Background
Method
Stage 1: identification of research question
Stage 2: identifying relevant data
Stage 3: data selection
Stage 4 and 5: charting and collating data
Stage 6: consultation exercise
Results
Categorization of health professionals and patients
Characteristics of the observational studies
Diagnosis | Health care profession | Number of studies |
---|---|---|
Depression (n = 3) | Health care students | 1 |
Pharmacists | 1 | |
Medical doctors | 1 | |
Borderline (n = 2) | Nurses | 1 |
Emergency personnel | 1 | |
Schizophrenia (n = 9) | Health professionals and health care students | 2 |
Nursing students | 1 | |
Pharmacy students | 2 | |
Pharmacists | 1 | |
Medical students | 1 | |
Medical doctors | 1 | |
General practitioners | 1 | |
Eating disorder (n = 5) | Health care students | 1 |
Health professionals | 1 | |
Medical doctors | 2 | |
General practitioners | 1 | |
Self-harm (n = 10) | Health professionals | 2 |
Medical doctors | 2 | |
Emergency personnel | 6 | |
Mixed mental disorders (n = 40) | Physiotherapy students | 1 |
Midwifes | 1 | |
Health professionals and health care students | 5 | |
Nursing students | 6 | |
Nurses | 5 | |
Health professionals | 3 | |
Pharmacy students | 1 | |
Pharmacists | 4 | |
Medical students | 4 | |
Medical doctors | 3 | |
General practitioners | 3 | |
Emergency personnel | 5 | |
Dual diagnosis (n = 4) | Health professionals | 2 |
Medical doctors | 1 | |
Emergency personnel | 1 | |
Total | 73 |
First author, year, reference | Country | Population | Sample size | Diagnosis | Design |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abood, 2009 [30] | UK | Medical doctors | N = 47 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Anderson, 2017 [31] | USA | Medical doctors | N = 80 | Eating disorder | Quantitative |
Arbanas, 2019 [32] | Croatia | Health professionals | N = 387 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Artis, 2013 [33] | UK | Emergency personnel | N = 10 | Self-harm | Qualitative |
Arvaniti, 2009 [34] | Greece | Health professionals and health care students | N = 592 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Avery, 2019 [35] | USA | Medical doctors | N = 411 | Dual diagnosis | Quantitative |
Bannatyne, 2017 [36] | Australia | Health care students | N = 126 | Eating disorder | Quantitative |
Bell, 2010 [37] | Australia, Belgium, India, Finland, Estonia, Latvia | Pharmacy students | N = 649 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Bell, 2008 [38] | Australia, Belgium, India, Finland, Estonia, Latvia | Pharmacy students | N = 642 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Bjorkman, 2008 [39] | Sweden | Nurses | N = 120 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Brunero, 2017 [40] | Australia | Nurses | N = 16 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Castillejos, 2019 [41] | Spain | General practitioners | N = 145 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Ceylan, 2019 [42] | Turkey | Nurses | N = 186 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Chapman, 2014 [43] | Australia | Emergency Personnel | N = 186 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Clifton, 2016 [44] | UK | Health professionals | N = 85 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Conlon, 2012 [45] | Ireland | Emergency personnel | N = 87 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Crapanzano, 2018 [46] | USA | Medical doctors | N = 96 | Depression | Quantitative |
Currin, 2009 [47] | UK | General practitioners | N = 154 | Eating disorders | Quantitative |
Cutler, 2009 [48] | USA | Medical students | N = 47 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Dixon, 2008 [49] | UK | Medical students | N = 1081 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Ewalds-Kvist, 2013 [50] | Sweden | Nursing students | N = 246 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Gawley, 2011 [51] | Canada | Health care students | N = 309 | Depression | Quantitative |
Giannetti, 2018 [52] | USA | Pharmacists | N = 239 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Gordon, 2012 [53] | UK | Emergency personnel | N = 32 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Granados-Gamez, 2017 [54] | Spain | Nursing students | N = 194 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Happell, 2008 [55] | Australia | Nursing students | N = 148 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Happell, 2018 [56] | Australia, Ireland, Finland, Norway, Netherland | Nursing students | N = 423 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Heyward-Chaplin, 2018 [57] | UK | Health professionals | N = 59 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Ihalainen-Tamlander, 2016 [58] | Finland | Nurses | N = 218 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Janouskova, 2017 [59] | The Czech Republic | Health professionals and health care students | N = 308 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Jones, 2009 [60] | USA | Medical doctors | N = 51 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Koning, 2018 [61] | Australia | Emergency personnel | N = 15 | Self-harm | Qualitative |
Thongpriwan, 2015 [62] | USA | Nursing students | N = 229 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Kopera, 2015 [63] | Polonia | Health professionals and health care students | N = 57 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Korszun, 2012 [64] | UK | Medical students | N = 760 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Kuzman, 2014 [65] | The Czech Republic | Medical students | N = 199 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Leddy, 2009 [66] | USA | Medical doctors | N = 504 | Eating disorder | Quantitative |
Liekens, 2012 [67] | Belgium | Pharmacists | N = 149 | Depression | Quantitative |
Magliano, 2011 [68] | Italy | Medical students | N = 194 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Magliano, 2017 [69] | Italy | General practitioners | N = 387 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
McCann, 2018 [70] | Australia | Emergency personnel | N = 1230 | Dual diagnosis | Quantitative |
McCarthy, 2010 [71] | Ireland | Emergency Personnel | N = 68 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Morral, 2016 [72] | UK | Pharmacists | N = 351 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Muehlenkamp, 2013 [73] | Belgium | Health professionals | N = 342 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Nash, 2013 [13] | UK | Emergency personnel | N = 39 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Nauta, 2019 [74] | Netherlands | Medical doctors | N = 187 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Neauport, 2012 [75] | France | Medical doctors | N = 322 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Noonan, 2018 [76] | Ireland | Midwifes | N = 157 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Nutt, 2017 [77] | Scotland | Health professionals | N = 113 | Dual diagnosis | Quantitative |
O’Reilly, 2012 [78] | Australia | Health professionals and health care students | N = 23 | Mixed | Qualitative |
O’Reilly, 2015 [79] | Australia | Pharmacists | N = 188 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Peitl, 2011 [80] | Croatia | Health professionals and health care students | N = 151 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Perboell, 2015 [81] | Denmark | Emergency personnel | N = 122 | Self-harm | Quantitative |
Prener, 2015 [82] | USA | Emergency personnel | N = 20 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Rai, 2019 [83] | UK | Medical doctors | N = 37 | Self-harm | Mixed methods |
Rao, 2009 [84] | UK | Health professionals | N = 108 | Dual diagnosis | Quantitative |
Raveneau, 2014 [85] | USA | Health professionals | N = 82 | Eating disorder | Quantitative |
Reavley, 2014 [86] | Australia | Health professionals | N = 1536 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Rickles, 2010 [87] | USA | Pharmacists | N = 292 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Sandhu, 2019 [88] | Canada | Health professionals and health care students | N = 538 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Schafer, 2011 [89] | UK | Nursing students | N = 288 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Schmidt, 2017 [90] | Netherlands | General practitioners | N = 63 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Serafini, 2011 [91] | Italy | Health professionals and health care students | N = 202 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Shefer, 2014 [15] | UK | Emergency personnel | N = 39 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Stumbo, 2018 [92] | USA | General practitioners | N = 597 | Mixed | Mixed methods |
Treloar, 2009 [93] | Australia | Emergency personnel | N = 140 | Borderline personality disorder | Qualitative |
Van Nieuwenhui, 2013 [94] | UK | Emergency personnel | N = 25 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Volmer, 2008 [95] | Estonia | Pharmacy students | N = 157 | Schizophrenia | Quantitative |
Weare, 2019 [96] | Australia | Nurses | N = 40 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Winkler, 2016 [97] | The Czech Republic | Medical doctors | N = 3010 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Woollaston, 2008 [98] | UK | Nurses | N = 6 | Borderline personality disorder | Qualitative |
Yildirim, 2015 [99] | Turkey | Physiotherapy students | N = 524 | Mixed | Quantitative |
Zolnierek, 2012 [100] | USA | Nurses | N = 1 | Mixed | Qualitative |
Characteristics of the intervention studies
Diagnosis | Health care profession | Number of studies |
---|---|---|
Depression (n = 5) | General practitioners | 3 |
Pharmacists | 2 | |
Borderline (n = 2) | Emergency personnel | 1 |
Health professionals | 1 | |
Schizophrenia (n = 4) | Medical doctors | 1 |
Medical students | 3 | |
Eating disorder (n = 4) | General practitioners | 1 |
Medical students | 1 | |
Nursing students | 2 | |
Self-harm (n = 3) | Emergency personnel | 2 |
Nursing students | 1 | |
Bipolar disorder (n = 1) | Health professionals | 1 |
Mixed mental disorders (n = 45) | General practitioners | 4 |
Medical students | 16 | |
Pharmacy students | 6 | |
Health care students | 1 | |
Nurses | 1 | |
Nursing students | 17 | |
Total | 64 |
First author, year | Country | Population | Sample size | Diagnosis | Design | Intervention |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Airagnes, 2014 [101] | France | Medical students | N = 163 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Arbanas, 2018 [102] | Croatia | Nursing students | N = 51 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Bannatyne, 2015 [103] | Australia | Medical students | N = 41 | Eating disorder | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Beaulieu, 2017 [104] | Canada | General practitioners | N = 73 | Mixed | RCT | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Bilge, 2017 [105] | Turkey | Nursing students | N = 322 | Mixed | Other | Lectures |
Bingham, 2018 [106] | New Zealand | Nursing students | N = 45 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Brenner, 2011 [107] | USA | Medical students | N = 100 | Mixed | Qualitative | Expeditionary interventions |
Calloway, 2017 [108] | USA | Nurses | N = 82 | Mixed | Qualitative | Interventions targeting health professionals |
Chiles, 2017 [109] | USA | Medical students | N = 289 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Observational studies |
Clement, 2012 [110] | UK | Nursing students | N = 216 | Mixed | RCT | Contact-based interventions |
Coppens, 2018 [111] | Portugal, Germany, Ireland, Hungary | General practitioners | N = 208 | Depression | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Crisafulli, 2008 [112] | USA | Nursing students | N = 115 | Eating disorder | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Crockett, 2009 [113] | Australia | Pharmacists | N = 32 | Depression | RCT | Interventions targeting pharmacists |
Demiroren, 2016 [114] | Turkey | Medical students | N = 190 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Dipaula, 2011 [115] | USA | Pharmacy students | N = 278 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Duffy, 2016 [116] | USA | Nursing students | N = 131 | Eating disorder | Quasi-experimental without control group | Lectures |
Duman, 2017 [117] | Turkey | Nursing students | N = 202 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Economou, 2017 [118] | Greece | Medical students | N = 678 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Economou, 2012 [119] | Greece | Medical students | N = 158 | Schizophrenia | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Eksteen, 2017 [120] | The South African Republic | Medical students | N = 616 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Esen Danaci, 2016 [121] | Turkey | Medical students | N = 106 | Schizophrenia | Quasi-experimental without control group | Observational studies |
Failde, 2014 [122] | Spain | Medical students | N = 171 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Observational studies |
Fernandez, 2016 [123] | Malaysia | Medical students | N = 102 | Mixed | RCT | Contact-based interventions |
Flanagan, 2016 [124] | USA | General practitioners | N = 27 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Fokuo, 2017 [125] | USA | Nursing students | N = 70 | Mixed | Qualitative | Contact-based interventions |
Gable, 2011 [126] | USA | Pharmacy students | N = 39 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Galletly, 2011 [127] | Australia | Medical students | N = 87 | Schizophrenia | Quasi-experimental without control group | Contact-based interventions |
Gibson, 2019 [128] | UK | Nursing students | N = 55 | Self-harm | Quasi-experimental without control group | Lectures |
Happell, 2008 [129] | Australia | Nursing students | N = 687 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Happell, 2019 [130] | Australia, Ireland, Finland | Nursing students | N = 194 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Contact-based interventions |
Hastings, 2017 [131] | USA | Nursing students | N = 310 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Itzhaki, 2017 [132] | Israel | Nursing students | N = 101 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Contact-based interventions |
Kassam, 2011 [133] | UK | Medical students | N = 110 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Contact-based interventions |
Knaak, 2015 [134] | Canada | Health professionals | N = 191 | Borderline personality disorder | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting health professionals |
Lam, 2011 [135] | Hong Kong | General practitioner | N = 69 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Lam, 2015 [136] | Hong Kong | General practitioners | N = 566 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Liekens, 2013 [137] | Belgium | Pharmacists | N = 141 | Depression | RCT | Interventions targeting pharmacists |
Linville, 2013 [138] | USA | General practitioners | N = 45 | Eating disorder | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Lyons, 2015 [139] | Australia | Medical students | N = 151 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Manzanera, 2018 [140] | Spain | General practitioners | N = 1322 | Depression | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Markstrom, 2009 [141] | Sweden | Health care students | N = 167 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Martinez-Martinez, 2019 [142] | Spain | Nursing students | N = 185 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Contact-based interventions |
McAllister, 2009a [143] | Australia | Emergency personnel | N = 28 | Self-harm | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting emergency personnel |
McAllister, 2009b [144] | Australia | Emergency personnel | N = 36 | Self-harm | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting emergency personnel |
Michalak, 2014 [145] | Canada | Health professionals | N = 164 | Bipolar disorder | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting health professionals |
Morrison, 2009 [146] | Australia | Nursing students | N/A | Mixed | Qualitative | Contact-based interventions |
Moxham, 2016 [147] | Australia | Nursing students | N = 9 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Muzyk, 2017 [148] | USA | Pharmacy students | N = 74 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Lectures |
O′ Connor, 2013 [149] | Ireland | Medical students | N = 285 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Omori, 2012 [150] | Japan | Medical doctors | N = 51 | Schizophrenia | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
O’Reilly, 2010 [151] | Australia | Pharmacy students | N = 178 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Contact-based interventions |
O’Reilly, 2011 [152] | Australia | Pharmacy students | N = 60 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Papish, 2013 [153] | Canada | Medical students | N = 111 | Mixed | RCT | Expeditionary interventions |
Patten, 2012 [154] | Canada | Pharmacy students | N = 131 | Mixed | RCT | Contact-based interventions |
Poreddi, 2015 [155] | India | Medical students | N = 176 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Lectures |
Romem, 2008 [156] | Israel | Nursing students | N = 126 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Shen, 2014 [157] | China | Medical students | N = 325 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Stacey, 2018 [158] | UK | Nursing students | N/A | Mixed | Qualitative | Lectures |
Stuhlmiller, 2019 [159] | USA | Nursing students | N = 85 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Expeditionary interventions |
Telles-Correia, 2015 [160] | Portugal | Medical students | N = 398 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental without control group | Observational studies |
Treloar, 2009 [161] | Australia | Emergency personnel | N = 65 | Borderline personality disorder | Quasi-experimental with control group | Interventions targeting emergency personnel |
Upshur, 2008 [162] | USA | General practitioners | N = 9 | Depression | Quasi-experimental without control group | Interventions targeting general practitioners and medical doctors |
Wang, 2016 [163] | Taiwan | Medical students | N = 72 | Mixed | Quasi-experimental with control group | Observational studies |
Winkler, 2017 [164] | The Czech Republic | Nursing students | N = 499 | Mixed | RCT | Contact-based interventions |