Perceptions in orthopedic surgery on the use of cannabis in treating pain: a survey of patients with spine pain (POSIT Spine)

Back pain is the leading cause of activity limitation and work absence worldwide, with back-related disability and population burden on the rise [1]. It affects 50–80% of the population [2]. Furthermore, it is associated with an enormous economic burden on individuals, families, communities, industry, and governments [3, 4]. In the United States (US) alone, the annual costs of back pain exceed US$100 billion [5].

Treatment guidelines for non-specific back pain recommend non-pharmacological care as first-line and discourage the use of opioids [6, 7]. Pharmacological treatment should only follow if there is an inadequate response to non-pharmacological interventions, and then it should start with oral NSAIDs at the lowest effective dose for the shortest possible time [8]. Opioids, although effective for treating pain, come with significant risks and potential side effects, including addiction, tolerance, and overdose, and therefore their routine use is not recommended and should only be used for a short duration in carefully selected patients, and with appropriate monitoring [9].

However, despite a lack of high-quality data on the benefits, opioids are still commonly prescribed for chronic musculoskeletal (MSK) pain [10]. Insurance claims data suggest that opioids are the most commonly prescribed class of drug for back pain [11]. This problem seems to be characteristic of the US and Canada, which prescribe postoperative opioids in higher doses and more frequently than other countries [12, 13]. One-fifth of all opioid-related deaths are linked to prescriptions [14], and orthopedic surgeons are the third-highest prescribers of opioids [15]. In 2016, there were approximately 3000 apparent opioid-related deaths in Canada, which is equivalent to eight people dying every day [16]. This number has more than doubled in 2021 (7169) [17]. The restrictions implemented to control the COVID-19 spread have also limited the access to services essential for vulnerable populations, resulting in a higher risk of withdrawal, overdose, and death [18, 19].

North America has been going through an opioid epidemic, and opioid-sparing alternatives are needed for pain management. There are many recorded instances of cannabis being used as an analgesic throughout human history, some as early as the second century AD [20]. Cannabis contains cannabinoids, which have been found to have pain-relieving and anti-inflammatory properties. In recent years, there has been growing interest in cannabis for pain management, including for back and neck pain. Nevertheless, high-quality data regarding cannabis use for pain management in Orthopedic surgery is scarce, indicating that more research is needed [21, 22]. While research on the effectiveness of cannabis for pain management is still ongoing, some have reported significant improvements in their symptoms with its use [23]. In Canada, medical cannabis has been legal since 2001, and in 2018 Canada legalized the recreational use of cannabis, presenting a unique setting for cannabis research.

The objectives of this study were to examine the patients' positions and perceptions regarding cannabis in the treatment of back pain. The primary aim was to determine the perceived effects of cannabis on back and neck pain. Our secondary goals were to explore patient preferences, insight, and attitudes surrounding cannabis use for MSK pain management and identify possibilities for future research.

This is a multi-center survey-based study designed to determine patients' positions, preferences, and insight on cannabis use for back pain. English-speaking adult patients presenting at the three participating clinics (Hamilton, ON) with back or neck pain were screened for inclusion. Patients who were cognitively impaired, too ill or injured to participate, or being at the clinics for a traumatic injury or arthritis were excluded.

The questionnaire was developed by consulting current literature, patients, and a multidisciplinary group of experts (orthopedic surgeons, rheumatologists, anesthesiologists, epidemiologists, cannabis dispensary operators and licensed producers). It consisted of 50 questions using a multiple-choice and Likert-scale format to enhance the answer rate [24]. The questionnaire collected information on patient and injury characteristics; pain severity and analgesic usage; perceptions and positions about medical cannabis; perceived effectiveness of medical cannabis for back pain; and barriers to appropriate clinical use. We used the visual analog scale (VAS) to estimate pain severity, starting from 0 for no pain to 100 for severe pain. We used a continuous scale (0–100%) to measure the perceived effectiveness of cannabis, where patients rated how much pain they felt could be or is being treated by cannabis. We also assessed patients for anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) using the PROMIS (Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System) SF v1.0-Anxiety 4a (four questions) and the Short Screening Scale version of the DSM-IV PTSD test (seven questions) [25, 26]. We then tested the questionnaire draft through interviews and focused feedback with our group of experts for comprehensiveness, readability, and clarity.

Members of the research team approached patients consecutively at the participating clinics and screened them for study inclusion. Eligible patients that provided consent completed the questionnaire administered by the research member using a tablet device. Surveys were anonymous, and the anonymous data was entered into the REDCap database. We summarized continuous data as means and standard deviations and categorical data as counts and percentages. Our primary outcome was perceived effect of cannabis on back pain, while secondary outcomes were perceptions regarding potential applications and barriers to cannabis use. Additionally, a regression analysis to determine associations with patients' perceived effectiveness of cannabis was done. The independent variables were patient and injury characteristics, previous surgery for the pain, pain frequency and severity, opioid use, past experience with cannabis, and the presence of PTSD and anxiety. The P-values were two-tailed, with a threshold of 0.05 considered statistically significant.

We calculated our sample size based on our primary regression analysis. We used a sample size calculation with a significance level 0.05 with an estimated medium effect size of 0.3 to be powered for 80%. This was a conservative estimate. Accounting for possible correlation and response categories, an estimated 174 patients would achieve adequate power to assess the relationship for perceived effectiveness. We also added an additional 20% to account for patients with incomplete data.

The opioid crisis in North America is worsening. Deaths involving opioids increased by 500% in 2017 compared to 2016, and the COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated this public health problem by adding more strain on the healthcare system [16, 19, 27]. Opioid prescriptions play a substantial role in these deaths and are still commonly prescribed for MSK pain. Finding a safe and effective non-opioid alternative is critical.

This survey asked 259 patients presenting to Orthopedic clinics about their beliefs and perceptions regarding the effect of cannabis on spine pain. The literature on cannabis for MSK pain is somewhat inconsistent [28]. The National Academies for Science, Engineering, and Medicine of the USA published a review stating that cannabis was effective for non-cancer chronic pain treatment [29]. However, a year later, a systematic review concluded that the evidence for the effectiveness of medical cannabis on chronic non-cancer pain is limited [30]. Our findings show that 88.4% of the patients believed cannabis was an effective treatment option for back pain and could treat 54.3% of their pain and replace nearly half (46.2%) of their current pain medications. Additionally, most patients believed cannabis would be more beneficial for treating their pain if started earlier, specifically in the first three months. A third (35.3%) already used medical cannabis for treating pain, most within the last year.

Nearly three-quarters of the patients in this study used opioids to manage their back pain. Considering all the campaigns aimed at restricting opioid use for chronic non-cancer pain, these findings are very concerning and seem to be a common theme, as other studies have also shown opioids being used as a first-line for MSK pain [7, 31‐33]. However, in our study, eight out of ten patients also felt cannabis could decrease their opioid needs. A small qualitative study including 20 patients with MSK pain showed similar findings, and although not specific to MSK and spine pain, there is other data that endorses the potential of cannabis to reduce opioid use [34‐37]. This finding further supports considering cannabis for musculoskeletal pain control.

Patients generally felt comfortable discussing cannabis with their physicians, with nearly two-thirds (64.8%) describing it as a positive experience. However, only a third (30.8%) reported having had a conversation with their physicians on cannabis for their pain. The number one barrier patients stated was not knowing they could use cannabis for medical purposes. Considering that concerns regarding side-effects or addiction were low (14–18%), we believe this is likely due to the fact that cannabis is not yet approved for treating MSK pain by most regulatory bodies, such as Health Canada or the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

As this was a survey-based study, the main limitation was recall bias. Nonresponse bias could also be considered a limitation, as cannabis is still considered a schedule 1 drug in the US and associated with some stigma [38, 39]. Hopefully, the recent shift toward more permissive views on cannabis and our study showing that moral or religious objections to using cannabis were low (4%) has helped offset this inclination. A potential weakness could be considered that the study was done in 2018; however, in Canada, legislation regarding medical cannabis has not changed since then, and the change in the legal status of recreational cannabis was in 2018, which is when we conducted the study.

There is an increased interest in exploring the potential analgesic applications of cannabis [40]. There has been evidence showing that cannabis can be effective for back pain, although the quality of the evidence is poor [21, 41]. In our study, patients reported interest in participating in randomized clinical trials (RCT) comparing cannabis to standard treatments, as more than half of the participants (54.8%) responded they would participate in such a clinical trial.

Patients with spine pain perceived cannabis as an effective pain medication, with one in three already using it for their back pain. Additionally, cannabis could potentially be used for opioid-sparing purposes, as eight out of ten patients also believed cannabis could reduce opioid use and replace nearly half of their opioid medications. Before we can add cannabis as another resource to our pain management arsenal, more research and high-quality data from RCTs are necessary. Our data on the barriers (educating physicians and patients on cannabis), timing (acute period), and preferences (government distributors and oral formulations) could help guide future research and clinical application of cannabis.