Characteristics and health related quality of life in a population with advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, a cross-sectional study

The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that 65 million people have moderate to severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) (http://​www.​who.​int/​respiratory/​copd/​burden/​en/​). In Denmark, approximately 320,000 persons have COPD and 50,000 of these have advanced COPD (https://​www.​lunge.​dk/​lunger/​viden-noegletal-om-lungesygdomme). Worldwide, 5 % of all deaths are caused by COPD corresponding to more than 3 million annual deaths. In Denmark, 5500 persons die due to COPD each year, making the disease the third most frequent cause of death in Denmark, and the highest mortality rate of COPD in the EU (https://​www.​lunge.​dk/​lunger/​viden-noegletal-om-lungesygdomme). There is growing evidence that patients with advanced COPD are marked by a high symptom burden, impaired health related quality of life (HRQoL) and live their last years of life with unmet palliative needs [1‐5].

In the past years we have developed and implemented a new Danish pulmonary outpatient structure named CAPTAIN with the aim of improving the basic palliative care offered to patients with advanced COPD [6]. All patients were assigned to a CAPTAIN-nurse who were responsible for establishing and maintaining an individualized relationship with the patients and identifying their need for care and treatment. Routine patient controls were replaced with ad hoc physician consultations and planned advance care dialogues. Our qualitative evaluations illustrated how this new outpatient structure made it possible to respond to the individual and fluctuating palliative needs of patients with advanced COPD, and how both patients and health care professionals experienced that the quality of care improved. CAPTAIN is currently considered standard care for all patients with advanced COPD affiliated to our outpatient clinics [6‐8].

Until now, the majority of studies investigating symptom burden and HRQoL in patients with COPD include mainly patients with COPD in a mild or moderate state and treated in traditional organizations with semi-annual or annual medical checks [9, 10]. The explanation may be that it is difficult to recruit patients with advanced COPD to research projects, just like it requires special attention and devoted resources from the researchers to reduce missing data and dropouts. The CAPTAIN structure and assigned CAPTAIN-nurses gave us the opportunity to collect this data through validated questionnaires - either administered by self-report or interview, and thereby generate knowledge about the population with advanced COPD in a stable phase of the disease.

There is a need for knowledge about the symptom burden and HRQoL in patients with advanced COPD, living at home and treated in an outpatient structure that already focuses on the patients’ individual basic palliative needs. HRQoL is arguable the most relevant outcome from a patient’s perspective and associated with both COPD mortality and morbidity [9, 11‐14]. Therefore, the aim of this study was to describe the psychosocial and demographic characteristics of a population with advanced COPD in a stable phase of the disease.

Demographic and clinical baseline characteristics of the included patients (n = 242) are presented in Table 2. The patients were aged 39–91 years with a mean of 72 years (8.4) and 58% were females. Except for one patient, all had an ethnicity of Danish origin. One fifth of the patients were current smokers and more than 13% consumed more alcohol than recommended by the Danish National Board of Health.

Patients demonstrated a mean FEV1 of 38% of predicted value (12.7), and 19% were treated in their home with long term oxygen. In addition, 12% of the patients had been treated with NIV in the previous 12 months and 66% (the sum of patients with 1 or 2 exacerbations and those with > 2 exacerbations) of the patients had one or more exacerbations within the last 12 months.

Selected pharmacological preparations extracted from the patient’s record is presented in Table 3. Nearly 50 % of the patients were treated for pain (weak analgesics, NSAID or opioids). Thirteen patients (6%) were treated with opioids to relieve their dyspnea, whereas only one patient was treated with cannabis oil. Thirty-two patients (13%) were treated with antidepressant, ten (4%) with antipsychotics and six-teen (7%) with benzodiazepines.

More than 50 % of the patients were prescribed triple therapy (ICS/LABA/LAMA) and the rest a two-drug combination. Only seven patients received single drug treatment. Not surprisingly, more than 90 % were prescribed short acting bronchodilators.

Table 4 shows the patient reported psychosocial outcomes assessed by the standardised questionnaires. The CRQ assessed HRQoL based on four domains. Each domain was scored separately, and higher scores indicated better quality of life. On average did the patients have a CRQ-D score of 4.21 points, CRQ-M of 4.88 points, CRQ-E of 4.81 points and CRQ-F of 3.93 points. The patients had on average the lowest score on the fatigue domain indicating most HRQoL impairment compared to the domains: dyspnea, mastery and emotion. However, all patients experienced impairment in all domains.

The mean CAT-score was 18.41 points. Forty-four percent had a CAT score ≥ 20 points and more than 90% a score ≥ 10 points. The mean MRC was 3.35 points and 73% had an MRC score ≥ 3.

Sixty patients (32%) had a HADS-D subscale score ≥ 8 point and forty-five patients (24%) a HADS-A subscale score ≥ 8 points. Thirteen percent of the patients had a both HADS A and a HADS D score ≥ 8 point.

More than half of the patients rated their health as reasonable and 30% as bad or very bad. However, 18.5% rated their health as very good or good.

Twenty-nine patients died during the data collection period of 1.5 year corresponding to a crude mortality rate of 12%. The majority, 70% died in the hospital, 24% died at home and 6% died at hospice. The patients who died consisted of 58.6% males, and 66% were living alone. On average 31% of the patients who died rated their health as bad or very bad. Their mean CRQ-domain scores were: CRQ-D 3.7 (±1.4), CRQ-F 3.4 (±1.4), CRQ-E 4.5 (±1.4), CRQ-M 4.6 (±1.5). Their mean CAT score was 18.54 (±4.6). They had a mean HADS-A score of 6.6 points (± 5.3) and a HADS-D score of 7.3 (± 5.1). The patients (n = 29) who died had an average of 1.52 points [95% CI, 0.10 to 2.94] higher HADS-D score compare to the rest of the patients (p = 0.0454). On the HADS-A, the difference was on average 1.51 points [95% CI, 0.07 to 2.95] higher score (p = 0.049). The frequency of ≥2 annual exacerbations were 41.4% in the patients who died compared to 34.1% among the rest of the patients. A multi logistic regression analysis did not show any significant association between mortality and CAT, MRC, CRQ, and HADS scores with and without adjustments for age and gender (data not shown). There was a significant association between age and mortality OR: 1.09, [1.001; 1.18] p = 0.05.

Our study contributes knowledge of the psychosocial status of patients with advanced COPD in a stable phase of the disease and show a widespread level of HRQoL impairment. Nearly all patients had a CAT score ≥ 10 points and more than 44% a CAT-score ≥ 20 points. The Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) recommend a CAT score ≥ 10 points as a threefold for considering treatment for symptoms [5] which comply with the recommendations of offering all patients with advanced COPD early integrated palliative care [11, 23, 24].

Although the patients in our study were treated in an altered outpatient structure focusing on the patients’ basic palliative needs [6, 7], our patients still lived with impaired HRQoL. However, we cannot know if our population’s HRQoL actually were higher compared to patients treated in traditional outpatient clinics. Nibber et al. found in a retrospective cohort of patients with severe/very severe COPD a mean (SD) CAT-score of 26.1 (7.6) points [25], which is significantly higher than our mean CAT-score of 18.41 (6.7) points.

According to the CRQ was fatigue the problem affecting the patients’ HRQoL most. Fatigue is a cardinal but multifaceted symptom of advanced COPD and described as a profound feeling of physical and psychological wariness that is not relieved by sleep or rest [11, 26]. Studies report fatigue prevalences in patients with advanced COPD to 71 and 96% in palliative patients [26]. Fatigue do often co-exist with breathlessness and cough in what is called the respiratory cluster [11, 27], just like fatigue is associated with depression and anxiety [28].

In this study the prevalences of anxiety and depression were within the ranges of what is previous described for COPD outpatients in a stable phase of the disease [28]. However, it is worth noticing that 13% of the patients did suffer both symptoms of anxiety and depression; a known condition with heightened risk of suicidal ideation, increased physical disability and chronic depressive symptoms [29, 30]. The frequency of patients treated with benzodiazepines in this study were lower than reported by Vozoris et al. in a population of older adults with COPD [31]. Nearly 50 % of patients in this study were treated for pain which correspond to the findings of others reporting prevalences of pain ranging from 32 to 77% in patients with all stage COPD [32, 33]. However, little is known about the cause and level of pain in patients with advanced COPD and how pain is effectively managed both pharmacological and non-pharmacological in this population [33]. It can be assumed that the cause of pain in patients with advanced COPD can be muscular, related to osteoporosis, arthritis or other comorbidities just like pain properly will be associated with anxiety, depression and dyspnea. Further research is recommended.

The patients who died (n = 29) had a clinically significant higher level of anxiety and depression compared to the rest of the patients [17], although it did not show in impaired HRQoL assessed by the CRQ or CAT. In this study, the prevalence of two or more annual exacerbations were more frequent among the patients who died compared to the rest of the patients. This result is not surprising as it is well known that COPD patients with comorbid anxiety and/or depression have a higher risk of exacerbations and mortality after exacerbations, compared to patients without these comorbidities [12, 34, 35]. The majority of the patients died in the hospital, which mirror other studies results, although the patients’ general preference is to die at home [11, 36‐38].

It is thought-provoking that despite the population was characterized by severe pulmonary disease, one-fifth was current smokers. Although patients with advanced COPD are in the last stage of the disease and presumably have a limited life span, smoking cessation still makes sense and contribute to prevent further deterioration [5, 39]. In Denmark, smoking cessation courses are free but requires attendance at a given location outside the patients’ home. Transport are a known barrier for patients with advanced COPD and a significant reason that they do not profit from health promotion intervention outside their home [40, 41]. It would have been interesting if we had collected data on whether smoking patients had been offered smoking cessation interventions in form of pharmacology, non-pharmacological or combinations. Our results underpin a need for further knowledge about how to motivate and support patients with advanced COPD with smoking cessation.

With this study we have described the characteristics of a population with advanced COPD. The prevalences of high CAT, MRC, HADS, or low CRQ scores were high, and indicate a need for a more intensive palliative care intervention than actually offered. Intensive palliative care should be individualized and address the needs that are currently most relevant to the patient concerned. Systematic screening of the symptom burden using validated questionnaires could be a method of targeting and intensifying a palliative effort.

Our results illustrate that if we for example define a CAT-score above 20 points as an indicator for intensified palliative needs [5], the target population will be huge and at the same time not target the patients who die as they had a mean CAT score of 18 points. In Denmark 50,000 patients suffer from severe COPD [2]. It may be assumed that many of them have a CAT score above 20 points, and if 44% of these patients were offered intensified palliative care this alone would correspond to 22,000 patients. In addition, our population may not be fully representative for the general population of patients with severe COPD. Our patients are already treated in a palliative care setting [6], and the percentages with a CAT scores above 20 points may therefore be even higher than the 44% in a general COPD population.

In Denmark, specialized palliative care is initially developed and targeted to cancer patients and organized in oncology. Currently, the need for specialized palliation and hospice stays among Danish cancer patients exceeds the current capacity and patients with cancer are often waitlisted before receiving a palliative offer (www.​repha.​dk). More than 95 % of the specialized palliative resources in Denmark are used on cancer patients, and only few COPD patients are offered specialized palliative care or admitted to a hospice [42‐45]. The size of the COPD population with unmet palliative needs makes it, in our opinion, unrealistic to think that patients with advanced COPD can be accommodated into existing specialized palliative offers. We recommend that future research and initiatives aiming at improving palliative care for COPD patients take the COPD population size into consideration. If we want to offer early and integrated palliative care and be able to accommodate the size of the COPD population, we have to reflect on how to use and expand our existing outpatient structures and competences among pulmonary nurses and physicians in a formalized collaboration with the specialized palliation.

This study describes the characteristics of a population with advanced COPD in a stable phase of the disease. If a CAT-score above 20 points are used as an indicator for intensified palliative needs in patients with COPD, the target population will be huge and at the same time not target the patients who die. Our results illustrate how the population, although treated in an outpatient structure already focusing on palliative needs, still live with unmet palliative needs and impaired HRQoL and how one out of five patients currently smokes.