Introduction
Aims of the Study
Methods
Search Strategy
Study Selection Process
Outcome Evaluation
Results
Type of intervention | Including | No. of studies | Evidence |
---|---|---|---|
Societal recovery | Approaches aiming at personal goals, (social) skills training, occupational therapy | 22 | 4 added value 11 promising results 7 no evidence yet |
Personal recovery | Peer run, empowerment, confidence, hope, meaning | 6 | 2 added value 4 promising results |
Functional recovery | Cognitive remediation/training, cognitive adaptation | 5 | 3 added value 2 no evidence yet |
Lifestyle | Health promotion, exercise, healthy meals | 13 | 7 promising results 6 no evidence yet |
Spiritual and creative | Tai chi, music therapy, art therapy | 7 | 3 added value 3 promising results 1 no evidence yet |
Evaluation of Results of the Interventions
Authors | Design and study duration | Setting | Study population (N) | Intervention | Main outcomes | Main findings | Added value/promising first result/no evidence for effectiveness yet |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Societal recovery | |||||||
Park and Han (2018) | Quasi-experimental pretest–posttest Duration: 5 weeks | Rehabilitation centers | People with chronic schizophrenia (n = 41) | CEP-S: Communication Enhancement Program | Communication skills Empathy Relationship skills Problem-solving skills | Increased communication skills and relationship skills | Promising first results |
Beentjes et al. (2018) | Exploratory cluster RCT Duration: 12 months | Extensive inpatient and/or outpatient psychiatric treatment including case management at nine MHC institutes, including supported housing | People with SMI (N = 41) | e-IMR + IMR | Illness management, self-management, recovery, symptoms, quality of life, and general health | No significant results and low e-IMR use | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Sheridan et al. (2018) | Qualitative, written diary data Duration: 9 months | Mental health services including 28% supported accommodation | People with enduring mental illness (N = 34) | Volunteer partner group, supported socialisation programme to stimulate social/leisure activities | n/a | Positive findings on: involvement ‘normalising’ life, sense of connectedness, physical health, and facilitating engagement with culture, integrate socialising into identity, perceived social capacity | Promising first results |
Bitter et al. (2017) | Cluster RCT Duration: 20 months | Sheltered/supported housing facilities | People suffering from SMI (N = 263) 71% inpatients | Comprehensive approach to rehabilitation (CARe) Methodology | Functioning Personal recovery Quality of life | Quality of life increased and amount of care needs decreased in both groups | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Loi et al. (2016) | Pre-post, non- randomized, study Duration: 6 weeks | Residential facility | Older adults suffering from SMI (N = 5) | Short educational training course on using the internet and touch screen | Social isolation Self esteem Internet use | No sign improvements or worsening in both outcomes | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Magliano et al. (2016) | Controlled non-randomized study Duration: 2 months | Residential facilities | People suffering from SMI (N = 114) | VADO Approach: Skills assessment and definition of goals (based on Falloon’s CBT and inspired by Boston (or choose-get-keep) approach) | Functioning | Positive result on functioning | Promising first results |
Killaspy et al. (2015) | Cluster RCT Duration: 12 months | Inpatient rehabilitation units | People suffering from SMI (N = 344) | Staff training program designed to increase patients’ engagement in activities | The degree to which patients were engaged in activity over the previous week | No difference between the groups in engagement in activities | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Sanches et al. (2015) | Multi site RCT Duration: 12 months | FACT teams and supported and sheltered housing facilities | People suffering from SMI | Boston university approach to psychiatric rehabilitation (BPR; aka choose-get-keep) | Societal participation Patients’ experience of success Quality of life Recovery | Protocol | Results not known yet |
Anthony et al. (2014) | Pre-post study Duration: 18 months | 28 service programs | People suffering from SMI (N = 238) 49% sheltered facility | Residential and employment goal setting procedure in a choose-get-keep rehabilitation program | Employment status Residential status Earnings | Participants with residential goals improved sign on residential status and earnings; intervention completers improved on employment status – Participants with employment goals improved significant on employment status and earnings | Promising first results |
Lindstrom et al. (2012) | Prospective pre-test, post-test, and follow up test Duration: 6 months | Supported or sheltered housing facilities | People suffering from SMI (N = 17) 82% inpatients | Home based occupational therapy intervention aiming at identifying, realising and sustaining meaningful daily occupations | Goal attainment Motor and process skills Social interaction Satisfaction with daily occupations ADL Psychiatric symptoms | Sign improvements on goal attainment, social interaction, and satisfaction with daily occupations, ADL and psychiatric symptoms | Promising first results |
Ellison et al. (2011) | Pre-post design Duration: 12 months | State-wide implementation in several community facilities and supervised facilities | People suffering from SMI (N = 511 and 221) controls for the analysis of service use and costs (40% inpatients) | Intensive psychiatric rehabilitation based on choose-get-keep model | Role functioning on several domains Service use and service costs | A positive effect on residential status and earnings for completers | Promising first results |
McMurran et al. (2011) | Pragmatic multi centre RCT Duration: 1.5 year | Community settings including residential or supported care settings | 340 planned suffering from personality disorder | Psycho education combined with problem solving (PEPS) therapy | Social Functioning (SFQ) | Protocol | No results yet |
Fagan-Pryor et al. (2009) | Retrospective outcome evaluation Duration: 3 years prior to- and 3 year post-implementation | Inpatient psychiatric facility | Male veterans suffering from SMI (N = 47) | Psychiatric rehabilitation and recovery based program based on choose-get-keep model with focus on housing | Discharge Community tenure Number of admissions | – Significant larger community tenure in discharged participants pre-post implementation | Promising first results |
Levitt et al. (2009) | RCT Duration: 12 months | Supportive housing | 104 persons with SMI | Illness management and recovery | Illness Management and Recovery Scales Psychosocial functioning Quality of life Symptoms | Significant difference in self-reported and clinician ratings of illness management, symptoms and psychosocial functioning of the quality of life scale | Added value |
RCT Duration: 3 years | Community residents, | Older adults (> + 50 years) suffering from SMI (N = 183) 50% inpatients | HOPES program: Social skills training and health management; 24 months | Psychosocial functioning Community functioning Self-efficacy Health | – Significant improvements in performance measures of social skills, psychosocial and community functioning, negative symptoms, and self-efficacy | Added value | |
Vandevooren et al. (2007) | Retrospective repeated measures design Duration: Prior to program: Annually over a 6-year period, before and after, 1 year follow up | Residential home | People suffering from SMI (N = 25) | Systematic rehabilitation approach based on choose-get-keep model | Community tenure Number of admissions Living situation | – Significant change in community tenure over 7 year period | Promising first results |
Seo et al. (2007) | Quasi experimental design Duration: 2 months | Inpatient ward in psychiatric hospital | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 74) | Social skills group training based on Liberman and Bellack modules | Social skills Self esteem Assertiveness skills Problem-solving skills Conversational skills | Differences in improvements of a number of social skills and self-esteem in favour of the intervention group | Promising first results |
Pioli et al. (2006) | Partially randomized multi centric trial Duration: 12 months | Residential and day care centres | People diagnosed with schizophrenic disorder (N = 98) 33% living in sheltered facilities | VADO: Skills assessment and definition of goals | Social functioning Psychiatric symptoms | Significant improvement on psychiatric symptoms and social functioning | Promising first results |
Rogers et al. (2006) | RCT Duration: 24 months | Intensive care receivers of State Department of Mental Health | Adults suffering from major mental illness (N = 135) 50% inpatients | Psychiatric vocational rehabilitation (PVR) using choose-get-keep model | Psychiatric symptoms Quality of life Self esteem Vocational & educational status | No sign differences over time in employment status, symptoms, quality of life or self-esteem | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Oka et al. (2004) | Retrospective study Duration: Minimal 3 yrs. follow up | Previously long term hospitalized persons, recently discharged and living independently or in a residential home | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 52) | Hybrid occupational therapy and supported employment | Hospitalization Community tenure Social functioning | Social functioning improved significantly greater after supported employment was started Mean number of hospitalization decreased Community tenure increased significantly | Promising first results |
Anzai et al. (2002) | RCT Duration: 1 year | Inpatient facility | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 32) | Illness self-management skills training program based on the community re-entry module of Liberman et al. | Psychotic symptoms Knowledge and skills Rehabilitation skills | Significant improvement in knowledge and (rehabilitation) skills in the intervention group Patients in the intervention group spent significantly more time in community in comparison to the control group | Added value |
Tsang and Pearson (2001) | Cluster randomized pilot test Duration: 3 months | Community-based staffed residential facilities | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 97) | Social skills training in the context of vocational rehabilitation | Work related social skills, self-perceived Social skills in role play exercise Job motivation checklist Vocational outcome and adjustment | Work related social skills; self-perceived and measured with role play were both significantly higher in the two training groups Training group with follow up support most successful in job search | Added value |
Personal recovery | |||||||
Nowak et al. (2018) | Pre-post evaluation Duration: 6 weeks | Clinics | People diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 46) | Recovery-oriented cognitive behavioral workshop | Recovery Psychosocial functioning | No significant change over time in total recovery Improvement regarding confidence and hope, feeling less dominated by symptoms, psychosocial functioning and psychopathology | Promising first results |
Boevink et al. (2016) | RCT Duration: 24 months | 2 community treatment teams and 2 sheltered housing organisations | Persons suffering from severe mental illness (N = 163) 28% inpatients | User run recovery programme TREE | Empowerment Mental health confidence Loneliness | Sign more mental health confidence Less care needs Less self-reported symptoms Less likelihood of institutional residence | Added value |
Mancini et al. (2013) | Quasi-experimental design Duration: 6 months | Psychiatric hospitals | People suffering from SMI (N = 110) | Pro-recovery; a 14-week consumer developed approach including structured group-sessions | Pro-recovery Evaluation Instrument: social satisfactions; quality of life, well-being, recovery | Significant effect on consumer’s perception of the recovery attitudes of staff | Promising first results |
Park and Sung (2013) | Repeated-measure design with matched controls Duration: 10 weeks | Psychiatric hospitals | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 46) | The empowerment program for schizophrenic patients: A nursing intervention focusing on patients’ strength and hopes of recovery | Helplessness Recovery (patient report and nurse report) | Significant effect on helplessness and recovery | Added value |
Willemse et al. (2009) | Pilot evaluation Duration: 12 weeks | Long stay ward of three psychiatric hospitals and one sheltered housing | Older people (mean age: 67) (N = 36) | Searching for meaning in life-program | The Philadelphia geriatric center morale Quality of life | Significant increase in life satisfaction | Promising first results |
Randal et al. (2003) | Matched control evaluation study Duration: depending on individual trajectories | Inpatient rehabilitation unit | 9 people with treatment resistant schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder | Individual, flexible, recovery-focused multimodal therapy (21 months) | Positive and negative symptoms, rehabilitation | Reduction in positive symptoms, negative symptoms, and in general psychopathology symptoms. General behavior scores on the Rehabilitation Evaluation of Hall and Baker were clinically improved | Promising first results |
Functional recovery | |||||||
Schutt et al. (2017) | Pre-post pilot study Duration: 2 months | Group home | 6 residents | Cognitive remediation | Neurocognitive performance | No significant gains in cognitive performance | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Stiekema et al. (2015) | Cluster RCT Duration: 24 months | Long stay departments of 3 institutions | 100 planned | Cognitive adaptation training of nurses and specialists | Executive functioning Cognitive strengths and weakness Everyday functioning Quality of life Empowerment | Protocol | Results not known yet |
Sánchez et al. (2013) | RCT Duration: 3 months | Psychiatric hospital | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 84) | REHACOP, integrative cognitive remediation program that taps all basic cognitive functions | Neuro-cognition Clinical symptoms Functioning | Significant effect on neuro-cognition, negative symptoms, disorganization, and emotional distress | Added value |
Lindenmayer et al. (2012) | RCT Duration: 3 months | Persons diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 59) (93% inpatients) | Cognitive remediation (CR) + social cognitive intervention | Social cognition and neurocognitive functions, psychopathology and social functions | Combined CR with emotion perception remediation produced greater improvements in emotion recognition, emotion discrimination, social functioning, and neurocognition compared with CR alone | Added value | |
Medalia et al. (2001) | RCT Duration: 5–6 weeks | Inpatient psychiatric centre | Persons with schizophrenia (N = 54) | Remediation of cognitive problem solving skills | Independent community living Verbal knowledge, judgement, and problem solving Verbal memory and narrative recall | For independent living change scores, a significant between-group difference was found | Added value |
Healthy lifestyle | |||||||
Looijmans et al. (2019) | Multi-site randomized controlled pragmatic trial Duration 12 months | Flexible Assertive Community Treatment (F- ACT) teams and sheltered living teams | SMI patients (N = 140) | Multimodal lifestyle approach, including a web-based tool to improve patients’ cardiometabolic health | Primary: differences in waist circumstance at 6 and 12 months Secondary: BMI and metabolic syndrome Zscore | No statistical significant differences found on the p and s outcomes Readiness to change dietary behavior improved | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Sweeney et al. (2019) | RCT and cost effectiveness evaluation Duration 8 months | Residential and non-residential community mental health services | Smokers with SMI (N = 382) | Quitlink utilizing the existing mental health peer workforce to link SSMI to a tailored smoking quitline service | Continuous abstinence Secondary: 7-day abstinence, increased quit attempts, and reductions in cigarettes per day, cravings and withdrawal, mental health symptoms and other substance use, and improvements in quality of life | Protocol | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Ringen et al. (2018) | Prospective naturalistic intervention study Duration: 7 months | University hospital and a private inpatient psychiatric care facility | Long term inpatients (N = 83) | Motivational interventions, psychical activity and establishment of a basic infrastructure regarding activity and diet | Psychical activity, motivation, self-esteem, life satisfaction, functioning, symptoms | No increase of physical activity level. Triglyceride levels and numbers of smokers were significantly reduced and a significant decrease in symptom levels was observed | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
O’Hara et al. (2017) | Structured interviews and qualitative data: two focus groups and field notes Duration: 12 weeks | Supportive housing | People with SMI | Peer based group Lifestyle balance | Feasibility, acceptability, adaptations | Participants attended on average 8/12 sessions Perceived it as helpful and satisfactory | Promising first results |
Looijmans et al. (2017) | Cluster RCT Duration: 12 months | Residential and long-term teams of 2 mental health care organizations | People suffering from severe mental illness (N = 371) | Lifestyle intervention focusing on cardio metabolic health | Waist circumference Body mass index Metabolic syndrome z-score | Waist circumference decreased 1.51 cm in the intervention group versus control group after 3 months and metabolic syndrome z-score decreased 0.22. After 12 months, the decrease in waist circumference was no longer significant | Promising first results |
Hjorth et al. (2016) | Cluster RCT Duration: 12 months | Longterm psychiatric treatment facilities | Staff members serving as role models for severely and chronically mental ill patients (N = 174) | Health promotion intervention for staff as role modelling for patients | Waist circumference BMI Weight Lung PEEP Blood pressure Physical fitness Tobacco and alcohol consumption Quality of life | No effects found on client level There was a relation in: Staff and patient change in quality of life | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Hutchison et al. (2016) | Pre-post study Duration: 12 months | Long term residential mental health care facility | Persons suffering from with severe mental illness (N = 43) | In SHAPE program, a health promotion program aiming at physical activity and healthy diet, using assessment, fitness plan, weekly meetings education, incentives, and group motivational celebrations | Physical activity Physical health Recovery Severity of depression Self-perceived ability to implement health-promoting behaviors Hopefulness | 100% expressed a nutrition and exercise goal, and weekly logs were filled in by the majority Physical activity, health has increased Recovery and depression improved significantly Self-perceived ability improved for wellbeing and exercise | Promising first results |
Gill et al. (2016) | Pilot: Single group pre-post design Duration: 8 weeks | Supported housing programs and ACT program | Adults with serious mental illnesses (N = 77) | Wellness for life inter-professional health promotion intervention Including: Exercise, nutritional counselling, health literacy education, and peer wellness coaching | Blood pressure Blood glucose Waist circumference Body weight Physical strength and flexibility BMI Readiness to change Health status | Average blood pressure and waist circumference decreased Strength and flexibility improved Readiness for diet and exercise improved | Promising first results |
Loh et al. (2016) | Pilot RCT Duration: 3 months | Long stay ward | Patients diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 104) | Structured walking intervention | Health related quality of life | Positive effect on quality of life, wellbeing and psychiatric symptoms | Promising first results |
Cabassa et al. (2015) | RCT Duration: 18 months | Supportive housing | 300 planned | Peer-led healthy lifestyle program | Weight Quality of life Recovery | Protocol | No results yet |
Oertel-Knochel et al. (2014) | Matched pre-post design Duration: 1 week before and 1 week after the intervention | Long-term patients suffering from a major depression or schizophrenia (N = 51) | Exercise group: Cognitive training + aerobic exercise Relaxation group: Cognitive training + relaxation 12 sessions in for weeks | Cognitive performance Symptoms Wellbeing | Increase in cognitive performance in the domains visual learning, working memory and speed of processing, a decrease in state anxiety and an increase in subjective quality of life between pre- and post-testing | Promising first results | |
Verhaeghe et al. (2013) | Cluster preference RCT Duration: 6 months | Sheltered housing organisations | Adults with mental disorders (N = 324) | Health promotion program aiming at physical activity and healthy eating | Body weight BMI Waist circumference Fat mass Health-related quality of life Psychiatric symptom severity | Significant results on body weight, BMI, waist circumference, fat mass, however disappeared during follow up except for fat mass | Promising first results |
Forsberg et al. (2010) | Cluster RCT Duration: 12 months | 8 Supported housing facilities and 2 housing support programmes | Persons with severe mental illness (N = 41) | 12 month Lifestyle intervention program | Quality of life Functioning Psychiatric symptoms | No difference found between the study groups | No evidence for effectiveness yet |
Spiritual and creative | |||||||
Berry et al. (2016) | Cluster RCT Duration: 6 months | Psychiatric rehabilitation wards | Patients with complex mental health needs (N = 51 patients and 85 staff) | 24 one-hour sessions focussing on staff-patients relationships per ward over 6 months | Staff and patient relationships Staff wellbeing Patient functioning | Significant less depersonalization in staff Less feeling of criticism by patients and improvement of ward organization and relationships by patients | Added value |
Ho et al. (2014) | 3-arm RCT Duration: 24 weeks | Residential rehabilitation complex | Patients diagnosed with schizophrenia (N = 153) | Tai chi | Symptom management Motor coordination Memory Daily living function Stress levels | Protocol | No results yet |
Gold et al. (2013) | Pragmatic parallel trial Duration: 9 months | Specialised mental health care settings | Adults with severe mental disorders (N = 144) | 3 months biweekly individual resource-oriented music therapy | Negative symptoms General symptoms Motivation for change Self-efficacy Self-esteem Social relationships | Effect on negative symptoms, functioning, clinical global impressions, social avoidance through music, and vitality | Added value |
Kwon et al. (2013) | Quasi-experimental pretest–posttest design Duration: 7 weeks | Mental health rehabilitation complex | Adults with severe mental disorders (N = 55) | 7 week group music therapy | Brain wave, cognitive function, behavior | Effect on alpha waves revealing that the participants in the music therapy may have experienced more joyful emotions throughout the sessions. The experimental group also showed improved cognitive function and positive behavior (social competence, social interest & personal neatness) while their negative behaviors was significantly less | Promising first results |
Ho et al. (2012) | Pilot RCT Duration: 12 weeks | Mental health rehabilitation complex | Patients with chronic schizophrenia (N = 30) | Tai chi (6 weeks) | Movement coordination Negative symptoms Disability | Effect on movement coordination and interpersonal functioning. Fewer disruptions to life activities at 6 weeks after the intervention | Promising first results |
Gelkopf et al. (2006) | Cluster randomized trial Duration: 3 months | Psychiatric hospital | Patients with chronic schizophrenia (N = 29) | Humorous movies Daily for 3 months | Positive and negative symptoms Anxiety Depression Anger Social functioning Treatment insight Therapeutic alliance | Significant larger difference over time in reduction of negative symptoms, depression and anxiety than in control group The intervention group showed a significant larger improvement in time than the control group on the social functioning scale | Added value |
Hayashi et al. (2002) | Non randomized, controlled study Duration: 4 months | Long stay wards of mental health care institute | Female patients with chronic psychoses (N = 66) | Group musical therapy Including, listening to and making music and group communication about it | Psychotic symptoms Objective quality of life Subjective musical experiences Ward activity and—adjustment | A significant advantage was found of the intervention for psychotic symptoms, quality of life, musical experience, and ward activity over time during the intervention Effects did not last at follow up | Promising first results |