast 4/20, gastrointestinal 4/20, other 1/20 G2: lung 10/22, breast 6/22, kidney 3/22, gastrointestinal 1/22 G3: lung 10/24, breast 7/24, kidney 3/24, gastrointestinal 1/24 G4: lung 12/23, breast 5/23, gastrointestinal 2/23, kidney 2/23 # of brain metastases: Not reported Extra-cranial disease: Note reported Baseline functional performance: Mean KPS ± SD (range) G1: 58.5 ± 11.8 (40–80) G2: 61.4 ± 9.4 (50–80) G3: 65.0 ± 10.6 (40–80) G4: 57.8 ± 14.1(30–80) |
Primary outcome
Change in KPS on day 7 from day 0
First RCT
Mean (SD) absolute change in KPS at day 7: G1: 8.0 ± 10.1; G2: 7.3 ± 14.2 (P = NS) % pts with improved KPS on day 7: G1: 60%; G2: 54% Mean (SD) absolute change in KPS at day 28: G1: 6.7 ± 18.4; G2: 13.8 ± 14.5 (P = NS) % pts with improved KPS on day 28: G1: 53%; G2: 81%
Second RCT
Mean (SD) absolute change in KPS at day 7: G3: 6.7 ± 11.3; G4: 9.1 ± 12.4 (P = NS) % pts with improved KPS on day 7: G3: 67%; G4: 70% Mean change in KPS (SD) at day 28 G3: 7.1 ± 18.2; G4: 5.6 ± 18.5 (P = NS) % pts improved: G3: 62%; G4: 50%
Adverse events: reported combined results
Toxic effects more frequent in G2 + G4 (16 mg) (P < 0.03) Incidence of cushingoid facies or ankle edema increased with duration of treatment (P = 0.02 at day 7 and P = 0.03 at day 28) and with higher doses of dexamethasone At day 28: reported combined results from both RCTs Raised glucose: G1: 25%; G2/G4: 21%; G3: 18% Raised blood pressure: G1: 12%; G2/G4: 26%; G3: 45% Infectious disease: G1: 6%; G2/G4: 9%; G3: 9% Gastrointestinal complaints: G1: 6%; G2/G4: 24%; G3: 18% Mental changes: G1: 19%; G2/G4: 21%; G3: 14% Ankle edema: G1: 13%; G3: 14%; G2/G4: 26% Cushingoid facies: G1: 69%; G3: 32%; G2/G4: 65% Proximal weakness: G1: 38%; G3: 14%; G2/G4: 38% |
AANS/CNS evidence classification: Class 1
Due to the relatively small size, heterogeneity in study design and lack of clarity in the statistical presentation and analysis there are concerns about over generalizing the results and conclusions of this trial.
|
First author (year): Wolfson et al. (1994), [6] | ||
---|---|---|
Study design: prospective randomized phase II trial [stratified by response to high-dose dexamethasone]
Inclusion criteria
Measurable BM on CT; histologically confirmed primary malignancy; granulocyte counts >1,000/mm3 and serum glucose <300 mg%
Exclusion criteria
Primary malignancies including lymphomas, germ cell tumors, primary CNS tumors, SCLC, multiple primaries, and unknown primaries; resected BMs; illnesses such as active peptic ulcer disease, uncontrolled diabetes mellitus (serum glucose ≥ 300 mg%), adrenal insufficiency or being seropositive for HIV prior cranial RT; administration of steroid therapy more than 24 h prior to study entry
Interventions
G1: dexamethasone 24 mg i.v. every 6 h for 48 h prior to WBRT; then dexamethasone 4 mg p.o. every 6 h for 2 weeks during WBRT G2: dexamethasone 24 mg i.v. every 6 h for 48 h prior to WBRT
Doses
G1: WBRT: 30 Gy at 3 Gy/fraction G2: WBRT: 30 Gy at 3 Gy/fraction Note: all pts given H-2 blockers during steroid administration and oral phenytoin for seizure prophylaxis Median follow-up: not reported # male
G1: 2/7; G2: 3/5 Median age (range): not reported by treatment group Overall median age: 58 years
Tumor type
G1: NSCLC 5/7, breast 2/7 G2: NSCLC 3/5, breast 1/5, bladder 1/5 # of brain metastases
G1: 1 BM 2/7, 2 BM 4/7, >2 BM 1/7 G2: 1 BM 2/5, 2 BM 1/5, >2 BM 2/5 Extra-cranial disease: Extra-cranial metastases: G1: 5/7; G2: 3/5
Baseline functional performance
Not reported |
Primary outcome
Overall survival
Survival
Overall median survival: 4 months (no between group statistical analyses due to limited pt numbers)
Functional performance
Change in general performance status: G1: improved 2/7, deteriorated 1/7, no change 4/7 G2: improved 0/5, deteriorated 1/5, no change 4/5 Change in neurological function class: G1: improved 1/7, deteriorated 1/7, no change 5/7 G2: improved 0/5, deteriorated 1/5, no change 4/5
Cause of death
Non-specific and not reported by treatment group
Adverse events/other
Transient hyperglycemia: 1/12 | AANS/CNS evidence classification: class 1
Despite this qualifying as class I the small size and lack of any statistical analysis render this article useless for any recommendations.
|
Discussion
Role of steroids in metastatic brain disease
Effect of steroids on radiographic edema
Dosing and toxicity
Summary and conclusions
Steroid therapy versus no therapy
Comparison of different doses of steroid therapy
Key issues for further investigation
No ongoing or recently closed clinical trials on the use of steroids for the management of brain metastases were found that met the eligibility criteria.