Introduction
The work of the scientist is essentially to measure.–A. Szent-Györgyi, 1937 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine
Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery
Consensus Focus
Consensus Meeting and Statement
Methods
Meeting Design and Voting Process
Consensus Phases
Manuscript Development
Statistical Analysis
Results
Procedure Consensus Outcomes
Figure no. depicting anatomic configuration | Procedure | Voting group | Vote 1 (%) | Vote 2 (%) | Final consensus (yes ≥ 70%) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Yes | Consensus (√ ≥ 70%) | Yes | Consensus (√ ≥ 70%) | ||||
Sleeve gastrectomy and variants | |||||||
1 | Standard sleeve gastrectomy (SG) | A | 71.7 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 59.0 | No | 70.2 | √ | Yes | ||
2 | Banded sleeve gastrectomy (BSG) | A | 80.0 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 92.9 | √ | Yes | ||||
3 | Sleeve gastrectomy with jejunojejunostomy/enteral bypass (SG-JJEB) | A | 65.9 | No | No | ||
B | 70.0 | √ | Yes | ||||
4 | Single-anastomosis duodenoileal bypass with sleeve gastrectomy (SAD-I) | A | 80.0 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 84.1 | √ | Yes | ||||
5 | Sleeve gastrectomy with jejunoileostomy anastomosis (SG-JIA) | A | 58.2 | No | No | ||
B | 69.2 | No | 85.7 | √ | Yes | ||
6 | Sleeve gastrectomy with duodenojejunal bypass (SG-DJB) | A | 69.2 | No | No | ||
B | 59.4 | No | 79.6 | √ | Yes | ||
7 | Sleeve gastrectomy with loop duodenojejunal bypass (SG-LDJB) | A | 82.9 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 69.0 | No | 84.2 | √ | Yes | ||
8 | Sleeve gastrectomy with transit bipartition (SG-TB) | A | 68.0 | No | No | ||
B | 41.0 | No | 78.7 | √ | Yes | ||
9 | Sleeve gastrectomy with jejunoileal interposition (SG-JII) and duodenal ileal interposition (SG-DII) | A | 79.2 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 59.3 | No | 71.4 | √ | Yes | ||
10 | Single-anastomosis sleeve with ileal bypass (SASI) | A | 65.9 | No | No | ||
B | 51.6 | No | 77.8 | √ | Yes | ||
11 | Endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty (E-SG) | A | 63.6 | No | No | ||
B | 64.0 | No | 79.1 | √ | Yes | ||
Roux-en-Y gastric bypass and variants | |||||||
12 | Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGBP) | A | 62.5 | No | No | ||
B | 37.5 | No | 90.7 | √ | Yes | ||
13 | Banded gastric bypass (BGBP) | A | 82.0 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 82.0 | √ | Yes | ||||
14 | One-anastomosis gastric bypass or mini gastric bypass (OAGB/MGB) | A | 75.8 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 72.0 | √ | Yes | ||||
15 | Diverted one-anastomosis gastric bypass or mini gastric bypass (D-OAGB/D-MGB) | A | 38.9 | No | Insufficient + conflicting information = no vote | – | |
B | 36.8 | No | – | ||||
16 | Single-anastomosis gastroileal bypass (SAG-I) | A | 59.3 | No | Insufficient + conflicting information = no vote | – | |
B | 46.9 | No | – | ||||
Laparoscopic adjustable band | |||||||
17 | Laparoscopic adjustable gastric band (LAGB) | A | 87.5 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 93.5 | √ | Yes | ||||
Biliopancreatic diversion and variant | |||||||
18 | Biliopancreatic diversion (BPD) | A | 81.6 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 81.3 | √ | Yes | ||||
19 | Biliopancreatic diversion with duodenal switch (BPD/DS) | A | 86.1 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 85.0 | √ | Yes | ||||
Emerging and experimental procedures/techniques | |||||||
20 | Intragastric balloon (IGB) | A | 79.4 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 85.7 | √ | Yes | ||||
21 | vBloc | A | 80.0 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 86.7 | √ | Yes | ||||
22 | Gastric plication (GP) | A | 71.4 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 73.3 | √ | Yes | ||||
23 | Adjustable banded gastric plication (BGP) | A | 65.2 | No | No | ||
B | 57.7 | No | 61.4 | No | |||
24 | EndoBarrier | A | 69.0 | No | No | ||
B | 62.5 | No | 100.0 | √ | Yes | ||
25 | AspireAssist | A | 71.0 | √ | Yes | ||
B | 82.9 | √ | Yes |