Background
Methods
Data Source
Variables
Dependent Variables
Explanatory Variables
Statistical Analysis
Ordinary Binary Logistic Regression Model
Bivariate Binary logistic Regression Model
Parameter Estimation and Model Diagnosis
Results
Exploratory Analysis
Dependent variables | Categories (Codes) | n (%) |
---|---|---|
CIAF | Yes (1) No(0) | 4393 (46.7%) 5018 (53.3%) |
Wealth index | poor (1) rich (0) | 4371 (46.4%) 5040 (53.6%) |
Variables | Categories (Codes) | n (%) | Variables | Categories (Codes) | n (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Age of child | 0–5 (0) | 1047 (11.1) | Mother’s education | No education (0) | 6194 (65.8) |
6–11 (1) | 953 (10.1) | Level | Primary (1) | 2577 (27.4) | |
12–23 (2) | 1809 (19.2) | Secondary and above (2) | 641 (6.8) | ||
24–35 (3) | 1884 (20.0) | ||||
36–47 (4) | 1848 (19.6) | Age of mothers | < 20 (0) | 6113 (65.0) | |
48–59 (5) | 1870 (19.9) | at first birth | 20–34 (1) | 3288 (34.9) | |
35–49 (2) | 10 (0.1) | ||||
Sex of child | Male (1) | 4816(51.2) | |||
Female (2) | 4595(48.8) | Mothers BMI | Thin (0) | 1829 (19.4) | |
Normal (1) | 6877 (73.1) | ||||
Region | Tigray (1) | 643(6.8) | Overweight (2) | 615 (6.5) | |
Afar (2) | 90 (1.0) | ||||
Amhara (3) | 1824 (19.4) | Anemia | Non Anemic (0) | 4722 (50.2) | |
Oromia (4) | 4145 (44.0) | Anemic (1) | 3511 (37.3) | ||
Somali (5) | 391 (4.2) | Missing | 1179 (12.5) | ||
Benishangul (6) | 100 (1.1) | ||||
SNNPR (7) | 1935 (20.6) | Cough | No (0) | 7512(79.8) | |
Gambela (8) | 22 (0.2) | Yes (1) | 1900 (20.2) | ||
Harari (9) | 20 (0.2) | ||||
Addis Adaba (10) | 206 (2.2) | Diarrhea | No (0) | 8274 (87.9) | |
Dire Dawa (11) | 36 (0.4) | Yes (1) | 1120 (11.9) | ||
Missing | 18 (0.2) | ||||
Residence | Urban (1) | 1022 (10.9) | |||
Rural (2) | 8389 (89.1) | Fever | No (0) | 8021 (85.2) | |
Yes (1) | 1381 (14.7) | ||||
Birth oder | 1st (0) | 1700(18.1) | Missing | 10 (0.1) | |
2–3 (1) | 2895 (30.8) | ||||
4–5 (2) | 2263 (24.0) | Husband/partner’s | No education (0) | 4232 (45.0) | |
6 and more (3) | 2553 (27.1) | education level | Primary (1) | 3589 (38.1) | |
Secondary and above (2) | 1050 (11.2) | ||||
Number of children | 1(0) | 3423 (36.4) | Missing | 540 (5.7) | |
under-five years | 2 (1) | 2651(27.9) | |||
in the household | 3 or more (2) | 1670 (17.7) | 1–4 (small) (0) | 2411 (25.6) | |
Household size | 5–9 (medium (1) | 6450 (68.5) | |||
Source of drinking | unimproved source (0) | 4207 (44.7) | 10 and more (Large) (2) | 550 (5.8) | |
water | Improved source (1) | 5204(55.3%) | Religion | Orthodox (1) | 3253(34.6) |
Multiple birth | Single birth (0) | 9193 (97.7) | Protestant (2) | 2032(21.6) | |
1st of multiple (1) | 117 (1.2) | Muslim (3) | 3842(40.8) | ||
2nd of multiple (2) | 102 (1.1) | Others (4) | 285(3.0) |
Covariates | childCIAF | p-value | HHWI | p-value | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
yes(n%) | no(%) | poor(%) | rich(%) | |||
Age of child 0–5 | 455(10.4) | 592(11.7) | 464(10.6) | 583(11.6) | ||
6–11 | 407(9.3) | 545(10.8) | 436(9.9) | 516(10.3) | ||
12–23 | 840(19.2) | 969(19.2) | 888(20.2) | 921(18.4) | ||
24–35 | 924(21.1) | 961(19.1) | 0.001 | 862(19.6) | 1022(20.4) | 0.132 |
36–47 | 908(20.8) | 940(18.7) | 851(19.4) | 997(19.9) | ||
48–59 | 837(19.1) | 1033(20.5) | 891(20.3) | 980(19.5) | ||
Sex of child male female | 2370(54.2) 2001(45.8) | 2446(48.5) 2594(51.5) | 0.000 | 2257(51.4) 2136(48.6) | 2560(51.0) 2459(49.0) | 0.367 |
Region Tigray | 306(7.0) | 337(6.7) | 326(7.4) | 318(6.3) | ||
Afar | 48(1.1) | 41(0.8) | 73(1.7) | 17(0.3) | ||
Amhara | 993(22.7) | 831(16.5) | 824(18.8) | 1001(19.9) | ||
Oromia | 1875(42.9) | 2270(45.0) | 1935(44.0) | 2210(44.0) | ||
Somalia | 180(4.1) | 211(4.2) | 301(6.9) | 91(1.8) | ||
Benshangul | 50(1.1) | 49(1.0) | 0.000 | 60(1.4) | 40(0.8) | 0.000 |
SNNPR | 846(19.4) | 1089(21.6) | 842(19.2) | 1093(21.8) | ||
Gambela | 8(0.2) | 14(0.3) | 11(0.3) | 11(0.2) | ||
Harari | 8(0.2) | 12(0.2) | 7(0.2) | 13(0.3) | ||
Addis Ababa | 38(0.9) | 167(3.3) | 0(0.0) | 206(4.1) | ||
Dire Dawa | 18(0.4) | 18(0.4) | 15(0.3) | 20(0.4) | ||
Residence Urban Rural | 340(7.8) 4032(92.2) | 682(13.5) 4358(86.5) | 0.000 | 77(1.8) 4316(98.2) | 945(18.8) 4073(81.2) | 0.000 |
Birth order 1st 2–3 4–5 | 742(17.0) 1281(29.3) 1086(24.8) | 958(19.0) 1615(32.0) 1177(23.4) | 0.000 | 668(15.2) 1319(30.0) 1116(25.4) | 1032(20.6) 1576(31.4) 1147(22.9) | 0.000 |
6 and more | 1263(28.9) | 1290(25.6) | 1290(29.4) | 1263(25.2) | ||
No. of children(< 5 yrs) 1 | 1523(34.8) | 1900(37.7) | 1254(28.5) | 2169(43.2) | ||
2 | 2083(47.6) | 2236(44.4) | 0.004 | 2239(51.0) | 2079(41.4) | 0.000 |
3 or more | 766(17.5) | 904(17.9) | 900(20.5) | 770(15.3) | ||
Source of drinking water unimproved source Improved source | 2075(47.5) 2296(52.5) | 2132(42.3) 2908(57.7) | 0.000 | 2714(61.8) 1679(38.2) | 1493(29.7) 3526(70.3) | 0.000 |
Multiple birth Single birth | 4234(98.4) | 4958(96.9) | 4303(98.0) | 4889(97.4) | ||
1st of multiple | 71(1.6) | 46(0.9) | 0.000 | 48(1.1) | 69(1.4) | 0.245 |
2nd of multiple | 66(1.5) | 36(0.7) | 42(1.0) | 60(1.2) | ||
Age of mother(at 1st birth) < 20 | 2925(66.9) | 3188(63.3) | 2987(68.0) | 3126(62.3) | ||
20–34 | 1444(33.0) | 1844(36.6) | 0.001 | 1404(32.0) | 1885(37.6) | 0.000 |
35–49 | 3(0.1) | 7(0.1) | 3(0.1) | 8(0.2) | ||
Mothers BMI Thin | 935(21.6) | 894(17.9) | 962(22.2) | 867(17.4) | ||
Normal | 3217(74.3) | 3659(73.3) | 0.000 | 3208(73.9) | 3669(73.7) | 0.000 |
Overweight | 176(4.1) | 439(8.8) | 170(3.9) | 445(8.9) | ||
Anemia Non Anemic Anemic | 1514(37.8) 2488(62.2) | 1997(47.2) 2233(52.8) | 0.000 | 1433(37.2) 2419(62.8) | 2078(47.4) 2303(52.6) | 0.000 |
Cough No Yes | 3458(79.1) 913(20.9) | 4053(80.4) 987(19.6) | 0.291 | 3573(81.3) 820(18.7) | 3938(78.5) 1080(21.5) | 0.003 |
Diarrhea No Yes | 3812(87.3) 555(12.7) | 4462(88.8) 565(11.2) | 0.015 | 3888(88.7) 493(11.3) | 4386(87.5) 627(12.5) | 0.033 |
Fever No Yes | 3660(83.8) 710(16.2) | 4361(86.6) 672(13.4) | 0.000 | 3809(86.7) 582(13.3) | 4211(84.0) 800(16.0) | 0.000 |
Husband/partner education level No education | 2175(53.0) | 2057(43.1) | 2524(61.1) | 1708(36.0) | ||
Primary | 1570(38.3) | 2019(42.3) | 0.000 | 1460(35.4) | 2129(44.9) | 0.000 |
Secondary and above | 358(8.7) | 692(14.5) | 145(3.5) | 905(19.1) | ||
Mothers education level No education | 3094(70.8) | 3099(61.5) | 3428(78.0) | 2766(55.1) | ||
Primary | 1113(25.5) | 1465(29.1) | 0.000 | 921(21.0) | 1657(33.0) | 0.000 |
Secondary and above | 165(3.8) | 476(9.4) | 45(1.0) | 596(11.9) | ||
Household size 1–4 (small) | 1075(24.6) | 1337(26.5) | 1055(24.0) | 1356(27.0) | ||
5–9 (medium) | 3034(69.4) | 3416(67.8) | 0.076 | 3105(70.7) | 3344(66.6) | 0.000 |
10 and more (large) | 263(6.0) | 287(5.7) | 233(5.3) | 318(6.3) | ||
Religion Orthodox | 1521(34.8) | 1732(34.4) | 1334(30.4) | 1919(38.2) | ||
Protestant | 897(20.5) | 1135(22.5) | 0.008 | 788(17.9) | 1245(24.8) | 0.000 |
Muslim | 1799(41.1) | 2043(40.5) | 2090(47.6) | 1752(34.9) | ||
Others | 155(3.5) | 130(2.6) | 182(4.1) | 103(2.1) |
Covariates | No CAIF | No CAIF | CAIF | CAIF |
---|---|---|---|---|
and rich (%) | and poor (%) | and rich (%) | and poor | |
Age of child 0–5 | 356(12.0) | 235(11.4) | 225(11.0) | 230(9.9) |
6–11 | 326(10.9) | 219(10.6) | 190(9.3) | 217(10.6) |
12–23 | 540(18.1) | 429(20.8) | 381(18.7) | 460(19.7) |
24–35 | 598(20.1) | 363(17.6) | 425(20.8) | 499(21.4) |
36–47 | 573(19.2) | 367(17.8) | 424(20.8) | 484(20.8) |
48–59 | 585(19.6) | 449(21.8) | 395(19.4) | 441(18.9) |
Sex of child male | 1427(47.9) | 1019(49.4) | 1132(55.5) | 1238(53.1) |
female | 1551(52.1) | 1043(50.6) | 908(44.5) | 1093(46.9) |
Region Tigray | 181(6.1) | 156(7.6) | 137(6.7) | 169(7.3) |
Afar | 9(0.3) | 33(1.6) | 8(0.4) | 41(1.8) |
Amhara | 520(17.5) | 311(15.1) | 481(23.6) | 512(22.0) |
Oromia | 1349(45.3) | 921(44.7) | 861(42.2) | 1014(43.5) |
Somalia | 57(1.9) | 154(7.5) | 33(16.2) | 147(6.3) |
Benshangul | 24(0.8) | 26(1.3) | 16(0.8) | 35(1.5) |
SNNPR | 643(21.6) | 445(21.6) | 450(22.1) | 396(17.0) |
Gambela | 7(0.2) | 7(0.3) | 3(0.1) | 5(0.2) |
Harari | 8(0.3) | 3(0.1) | 4(0.2) | 4(0.2) |
Addis Ababa | 167(5.6) | 0(0.0) | 38(18.6) | 0(0.0) |
Dire Dawa | 12(0.4) | 6(0.3) | 8(0.4) | 10(0.4) |
Residence Urban | 657(22.1) | 25(1.2) | 288(14.1) | 52(2.2) |
Rural | 2321(77.9) | 2037(98.8) | 1753(84.9) | 2279(97.8) |
Birth order 1st | 652(21.9) | 306(14.8) | 380(18.6) | 362(15.5) |
2–3 | 976(32.8) | 638(30.9) | 600(29.4) | 681(29.2) |
4–5 | 656(22.0) | 521(25.3) | 491(24.1) | 595(25.5) |
6 and more | 693(23.3) | 597(29.0) | 569(27.9) | 693(29.7) |
No. of children(< 5 years) 1 | 1333(44.7) | 567(27.5) | 836(41.0) | 687(29.5) |
2 | 1192(40.0) | 1044(50.6) | 887(43.5) | 1196(51.3) |
3 or more | 453(15.2) | 451(21.9) | 317(15.5) | 449(19.3) |
Source of drinking water unimproved source | 868(29.1) | 1264(61.3) | 625(30.6) | 1451(62.2) |
Improved source | 2110(70.9) | 798(38.7) | 1416(69.4) | 881(37.8) |
Multiple birth Single birth | 2915(97.9) | 2043(99.1) | 1974(96.8) | 2260(97.0) |
1st of multiple | 38(1.3) | 8(0.4) | 31(1.5) | 40(1.7) |
2nd of multiple | 25(0.8) | 11(0.5) | 35(1.7) | 31(1.3) |
Age of mother (at 1st birth) < 20 | 1845(30.2) | 1343(45.1) | 1280(62.7) | 1644(70.5) |
20–34 | 1126(34.2) | 718(24.1) | 759(37.2) | 685(29.4) |
35–49 | 6(0.2) | 1(0.05) | 1(0.04) | 2(0.08) |
Mothers BMI Thin | 488(16.4) | 406(19.7) | 379(18.6) | 556(23.9) |
Normal | 2113(71.0) | 1546(75.0) | 1156(56.7) | 1662(71.3) |
Overweight | 353(11.9) | 86(4.2) | 92(4.5) | 84(3.6) |
Anemia Non Anemic | 1305(51.4) | 692(40.9) | 773(41.9) | 741(34.3) |
Anemic | 1232(48.6) | 1002(59.1) | 1072(58.1) | 1417(65.7) |
Cough No | 2358(79.2) | 1695(82.2) | 1580(77.5) | 1879(80.6) |
Yes | 620(20.8) | 367(17.8) | 460(22.5) | 453(19.4) |
Diarrhea No | 2615(88.0) | 1847(89.9) | 1771(86.8) | 2041(87.7) |
Yes | 358(12.0) | 207(10.1) | 269(13.2) | 285(12.3) |
Fever No | 2542(85.6) | 1819(88.2) | 1670(81.9) | 1990(85.4) |
Yes | 429(14.4) | 243(11.8) | 370(18.1) | 339(14.6) |
Husband/partner education No education | 914(32.4) | 1144(58.8) | 794(41.4) | 1381(63.2) |
Primary | 1292(43.4) | 727(37.4) | 837(43.6) | 734(33.6) |
Secondary and above | 618(21.9) | 75(3.9) | 288(15.0) | 70(3.2) |
Mothers education level No education | 1530(51.4) | 1569(76.1) | 1235(60.5) | 1859(79.8) |
Primary | 1009(33.9) | 456(22.1) | 648(31.8) | 465(19.9) |
Secondary and above | 439(14.7) | 37(1.8) | 157(7.7) | 8(0.3) |
Household size 1–4 (small) | 855(28.7) | 482(23.4) | 502(24.6) | 573(24.6) |
5–9 (medium) | 1941(65.2) | 1474(71.5) | 1403(68.8) | 1631(70.0) |
10 and more (large) | 182(6.1) | 106(5.1) | 136(6.7) | 127(5.4) |
Religion Orthodox | 1136(38.1) | 596(20.9) | 783(38.4) | 738(31.7) |
Protestant | 756(25.3) | 379(12.7) | 488(23.9) | 409(17.5) |
Muslim | 1024(34.4) | 1019(49.4) | 727(35.6) | 1071(45.9) |
Others | 62(2.1) | 68(3.3) | 41(2.1) | 114(4.9) |
HHWI | Marginal of CIAF | Odds Ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
poor = 1 | rich = 0 | ||||
CIAF | Yes = 1 No = 0 | 2331 (0.248) 2062 (0.219) | 2040 (0.217) 2978 (0.316) | 4371 (0.464) 5040 (0.536) | 1.469 |
Marginal of HHWI | 4393 (0.467) | 5018 (0.533) | 9411 (1.00) |
Variables | CIAF | HHWI | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
est.(se) | OR (95% CI) | est.(se) | OR (95% CI) | |
Intercept | 0.13(0.18) | 1.14(0.80,1.61) | 1.08(0.23) | 0.34(0.22,0.53) |
Region Tigray (*) Afar | 0.23(0.15) | 0.80(0.60,1.06) | 1.06(0.21) | 2.89(1.93,4.32) |
Amhara | 0.18(0.11) | 1.19(0.96,1.49) | 0.94(0.13) | 0.39(0.31,0.50) |
Oromia | 0.51(0.12) | 0.60(0.47,0.76) | 1.48(0.14) | 0.23(0.17,0.30) |
Somalie | 0.57(0.14) | 0.56(0.42,0.74) | 0.35(0.18) | 1.41(0.99,0.20) |
Benshangul | 0.034(0.13) | 0.97(0.75,1.25) | 0.22(0.15) | 0.80(0.60,1.07) |
Gambela | 0.41(0.13) | 0.67(0.52,0.86) | 1.20(0.15) | 0.30(0.22,0.40) |
SNNPR | 0.66(0.16) | 0.52(0.38,0.71) | 1.01(0.20) | 2.73(1.86,4.02) |
Harari | 0.50(0.16) | 0.60(0.44,0.83) | 1.40(0.20) | 0.25(0.17,0.37) |
Addis Ababa | 0.82(6.37) | 0.44(0.01,0.78) | 55.34(4460) | 0.01(0.00,2.50) |
Dire Dawa | 0.21(0.17) | 0.81(0.58,1.12) | 0.25(0.21) | 0.78(0.51,1.18) |
Residence Urban (*) Rural | 0.08(0.09) | 1.08(0.91,1.29) | 2.74(0.137) | 15.49(11.80,20.30) |
Religion Orthodox (*) Protestant | 0.26(0.11) | 1.30(1.05,1.60) | 0.53(0.12) | 1.70(1.34,2.17) |
Muslim | 0.33(0.09) | 1.38(1.15,1.66) | 0.61(0.11) | 1.83(1.48,2.26) |
Catholic and others | 0.51(0.18) | 1.67(1.17,2.38) | 1.33(0.23) | 3.78(2.42,5.90) |
Education level of women No education (*) Primary | 0.20(0.07) | 0.82(0.72,0.94) | 0.48(0.08) | 0.62(0.53,0.72) |
Secondary and higher | 0.66(0.13) | 0.52(0.40,0.67) | 1.11(0.18) | 0.33(0.23,0.47) |
Diarrhea No (*) Yes | 0.10(0.08) | 1.11(0.94,1.30) | 0.02(0.10) | 0.98(0.81,1.19) |
Fever No (*) Yes | 0.11(0.09) | 1.11(0.94,1.32) | 0.02(0.11) | 0.98(0.79,1.21) |
Cough No (*) Yes | 0.01(0.08) | 1.00(0.85,1.17) | 0.10(0.10) | 1.11(0.91,1.34) |
Multiple birth Single birth (*) First of multiple | 0.47(0.24) | 1.59(1.01,2.53) | 0.13(0.28) | 0.88(0.51,1.51) |
Second of multiple | 0.49(0.25) | 1.63(1.00,2.66) | 0.07(0.31) | 0.93(0.51,1.70) |
Sex of Child male (*) female | 0.16(0.05) | 0.85(0.77,0.94) | 0.01(0.06) | 0.99(0.88,1.12) |
Education level of husband No education (*) Primary | 0.19(0.06) | 0.83(0.73, 0.93) | 0.62(0.07) | 0.54(0.47,0.62) |
Secondary and higher | 0.11(0.09) | 0.89(0.75, 1.07) | 1.03(0.12) | 0.36(0.29,0.45) |
Source of drinking water Not improved (*) Improved | 0.04(0.06) | 0.96(0.86, 1.07) | 1.00(0.07) | 0.37(0.32,0.42) |
Birth order 1st (*) 2–3 | 0.14(0.08) | 0.87(0.74, 1.02) | 0.22(0.10) | 0.80(0.66,0.98) |
4–5 | 0.06(0.10) | 0.95(0.78, 1.14) | 0.16(0.12) | 0.85(0.67,1.07) |
6 and more | 0.07(0.10) | 0.94(0.77, 1.14) | 0.05(0.12) | 0.95(0.75,1.21) |
Age of mother at first birth less than 20 (*) between 20 and 24 | 0.11(0.05) | 0.90(0.81,1.00) | 0.05(0.07) | 0.95(0.83,1.08) |
between 35 and 49 | 0.45(1.06) | 1.57(0.20,2.60) | 1.56(2.30) | 4.74(0.05,2.90) |
Household size small (1–4) (*) medium (5–9) | 0.06(0.08) | 1.06(0.91,1.23) | 0.31(0.09) | 0.73(0.61,0.88) |
large (10 and more) | 0.18(0.14) | 1.20(0.92,1.56) | 0.65(0.16) | 0.52(0.38,0.72) |
Body mass index Thin (*) Normal | 0.24(0.06) | 0.78(0.70,0.88) | 0.20(0.07) | 0.82(0.71,1.00) |
Overweight | 0.80(0.12) | 0.45(0.36,0.56) | 0.69(0.15) | 0.50(0.37,0.67) |
Anemia No (*) Yes | 0.37(0.05) | 1.44(1.30,1.60) | 0.37(0.07) | 1.44(1.27,1.64) |
No. of under five children 1 (*) 2 | 0.19(0.06) | 1.21(1.07,1.36) | 0.44(0.07) | 1.55(1.35,1.79) |
3 and more | 0.15(0.08) | 0.86(0.73,1.01) | 0.43(0.10) | 1.54(1.26,1.87) |
Age of child 0–5 (*) 6–11 | 0.01(0.11) | 1.00(0.80,1.23) | 0.04(0.13) | 1.04(0.81,1.35) |
12–23 | 0.15(0.10) | 1.16(0.96,1.41) | 0.26(0.12) | 1.29(1.03,1.62) |
24–35 | 0.17(0.10) | 1.18(0.98,1.43) | 0.05(0.12) | 1.05(0.84,1.32) |
36–47 | 0.18(0.10) | 1.20(0.99,1.45) | 0.16(0.12) | 1.17(0.93,1.47) |
48–59 | 0.05(0.10) | 1.05(0.87,1.27) | 0.23(0.12) | 1.25(1.00,1.58) |
Measure of Dependency Odds Ratio (OR) | 1.498 |
Parameter Estimates
HHWI | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
rich | poor | ||||
observed | predicted | observed | predicted | ||
CAIF | Yes | 2363 | 2030 | (1100) | (3420) |
No | 3010 | (2060) | 2008 | (2831) |