For the accurate measurement of kinetic and kinematic outputs during resistance training, it is advised that linear transducers are utilised. These devices have demonstrated greater accuracy and reproducibility when compared to other technology. |
It is strongly advised that future validity studies utilise gold-standard criterion measures across a range of relative intensities and exercises. |
For the assessment of reliability, technological and biological error must be acknowledged and separated, so that the precision of each device during exercise can be accurately reported. |
1 Introduction
2 Methods
2.1 Search Strategy
Search 1 | Search 2 | Search 3 | Search 4 |
---|---|---|---|
“Linear position transducer” OR “Accelerometer” OR “High-speed camera” OR “Laser optics” OR “GymAware” OR “Push Band” OR “FLEX” OR “Tendo” OR “Beast sensor” OR “Trio-OptiTrack” OR “T-Force” OR “Chronojump” OR “Speed4Lift” OR “Velowin” OR “PowerLift” OR “WIMU” OR “iLOAD” | “Validity” OR “Reliability” | “Kinetic” OR “Kinematic” OR “Force” OR “Power” OR “Velocity” | “Strength training” OR “Resistance training” OR “Plyometrics” |
2.2 Selection Criteria
2.3 Assessment of Reporting Quality
Study | Items assessed using modified Downs and Black checklist | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Reporting | Internal validity | |||||||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 6 | 7 | 10 | 16 | 18 | 20 | Total | |
Abbott et al. [59] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 8 |
Askow et al. [25] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 7 |
Balsalobre-Fernandez et al. [62] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 8 |
Balsalobre-Fernandez et al. [69] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 8 |
Balsalobre-Fernandez et al. [70] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 8 |
Banyard et al. [8] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Beckham et al. [28] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 7 |
Boehringer and Whyte [77] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 7 |
Chéry and Ruf [60] | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 6 |
Comstock et al. [49] | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 |
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Crewther et al. [50] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
de Sa et al. [80] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Dorrell et al. [26] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Drinkwater et al. [27] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Fernandes et al. [55] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
García-Mateo [63] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 7 |
García-Pinillos et al. [61] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
García-Ramos et al. [71] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Garnacho-Castano et al. [56] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Goldsmith et al. [53] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Gonzalez et al. [57] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Hughes et al. [52] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 7 |
Jennings et al. [79] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Lake et al. [29] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Laza-Cagigas et al. [68] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Lorenzetti et al. [54] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 6 |
Martinez-Cava et al. [51] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 9 |
McGrath et al. [58] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 7 |
Mitter et al. [9] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 8 |
Muyor et al. [38] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Orange et al. [48] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Orange et al. [47] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Pino-Ortega et al. [66] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Peña García-Orea et al. [82] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 9 |
Peña García-Orea et al. [72] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 9 |
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Sanchez-Pay et al. [23] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Sanudo et al. [81] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
Sato et al. [37] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 7 |
Stock et al. [78] | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 7 |
Thompson et al. [24] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
van den Tillaar and Ball [11] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 8 |
Weakley et al. [22] | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 9 |
2.4 Criteria for ‘Acceptable’ Validity and Reliability
3 Results
3.1 Identification of Studies
3.2 Research Reporting Quality
3.3 Study Characteristics
Category | Device | Validity | Reliability |
---|---|---|---|
Accelerometer | PUSH Band | ||
PUSH Band 2.0 | |||
Beast Sensor | |||
Bar Sensei | |||
MyoTest | Lorenzetti et al. [54] | ||
WIMU System | |||
RehaGait | García-Mateo [63] | García-Mateo [63] | |
Linear transducer | GymAware | ||
SmartCoach | Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [69] | ||
1080Q | Boehringer [77] | Boehringer et al. [77] | |
T-Force | |||
Chronojump | |||
Tendo | |||
Speed4Lifts | |||
FitroDyne (fitronic) | Jennings et al. [79] | ||
Open Barbell System | |||
Musclelab (Ergotest) | van den Tillar et al. [11] | ||
Mobile phone devices/applications | PowerLift | ||
iLoad v1.0 | de Sa et al. [80] | ||
Kinovea via Samsung S6 | Sanchez-Pay et al. [23] | ||
Kinovea via Xiaomi A1 | Sanchez-Pay et al. [23] | ||
Kinovea via iPhone X | Sanchez-Pay et al. [23] | ||
Kinovea via Casio FH20 | Sanchez-Pay et al. [23] | ||
Kinovea via Digital Camera | Sanudo et al. [81] | ||
Optic devices | Velowin | ||
Flex | Weakley et al. [22] | Weakley et al. [22] |
Study | Device | Criterion | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Askow et al. [25] | GymAware | Qualysis Motion Capture System & AMTI Force Plate | F/W Back Squat | 75–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.966; ES: 0.28 |
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.982; ES: − 0.57 | |||||
Mean force | ICC: 0.992; ES: 0.11 | |||||
Peak force | ICC: 0.979; ES: − 0.03 | |||||
Mean power | ICC: 0.972; ES: 0.31 | |||||
Peak power | ICC: 0.993; ES: − 0.13 | |||||
Banyard et al. [8] | GymAware | 4 x Celesco PT5A-250 LPT & 1 x AMTI BP6001200 Force Plate | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.96; CV: 3.6%; ES: 0.17; SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | r: 0.94; CV: 4.1%; ES: − 0.03; SEE: 0.08 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.99; CV: 2.2%; ES: 0.57; SEE: 22.57N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.96; CV: 5.5%; ES: 0.61; SEE: 114.2N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.98; CV: 4%; ES: 0.72; SEE: 49.7W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.98; CV: 4.9%; ES: 0.81; SEE: 114.6W | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.97; CV: 3.2%; ES: 0.19; SEE: 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.97; CV: 2.9%; ES: 0.02; SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.99; CV: 1.8%; ES: 0.37; SEE: 25.75N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.99; CV: 3.4%; ES: 0.38; SEE: 65.1N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.97; CV: 4.3%; ES: 0.6; SEE: 55.39W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.97; CV: 5.7%; ES: 0.67; SEE: 143.87W | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.95; CV: 3.1%; ES: 0.11; SEE: 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.96; CV: 3.7%; ES: − 0.02; SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.99; CV: 1.7%; ES: 0.29; SEE: 29.33N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.99; CV: 3.3%; ES: 0.29; SEE: 74.63N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.97; CV: 4.7%; ES: 0.34; SEE: 66.02W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.97; CV: 5.7%; ES: 0.53; SEE: 152.84W | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.96; CV: 3%; ES: 0.14; SEE: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.97; CV: 5.4%; ES: 0.07; SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.99; CV: 1.6%; ES: 0.16; SEE: 34.88N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.99; CV: 3.5%; ES: 0.29; SEE: 79.78N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.99; CV: 3.5%; ES: 0.27; SEE: 37.79W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.98; CV: 6%; ES: 0.36; SEE: 145.79W | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.96; CV: 2.8%; ES: 0.06; SEE: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.95; CV: 5.8%; ES: 0.12; SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 1.00; CV: 1.1%; ES: 0.1; SEE: 23.83N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.99; CV: 3.2%; ES: 0.29; SEE: 85.27N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.99; CV: 4.7%; ES: 0.13; SEE: 44.9W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.96; CV: 7.7%; ES: 0.33; SEE: 166.75W | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.99; CV: 2.5%; ES: 0.39; SEE: 0.01 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.96; CV: 5.4%; ES: 0.04; SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 1.00; CV: 0.7%; ES: 0.06; SEE: 16.9N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.96; CV: 5.5%; ES: 0.13; SEE: 140.28N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.99; CV: 5.3%; ES: 0.26; SEE: 23.89W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.95; CV: 7.3%; ES: 0.19; SEE: 126.8W | |||||
Boehringer and White [77] | 1080Q | GymAware | S/M Bench Press | 40–80%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.018 ± 0.024 m·s−1; r:1.00 |
Mean force | MD: − 116.3 ± 20.5N; r:0.99 | |||||
Mean power | MD: − 93.8 ± 35.3W; r:0.97 | |||||
Peak velocity | MD: 0.033 ± 0.026 m·s−1; r:1.00 | |||||
Peak force | MD: 193.0 ± 126.2N; r:0.91 | |||||
Peak power | MD: − 59.2 ± 35.9W; r:0.98 | |||||
Chery & Ruf [60] | Tendo | GymAware | F/W Deadlift | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 1.72%; MD: 0.03 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | CV: 1.03%; MD: − 0.16 m·s−1 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.17%; MD: 0.01 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 1.47%; MD: − 0.11 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.65%; MD: 0.01 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 1.08%; MD: − 0.09 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.99%; MD: 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 1.37%; MD: − 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.50%; MD: 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 1.36%; MD: − 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.07%; MD: 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 3.76%; MD: − 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
All Loads | Mean velocity | CV: 4.08%; MD: 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 1.56%; MD: − 0.08 m·s−1 | |||||
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | Chronojump | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 6.1%; ICC: 0.992 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 6.8%; ICC: 0.997 | |||||
PEAK velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 2.8%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 10.6%; ICC: 0.984 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.7%; ICC: 0.986 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 2.9%; ICC: 0.989 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.9%; ICC: 0.993 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.2%; ICC: 0.994 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 2.8%; ICC: 0.997 | |||||
Crewther et al. 2011 [50] | GymAware | Force plate | F/W Loaded Squat Jump | 20 kg | Peak force | r: 0.59; bias: 202 ± 579N |
Peak power | r: 0.67; bias: 401 ± 879W | |||||
40 kg | Peak force | r: 0.83; bias: 108 ± 255N | ||||
Peak power | r: 0.82; bias: 178 ± 611W | |||||
60 kg | Peak force | r: 0.87; bias: 39 ± 255N | ||||
Peak power | r: 0.74; bias: 45 ± 748W | |||||
80 kg | Peak force | r: 0.87; bias: 57 ± 414N | ||||
Peak power | r: 0.62; bias: 198 ± 762W | |||||
Dorrell et al. [26] | GymAware | Rapture-E 3D cameras and | F/W Back Squat | 80%1RM | Bar displacement | MD: − 0.009 ± 0.005m |
force plate | Peak velocity | MD: 0.005 ± 0.007 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | MD: 0.029 ± 0.010 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 80%1RM | Bar displacement | MD: − 0.009 ± 0.009m | |||
Peak velocity | MD: 0.002 ± 0.007 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean velocity | MD: 0.017 ± 0.016 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Deadlift | 80%1RM | Bar displacement | MD: − 0.016 ± 0.009m | |||
Peak velocity | MD: 0.004 ± 0.004 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean velocity | MD: 0.100 ± 0.037 m·s−1 | |||||
Drinkwater et al. [27] | GymAware | Sony Digital Video Recorder DRC-TRV900E (High speed camera) | S/M Back Squat | 1 rep @ 3RM | Mean power (ecc) | SEE: 3.6W; CV: 1.16%; r: 1.00 |
Mean power (con) | SEE: 4.1W; CV: 1.08%; r: 1.00 | |||||
Peak power (ecc) | SEE: 11.2W; CV: 1.43%; r: 1.00 | |||||
Peak power (con) | SEE: 14.4W; CV: 2.16%; r: 1.00 | |||||
S/M Bench Throw | 40 kg | Mean power (con) | SEE: 10.8W; CV: 2.78%; r: 0.97 | |||
Max power (con) | SEE: 14.0W; CV: 1.85%; r: 0.99 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 1 rep @ 3RM | Mean power (ecc) | SEE: 7.1W; CV: 2.27%; r: 0.99 | |||
Mean power (con) | SEE: 3.7W; CV: 1.50%; r: 1.00 | |||||
Peak power (ecc) | SEE: 7.8W; CV: 1.33%; r: 1.00 | |||||
Peak power (con) | SEE: 13.2W; CV: 3.02%; r: 0.99 | |||||
Fernandes et al. [55] | FitroDyne (fitronic) | GymAware | S/M Bench Press | 20%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 11.2 + 25.9 cm·s−1; r: 0.86 |
Mean velocity | LoA: − 4.8 + 13.6 cm·s−1; r: 0.92 | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 10.7 + 22.9 cm·s−1; r: 0.79 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 2.0 + 13.1 cm·s−1; r: 0.88 | |||||
40%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 10.7 + 12.1 cm·s−1; r: 0.92 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 0.9 + 9.3 cm·s−1; r: 0.89 | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 10.1 + 4.5 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 0.1 + 9.5 cm·s−1 ; r: 0.86 | |||||
60%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 7.7 + 3.8 cm·s−1; r: 0.99 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 0.0 + 11.6 cm·s−1; r: 0.86 | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 7.5 + 9.6 cm·s−1; r: 0.95 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 0.2 + 7.4 cm·s−1; r: 0.93 | |||||
80%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 5.5 + 10.1 cm·s−1; r: 0.96 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 1.0 + 6.8 cm·s−1; r: 0.94 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 12.0 + 8.8 cm·s−1; r: 1.00 | |||
Mean velocity | LoA: 2.0 + 6.3 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 10.6 + 9.3 cm·s−1; r: 0.99 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 0.6 + 7.5 cm·s−1; r: 0.97 | |||||
40%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 10.4 + 9.1 cm·s−1; r: 0.99 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 1.2 + 5.4 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 9.2 + 7.4 cm·s−1 m·s−1; r: 0.99 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 2.3 + 3.3 cm·s−1; r: 0.99 | |||||
60%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 8.5 + 5.8 cm·s−1; r: 1.00 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 2.0 + 3.0 cm·s−1; r: 0.99 | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 8.3 + 5.4 cm·s−1; r: 1.00 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 2.2 + 2.1 cm·s−1; r: 1.00 | |||||
80%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 8.0 + 6.5 cm·s−1; r: 1.00 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 1.1 + 6.0 cm·s−1; r: 0.94 | |||||
S/M Bent Over Row | 20%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 14.6 + 25.0 cm·s−1; r: 0.94 | |||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 0.1 + 12.0 cm·s−1; r: 0.96 | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 14.6 + 18.9 cm·s−1; r: 0.93 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 0.8 + 7.3 cm·s−1; r: 0.97 | |||||
40%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 13.6 + 12.0 cm·s−1; r: 0.97 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 0.4 + 11.6 cm·s−1; r: 0.91 | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 10.6 + 6.8 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: 0.6 + 4.9 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | |||||
60%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 7.3 + 18.2 cm·s−1; r: 0.92 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 0.3 + 6.0 cm·s−1; r: 0.97 | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 7.7 + 15.3 cm·s−1; r: 0.91 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 0.2 + 4.2 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | |||||
80%1RM | Peak velocity | LoA: 7.3 + 14.9 cm·s−1; r: 0.92 | ||||
Mean velocity | LoA: − 0.2 + 3.9 cm·s−1; r: 0.98 | |||||
Garnacho-Castano et al. [56] | Tendo | T-Force | S/M Back Squat | 40–60 kg, 85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.02 ± 0.07 m·s−1; ICC: 0.985 |
Peak velocity | Bias: − 0.08 ± 0.13 m·s−1; ICC: 0.963 | |||||
Mean power | Bias: 0.8 ± 44.31W; ICC: 0.966 | |||||
40–60 kg, 85%1RM | Peak power | Bias: − 209.99 ± 153.92W; ICC: 0.853 | ||||
Tendo | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.01 ± 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.989 | ||
Peak velocity | Bias: -0.06 ± 0.10 m·s−1; ICC: 0.963 | |||||
Mean power | Bias: 5.29 ± 38.48W; ICC: 0.968 | |||||
Peak power | Bias: − 105.13 ± 109.76W; ICC: 0.905 | |||||
Goldsmith et al. [53] | Tendo | OptoTrak | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | LoA (95% CI): − 0.006357 (− 0.06042 to 0.04771) m·s−1; ICC: 0.9364 |
Peak concentric velocity | LoA (95% CI): 0.07569 (− 0.05406 to 0.2054) m·s−1; ICC: 0.9362 | |||||
Open Barbell System | OptoTrak | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | LoA (95% CI): − 0.01163 (− 0.06855 to 0.04528) m·s−1; ICC: 0.8696 | |
Peak concentric velocity | LoA (95% CI): 0.03986 (− 0.1016 to 0.1813) m·s−1; ICC: 0.8351 | |||||
Gonzalez et al. [57] | Open Barbell System | Tendo | F/W Back Squat | Overall | Peak velocity | MD: 0.11 + 0.01 m·s−1 |
Mean velocity | MD: 0.01 + 0.01 m·s−1 | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.95; Bias: 0.163 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.27; Bias: 0.012 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.73; Bias: 0.125 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.35; Bias: 0.007 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.87; Bias: 0.086 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.03; Bias: 0.008 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.58; Bias: 0.053 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.25; Bias: 0.009 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Front Squat | Overall | Peak velocity | MD: 0.11 + 0.01 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | MD: 0.01 + 0.01 m·s−1 | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.86; Bias: 0.158 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.44; Bias: 0.010 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.76; Bias: 0.119 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: − 0.27; Bias: 0.012 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.84; Bias: 0.091 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.29; Bias: 0.013 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Peak velocity | r: 0.49; Bias: 0.055 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | r: 0.60; Bias: 0.007 m·s−1 | |||||
Lorenzetti et al. [54] | T-Force | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.070 m·s−1; MD: 0.062 m·s−1 |
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.151 m·s−1; MD: 0.199 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.026s; MD: 0.010s | |||||
F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.167 m·s−1; MD: 0.102 m·s−1 | |||
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.263 m·s−1; MD: 0.150 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.045s; MD: − 0.007s | |||||
Tendo | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.046 m·s−1; MD: 0.020 m·s−1 | |
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.194 m·s−1; MD: 0.159 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.041s; MD: 0.031s | |||||
F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.157 m·s−1; MD: − 0.083 m·s−1 | |||
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.315 m·s−1; MD: 0.217 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.064s; MD: 0.046s | |||||
GymAware | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.064 m·s−1; MD: 0.046 m·s−1 | |
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.163 m·s−1; MD: 0.128 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.042s; MD: 0.037s | |||||
F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.160 m·s−1; MD: − 0.091 m·s−1 | |||
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.304 m·s−1; MD: 0.187 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.046s; MD: 0.024s | |||||
Martinez-Cava et al. [51] | Speed4Lifts | T-Force | S/M Back Squat | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.60%; ICC: 0.997 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.09%; ICC: 0.995 r: 0.9936; SEE: 0.032 m·s−1 | |||||
S/M Bench Press | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 4.94%; ICC: 0.995 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 2.72%; ICC: 0.999 r: 0.9985; SEE: 0.024 m·s−1 | |||||
McGrath et al. [58] | Tendo Fitrodyne | 3D Motion Camera Eagle Motion Camera | F/W Bench Press | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.977 |
80%1RM | Mean velocity | |||||
Combined Load | Mean velocity | |||||
Mitter et al. [9] | GymAware | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.019 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.025 m·s−1 |
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.024 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.035 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.014 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.017 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.030 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.041 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Deadlift | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.017 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.021 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.029 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.029 m·s−1 | |||||
FitroDyne (Fitronic) | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.022 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.043 m·s−1 | |
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.073 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.104 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.019 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.022 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.100 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.162 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Deadlift | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.018 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.035 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.084 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.182 m·s−1 | |||||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | T-Force | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.01 ± 0.03 m·s−1 |
Chronojump | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.03 ± 0.03 m·s−1 | |
Speed4Lift | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.04 ± 0.02 m·s−1 | |
Thompson et al. [24] | GymAware | 12 Camera Raptor 3D Motion Capture | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.05 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | R2: 0.97; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.98; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.98; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.97; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.01 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.96; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.10 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.97; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.97; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
Power Clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.93; LoA: − 0.03 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | |||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.91; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.14 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: − 0.03 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.93; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.12 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: − 0.03 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.10 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.78; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.86; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.91; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.10 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.42; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.11 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.86; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.11 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.64; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.86; LoA: 0.08 ± 0.11 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.94; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.96; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.11 m·s−1 |
Study | Device | Criterion | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abbott et al. [59] | Bar Sensei | Vicon (Nexus 1.8.5) | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 |
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.11 m·s−1 | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.08 m·s−1 | |||||
40%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.07 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.10 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.09 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.14 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.07 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.17 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.19 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEE: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [62] | Push Band | T-Force | S/M Back Squat | 20–70 kg | Peak velocity | r: 0.91; SEE: 0.1 m·s−1; MD: − 0.07 ± 0.1 m·s−1 |
Mean velocity | r: 0.86; SEE: 0.08 m·s−1; MD: 0.11 ± 0.1 m·s−1 | |||||
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [69] | Beast Sensor (wrist) | SmartCoach Power Encoder | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.03 ± 0.06 m·s−1; SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 |
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.009 ± 0.04 m·s−1; SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||
F/W Hip-Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.06 ± 0.07 m·s−1; SEE: 0.07 m·s−1 | |||
Beast Sensor (barbell) | SmartCoach Power Encoder | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.003 ± 0.05 m·s−1; SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.04 ± 0.05 m·s−1; SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||
F/W Hip-Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.03 ± 0.05 m·s−1; SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||
Banyard et al. [8] | Push Band | 4 x Celesco PT5A-250 LPT & 1 x AMTI BP6001200 Force Plate | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.86; CV: 6.9%; ES: 0.24; SEE: 0.08 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | r: 0.80; CV: 8.1%; ES: 0.03; SEE: 0.16 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.91; CV: 6.1%; ES: 2.29; SEE: 63.9N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.98; CV: 4%; ES: 0.04; SEE: 79.75N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.89; CV: 9.6%; ES: 0.28; SEE: 122.22W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.87; CV: 11.9%; ES: − 0.29; SEE: 299.89W | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.80; CV: 8.2%; ES: 0.18; SEE: 0.08 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.76; CV: 9.6%; ES: − 0.16; SEE: 0.15 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.96; CV: 5%; ES: 1.41; SEE: 70.29Nr: 0.98; CV: 4.7%; ES: 0.04; SEE: 109.92N | |||||
Peak force | ||||||
Mean power | r: 0.82; CV: 10.9%; ES: − 0.35; SEE: 145.92W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.81; CV: 14.2%; ES: − 0.5; SEE: 364.36W | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.76; CV: 8.4%; ES: 0.49; SEE: 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.74; CV: 10%; ES: − 0.22; SEE: 0.13 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.96; CV: 5%; ES: 1.2; SEE: 87.53N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.97; CV: 5%; ES: 0.09; SEE: 117.37N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.79; CV: 13.1%; ES: − 0.36; SEE: 163.11W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.79; CV: 15.8%; ES: − 0.33; SEE: 383.25W | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.73; CV: 10.7%; ES: 0.54; SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.68; CV: 13.2%; ES: − 0.29; SEE: 0.14 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.97; CV: 4.9%; ES: 0.83; SEE: 102.78N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.98; CV: 4.2%; ES: 0.07; SEE: 103.68N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.78; CV: 14.2%; ES: − 0.09; SEE: 126.79W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.78; CV: 18.7%; ES: − 0.5; SEE: 402.16W | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.65; CV: 11.8%; ES: 0.69; SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.65; CV: 12.9%; ES: − 0.52; SEE: 0.12 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.98; CV: 3.4%; ES: 0.65; SEE: 77.28N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.97; CV: 4.9%; ES: 0.13; SEE: 135.34N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.67; CV: 22.7%; ES: 0.35; SEE: 163.23W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.81; CV: 17.1%; ES: − 0.41; SEE: 346.51W | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.33; CV: 27.2%; ES: 1.62; SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | r: 0.49; CV: 18.4%; ES: − 0.13; SEE: 0.13 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean force | r: 0.97; CV: 5%; ES: 0.52; SEE: 115.17N | |||||
Peak force | r: 0.92; CV: 8.3%; ES: 0.26; SEE: 213.05N | |||||
Mean power | r: 0.32; CV: 38.3%; ES: 1.23; SEE: 162.09W | |||||
Peak power | r: 0.66; CV: 18.7%; ES: − 0.18; SEE: 319.13W | |||||
Beckham et al. [28] | Bar Sensei | GymAware | F/W Back Squat | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.482; MD: − 0.106 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.555; MD: 0.009 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.303; MD: − 0.094 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.362; MD: − 0.037 m·s−1 | |||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.329; MD: − 0.081 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.361; MD: − 0.099 m·s−1 | |||||
Chery & Ruf [60] | PUSH Band | GymAware | F/W Deadlift | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 11.21%; MD: 0.05 m·s−1CV: 10.63%; MD: 0.12 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | ||||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 17.51%; MD: − 0.10 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 15.23%; MD:− 0.16 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.51%; MD: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 10.34%; MD: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 16.02%; MD: 0.13 m·s−1CV: 11.76%; MD: 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ||||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 14.23%; MD: 0.10 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 8.15%; MD: 0.12 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 35.00%; MD: 0.08 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 33.34%; MD: 0.13 m·s−1 | |||||
All Loads | Mean velocity | CV: 22.69%; MD: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | CV: 20.35%; MD: 0.07 m·s−1 | |||||
Comstock et al. [48] | Myotest | Ballistic Measurement System force plate and Celesco linear transducer | S/M Bench Press | 100% 1RM | Peak force | R2:0.92 |
S/M Bench Throw | 30% 1RM | Peak power | R2: 0.92 | |||
S/M Squat | 100% 1RM | Peak force | R2: 0.97 | |||
S/M Squat Jump | 30% 1RM | Peak power | R2: 0.82 | |||
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | Push Band | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 18.3%; ICC: 0.928 |
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.23 m·s−1; CV: 17.1%; ICC: 0.937 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 8.8%; ICC: 0.941 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 6.4%; ICC: 0.952 | |||||
Crewther et al. [50] | MyoTest | Force Plate | F/W Loaded squat jump | 20 kg | Peak force | r: 0.87; bias: 171 ± 336N |
Peak power | r: 0.66; bias: 141 ± 896W | |||||
40 kg | Peak force | r: 0.89; bias: 73 ± 256N | ||||
Peak power | r: 0.88; bias: − 180 ± 593W | |||||
60 kg | Peak force | r: 0.95; bias: 32 ± 196N | ||||
Peak power | r: 0.82; bias: − 112 ± 610W | |||||
80 kg | Peak force | r: 0.97; bias: 7 ± 219N | ||||
Peak power | r: 0.90; bias: 23 ± 400W | |||||
Garcia-Pinillos et al. [61] | WIMU System | T-Force | S/M Concentric-Only Half ROM Back Squat | 10–100%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.02 ± 0.06 m·s−1 |
Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: 0.06 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | Bias: 0.16 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | |||||
10%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.865 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.898 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.971 | |||||
20%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.520 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.398 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.773 | |||||
30%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.696 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.813 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.196 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.877 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.882 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.842 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.760 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.823 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.908 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.646 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.645 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.729 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.419 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.628 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.819 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.662 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.632 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.498 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.739 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.717 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.742 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.687 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | r: 0.685 | |||||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.861 | |||||
Hughes et al. [52] | PUSH Band 2.0 (body) | GymAware | F/W Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 |
F/W Bench Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 | ||||
F/W Bench Pull | Mean velocity | r: 0.98 | ||||
F/W OH Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 | ||||
S/M Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.97 | |||
S/M Bench Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 | ||||
S/M Bench Pull | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 | ||||
S/M OH Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 | ||||
PUSH Band 2.0 (bar) | GymAware | F/W Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.97 | |
F/W Bench Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.99 | ||||
F/W OH Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.96 | ||||
S/M Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.97 | |||
S/M Bench Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.98 | ||||
S/M OH Press | Mean velocity | r: 0.96 | ||||
Lake et al. [29] | PUSH Band 2.0 | Vicon T40S | F/W Bench Press | 60%1RM | Peak velocity | MD: − 0.039 m·s−1; LPR: 0.907 |
Mean velocity | MD: − 0.065 m·s−1; LPR: 0.797 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 90%1RM | Peak velocity | MD: − 0.063 m·s−1; LPR: 1.110 | |||
Mean velocity | MD: − 0.038 m·s−1; LPR: 0.816 | |||||
Lorenzetti et al. [54] | MyoTest | Vicon | F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.233 m·s−1; MD: 0.149 m·s−1 |
Maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.418 m·s−1; MD: 0.278 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to maximum velocity | RMSE: 0.054s; MD: − 0.034s | |||||
Garcia-Mateo [63] | RehaGait (bar)RehaGait (body) | MyLift via iPhone 6 iOS 9.3.2MyLift via iPhone 6 iOS 9.3.2 | F/W Squat with arms extended | <1 kg | Mean velocity | MD ± SD: 0.364 ± 0.069 m·s−1 |
F/W Squat with arms extended | <1 kg | Mean velocity | MD ± SD: 0.318 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | |||
McGrath et al. [58] | PUSH Band | 3D Motion Camera Eagle Motion Camera | F/W Bench Press | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | Mean ± SD: 0.746 ± 0.124 m·s−1; CV: 16.62% |
80%1RM | mean velocity | Mean ± SD: 0.322 ± 0.124 m·s−1; CV: 38.50% | ||||
Combined Load | Mean velocity | Mean ± SD: 0.510 ± 0.244 m·s−1; CV: 47.83%; ICC: 0.923 | ||||
Mitter et al. [9] | Beast Sensor | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.176 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.320 m·s−1SEE: 0.116 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.177 m·s−1 |
Mean velocity | ||||||
F/W Bench Press | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.113 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.134 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.084 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.098 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Deadlift | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.147 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.361 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.105 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.200 m·s−1 | |||||
PUSH Band | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.137 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.229 m·s−1 | |
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.078 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.147 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.113 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.121 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.065 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.101 m·s−1 | |||||
F/W Deadlift | 30–100%1RM | Peak velocity | SEE: 0.183 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.235 m·s−1 | |||
Mean velocity | SEE: 0.105 m·s−1; RMSE: 0.136 m·s−1 | |||||
Muyor et al [38] | WIMU | T-Force | S/M Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity (con) | ES: 0.34d; SEM: 0.003 m·s−1; ICC: 0.970 |
Mean velocity (ecc) | ES: 0.21d; SEM: 0.007 m·s−1; ICC: 0.971 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity (con) | ES: 0.25d; SEM: 0.003 m·s−1; ICC: 0.976 | ||||
Mean velocity (ecc) | ES: 0.44d; SEM: 0.005 m·s−1; ICC: 0.953 | |||||
Orange et al. [47] | PUSH Band PUSH Band | GymAware | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.61 m·s−1; r:0.80 |
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.53 m·s−1; r:0.80 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.51W; r:0.91 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 1.20W; r:0.90 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.17 m·s−1; r: 0.72 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.20 m·s−1; r:0.70 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 1.10W; r:0.77 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 1.01W; r:0.88 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.41 m·s−1; r: 0.78 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.58 m·s−1; r:0.68 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 1.73W; r:0.76 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 1.39W; r:0.77 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 2.23 m·s−1; r: 0.79 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 2.23 m·s−1; r:0.84 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 2.24W; r:0.76 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 1.43W; r:0.85 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 2.61 m·s−1; r:0.66 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 2.74 m·s−1; r:0.41 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 2.08W; r:0.67 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 1.59W; r:0.59 | |||||
GymAware | F/W Bench Press | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.06 m·s−1; r: 0.30 | ||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.55 m·s−1; r:0.44 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.35W; r:0.50 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.74W; r:0.66 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.68 m·s−1; r: 0.85 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.37 m·s−1; r:0.73 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.31W; r:0.88 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.73W; r:0.59 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.55 m·s−1; r: 0.59 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.18 m·s−1; r:0.52 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.00W; r:0.68 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.70W; r:0.62 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.03 m·s−1; r: 0.73 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.00 m·s−1; r: 0.50 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.64W; r:0.76 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.88W; r:0.46 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 1.12 m·s−1; r: 0.44 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.10 m·s−1; r: 0.45 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.60W; r:0.48 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.48W; r:0.49 | |||||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | PUSH Band | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.10 ± 0.06 m·s−1 |
Beast sensor | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.05 ± 0.21 m·s−1 | |
Pino-Ortega et al. [66] | WIMU | GymAware | Leg Extension Machine | 30–90 kg | Mean linear velocity | R2:0.9995; Bias: 0.011 ± 0.006 m·s−1; LoA: − 0.024 to 0.01 m·s−1 |
Sato et al. [37] | PUSH Band | Vicon (Nexus 1.8.5) | DB Biceps Curl | 4.54–6.82 kg | Mean velocity | TE: 0.060 m·s−1; RTE: 7.2%; r: 0.883 |
Peak velocity | TE: 0.105 m·s−1; RTE: 6.5%; r: 0.923 | |||||
DB Shoulder Press | 4.54–6.82 kg | Mean velocity | TE: 0.090 m·s−1; RTE: 12.6%; r: 0.864 | |||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.163 m·s−1; RTE: 14.0%; r: 0.801 | |||||
Thompson et al. [24] | PUSH Band (body) PUSH Band (bar) Bar Sensei Beast Sensor | 12 Camera raptor 3D motion capture | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.92; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.06 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | R2: 0.94; LoA: 0.09 ± 0.10 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.96; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.76; LoA: 0.09 ± 0.22 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.45; LoA: 0.12 ± 0.33 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.88; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.60; LoA: 0.11 ± 0.29 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.92; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.37; LoA: 0.13 ± 0.44 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.79; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.10 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.53; LoA: 0.15 ± 0.30 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.58; LoA: − 0.07 ± 0.10 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.48; LoA: 0.12 ± 0.35 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.97; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.09 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.80; LoA: 0.12 ± 0.30 m·s−1 | |||||
Power clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.38; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.24 m·s−1 | |||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.27; LoA: 0.61 ± 0.40 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.50; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.23 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.43; LoA: 0.60 ± 0.38 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.50; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.24; LoA: 0.56 ± 0.42 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.66; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.43; LoA: 0.59 ± 0.32 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.54; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.22 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.27; LoA: 0.58 ± 0.36 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.61; LoA: 0.10 ± 0.19 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.60; LoA: 0.62 ± 0.24 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.34; LoA: 0.09 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.66; LoA: 0.59 ± 0.17 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.72; LoA: 0.08 ± 0.19 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.65; LoA: 0.59 ± 0.32 m·s−1 | |||||
12 Camera raptor 3D motion capture | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.69; LoA: − 0.08 ± 0.09 m·s−1 | ||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.91; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.14 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: − 0.06 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.89; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.14 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.83; LoA: − 0.07 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.84; LoA: 0.06 ± 0.17 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.84; LoA: − 0.07 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.80; LoA: 0.09 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.87; LoA: − 0.07 ± 0.09 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.60; LoA: 0.08 ± 0.28 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.92; LoA: − 0.07 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.56; LoA: 0.08 ± 0.29 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.39; LoA: 0.10 ± 0.13 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.41; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.36 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.97; LoA: − 0.07 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.86; LoA: 0.06 ± 0.23 m·s−1 | |||||
Power clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.62; LoA: 0.22 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | |||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.59; LoA: 0.35 ± 0.43 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.54; LoA: 0.22 ± 0.22 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.11; LoA: 0.36 ± 0.62 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.50; LoA: 0.22 ± 0.15 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.68; LoA: 0.35 ± 0.26 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.24; LoA: 0.16 ± 0.26 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.08; LoA: 0.31 ± 0.74 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.35; LoA: 0.14 ± 0.22 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.06; LoA: 0.30 ± 0.64 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.41; LoA: 0.19 ± 0.15 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.26; LoA: 0.46 ± 0.35 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.23; LoA: 0.14 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.60; LoA: 0.35 ± 0.23 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.62; LoA: 0.18 ± 0.20 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.48; LoA: 0.35 ± 0.49 m·s−1 | |||||
12 Camera raptor 3D motion capture | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.82; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.12 m·s−1 | ||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.96; LoA: 0.03 ± 0.12 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.75; LoA: 0.05 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.93; LoA: 0.07 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | |||||
Power clean | 60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.67; LoA: 0.04 ± 0.12 m·s−1 | |||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.82; LoA: 0.12 ± 0.17 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.86; LoA: 0.04 ± 0.08 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.66; LoA: 0.19 ± 0.25 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.66; LoA: 0.05 ± 0.11 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.52; LoA: 0.31 ± 0.33 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.23; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.21 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.10; LoA: 0.31 ± 0.33 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.01; LoA: − 0.05 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.02; LoA: 0.24 ± 0.49 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.87; LoA: 0.03 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.80; LoA: 0.18 ± 0.37 m·s−1 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.82; LoA: − 0.13 ± 0.14 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.47; LoA: − 0.36 ± 0.38 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.82; LoA: − 0.08 ± 0.15 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.22; LoA: − 0.25 ± 0.49 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.73; LoA: − 0.10 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.61; LoA: − 0.20 ± 0.35 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.04; LoA: − 0.02 ± 0.34 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.50; LoA: − 0.15 ± 0.38 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.07; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.27 m·s−1 | ||||
peak velocity | R2: 0.69; LoA: − 0.12 ± 0.27 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.18; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.22 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.84; LoA: − 0.04 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.02; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.27 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.57; LoA: − 0.05 ± 0.27 m·s−1 | |||||
Mean velocity | R2: 0.73; LoA: − 0.04 ± 0.25 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Peak velocity | R2: 0.74; LoA: − 0.17 ± 0.39 m·s−1 | ||||
12 Camera raptor 3D motion capture | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.64; LoA: − 0.01 ± 0.16 m·s−1 | ||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.10; LoA: − 0.05 ± 0.50 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.71; LoA: 0.04 ± 0.13 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.12; LoA: − 0.04 ± 0.43 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.49; LoA: 0.08 ± 0.21 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.00; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.53 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.46; LoA: 0.11 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.00; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.56 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.58; LoA: 0.16 ± 0.18 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.02; LoA: 0.04 ± 0.44 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.12; LoA: 0.10 ± 0.22 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.58; LoA: 0.22 ± 0.28 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.20; LoA: − 0.09 ± 0.26 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.15; LoA: 0.25 ± 0.52 m·s−1 | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.80; LoA: 0.06 ± 0.24 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | R2: 0.57; LoA: 0.06 ± 0.51 m·s−1 | |||||
van den Tillaar and Ball [11] | PUSH Band | ET-Enc-02 Ergotest linear encoder | F/W Bench Press | 50%1RM, + 10 to 30 kg | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.11 m·s−1; SEE: 0.17 m·s−1; r:0.62 |
Mean peak velocity | Bias: 0.22 m·s−1; SEE: 0.33 m·s−1; r:0.49 | |||||
Push-Up | Body Weight, 10–30 kg Weight vests | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.12 m·s−1; SEE: 0.16 m·s−1; r: 0.70 | |||
Mean peak velocity | Bias: 0.15 m·s−1; SEE: 0.34 m·s−1; r: 0.46 |
Study | Device | Criterion | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [69] | PowerLift (v4.0 iOS) | SmartCoach Power Encoder | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.005 ± 0.04 m·s−1 |
SEE: 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||||
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.01 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | |||
SEE: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||||
F/W Hip-Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.02 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | |||
SEE: 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||||
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [70] | PowerLift (v2.8 iOS) | SmartCoach Power Encoder | F/W Bench Press | 75–100%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.94; SEE: 0.028 m·s−1; ICC: 0.965 |
MD: 0.008± 0.03 m·s−1 | ||||||
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | PowerLift (v4.0 iOS) | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 11.7%; ICC: 0.966 |
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 7.6%; ICC: 0.955 | |||
de Sá et al. [80] | iLoad App (v 1.0) | Chronojump | S/M Half ROM Back Squat | 10RM | Mean velocity | Bias ± random error: − 0.022 ± 0.034 m·s−1 |
ES: − 0.21 (− 0.39, − 0.04); r: 0.948 | ||||||
10RM | Total work | Bias ± random error: 0.706 ± 3.391 kJ | ||||
ES: 0.04 (− 0.07, 0.16); r: 0.977 | ||||||
Martinez-Cava et al. [51] | My Lift (v8.1 iOS) | T-Force | S/M Back Squat | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 7.59%; ICC: 0.937 |
S/M Bench Press | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 7.04%; ICC: 0.991 | |||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | PowerLift (v.6.0.1 iOS) | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.01 ± 0.05 m·s−1 |
Sanchez-Pay et al. [23] | Kinovea (v0.8.15) via | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | All loads | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.10 ± 0.06 m·s−1; r: 0.997 |
Samsung S6 | Distance | Bias: 1.07 ± 0.65 cm; r: 0.996 | ||||
Time | Bias: − 61.6 ± 36.1 ms; r: 0.998 | |||||
High Loads (MV < 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.06 ± 0.05 m·s−1; r: 0.986 | ||||
Distance | Bias: − 0.95 ± 0.69 cm; r: 0.992 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 76.6 ± 41.3 ms; r: 0.997 | |||||
Low Loads (MV > 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.14 ± 0.06 m·s−1; r: 0.985 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 1.21 ± 0.59 cm; r: 0.996 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 44.2 ± 17.2 ms; r: 0.978 | |||||
Kinovea (v0.8.15) via | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | All Loads | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.09 ± 0.06 m·s−1; r: 0.996 | |
Xiaomi A1 | Distance | Bias: 1.24 ± 0.45 cm; r: 0.998 | ||||
Time | Bias: − 57.4 ± 33.4 ms; r: 0.998 | |||||
High Loads (MV < 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.06 ± 0.03 m·s−1; r: 0.994 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 1.21 ± 0.47 cm; r: 0.995 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 74.3 ± 34.5 ms; r: 0.998 | |||||
Low Loads (MV > 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.13 ± 0.06 m·s−1; r: 0.981 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 1.38 ± 0.39 cm; r: 0.997 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 37.6 ± 18.0 ms; r: 0.975 | |||||
Kinovea (v0.8.15) via iPhone X | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | All Loads | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.11 ± 0.08 m·s−1; r: 0.994 | |
Distance | Bias: 1.34 ± 0.75 cm; r: 0.993 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 69.5 ± 34.8 ms; r: 0.998 | |||||
High Loads (MV < 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.07 ± 0.04 m·s−1; r: 0.995 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 1.29 ± 0.81 cm; r: 0.986 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 85.6 ± 41.3 ms; r: 0.998 | |||||
Low Loads (MV > 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.17 ± 0.09 m·s−1; r: 0.977 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 1.40 ± 0.68 cm; r: 0.993 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 50.4 ± 22.0 ms; r: 0.961 | |||||
Kinovea (v0.8.15) via Casio FH20 | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | All Loads | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.14 ± 0.09 m·s−1; r: 0.992 | |
Distance | Bias: 2.48 ± 0.87 cm; r: 0.990 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 69.5 ± 40.7 ms; r: 0.997 | |||||
High Loads (MV < 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.08 ± 0.05 m·s−1; r: 0.990 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 2.36 ± 0.91 cm; r: 0.984 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 83.4 ± 44.3 ms; r: 0.996 | |||||
Low Loads (MV > 0.80 m·s−1) | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.20 ± 0.09 m·s−1; r: 0.963 | ||||
Distance | Bias: 2.62 ± 0.81 cm; r: 0.989 | |||||
Time | Bias: − 53.2 ± 28.9 ms; r: 0.932 | |||||
Sanudo et al. [81] | Kinovea (v0.8.15) via Digital Video Camera (50Hz) | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | 20 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.43 m·s−1 |
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.57 m·s−1 | |||||
30 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.41 m·s−1 | ||||
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.59 m·s−1 | |||||
40 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.30 m·s−1 | ||||
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.42 m·s−1 | |||||
50 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.23 m·s−1 | ||||
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.36 m·s−1 | |||||
60 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.28 m·s−1 | |||||
70 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.14 m·s−1 | ||||
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.28 m·s−1 | |||||
80 kg | Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: − 0.16 m·s−1 | ||||
Maximal velocity | Bias: − 0.23 m·s−1 | |||||
Thompson et al. [24] | MyLift (PowerLift at the time of data collection) | 12 Camera raptor 3D motion capture | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.96; LoA: 0.02 ± 0.06 m·s−1 |
50%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.94; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.88; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.95; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.93; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.92; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.04 m·s−1 | ||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | R2: 0.85; LoA: 0.00 ± 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Full | Mean velocity | R2: 0.99; LoA: 0.01 ± 0.05 m·s−1 |
Study | Device | Criterion | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | Velowin | T-Force | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 3.1%; ICC: 0.998 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.5%; ICC: 0.997 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.7%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 4.4%; ICC: 0.992 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.6%; ICC: 0.992 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 2.3%; ICC: 0.993 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 8.1%; ICC: 0.967 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.25 m·s−1; CV: 8.1%; ICC: 0.967 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 1.9%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
Garcia-Ramos et al. [71] | Velowin | T-Force | F/W Back Squat | 20–70 kg | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.02 ± 0.05 m·s−1; SEE: 0.040 m·s−1 |
Mean propulsive velocity | Bias: 0.02 ± 0.06 m·s−1; SEE: 0.055 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | Bias: − 0.09 ± 0.06 m·s−1; SEE: 0.057 m·s−1 | |||||
Laza-Cagigas et al. [68] | Velowin | Oqus Infrared cameras and kistler multicomponent force platform | F/W Back Squat | < 30–90%1RM | Displacement | RMSE: 3.73 cm; CV: 6.6%; ICC: 0.84 |
Mean velocity | RMSE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 7.3%; ICC: 0.97 | |||||
Peak velocity | RMSE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 6.5%; ICC: 0.96 | |||||
Mean force | RMSE: 43N; CV: 3.6%; ICC: 0.99 | |||||
Peak force | RMSE: 100N; CV: 5.2%; ICC: 0.98 | |||||
Mean power | RMSE: 73W; CV: 8.2%; ICC: 0.92 | |||||
Peak power | RMSE: 160W; CV: 8.3%; ICC: 0.85 | |||||
Peña Garcia-Orea et al. [82] | Velowin | T-Force | S/M Squat | 20–70 kg | Mean velocity | No significant differences were found between the variances of the two devices |
Mean propulsive velocity | ||||||
Peak velocity | ||||||
Peña Garcia-Orea et al. [72] | Velowin | T-Force | Loaded CMJ | 3.5–43.5 kg | Mean velocity | No significant differences were found between the variances of the two devices |
Peak velocity | ||||||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | Velowin | OptiTrack | S/M Bench Press | 55–85%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.05 ± 0.03 m·s−1 |
Weakley et al. [22] | FLEX | Vicon | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.01 m·s−1; TEE: 0.06 ± 0.02 m·s−1; r: 0.97 ± 0.03 |
40%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.02 ± 0.008 m·s−1; r: 0.99 ± 0.01 | ||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.02 ± 0.008 m·s−1; r: 0.97 ± 0.03 | ||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.02 ± 0.004 m·s−1; r: 0.95 ± 0.05 | ||||
≥ 90%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.02 ± 0.004 m·s−1; r: 0.99 ± 0.01 | ||||
Overall | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.03 ± 0.004 m·s−1; r: 0.99 ± 0.00 | ||||
F/W Bench Press | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.01 ± 0.03 m·s−1; TEE: 0.08 ± 0.04 m·s−1; r: 0.97 ± 0.04 | |||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.02 ± 0.06 m·s−1; TEE: 0.04 ± 0.02 m·s−1; r: 0.99 ± 0.02 | ||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.01 m·s−1; TEE: 0.02 ± 0.04 m·s−1; r: 0.98 ± 0.02 | ||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.01 ± 0.005 m·s−1; r: 0.99 ± 0.01 | ||||
≥ 90%1RM | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.00 ± 0.00 m·s−1; TEE: 0.02 ± 0.005 m·s−1; r: 0.98 ± 0.01 | ||||
Overall | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.01 ± 0.01 m·s−1; TEE: 0.04 ± 0.005 m·s−1; r: 0.99 ± 0.00 |
Study | Device | Reliability | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable Measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [62] | T-Force | Intra-device | S/M Back Squat | 20–70 kg | Peak velocity | CV: 4.2 ± 2.5%; ICC: 0.988; r: 0.975 |
Mean velocity | CV: 3.9 ± 2.4%; ICC: 0.989; r: 0.989 | |||||
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [69] | SmartCoach | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.981 |
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.981 | |||
F/W Hip Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.966 | |||
Beckham et al. [28] | GymAware | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.774 |
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.793 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.752 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.775 | |||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.651 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.761 | |||||
Boehringer and Whyte [77] | 1080Q | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 30–80%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.004 m·s−1; CV:7.0%; ICC: 0.97 |
30%1RM | MD: − 0.003 m·s−1; CV: 4.5%; ICC: 0.64 | |||||
40%1RM | MD: 0.001 m·s−1; CV: 3.7; ICC: 0.82 | |||||
50%1RM | MD: 0.010 m·s−1; CV: 5.7 ICC: 0.53 | |||||
60%1RM | MD: 0.017 m·s−1; CV: 6.5 ICC: 0.45 | |||||
70%1RM | MD: 0.000 m·s−1; CV: 7.6 ICC: 0.63 | |||||
80%1RM | MD: − 0.003 m·s−1; CV: 11.0 ICC: 0.69 | |||||
30–80%1RM | Mean force | MD: − 0.3N; CV: 1.7%; ICC: 1.00 | ||||
30%1RM | MD: − 4.1N; CV: 2.0%; ICC: 0.93 | |||||
40%1RM | MD: − 0.9N; CV: 1.9%; ICC: 0.98 | |||||
50%1RM | MD: 3.4N; CV: 2.3%; ICC: 0.96 | |||||
60%1RM | MD: 3.2N; CV: 1.7%; ICC: 0.98 | |||||
70%1RM | MD: − 4.8N; CV: 1.1%; ICC: 0.99 | |||||
80%1RM | MD: − 0.9N; CV: 0.9%; ICC: 0.99 | |||||
30–80%1RM | Mean power | MD: 3.4W; CV: 8.0%; ICC: 0.90 | ||||
30%1RM | MD: − 4.1W; CV: 6.7%; ICC: 0.73 | |||||
40%1RM | MD: − 1.6W; CV: 5.1%; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
50%1RM | MD: 8.1W; CV: 7.3%; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
60%1RM | MD: 14.8W; CV: 7.6%; ICC: 0.74 | |||||
70%1RM | MD: − 0.4W; CV: 8.3%; ICC: 0.73 | |||||
80%1RM | MD: − 1.1W; CV: 11.4%; ICC: 0.65 | |||||
30–80%1RM | Peak velocity | MD: 0.002 m·s−1; CV: 6.3%; ICC: 0.97 | ||||
30%1RM | MD: 0.002 m·s−1; CV: 4.1%; ICC: 0.61 | |||||
40%1RM | MD: 0.001 m·s−1; CV: 3.6%; ICC: 0.84 | |||||
50%1RM | MD: 0.008 m·s−1; CV: 5.0%; ICC: 0.68 | |||||
60%1RM | MD: 0.000 m·s−1; CV: 5.0%; ICC: 0.75 | |||||
70%1RM | MD: 0.004 m·s−1; CV: 8.2%; ICC: 0.58 | |||||
80%1RM | MD: − 0.001 m·s−1; CV: 9.5%; ICC: 0.80 | |||||
30–80%1RM | Peak force | MD: − 2.6N; CV: 4.4%; ICC: 0.94 | ||||
30%1RM | MD: − 20.9N; CV: 7.0%; ICC: 0.51 | |||||
40%1RM | MD: − 4.9N; CV: 3.5%; ICC: 0.90 | |||||
50%1RM | MD: 7.4N; CV: 4.9%; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
60%1RM | MD: 1.3N; CV: 4.2%; ICC: 0.80 | |||||
70%1RM | MD: 0.4N; CV: 4.3%; ICC: 0.78 | |||||
80%1RM | MD: − 9.4N; CV: 3.7%; ICC: 0.87 | |||||
30–80%1RM | Peak power | MD: 2.0W; CV: 7.4%; ICC: 0.91 | ||||
30%1RM | MD: 2.4W; CV: 6.1%; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
40%1RM | MD: − 2.2W; CV: 5.1%; ICC: 0.92 | |||||
50%1RM | MD: 6.9W; CV: 7.0%; ICC: 0.85 | |||||
60%1RM | MD: 1.3W; CV: 6.1%; ICC: 0.88 | |||||
70%1RM | MD: 1.6W; CV: 8.9%; ICC: 0.77 | |||||
80%1RM | MD: 2.5W; CV: 10.2%; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | T-Force | Inter-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 1.4%; ICC: 1.000 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 1.3%; ICC: 1.000 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.6%; ICC: 1.000 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 1.0%; ICC: 0.999 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 1.1%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.8%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 2.1%; ICC: 0.998 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.9%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.8%; ICC: 1.000 | |||||
Chronojump | Inter-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.7%; ICC: 0.995 | |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 5.2%; ICC: 0.995 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.4%; ICC: 1.000 | |||||
20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.6%; ICC: 0.991 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.9%; ICC: 0.991 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 1.8%; ICC: 0.996 | ||||
20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.3%; ICC: 0.995 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.4%; ICC: 0.995 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 2.4%; ICC: 1.00 | ||||
T-Force | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.9%; ICC: 0.999 | |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.8%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 2.0%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 2.5%; ICC: 0.995 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 2.6%; ICC: 0.996 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 2.9%; ICC: 0.989 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.0%; ICC: 0.995 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.0%; ICC: 0.995 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 1.8%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
Chronojump | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.3%; ICC: 0.997 | |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.2%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 2.4%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.9%; ICC: 0.990 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.8%; ICC: 0.991 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 3.4%; ICC: 0.985 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 5.2%; ICC: 0.990 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 5.4%; ICC: 0.987 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 2.3%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
Dorrell et al. [26] | GymAware | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 80%1RM | Bar displacement | Mean TE: 3.8% (3.0–5.3%) |
Peak velocity | Mean TE: 8.1% (6.4–11.5%) | |||||
Mean velocity | Mean TE: 7.0% (5.6–10.0%) | |||||
Peak force | Mean TE: 4.3% (3.4–6.1%) | |||||
Mean force | Mean TE: 0.6% (0.5–0.9%) | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 80%1RM | Bar displacement | Mean TE: 3.0% (2.3–4.1) | |||
Peak velocity | Mean TE: 6.2% (4.9–8.7) | |||||
Mean velocity | Mean TE: 7.4% (5.8–10.5%) | |||||
F/W Deadlift | 80%1RM | Bar displacement | Mean TE: 2.0% (1.6–2.7%) | |||
Peak velocity | Mean TE: 8.8% (7.0–12.5%) | |||||
Mean velocity | Mean TE: 7.0% (5.5–9.8%) | |||||
Peak force | Mean TE: 3.1% (2.5–4.4%) | |||||
Mean force | Mean TE: 1.6% (1.3–2.2%) | |||||
Fernandes et al. [55] | FitroDyne (fitronic) | Intra-device (intra-day) | S/M Bench Press | 20%1RM | Peak power | TE: 18.3W; CV: 4.3% |
Mean power | TE: 8.2W; CV: 3.4% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 6.9 cm·s−1; CV: 3.3% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 3.4 cm·s−1; CV: 2.9% | |||||
30%1RM | Peak power | TE: 11.3W; CV: 2.1% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 8.4W; CV: 2.6% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 3.1 cm·s−1; CV: 1.7% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 2.9 cm·s−1; CV: 2.7% | |||||
40%1RM | Peak power | TE: 10.1W; CV: 1.6% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 11.0W; CV: 2.9% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 2.8 cm·s−1; CV: 1.8% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 2.9 cm·s−1; CV: 3.1% | |||||
50%1RM | Peak power | TE: 16.9W; CV: 2.6% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 10.7W; CV: 2.7% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 3.6 cm·s−1; CV: 2.8% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 2.2 cm·s−1; CV: 2.8% | |||||
60%1RM | Peak power | TE: 23.8W; CV: 4.0% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 17.7W; CV: 4.6% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 3.8 cm·s−1; CV: 3.9% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 2.8 cm·s−1; CV: 4.4% | |||||
70%1RM | Peak power | TE: 18.6W; CV: 3.4% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 16.4W; CV: 4.8% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 2.6 cm·s−1; CV: 3.3% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 2.2 cm·s−1; CV: 4.5% | |||||
80%1RM | Peak power | TE: 53.0W; CV: 12.2% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 44.2W; CV: 17.1% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 5.3 cm·s−1; CV: 9.7% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 4.3 cm·s−1; CV: 13.4% | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20%1RM | Peak power | TE: 21.8W; CV:4.9 % | |||
Mean power | TE: 13.3W; CV: 5.3% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 7.0 cm·s−1; CV: 4.1% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 3.9 cm·s−1; CV: 4.0% | |||||
30%1RM | Peak power | TE: 34.6W; CV: 5.4% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 19.9W; CV: 5.6% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 7.4 cm·s−1; CV: 4.5% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 4.2 cm·s−1; CV: 4.6% | |||||
40%1RM | Peak power | TE: 35.2W; CV: 4.3% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 28.2W; CV: 6.4% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 6.1 cm·s−1; CV: 4.0% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 4.8 cm·s−1; CV: 5.7% | |||||
50%1RM | Peak power | TE: 22.8W; CV: 2.4% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 14.2W; CV: 2.9% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 3.9 cm·s−1; CV: 2.7% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 2.4 cm·s−1; CV: 3.2% | |||||
60%1RM | Peak power | TE: 36.7W; CV: 3.5% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 22.3W; CV: 4.1% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 4.5 cm·s−1; CV: 3.3% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 3.0 cm·s−1; CV: 4.3% | |||||
70%1RM | Peak power | TE: 55.6W; CV: 4.9% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 29.6W; CV: 5.4% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 6.4 cm·s−1; CV: 5.2% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 3.8 cm·s−1; CV: 6.3% | |||||
80%1RM | Peak power | TE: 46.7W; CV: 3.9% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 28.4W; CV: 5.5% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 5.1 cm·s−1; CV: 4.4% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 3.1 cm·s−1; CV: 6.4% | |||||
S/M Bent Over Row | 20%1RM | Peak power | TE: 18.9W; CV: 5.1% | |||
Mean power | TE: 14.5W; CV: 6.6% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 8.8 cm·s−1; CV: 4.4% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 6.6 cm·s−1; CV: 5.6% | |||||
30%1RM | Peak power | TE: 20.0W; CV: 3.8% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 23.0W; CV: 7.4% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 7.1 cm·s−1; CV: 3.8% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 8.7 cm·s−1; CV: 7.9% | |||||
40%1RM | Peak power | TE: 21.6W; CV: 3.5% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 16.3W; CV: 4.3% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 6.1 cm·s−1; CV: 3.7% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 4.8 cm·s−1; CV: 4.7% | |||||
50%1RM | Peak power | TE: 20.8W; CV: 2.9% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 26.7W; CV: 6.1% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 4.0 cm·s−1; CV: 2.6% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 6.0 cm·s−1; CV: 6.4% | |||||
60%1RM | Peak power | TE: 33.0W; CV: 4.1% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 33.0W; CV: 6.9% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 5.7 cm·s−1; CV: 4.0% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 6.4 cm·s−1; CV: 7.5% | |||||
70%1RM | Peak power | TE: 62.8W; CV: 7.8% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 40.0W; CV: 8.2% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 10.5 cm·s−1; CV: 8.5% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 6.7 cm·s−1; CV: 9.0% | |||||
80%1RM | Peak power | TE: 61.1W; CV: 7.7% | ||||
Mean power | TE: 37.3W; CV: 7.8% | |||||
Peak velocity | TE: 8.8 cm·s−1; CV: 8.3% | |||||
Mean velocity | TE: 5.4 cm·s−1; CV: 8.5% | |||||
Garcia-Pinillos et al. [61] | T-Force | Intra-device | S/M Concentric-Only Half Back Squat | 10%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 8.60%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 |
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 11.28%; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 9.18%; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
20%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 6.76%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 8.29%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 8.17%; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
30%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 11.86%; SEM: 0.11 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 14.39%; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 7.42%; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.95%; SEM: 0.09 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 10.87%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 6.64%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.06%; SEM: 0.07 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 11.21%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 6.49%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.27%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 13.81%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 9.91%; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.50%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 12.27%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 8.68%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.09%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 9.07%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 5.67%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 11.02%; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 11.00%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 7.73%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 16.77%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 17.26%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 9.79%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Garcia-Ramos et al. [71] | T-Force | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 20 kg Load | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.052 m·s−1; CV: 4.65%; ICC: 0.90 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.059 m·s−1; CV: 4.87%; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.075 m·s−1; CV: 4.17%; ICC: 0.93 | |||||
40 kg Load | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.040 m·s−1; CV: 4.19%; ICC: 0.93 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.046 m·s−1; CV: 4.46%; ICC: 0.92 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.058 m·s−1; CV: 3.59%; ICC: 0.95 | |||||
50 kg Load | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.038 m·s−1; CV: 4.25%; ICC: 0.90 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.047 m·s−1; CV: 4.83%; ICC: 0.87 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.044 m·s−1; CV: 2.84%; ICC: 0.95 | |||||
60 kg Load | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.031 m·s−1; CV: 3.75%; ICC: 0.94 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.033 m·s−1; CV: 3.73%; ICC: 0.95 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.049 m·s−1; CV: 3.35%; ICC: 0.94 | |||||
70 kg Load | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.036 m·s−1; CV: 4.84%; ICC: 0.92 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.036 m·s−1; CV: 4.49%; ICC: 0.93 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.047 m·s−1; CV: 3.45%; ICC: 0.95 | |||||
Garnacho-Castano et al. [56] | Tendo | Intra-device | S/M Back Squat | 40–60 kg, | Mean velocity | Bias: − 0.02 ± 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 8.5% |
Peak velocity | Bias: − 0.05 ± 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 9.6% | |||||
+ 85%1RM | Mean power | Bias: − 5.45 ± 39.75W; CV: 10.9% | ||||
Peak power | Bias: − 19.99 ± 85.78W; CV: 13.0% | |||||
Tendo | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 40–60 kg, | Mean velocity | Bias: 0.001 ± 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 9.6% | |
Peak velocity | Bias: − 0.004 ± 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 9.0% | |||||
+ 85%1RM | Mean power | Bias: − 3.53 ± 27.87W; CV: 10.7% | ||||
Peak power | Bias: − 18.40 ± 49.35W; CV: 13.2% | |||||
30%, 60%, 90%1RM | ||||||
Hughes et al. [52] | GymAware | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.86, 0.78, 0.76; CV: 1.5%, 4.7%, 5.1% |
F/W Bench Press | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.97, 0.80, 0.85; CV: 0.6%, 2.0%, 2.4% | ||||
F/W Prone Bench Pull | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.90, 0.92, 0.85; CV: 1.2%, 1.0%, 2.3% | ||||
F/W OHP | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.88, 0.83, 0.85; CV: 1.2%, 2.4%, 2.5% | ||||
S/M Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.97, 0.80, 0.97; CV: 1.0%, 3.3%, 2.8% | |||
S/M Bench Press | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.98, 0.94, 0.93; CV: 0.4%, 1.4%, 1.7% | ||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.89, 0.98, 0.88; CV: 0.7%, 1.0%, 0.8% | ||||
S/M OHP | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.82, 0.86, 0.91; CV: 2.2%, 4.6%, 2.3% | ||||
Jennings et al. [79] | FitroDyne (fitronic) | Intra-device | F/W Biceps curls | 0–90%1RM | Maximum power | Limits of Agreement: 0.11 ± 13.60W; ICC: 0.97 |
F/W Squat Jump | 0–90%1RM | Maximum power | Limits of Agreement: − 17 ± 96W; ICC: 0.97 | |||
Lorenzetti et al. [54] | T-Force (v2.3) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.970; RMSE: 0.070 m·s−1 |
Maximum velocity | r: 0.933; RMSE: 0.151 m·s−1 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.985; RMSE: 0.026s | |||||
F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | r: 0.724; RMSE: 0.167 m·s−1 | |||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.810; RMSE: 0.263 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.655; RMSE: 0.045s | |||||
Tendo (v4.1.0) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.963; RMSE: 0.046 m·s−1 | |
Maximum velocity | r: 0.932; RMSE: 0.194 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.985; RMSE: 0.041s | |||||
F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | r: 0.770; RMSE: 0.157 m·s−1 | |||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.860; RMSE: 0.135 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.604; RMSE: 0.064s | |||||
GymAware (v1.1.2) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 70%1RM | Mean velocity | r: 0.958; RMSE: 0.064 m·s−1 | |
Maximum velocity | r: 0.957; RMSE: 0.163 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.990; RMSE: 0.042s | |||||
F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | r: 0.783; RMSE: 0.160 m·s−1 | |||
Maximum velocity | r: 0.852; RMSE: 0.304 m·s−1 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.701; RMSE: 0.046s | |||||
Martinez-Cava et al. 51] | T-Force | Inter-device | S/M Back Squat | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.46%; ICC: 1.000; r: 0.9997 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.58%; ICC: 1.000; r: 0.9998 | |||||
Mean velocity | SEM: <0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.44%; ICC: 1.000; r: 0.9998 | |||||
S/M Bench Press | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.45%; ICC: 1.000; r: 0.9998 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.62%; ICC: 1.000; r: 0.9999 | |||||
Mean velocity | SEM: <0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.55%; ICC: 1.000; r: 0.9999 | |||||
Speed4Lifts | Inter-device | S/M Back Squat | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 0.86%; ICC: 0.999 | |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.01 m·s−1; CV: 1.24%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
S/M Bench Press | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.54%; ICC: 1.000 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 1.80%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
Muyor et al [38] | Tendo | Intra-device | S/M Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity (con) | ES: 0.08; SEM: 0.007 m·s−1; CV: 2.00%; ICC: 0.979 |
Mean velocity (ecc) | ES: 0.15; SEM: 0.009 m·s−1; CV: 3.65%; ICC: 0.970 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity (con) | ES: 0.24; SEM: 0.013 m·s−1; CV: 4.28%; ICC: 0.855 | ||||
Mean velocity (ecc) | ES: 0.10; SEM: 0.011 m·s−1; CV: 4.55%; ICC: 0.924 | |||||
Orange et al. [48] | GymAware | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.21; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; ICC: 0.72 |
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.08; SEM: 0.09 m·s−1; ICC: 0.77 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.19; SEM: 102.5W; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.04; SEM: 250.4W; ICC: 0.81 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.22; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; ICC: 0.77 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.08; SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; ICC: 0.78 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.12; SEM: 79.6W; ICC: 0.82 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.02; SEM: 219.1W; ICC: 0.84 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.06; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; ICC: 0.83 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.13; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.07; SEM: 73.0W; ICC: 0.81 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.04; SEM: 196.4W; ICC: 0.77 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.22; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; ICC: 0.83 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.33; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.68 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.23; SEM: 76.7W; ICC: 0.79 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.43; SEM: 217.0W; ICC: 0.60 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.11; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; ICC:0.79 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.42; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.65 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.20; SEM: 76.2W; ICC: 0.77 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.50; SEM: 202.7W; ICC: 0.58 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.56; SEM: 0.09 m·s−1; ICC: 0.64 | |||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.27; SEM: 0.13 m·s−1; ICC: 0.70 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.33; SEM: 52.8W; ICC: 0.81 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.14; SEM: 60.9W; ICC: 0.87 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.27; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; ICC: 0.71 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.21; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.82 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.20; SEM: 27.4W; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.16; SEM: 43.2W; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.09; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; ICC: 0.70 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.12; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; ICC: 0.81 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.07; SEM: 27.1W; ICC: 0.89 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.16; SEM: 38.7W; ICC: 0.89 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.00; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; ICC: 0.78 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.03; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.77 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.00; SEM: 28.2W; ICC: 0.83 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.06; SEM: 51.8W; ICC: 0.77 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.00; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; ICC: 0.87 | ||||
Peak velocity | Standardised mean bias: 0.03; SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; ICC: 0.68 | |||||
Mean power | Standardised mean bias: 0.00; SEM: 29.6W; ICC: 0.85 | |||||
Peak power | Standardised mean bias: 0.06; SEM:78.0W; ICC: 0.64 | |||||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | T-Force | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.48%; ICC: 0.90 |
55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 1.82%; ICC: 0.95 | ||||
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.35%; ICC: 0.78 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.78%; ICC: 0.77 | ||||
85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.90%; ICC: 0.87 | ||||
Chronojump | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.31%; ICC: 0.87 | |
55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.09%; ICC: 0.90 | ||||
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 6.24%; ICC: 0.72 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.53%; ICC: 0.85 | ||||
85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 5.65%; ICC: 0.86 | ||||
45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.61%; ICC: 0.87 | ||||
Speed4Lift | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.39%; ICC: 0.84 | |
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.42%; ICC: 0.93 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.92%; ICC: 0.81 | ||||
85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.41%; ICC: 0.94 | ||||
Stock et al. [78] | Tendo | Intra-device | F/W Bench Press | 10%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.35 m·s−1; SEM: 4.2%; ICC: 0.717 |
20%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.33 m·s−1; SEM: 5.0%; ICC: 0.572 | ||||
30%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.17 m·s−1; SEM: 3.1%; ICC: 0.805 | ||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.21 m·s−1; SEM: 4.7%; ICC: 0.669 | ||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.17 m·s−1; SEM: 4.6%; ICC: 0.790 | ||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.15 m·s−1; SEM: 4.8%; ICC: 0.785 | ||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.14 m·s−1; SEM: 5.8%; ICC: 0.811 | ||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.19 m·s−1; SEM: 10.3%; ICC: 0.714 | ||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.18 m·s−1; SEM: 12.6%; ICC: 0.564 | ||||
Thompson et al. [24] | GymAware | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.5% |
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 5.6% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 4.9% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 2.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 6.0% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 4.5% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 8.3% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 7.0% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 8.6% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 9.5% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 12.6% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 13.6% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 22.0% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 9.8% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 11.3% | |||||
Power clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 3.6% | |||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 3.7% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 2.2% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 3.7% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 2.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 3.1% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.2% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 2.5% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 3.8% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 8.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 3.9% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 4.0% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 4.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 3.3% | |||||
van den Tillaar and Ball [11] | Musclelab (Ergotest) | Intra-device | F/W Bench Press | 50%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 6.6 ± 2.4%; r: 0.96 |
+ 10 kg | peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 6.9 ± 2.0%; r: 0.96 | ||||
+ 10 kg | ||||||
+ 10 kg | ||||||
F/W push-up | Body weight, 10–20–30 kg Weight Vest | mean velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 5.9 ± 1.7%; r: 0.95 | |||
peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 7.3 ± 3.0%; r: 0.95 |
Study | Device | Reliability | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abbott et al. [59] | Bar Sensei | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 14.17% |
Mean velocity | CV: 18.97% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 15.42% | |||||
30%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 12.44% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 15.79% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 15.73% | |||||
40%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 13.39% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 17.58% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 16.13% | |||||
50%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 15.38% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 20.89% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 17.98% | |||||
60%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 17.86% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 19.24% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 20.2% | |||||
70%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 23.97% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 18.82% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 19.21% | |||||
80%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 31.43% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 25.51% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 25.71% | |||||
90%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 33.36% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 29.94% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 25.58% | |||||
100%1RM | Peak velocity | CV: 43.77% | ||||
Mean velocity | CV: 43.02% | |||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 34.59% | |||||
Balsalobre-Fernández | PUSH Band | Intra-device | S/M Back Squat | 20–70 kg | Peak velocity | CV: 6.0 ± 3.9%; ICC: 0.981; r: 0.952 |
et al. [62] | Mean velocity | CV: 5.0 ± 4.1%; ICC: 0.978; r: 0.956 | ||||
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [69] | Beast Sensor (Wrist) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.975 |
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.977 | |||
F/W Hip Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.952 | |||
Beast Sensor (Barbell) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.979 | |
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.981 | |||
F/W Hip Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.958 | |||
Beckham et al. [28] | Bar Sensei | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.419 |
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.451 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.171 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.273 | |||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.295 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.349 | |||||
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | Push Band | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 12.2%; ICC: 0.974 |
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.18 m·s−1; CV: 13.7%; ICC: 0.962 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 5.6%; ICC: 0.979 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 5.9%; ICC: 0.944 | |||||
Garcia-Pinillos et al. [61] | WIMU System | Intra-device | S/M Concentric-Only Half Back Squat | 10%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.02%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 |
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 11.69%; SEM: 0.04 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 11.76%; SEM: 0.07 m·s−1 | |||||
20%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 6.19%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 8.14%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 8.45%; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
30%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 11.77%; SEM: 0.11 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 12.44%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 14.44%; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1 | |||||
40%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 7.90%; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 8.32%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 7.48%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 7.86%; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 8.99%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 7.52%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 10.41%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 11.23%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 13.62%; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 13.82%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 16.75%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 16.80%; SEM: 0.05 m·s−1 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 12.04%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 13.23%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 7.18%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 12.62%; SEM: 0.06 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 16.47%; SEM: 0.02 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 11.77%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 13.27%; SEM: 0.01 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | CV: 14.21%; SEM: 0.01 m·s−1 | |||||
Maximum velocity | CV: 15.66%; SEM: 0.03 m·s−1 | |||||
30%, 60%, 90%1RM | ||||||
Hughes et al. [52] | PUSH Band 2.0 (arm) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.89, 0.86, 0.85; CV: 1.6%, 4.6%, 5.5% |
F/W Bench Press | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.94, 0.90, 0.88; CV: 0.8%, 1.6%, 2.5% | ||||
F/W Prone Bench Pull | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.84, 0.88, 0.85; CV: 1.3%, 1.2%, 2.0% | ||||
F/W OHP | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.67, 0.88, 0.75; CV: 3.3%, 3.7%, 4.2% | ||||
S/M Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.86, 0.94, 0.85; CV: 1.3%, 3.3%, 6.9% | |||
S/M Bench Press | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.83, 0.85, 0.95; CV: 1.1%, 2.4%, 4.2% | ||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.80, 0.94, 0.75; CV: 2.1%, 1.5%, 2.3% | ||||
S/M OHP | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.80, 0.80, 0.75; CV: 2.1%, 5.1%, 3.2% | ||||
PUSH Band 2.0 (bar) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.81, 0.80, 0.85; CV: 1.9%, 5.1%, 7.1% | |
F/W Bench Press | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.84, 0.88, 0.80; CV: 1.5%, 0.7%, 3.8% | ||||
F/W OHP | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.58, 0.75, 0.72; CV: 3.2%, 3.8%, 5.7% | ||||
S/M Back Squat | 30–90%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.87, 0.93, 0.80; CV: 1.7%, 4.6%, 6.5% | |||
S/M Bench Press | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.88, 0.74, 0.75; CV: 1.2%, 3.5%, 3.8% | ||||
S/M OHP | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.86, 0.81, 0.65; CV: 1.8%, 3.0%, 4.2% | ||||
Lake et al. [29] | PUSH Band 2.0 (bar) | Intra-device | F/W Bench Press | 60%1RM | Peak velocity | ICC: 0.947; CV: 4.2% |
Mean velocity | ICC: 0.937; CV: 5.8% | |||||
90%1RM | Peak velocity | ICC: 0.957; CV: 4.7% | ||||
Mean velocity | ICC: 0.973; CV: 7.2% | |||||
Lorenzetti et al. [54] | MyoTest | Intra-device | F/W Ballistic Squat | 25 kg | Mean velocity | r: 0.610 |
Maximum velocity | r: 0.552 | |||||
Time to peak velocity | r: 0.700 | |||||
Garcia-Mateo [63] | RehaGait | Inter-device | F/W Squat with arms extended | <1 kg | Mean velocity | MD ± SD: 0.046 ± 0.052 m·s−1 |
Muyor et al [38] | WIMU | Intra-device | S/M Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity (con) | ES: 0.00; SEM: 0.007 m·s−1; CV: 2.60%; ICC: 0.976 |
Mean velocity (ecc) | ES: 0.06; SEM: 0.013 m·s−1; CV: 3.79%; ICC: 0.955 | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity (con) | ES: 0.00; SEM: 0.011 m·s−1; CV: 3.53%; ICC: 0.905 | ||||
Mean velocity (ecc) | ES: 0.11; SEM: 0.010 m·s−1; CV: 4.51%; ICC: 0.924 | |||||
Orange et al. [47] | PUSH Band (arm) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; ICC: 0.68 |
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.12 m·s−1; ICC: 0.71 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 128.3W; ICC: 0.82 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 261.2W; ICC: 0.80 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; ICC:0.62 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.18 m·s−1; ICC: 0.25 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 121.5W; ICC: 0.67 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 345.8W; ICC: 0.66 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 60%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.64 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.11 m·s−1; ICC: 0.55 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 105.9W; ICC: 0.58 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 279.4W; ICC: 0.67 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 80%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.60 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.11 m·s−1; ICC: 0.44 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 129.5W; ICC: 0.37 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 345.4W; ICC: 0.27 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 90%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.36 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.12 m·s−1; ICC: 0.66 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 117.0W; ICC: 0.41 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 359.5W; ICC: 0.34 | |||||
PUSH Band (arm) | Intra-device | F/W Bench Press | 20%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.11 m·s−1; ICC: 0.28 | |
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.21 m·s−1; ICC: 0.27 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 70.6W; ICC: 0.43 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 221.9W; ICC: 0.63 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; ICC: 0.60 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.11 m·s−1; ICC: 0.66 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 33.8W; ICC: 0.83 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 151.0W; ICC: 0.89 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 60%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; ICC: 0.58 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.12 m·s−1; ICC:58 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 51.6W; ICC: 0.69 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 273.0W; ICC: 0.38 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 80%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; ICC: 0.51 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; ICC: 0.47 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 51.3W; ICC: 0.58 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 137.5W; ICC: 0.55 | |||||
F/W Bench Press | 90%1RM | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; ICC: 0.37 | |||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.10 m·s−1; ICC: 0.40 | |||||
Mean power | SEM: 45.7W; ICC: 0.67 | |||||
Peak power | SEM: 131.9W; ICC: 0.59 | |||||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | PUSH Band (arm) | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 5.02%; ICC: 0.69 |
55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 7.84%; ICC: 0.46 | ||||
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 9.34%; ICC: 0.78 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 14.6%; ICC: 0.50 | ||||
Beast Sensor | 85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 19.1%; ICC: 0.47 | |||
Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 33.4%; ICC: 0.29 | ||
55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 24.2%; ICC: 0.64 | ||||
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 35.0%; ICC: 0.30 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 40.2%; ICC: 0.31 | ||||
85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 54.9%; ICC: 0.27 | ||||
Thompson et al. [24] | PUSH Band (body) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.5% |
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 6.0% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 4.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 9.9% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 5.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 9.1% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 5.0% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 8.9% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 5.2% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 6.8% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 15.6% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 11.0% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 14.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 11.4% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 10.6% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 11.3% | |||||
Power Clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 4.9% | |||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 4.9% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 5.2% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 5.2% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 4.5% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 4.5% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 7.7% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 7.7% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 10.2% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.14 m·s−1; CV: 10.2% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 11.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 11.3% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 11.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 11.4% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 8.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.11 m·s−1; CV: 8.3% | |||||
PUSH Band (bar) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 5.2% | |
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 5.7% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 9.2% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 7.5% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 5.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 9.4% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 5.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 8.3% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 14.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 8.8% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 20.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 14.2% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 15.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 11.6% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 14.5% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.11 m·s−1; CV: 11.0% | |||||
Power Clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.20 m·s−1; CV: 21.5% | |||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.36 m·s−1; CV: 21.5% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.18 m·s−1; CV: 19.0% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.33 m·s−1; CV: 17.9% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.17 m·s−1; CV: 18.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.42 m·s−1; CV: 25.4% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 14.6% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.22 m·s−1; CV: 13.4% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.14 m·s−1; CV: 16.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.25 m·s−1; CV: 15.6% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 18.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.31 m·s−1; CV: 22.2% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 13.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.23 m·s−1; CV: 17.5% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.21 m·s−1; CV: 18.6% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.32 m·s−1; CV: 20.5% | |||||
Bar Sensei | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 9.1% | |
Peak velocity | TE: 0.14 m·s−1; CV: 9.4% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 13.5% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 7.6% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 8.8% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 8.0% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 10.7% TE: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 10.7% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 10.2% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 18.3% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.24 m·s−1; CV: 35.8% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 19.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 18.0% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 60.5% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 28.5% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.09 m·s−1; CV: 22.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 18.7% | |||||
Power Clean | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.23 m·s−1; CV: 20.4% | |||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.20 m·s−1; CV: 7.7% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.16 m·s−1; CV: 13.8% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 6.5% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 12.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 5.8% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 11.8% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.19 m·s−1; CV: 8.8% TE: 0.19 m·s−1; CV: 8.8% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 14.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.13 m·s−1; CV: 6.1% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 17.7% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.14 m·s−1; CV: 7.9% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.14 m·s−1; CV: 18.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 8.5% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.16 m·s−1; CV: 15.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.17 m·s−1; CV: 8.7% | |||||
Beast Sensor | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 20.4% | |
Peak velocity | TE: 0.10 m·s−1; CV: 7.7% | |||||
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 13.8% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.11 m·s−1; CV: 6.5% | |||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 12.1% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 5.8% | |||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.12 m·s−1; CV: 11.8% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.27 m·s−1; CV: 8.8% | |||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.22 m·s−1; CV: 14.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.33 m·s−1; CV: 6.1% | |||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.21 m·s−1; CV: 17.7% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.48 m·s−1; CV: 7.9% | |||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.15 m·s−1; CV: 18.4% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.29 m·s−1; CV: 8.5% | |||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.14 m·s−1; CV: 15.9% | ||||
Peak velocity | TE: 0.30 m·s−1; CV: 8.7% | |||||
van den Tillaar and Ball [11] | PUSH Band (arm) | Intra-device | F/W Bench Press | 50%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.95; CV: 12.8 ± 2.4%; r: 0.87 |
+10 kg | Peak velocity | ICC: 0.92; CV: 13.3 ± 2.3%; r: 0.81 | ||||
+10 kg | ||||||
+10 kg | ||||||
F/W push-up | Body Weight, 10–20–30 kg Weight Vest | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 6.6 ± 1.3%; r: 0.95 | |||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 6.6 ± 1.3%; r: 0.94 |
Study | Device | Reliability | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [69] | PowerLift (v4.0) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.981 |
F/W Bench Press | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.974 | |||
F/W Hip Thrust | 50–95%1RM | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.961 | |||
Balsalobre-Fernández et al. [70] | PowerLift (v2.8) | Intra-observer | F/W Bench Press | 75–100%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: − 0.0007 ± 0.02 m·s−1 |
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | PowerLift App (v4.0) | Inter-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 10.4%; ICC: 0.973 |
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 6.0%; ICC: 0.974 | |||
PowerLift App (v4.0) | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 6.7%; ICC: 0.988 | |
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.6%; ICC: 0.986 | |||
M artinez-Cava et al. [51] | My Lift (v8.1 iOS) | Inter-device | S/M Back Squat | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 5.79%; ICC: 0.993 |
S/M Bench Press | 25–95 kg | Peak velocity | SEM: 0.08 m·s−1; CV: 5.02%; ICC: 0.972 | |||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | PowerLift (v6.0.1) | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.85%; ICC: 0.84 |
55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.97%; ICC: 0.85 | ||||
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.91%; ICC: 0.74 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.69%; ICC: 0.87 | ||||
85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 4.97%; ICC: 0.85 | ||||
Thompson et al. [24] | MyLift (PowerLift at time of data collection) | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 40%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.2% |
50%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.7% | ||||
60%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 5.5% | ||||
70%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 4.9% | ||||
80%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 6.8% | ||||
90%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 12.6% | ||||
100%1RM | Mean velocity | TE: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 13.8% | ||||
Full | Mean velocity | TE: 0.05 m·s−1; CV: 9.7% |
Study | Device | Reliability | Exercise | Intensity/load | Variable measured | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Courel-Ibanez et al. [36] | Velowin | Inter-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.5%; ICC: 0.997 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.4%; ICC: 0.997 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 2.1%; ICC: 0.999 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.6%; ICC: 0.995 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.5%; ICC: 0.995 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 3.2%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
Velowin | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 4.0%; ICC: 0.997 | |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.03 m·s−1; CV: 3.2%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 2.6%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
S/M Back Squat | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.04 m·s−1; CV: 3.7%; ICC: 0.988 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 4.6%; ICC: 0.987 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.07 m·s−1; CV: 3.5%; ICC: 0.983 | |||||
S/M Prone Bench Pull | 20–80 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 3.9%; ICC: 0.994 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 3.9%; ICC: 0.994 | |||||
Peak velocity | SEM: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 2.6%; ICC: 0.998 | |||||
Peña Garcia-Orea et al. [82] | Velowin (v.1.7.232) | Intra-device | S/M Squat | 20 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.95; CV: 3.35%; SEM: 0.225 m·s−1 |
Mean propulsive velocity | ICC: 0.96; CV: 3.29%; SEM: 0.287 m·s−1 | |||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.95; CV: 2.89%; SEM: 0.399 m·s−1 | |||||
30 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.97; CV: 2.20%; SEM: 0.227 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | ICC: 0.97; CV: 2.45%; SEM: 0.284 m·s−1 | |||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.97; CV: 2.46%; SEM: 0.373 m·s−1 | |||||
40 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.13%; SEM: 0.248 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.30%; SEM: 0.306 m·s−1 | |||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 2.29%; SEM: 0.363 m·s−1 | |||||
50 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 2.82%; SEM: 0.276 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.98%; SEM: 0.337 m·s−1 | |||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 2.56%; SEM: 0.362 m·s−1 | |||||
60 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.46%; SEM: 0.272 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.62%; SEM: 0.316 m·s−1 | |||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 2.39%; SEM: 0.313 m·s−1 | |||||
70 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.55%; SEM: 0.243 m·s−1 | ||||
Mean propulsive velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.79%; SEM: 0.280 m·s−1 | |||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 2.30%; SEM: 0.269 m·s−1 | |||||
Peña Garcia-Orea et al. [72] | Velowin (v1.7.232) | Intra-device | S/M Loaded Countermovement Jump | 3.5 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 2.41%; SEM: 0.0025 m·s−1 |
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 1.77%; SEM: 0.0021 m·s−1 | |||||
13.5 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.97; CV: 1.70%; SEM: 0.0021 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 1.68%; SEM: 0.0014 m·s−1 | |||||
23.5 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.95; CV: 2.56%; SEM: 0.0033 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.97; CV: 2.38%; SEM: 0.0023 m·s−1 | |||||
33.5 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.98; CV: 1.87%; SEM: 0.0022 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 1.60%; SEM: 0.0018 m·s−1 | |||||
43.5 kg | Mean velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 2.03%; SEM: 0.0040 m·s−1 | ||||
Peak velocity | ICC: 0.99; CV: 1.57%; SEM: 0.0027 m·s−1 | |||||
Garcia-Ramos et al. [71] | Velowin | Intra-device | F/W Back Squat | 20 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.045 m·s−1; CV: 4.29%; ICC: 0.91 |
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.054 m·s−1; CV: 4.61%; ICC: 0.90 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.088 m·s−1; CV: 4.77%; ICC: 0.92 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 40 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.041 m·s−1; CV: 4.34%; ICC: 0.92 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.047 m·s−1; CV: 4.60%; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.085 m·s−1; CV: 5.01%; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 50 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.033 m·s−1; CV: 3.74%; ICC: 0.90 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.043 m·s−1; CV: 4.50%; ICC: 0.88 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.050 m·s−1; CV: 3.04%; ICC: 0.95 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 60 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.039 m·s−1; CV: 4.75%; ICC: 0.89 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.037 m·s−1; CV: 4.20%; ICC: 0.92 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.069 m·s−1; CV: 4.44%; ICC: 0.91 | |||||
F/W Back Squat | 70 kg | Mean velocity | SEM: 0.031 m·s−1; CV: 4.12%; ICC: 0.93 | |||
Mean propulsive velocity | SEM: 0.041 m·s−1; CV: 5.15%; ICC: 0.90 | |||||
Maximum velocity | SEM: 0.053 m·s−1; CV: 3.57%; ICC: 0.95 | |||||
Perez-Castilla et al. [10] | Velowin | Intra-device | S/M Bench Press | 45%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 2.89%; ICC: 0.83 |
55%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.27%; ICC: 0.79 | ||||
65%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 3.99%; ICC: 0.83 | ||||
75%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 6.01%; ICC: 0.68 | ||||
85%1RM | Mean velocity | CV: 7.64%; ICC: 0.69 | ||||
Weakley et al. [22] | FLEX (technological and biological error) | Inter-device | F/W Back Squat | 20–100%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.070 m·s−1; CV: 9.82% |
FLEX (technological error) | F/W Bench Press | 20–100%1RM | Mean velocity | MD: 0.01 m·s−1; TE: 0.064 m·s−1; CV: 9.83% | ||
FLEX | Inter-device | Calibrated rig | 0.53 ± 0.27 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.017 m·s−1; CV: 3.96% | |
0.99 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.01 m·s−1 m·s−1; TE: 0.041 m·s−1; CV: 4.17% | ||||
0.84 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: − 0.01 m·s−1; TE: 0.06 m·s−1; CV: 7.10% | ||||
0.78 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.019 m·s−1; CV: 2.41% | ||||
0.71 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.016 m·s−1; CV: 2.28% | ||||
0.60 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: − 0.01 m·s−1; TE: 0.02 m·s−1; CV: 3.37% | ||||
0.54 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.016 m·s−1; CV: 2.99% | ||||
0.47 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.013 m·s−1; CV: 2.71% | ||||
0.38 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.013 m·s−1; CV: 3.49% | ||||
0.28 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.016 m·s−1; CV: 5.73% | ||||
0.17 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.006 m·s−1; CV: 3.81% | ||||
0.09 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.002 m·s−1; CV: 2.43% | ||||
Intra-device | Calibrated rig | 0.53 ± 0.27 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.016 m·s−1; CV: 3.77% | ||
0.99 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.032 m·s−1; CV: 3.28% | ||||
0.84 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.01 m·s−1; TE: 0.043 m·s−1; CV: 5.11% | ||||
0.78 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.021 m·s−1; CV: 2.71% | ||||
0.71 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: − 0.01 m·s−1; TE: 0.020 m·s−1; CV: 2.81% | ||||
0.60 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.023 m·s−1; CV: 3.82% | ||||
0.54 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.017 m·s−1; CV: 3.19% | ||||
0.47 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.014 m·s−1; CV: 3.01% | ||||
0.38 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.013 m·s−1; CV: 3.42% | ||||
0.28 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.016 m·s−1; CV: 5.93% | ||||
0.17 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.006 m·s−1; CV: 3.64% | ||||
0.09 ± 0.00 m·s−1 | Mean velocity | MD: 0.00 m·s−1; TE: 0.003 m·s−1; CV: 2.89% |