nach oben

Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie

Erschienen in:

20.08.2020 | Review Article/Brief Review

Efficacy of topical agents for prevention of postoperative sore throat after single lumen tracheal intubation: a Bayesian network meta-analysis

verfasst von: Narinder P. Singh, MD, Jeetinder K. Makkar, MD, Ron B. Cappellani, FRCPC, Ashish Sinha, MD, Anand Lakshminarasimhachar, MD, Preet Mohinder Singh, MD

Erschienen in: Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie | Ausgabe 11/2020

Einloggen, um Zugang zu erhalten

Abstract

Background

The optimal choice of prophylactic drugs to decrease postoperative sore throat is unclear. The objective of this network meta-analysis (NMA) was to compare and rank 11 topical agents used to prevent postoperative sore throat.

Methods

Various databases were searched independently for randomized-controlled trials (RCTs) comparing topical agents used for the prevention of postoperative sore throat. Inclusion criteria were parallel group studies comparing intervention with active or inactive control and reporting postoperative sore throat. The primary outcome was postoperative sore throat at 24 hr. Secondary outcomes were early sore throat at 4–6 hr, cough, and hoarseness at 24 hr.

Results

Evidence was synthesized from 70 RCTs reporting 7,141 patients. Topical application of lidocaine, corticosteroids, ketamine, magnesium, benzydamine, water-based lubricant, and liquorice applied along the tracheal tube, to the tracheal tube cuff, gargled or sprayed were compared with intracuff air and each other. Bayesian NMA showed that magnesium (odds ratio [OR], 0.10; 95% credible interval [CrI], 0.03 to 0.26), liquorice (OR, 0.14; 95% CrI, 0.03 to 0.55), and steroid application (OR, 0.11; 95% CrI, 0.06 to 0.22) most effectively prevented postoperative sore throat at 24 hr. Topical lidocaine was the least effective intervention.

Conclusion

Topical application of magnesium followed by liquorice and corticosteroids most effectively prevented postoperative sore throat 24 hr after endotracheal intubation.

Nur mit Berechtigung zugänglich

Macario A, Weinger M, Carney S, Kim A. Which clinical anesthesia outcomes are important to avoid? The perspective of patients. Anesth Analg 1999; 89: 652-8.PubMed

McHardy FE, Chung F. Postoperative sore throat: cause, prevention and treatment. Anaesthesia 1999; 54: 444-53.PubMed

Higgins PP, Chung F, Mezei G. Postoperative sore throat after ambulatory surgery. Br J Anaesth 2002; 88: 582-4.PubMed

El-Boghdadly K, Bailey CR, Wiles MD. Postoperative sore throat: a systematic review. Anaesthesia 2016; 71: 706-17.PubMed

Park SY, Kim SH, Lee SJ, et al. Application of triamcinolone acetonide paste to the endotracheal tube reduces postoperative sore throat: a randomized controlled trial. Can J Anesth 2011; 58: 436-42.PubMed

Flexman AM, Duggan LV. Postoperative sore throat: inevitable side effect or preventable nuisance? Can J Anesth 2019; 66: 1009-13.PubMed

Chandler M. Tracheal intubation and sore throat: a mechanical explanation. Anaesthesia 2002; 57: 155-61.PubMed

Kuriyama A, Maeda H, Sun R, Aga M. Topical application of corticosteroids to tracheal tubes to prevent postoperative sore throat in adults undergoing tracheal intubation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Anaesthesia 2018; 73: 1546-56.PubMed

Kuriyama A, Aga M, Maeda H. Topical benzydamine hydrochloride for prevention of postoperative sore throat in adults undergoing tracheal intubation for elective surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Anaesthesia 2018; 73: 889-900.PubMed

10.

Tanaka Y, Nakayama T, Nishimori M, et al. Lidocaine for preventing postoperative sore throat. Cochrane Database Sys Rev 2015; . https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004081.pub3.CrossRef

11.

Mayhood J, Cress K. Effectiveness of ketamine gargle in reducing postoperative sore throat in patients undergoing airway instrumentation: a systematic review. JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep 2015; 13: 244-78.PubMed

12.

Hutton B, Salanti G, Caldwell DM, et al. The PRISMA extension statement for reporting of systematic reviews incorporating network meta-analyses of health care interventions: checklist and explanations. Ann Intern Med 2015; 162: 777-84.PubMed

13.

Puhan MA, Schünemann HJ, Murad MH, et al. GRADE Working Group. A GRADE Working Group approach for rating the quality of treatment effect estimates from network meta-analysis. BMJ 2014; https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.g5630.

14.

Tonin FS, Rotta I, Mendes AM, Pontarolo R. Network meta-analysis: a technique to gather evidence from direct and indirect comparisons. Pharm Pract 2017; . https://doi.org/10.18549/PharmPract.2017.01.943.CrossRef

15.

Sterne JA, Savović J, Page MJ, et al. RoB 2: a revised tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ 2019; . https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l4898.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral

16.

Sumathi PA, Shenoy T, Ambareesha M, Krishna HM. Controlled comparison between betamethasone gel and lidocaine jelly applied over tracheal tube to reduce postoperative sore throat, cough, and hoarseness of voice. Br J Anaesth 2008; 100: 215-8.PubMed

17.

Agarwal A, Nath SS, Goswami D, et al. An evaluation of the efficacy of aspirin and benzydamine hydrochloride gargle for attenuating postoperative sore throat: a prospective, randomized, single-blind study. Anesth Analg 2006; 103: 1001-3.PubMed

18.

Canbay O, Celebi N, Sahin A, et al. Ketamine gargle for attenuating postoperative sore throat. Br J Anaesth 2008; 100: 490-3.PubMed

19.

Borazan H, Kececioglu A, Okesli S, Otelcioglu S. Oral magnesium lozenge reduces postoperative sore throat: a randomized, prospective, placebo-controlled study. Anesthesiology 2012; 117: 512-8.PubMed

20.

Souissi H, Fréchette Y, Murza A, et al. Intracuff 160 mg alkalinized lidocaine reduces cough upon emergence from N₂O-free general anesthesia: a randomized controlled trial. Can J Anesth 2016; 63: 862-70.PubMed

21.

Thomas D, Bejoy R, Zabrin N, Beevi S. Preoperative ketamine nebulization attenuates the incidence and severity of postoperative sore throat: a randomized controlled clinical trial. Saudi J Anaesth 2018; 12: 440-5.PubMedPubMedCentral

22.

Rajan S, Tosh P, Paul J, Kumar L. Effect of inhaled budesonide suspension, administered using a metered dose inhaler, on post-operative sore throat, hoarseness of voice and cough. Indian J Anaesth 2018; 62: 66-71.PubMedPubMedCentral

23.

Charan S, Khilji Mohd Y, Jain R, Devra V, Saxena M. Inhalation of ketamine in different doses to decrease the severity of postoperative sore throat in surgeries under general anesthesia patients. Anesth Essays Res 2018; 12: 625-9.PubMedPubMedCentral

24.

Budania LS, Chamala V, Rao M, et al. Effect of air, anesthetic gas mixture, saline, or 2% lignocaine used for tracheal tube cuff inflation on coughing and laryngotracheal morbidity after tracheal extubation. J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol 2018; 34(6): 386-91.PubMedPubMedCentral

25.

Thapa P, Shrestha RR, Shrestha S, Bajracharya GR. Betamethasone gel compared with lidocaine jelly to reduce tracheal tube related postoperative airway symptoms: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Res Notes 2017; . https://doi.org/10.1186/s13104-017-2694-6.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral

26.

Rajan S, Malayil G, Varghese R, Kumar L. Comparison of usefulness of ketamine and magnesium sulfate nebulizations for attenuating postoperative sore throat, hoarseness of voice, and cough. Anesth Essays Res 2017; 11: 287-93.PubMedPubMedCentral

27.

Jain S, Barasker SK. A comparative study of preoperative ketamine and MgSO4 nebulisation for incidence of post operative sore throat after endotracheal intubation. Int J Contemp Med Res 2017; 4: 1356-9.

28.

Sharma M, Gupta S, Purohit S, Goyal AK. The effect of intravenous dexamethasone on intraoperative and early postoperative pain in lumbar spine surgery: a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled study. Anesth Essays Res 2018; 12: 803-8.PubMedPubMedCentral

29.

Varghese Thoppil J, Rani Imanual S. Efficacy of ketamine gargle for attenuating postoperative sore throat in patients undergoing general anaesthesia with endotracheal intubation. J Evolution Med Dent Sci 2017; 6: 5707-11.

30.

Aditya AK, Das B, Mishra DK. Assessment of nebulized ketamine for reductions of incidence and severity of post-operative sore throat. Int J Med Health Res 2017; 3: 130-2.

31.

Lalwani J, Thakur R, Tandon M, Bhagat S. To study the effect of ketamine gargle for attenuating post operative sore throat, cough and hoarseness of voice. J Anest Inten Care Med 2017; . https://doi.org/10.19080/JAICM.2017.04.555642.CrossRef

32.

Takhelmatum SH, Longjam DE, Mithun R, et al. Effect of intracuff plain lignocaine and alkalinized lignocaine for prevention of postoperative sore throat. IJHRMLP 2017; 3: 64-8.

33.

Fayyaz A, Furqan A, Ammar A, Akhtar R. Comparing the effectiveness of betamethasone gel with lidocaine gel local application on tracheal tube in preventing post-operative sore throat (POST). J Pak Med Assoc 2017; 67: 873-6.PubMed

34.

Mafiana R, Maas EM, Theodorus, Wijaya W. Comparison of the efficacy between triamcinolone gel 0, 1% and lidocaine gel 2% applied over tracheal tube to reduce postoperative sore throat, cough, and hoarseness after general anesthesia. Int J Health Sci Res 2017; 7: 6-15.

35.

Firza TA, Umar N, Ihsan M. Comparison of benzydamine hydrochloride 22.5 mg and ketamine 40 mg mouthwash reduce sore throat and hoarseness after endotracheal intubation. Jurnal Anestesi Perioperatif 2017; 5: 57-66.

36.

Lee J, Lee YC, Son J-D, Lee JY, Kim HC. The effect of lidocaine jelly on a taper-shaped cuff of an endotracheal tube on the postoperative sore throat: a prospective randomized study. Medicine (Baltimore) 2017; . https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000008094.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral

37.

Gaur P, Ubale P, Khadanga P. Efficacy and safety of using air versus alkalinized 2% lignocaine for inflating endotracheal tube cuff and its pressure effects on incidence of postoperative coughing and sore throat. Anesth Essays Res 2017; 11: 1057-63.PubMedPubMedCentral

38.

Mehrotra S, Kumar N, Khurana G, Bist SS. Post operative sore throat: incidence after nebulization with ketamine, lidocaine and budesonide. Int J Medical Science Clin Invention 2017; 4: 2994-8.

39.

Narimani M, Mehdi SA, Gholami F, et al. The effect of betamethasone gel and lidocaine jelly applied over tracheal tube cuff on postoperative sore throat, cough, and hoarseness. J Perianesth Nurs 2016; 31: 298-302.PubMed

40.

Mekhemar NA, El-Agwany AS, Radi WK, El-Hady SM. Comparative study between benzydamine hydrochloride gel, lidocaine 5% gel and lidocaine 10% spray on endotracheal tube cuff as regards postoperative sore throat. Braz J Anesthesiol 2016; 66: 242-8.PubMed

41.

Chari VR, Paul A. Comparative study to analyze the incidence of sore throat, cough, and hoarseness of voice after general anesthesia with the use of topical benzydamine hydrochloride and 2% lignocaine gel with placebo. Med J DY Patil Univ 2016; 9: 61-5.

42.

Gaikwad S, Rupwate K, Tendolkar B. A prospective, randomized, double blind, placebo controlled clinical trial to study efficacy and safety of benzydamine 0.15% gargles in prevention of postoperative sore throat. Int J Res Med Sci 2016; 4: 2420-7.

43.

Yadav M, Chalumuru N, Gopinath R. Effect of magnesium sulfate nebulization on the incidence of postoperative sore throat. J Anaesthiol Clin Pharmacol 2016; 32: 168-71.

44.

Chattopadhyay S, Das A, Nandy S, et al. Postoperative sore throat prevention in ambulatory surgery: a comparison between preoperative aspirin and magnesium sulfate gargle – a prospective, randomized, double-blind study. Anesth Essays Res 2017; 11: 94-100.PubMedPubMedCentral

45.

Zheng Y, Wu M, Bai Y. Effect of betamethasone gel on postoperative sore throat, cough and hoarseness after tracheal intubation. China Medicine 2016; 11: 1852-4.

46.

Sarki AM, Mohammed AD. A comparison of betamethasone gel and lidocaine jelly as prophylaxis against intubation-associated throat complications. Niger J Basic Clin Sci 2015; 12: 105-10.

47.

Handady SO, Elsir Y, Sanhouri M, Mimoun H, Alawad AA. The effect of betamethasone gel in reducing post operative sore throat and cough after tracheal intubation in Khartoum teaching hospital in Sudan. Open Sci J Clin Med 2015; 3: 140-4.

48.

Muhammad M, Fuadi I, Mawawi AM. Effectiveness of benzydamine HCl 0.15% spray and lidocaine 2% gel on post-operative sore throat incidence. Jurnal Anestesi Perioperatif 2015; 3: 123-30.

49.

Ahuja V, Mitra S, Sarna R. Nebulized ketamine decreases incidence and severity of post-operative sore throat. Indian J Anaesth 2015; 59: 37-42.PubMedPubMedCentral

50.

Kamble NP, Gajbhare NK. Efficacy of ketamine gargles in the prevalence of postoperative sore throat after endotracheal intubation. Indian J Clin Anaesth 2015; 2: 251-5.

51.

Sharma RP, Vaidya PR, Chand MB. The efficacy of ketamine gargle in attenuating postoperative sore throat: a randomized control trial. J Lumbini Med Coll 2015; 3: 8-11.

52.

Salman W, Shamim A, Shounthoo RS, Gul DS. A comparative study between intracuff alkalinized lignocaine, intracuff plain lignocaine and intracuff air for decreasing post intubation sore throat and emergence phenomena. IOSR J Dental Med Sci 2015; 14: 60-6.

53.

Banihashem N, Alijanpour E, Hasannasab B, Zarei A. Prophylactic effects of lidocaine or beclomethasone spray on post-operative sore throat and cough after orotracheal intubation. Iranian J Otorhinolaryngol 2015; 27: 179-84.

54.

Teymourian H, Mohajerani SA, Farahbod A. Magnesium and ketamine gargle and postoperative sore throat. Anesth Pain Med 2015; . https://doi.org/10.5812/aapm.5(3)2015.22367.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral

55.

Safavi M, Honarmand A, Fariborzifar A, Attari M. Intravenous dexamethasone versus ketamine gargle versus intravenous dexamethasone combined with ketamine gargle for evaluation of post-operative sore throat and hoarseness: a randomized, placebo-controlled, double blind clinical trial. Adv Biomed Res 2014; . https://doi.org/10.4103/2277-9175.143257.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral

56.

Tabari M, Soltani G, Zirak N, Alipour M, Khazaeni K. Comparison of effectiveness of betamethasone gel applied to the tracheal tube and IV dexamethasone on postoperative sore throat: a randomized controlled trial. Iran J Otorhinolaryngol 2013; 25: 215-20.PubMedPubMedCentral

57.

Akram A, Ali L, Aslam M, Ali SK. Comparison of frequency of postoperative sore throat, cough and hoarseness of voice with and without betamethasone gel application on tracheal tube. Pakistan J Med and Health Sci 2013; 7: 820-3.

58.

Nimmaanrat S, Chokkijchai K, Chanchayanon T. Efficacy of benzydamine hydrochloride dripping at endotracheal tube cuff for prevention of postoperative sore throat. J Med Assoc Thailand 2013; 96: 1331-7.

59.

D’Aragon F, Beaudet N, Gagnon V, Martin R, Sansoucy Y. The effects of lidocaine spray and intracuff alkalinized lidocaine on the occurrence of cough at extubation: a double-blind randomized controlled trial. Can J Anesth 2013; 60: 370-6.PubMed

60.

Ghaleb MA, Falatah S, Al-Amoudi FA. The efficacy of licorice gargle for attenuating postoperative sore throat. American J Res Communication. 2013; 1: 379-94.

61.

Gupta D, Agrawal S, Sharma JP. Effect of preoperative licorice lozenges on incidence of postextubation cough and sore throat in smokers undergoing general anesthesia and endotracheal intubation. Middle East J Anaesthesiol 2013; 22: 173-8.PubMed

62.

Shaaban AR, Kamal SM. Comparison between betamethasone gel applied over tracheal tube and ketamine gargle for attenuating postoperative sore throat, cough and hoarseness of voice. Middle East J Anaesthesiol 2012; 21: 513-9.PubMed

63.

Rajkumar G, Eshwori L, Konyak PY, et al. Prophylactic ketamine gargle to reduce post-operative sore throat following endotracheal intubation. J Med Soc 2012; 26: 175-9.

64.

Navarro LH, Lima RM, Aguiar AS, et al. The effect of intracuff alkalinized 2% lidocaine on emergence coughing, sore throat, and hoarseness in smokers. Rev Assoc Med Bras 2012; 58: 248-53.PubMed

65.

Guo H-M, Pang Z-l, Sun Z, Li P-H, Han X-P. The clinical research of compound dexamethasone gel applied over tracheal tube to prevent postoperative airway complications. Henan Med Res 2012; 21: 60-2.

66.

Doukumo D, Faponle A, Adenekan A, Olateju S, Bolaji B. Effects of lidocaine and K-Y jellies on sore throat, cough, and hoarseness following endotracheal anaesthesia. J West Afr Coll Surg 2011; 1: 44-61.PubMedPubMedCentral

67.

Narasethakamol A, Techanivate A, Saothongthong J, Yurakate N, Cousnit P. Application of mometasone spray to reduce sore throat after tracheal intubation. J Med Assoc Thailand 2011; 94: 958-64.

68.

Hung NK, Wu CT, Chan SM, et al. Effect on postoperative sore throat of spraying the endotracheal tube cuff with benzydamine hydrochloride, 10% lidocaine, and 2% lidocaine. Anesth Analg 2010; 111: 882-6.PubMed

69.

Huang YS, Hung NK, Lee MS, et al. The effectiveness of benzydamine hydrochloride spraying on the endotracheal tube cuff or oral mucosa for postoperative sore throat. Anesth Analg 2010; 111: 887-91.PubMed

70.

Shrestha SK, Bhattarai B, Singh J. Ketamine gargling and postoperative sore throat. J Nepal Med Assoc 2010; 50: 282-5.

71.

Tazeh-Kand NF, Eslami B, Mohammadian K. Inhaled fluticasone propionate reduces postoperative sore throat, cough, and hoarseness. Anesth Analg 2010; 111: 895-8.PubMed

72.

Rudra A, Ray S, Chatterjee S, Ahmed A, Ghosh S. Gargling with ketamine attenuates the postoperative sore throat. Indian J Anaesth 2009; 53: 40-3.PubMedPubMedCentral

73.

Jaichandran V, Bhanulakshmi I, Jagadeesh V, Thennarasu M. Intracuff buffered lidocaine versus saline or air—A comparative study for smooth extubation in patients with hyperactive airways undergoing eye surgery. South African J Anaesth Analg 2009; 15: 11-4.

74.

Sagheer AS, Iqbal M, Ali K. Effect of intracuff lignocaine on coughing during emergence and postoperative sore throat. Pakistan J Med and Health Sci 2009; 1: 50-4.

75.

Agarwal A, Gupta D, Yadav G, et al. An evaluation of the efficacy of licorice gargle for attenuating postoperative sore throat: a prospective, randomized, single-blind study. Anesth Analg 2009; 109: 77-81.PubMed

76.

Gulhas N, Canpolat H, Cicek M, et al. Dexpanthenol pastille and benzydamine hydrochloride spray for the prevention of post-operative sore throat. Acta Anaesth Scand 2007; 51: 239-43.PubMed

77.

Navarro LHC, Braz JRC, Nakamura G, Lima RM e, Silva F de P e, Módolo NSP. Effectiveness and safety of endotracheal tube cuffs filled with air versus filled with alkalinized lidocaine: a randomized clinical trial. Sao Paulo Med J 2007; 125: 322-8.

78.

Kazemi A, Amini A. The effect of betamethasone gel in reducing sore throat, cough, and hoarseness after laryngo-tracheal intubation. Middle East J Anaesthesiol 2007; 19: 197-204.PubMed

79.

Basaranoglu G, Erden V, Delatioglu H. Postoperative sore throat: effect of lidocaine jelly and pomade on endotracheal intubation. J Clin Anesth 2004; 16: 79-80.PubMed

80.

Soltani HA, Aghadavoudi O. The effect of different lidocaine application methods on postoperative cough and sore throat. J Clin Anesth 2002; 14: 15-8.PubMed

81.

Selvaraj T, Dhanpal R. Evaluation of the application of topical steroids on the endotracheal tube in decreasing postoperative sore throat. J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol 2002; 18: 167-70.

82.

Altintaş F, Bozkurt P, Kaya G, Akkan G. Lidocaine 10% in the endotracheal tube cuff: blood concentrations, haemodynamic and clinical effects. Eur J Anaesthesiol 2000; 17: 436-42.PubMed

83.

Ayoub MC, Ghobashy A, McGrimley L, Koch ME, Qadir S, Silverman DG. Wide spread application of topical steroids to decrease sore throat, hoarseness and cough after tracheal intubation. Anesth Analg 1998; 87: 714-6.PubMed

84.

Navarro RM, Baughman VL. Lidocaine in the endotracheal tube cuff reduces postoperative sore throat. J Clin Anesth 1997; 9: 394-7.PubMed

85.

Singh NP, Makkar JK, Wourms V, et al. Role of topical magnesium in post-operative sore throat: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Indian J Anaesth 2019; 63: 520-9.PubMedPubMedCentral

86.

Kuriyama A, Maeda H, Sun R. Topical application of magnesium to prevent intubation-related sore throat in adult surgical patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Can J Anesth 2019; 66: 1082-94.PubMed

87.

Parkes AW, Harper N, Herwadkar A, et al. Anaphylaxis to the chlorhexidine component of Instillagel: a case series. Br J Anaesth 2009; 102: 65-8.PubMed

88.

Schorr WF. Paraben allergy. A cause of intractable dermatitis. JAMA 1968; 204: 859-62.PubMed

89.

Hara K, Maruyama K. Effect of additives in lidocaine spray on postoperative sore throat, hoarseness and dysphagia after total intravenous anaesthesia. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2005; 49: 463-7.PubMed

90.

Liao AH, Yeoh SR, Lin YC, et al. Lidocaine lubricants for intubation-related complications: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Can J Anesth 2019; 66: 1221-39.PubMed

91.

Tu HN, Saidi N, Leiutaud T, et al. Nitrous oxide increases endotracheal cuff pressure and the incidence of tracheal lesions in anesthetized patients. Anesth Analg. 1999; 89: 187-90.PubMed

92.

Dunson DB. Commentary: practical advantages of Bayesian analysis of epidemiological data. Am J Epidemiol 2001; 153: 1222-6.PubMed

Titel: Efficacy of topical agents for prevention of postoperative sore throat after single lumen tracheal intubation: a Bayesian network meta-analysis
verfasst von: Narinder P. Singh, MD
Jeetinder K. Makkar, MD
Ron B. Cappellani, FRCPC
Ashish Sinha, MD
Anand Lakshminarasimhachar, MD
Preet Mohinder Singh, MD
Publikationsdatum: 20.08.2020
Verlag: Springer International Publishing
Erschienen in: Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie / Ausgabe 11/2020
Print ISSN: 0832-610X
Elektronische ISSN: 1496-8975
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12630-020-01792-4

Update AINS

Bestellen Sie unseren Fach-Newsletter und bleiben Sie gut informiert.

hier abonnieren

Springer Medizin

Efficacy of topical agents for prevention of postoperative sore throat after single lumen tracheal intubation: a Bayesian network meta-analysis