Background
Factors that impact on chiropractic decision making
Methods
Procedure
The questionnaire (see Additional file 1)
Neck pain
Low back
Psychological measurements
Other measurements
Variables of interest
Potential predictor variables
Outcome variables and their rationale
-
Indicated / non-indicated / contra-indicated care: Seven dependent variables were selected, three from the neck pain and four from the low back pain questionnaires. Of these two were contra-indicated cases, two non-indicated cases and three indicated cases. The ‘appropriate’ answers proposed in the previous study on this topic for the low back and neck questions were used [36]. The rationale is presented in Additional file 1.
-
X-ray usage: The number of X-rays requested for the last 10 new patients would be split into 2 groups using the median score. This would potentially result in a ‘low’ and ‘high’ group for ordering X-rays.
-
The number of informal and formal referrals made in the last full working week: Again we intended to create 2 groups (High, Low) on the basis of dichotomising the group on a 50% split, using the median score.
-
Identification with need for technique system: Participants would be dichotomised into those who used a chiropractic technique system to guide clinical care (“Yes, as best I can” and “Parts of it”) and those who did not (“Not at all” and “the technique but not the system”).
-
Reasons for taking X-rays: Respondents were to be dichotomised into those who ordered X-rays for a specified clinical reason and those who did not.
Analysis
Results
Descriptive information
Demographic Variable | Current Study | ACORN Cohort |
---|---|---|
Age: Mean (SD) | 44.3 (11) Range 25–70 | 41.9 (12) |
Male / Female: | 66.1% | 62.9% |
Years in practice: Mean (SD) | 17.9 (10.4) Range 2–44 | 15.6 (11.2) |
Hours / Week Work: Mean (SD) | 27.1 (10.3) Range 5–60 | 27.3 (12.8) |
Patients / Week: Mean (SD) | 91 (58.7) Range 8–310 | 87.5 (56.3) |
Domains | Variable | Variable construction | Number (%) |
---|---|---|---|
Patients / week
Missing 39
| Mean 91.4 (58.7) | Low | 27 (26) |
Median 82.5 / week | Average | 49 (45) | |
Range 7–310 | High | 26 (28) | |
X-rays (High and Low)
Missing 33
| New Patient X-rays, | ||
Mean 3.6 (2.7) | Low | 52 (48) | |
Median 3, | high | 41 (52) | |
Range 0–10 | |||
Reason X-rays
| Contraindications | Yes | 79 (73) |
Missing 39
| No | 29 (27) | |
Osteoarthritis | Yes | 70 (66) | |
Missing 35
| No | 36 (43) | |
Osteoporosis/paenia | Yes | 63 (61) | |
Missing 38
| No | 40 (39) | |
Patient progress | Yes | 5 (4) | |
Missing 2 | No | 135 (96) | |
Red Flags | Yes | 98 (91) | |
Missing 39
| No | 10 (9) | |
Scoliosis | Yes | 66 (61) | |
Missing 33
| No | 42 (39) | |
Subluxation | Yes | 15 (11) | |
Missing 1
| No | 125 (89) | |
Trauma | Yes | 99 (91) | |
Missing 32
| No | 10 (9) | |
Referral
| |||
Informal | Mean 4.9 (4.9) | No Referrals | 50 (52) |
(N = 108)
Missing 33
| Median 4, | At least one | 45 (48) |
Range 0–40 | |||
Formal | Mean 2.3 (2.7) | No Referrals | 9 (8) |
(N = 108)
Missing 33
| Median 2, | At least one | 99 (91) |
Range 0–20 | |||
Technique
| Advanced Bio-structural | Yes & parts of it | 7 (7) |
Correction | No to all else | 89 (93) | |
Missing 45
| |||
Activator | Yes & parts of it | 32 (26) | |
Missing 17
| No to all else | 92 (74) | |
Applied Kinesiology | Yes & parts of it | 42 (43) | |
Missing 19
| No to all else | 80 (66) | |
Chiropractic BioPhysics | Yes & parts of it | 12 (11) | |
Missing 36
| No to all else | 93 (89) | |
Functional Neurology | Yes & parts of it | 58 (51) | |
Missing 27
| No to all else | 56 (40) | |
Gonstead | Yes & parts of it | 45 (40) | |
Missing 27
| No all else | 69 (60) | |
Neural Organisation Technique | Yes & parts of it | 7(7) | |
Missing 38
| No to all else | 96 (93) | |
Sacro Occipital Technique | Yes & parts of it | 58 (49) | |
Missing 23
| No to all else | 60 (51) | |
Thompson | Yes & parts of it | 66 (54) | |
Missing 30
| No to all else | 55 (46) | |
Chiropractic Philosophy |
Missing 8
| Very / Important | 90 (68) |
All others | 43 (32) | ||
Subluxation |
Missing 1
| Very / Important | 75 (53) |
All others | 65 (47) | ||
Self-rating |
Missing 37
| I don’t know / Av | 29 (38) |
Above Av | 75 (72) |