Background
Critically ill patients frequently develop weakness of limb and respiratory muscles. Such intensive care unit (ICU)-acquired weakness has a high prevalence and is associated with greater post-ICU impairment, prolonged hospitalization, delayed rehabilitation, and late death [
1,
2]. Particularly patients suffering from sepsis are at risk of developing ICU-acquired weakness [
3].
Profound loss of muscle mass and quality characterizes ICU-acquired weakness [
4]. This loss of muscle mass is caused by activated myofibrillary breakdown without compensatory protein synthesis [
5‐
8]. In addition, the loss of myofiber quality is related to insufficiently activated autophagy and ongoing inflammation [
9‐
11]. Muscle regeneration is also severely impaired in prolonged critically ill patients, which hampers rehabilitation [
12]. Several interventions, such as aggressive sepsis treatment, early mobilization, prevention of hyperglycemia, and withholding early parenteral nutrition (PN), have been shown to partially protect against ICU-acquired weakness [
4,
9,
13,
14]. Nevertheless, to reduce the prevalence of this debilitating condition, additional clinical interventions are still required.
Recently, premorbid overweight/obesity has been shown to protect against muscle wasting and weakness in both critically ill patients and in septic mice [
15]. In these septic mice, the overweight/obese preserved their muscle mass while losing fat mass. In contrast, lean septic mice prioritized the maintenance of fat mass over muscle mass [
15]. Markers of fatty acid metabolism and ketogenesis also appeared more increased in overweight/obese than in lean septic mice [
15]. This suggested an intrinsically different metabolic response to sepsis with overweight/obesity. Importantly, diet-induced obesity does typically enhance basal lipolysis, hepatic lipid metabolism, fatty acid oxidation, and ketogenesis [
16‐
23].
Such an altered metabolic response in obese individuals, with increased release and metabolism of fatty acids to ketones, might mediate the observed protection against sepsis-induced muscle wasting and weakness. Indeed, in patients suffering from pancreatic cancer cachexia, a high-fat, ketogenic diet protected against muscle wasting. Additionally, in elite athletes, muscle function improved after exogenous ketone body administration [
24,
25]. Ketone bodies exert several functions that could benefit the muscle during critical illness. As energy substrates, they can alter muscle substrate metabolism from the use of glycogen to 3-hydroxybutyrate (3-HB) [
25‐
27]. Furthermore, as signaling molecules, ketone bodies have anti-inflammatory and autophagy-stimulating actions and can induce mTOR-mediated protein synthesis and muscle regeneration [
28‐
32].
As a general hypothesis, we state that the protection against ICU-acquired weakness in overweight/obese critically ill patients can be explained by their enhanced ability to release and metabolize fatty acids from their excess adipose tissue. This hypothesis was tested with four consecutive studies in a mouse model of prolonged abdominal sepsis [
33]. Of note, this centrally catheterized, fluid-resuscitated, and antibiotic-treated mouse model results in muscle wasting and weakness that is comparable to ICU-acquired weakness in patients [
15]. We aimed to assess (1) whether overweight/obesity causes enhanced mobilization and metabolism of endogenous fatty acids during sepsis and (2) whether such altered metabolic response protects the skeletal muscle. Furthermore, we aimed to evaluate (3) whether the obesity-induced muscle protection can be mimicked in lean septic mice by increased lipid availability. Lastly, we aimed to investigate (4) whether the observed muscle protection is mediated by ketone bodies that either function as alternative energy substrates or as signaling molecules.
Methods
Animal study design
Male, 24-week-old mice were anesthetized and a catheter was placed in the central jugular vein, followed by cecal ligation and puncture to induce sepsis [
33,
34]. Unless indicated, 57BL/6JRj mice (Janvier SAS, Chassal, France) were used. After surgery, mice were fasted and received intravenous fluid resuscitation for 20 h. Fasting was done to mimic the clinical setting in which PN is initially withheld. From day 1 onward, mice received standard mixed PN (5.8 kcal/day; Olimel N7E, Baxter, Lessines, Belgium) unless indicated. Throughout the study, mice were given antibiotics and pain medication. Pain/discomfort was assessed twice daily based on the Mouse Grimace Score [
35], and cumulative illness scores were calculated to assess the severity of illness. Individually caged healthy mice receiving standard chow at the same daily caloric intake as septic mice (pair-fed) were used as controls.
Study 1 - Fatty acid mobilization and metabolism in lean and overweight/obese septic mice (n=117)
After 12 weeks on standard chow (10% fat, E15745-04, ssniff, Soest, Germany) or a high-fat diet (45% fat, E15744-34, ssniff), lean and overweight/obese mice were randomized to “healthy control” or “sepsis”. They were sacrificed after either 1 or 5 days [day 1: lean healthy control n=15, obese healthy control n=10, lean sepsis n=15, obese sepsis n=15; day 5: lean healthy control n=17, obese healthy control n=15, lean sepsis n=15, obese sepsis n=15].
Study 2 – Effect of blocking fatty acid mobilization in overweight/obese septic mice on muscle wasting and weakness (n=73)
Adipose triglyceride lipase (ATGL)-flox mice were bred to Adipoq-Cre-mice to generate adipose tissue-specific ATGL knockout (AAKO; ATGL
flox/flox Cre/+) and wild-type (ATGL
flox/flox +/+) mice (Additional file
5). After 12 weeks on a high-fat diet, overweight/obese AAKO and wild-type mice were randomized to “healthy control” or “sepsis” and sacrificed after 5 days [wild-type healthy control
n=19, AAKO healthy control
n=18, wild-type sepsis
n=19, AAKO sepsis
n=17].
Study 3 – Effect of increased lipid availability on muscle wasting and weakness in lean septic mice (n=70)
From day 1 of sepsis onward, lean septic mice randomly received isocaloric amounts of either standard mixed PN (Olimel N7E: 35% lipids, 49% glucose and 16% amino acids), or a lipid-rich PN consisting of mainly long- and medium-chain triglycerides (5.8 kcal/day obtained from: 90% lipids (Smoflipid® Lipid Injectable Emulsion, Fresenius Kabi, Schelle, Belgium, containing 30% soybean oil, 30% medium-chain triglycerides, 15% fish oil and 25% olive oil) and 10% glucose). Mice were sacrificed after 5 days [healthy control n=24, sepsis receiving PN n=23, sepsis receiving lipid-rich PN n=23].
Study 4 – Effect of increased ketone body availability on muscle wasting and weakness in lean septic mice (n=49)
From day 1 of sepsis onward, lean septic mice received standard mixed PN supplemented with twice-daily subcutaneous bolus injections of isocaloric and isovolumetric amounts of either D-glucose (6.25 mg/g/day; PN+gluc) or D,L-3-HB sodium salt (5 mg/g/day; PN+3-HB). Mice were sacrificed after 5 days [healthy control n=15, sepsis PN+gluc n=17, sepsis PN+3-HB n=17].
All animals were treated according to the Principles of Laboratory Animal Care (U.S. national Society for Medical Research) and the Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals (National Institutes of Health). The Institutional Ethical Committee for Animal Experimentation of the KU Leuven had approved the protocols for these animal studies (project numbers P50/2015 and P009/2016). Mice in study 1 were sacrificed after 1 or 5 days, to assess both the acute and prolonged lipolytic response to sepsis (plasma and ex vivo glycerol) [
36,
37]. Mice in study 2-4 were sacrificed after 5 days, the timeframe required to develop sepsis-induced muscle weakness [
15]. Assessment of muscle weakness by ex vivo muscle force measurements was the primary endpoint of these studies. Data on survival are provided in Table
1. Additional information is provided in Additional file
7.
Table 1
Survival until day 5 of septic mice in the different mouse cohorts
Study 1: Fatty acid mobilization and metabolism in lean and obese septic mice | Lean | 15/18 (83) | 1.0 |
Obese | 15/18 (83) |
Study 2: Effect of blocking fatty acid mobilization in obese septic mice on the muscle | Wild-type | 19/22 (86) | 0.1 |
AAKO | 17/25 (68) |
Study 3: Effect of increased lipid availability on the muscle in lean septic mice | PN | 23/25 (92) | 0.8 |
Lipid PN | 23/26 (88) |
Study 4: Effect of increased ketone body availability on the muscle in lean septic mice | PN+gluc | 17/20 (85) | 0.8 |
PN+3-HB | 17/21 (81) |
Ex vivo muscle force
Directly after euthanasia, the extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscle was carefully dissected and suspended in a temperature controlled (30 °C) organ bath filled with HEPES-fortified Krebs-Ringer solution to measure muscle force (300C-LR Dual-Mode muscle lever, Aurora Scientific, Ontario, Canada). The small size of the EDL guaranteed proper diffusion of oxygen during the procedure. Maximal isometric tetanic force of the EDL muscle was measured by averaging three consecutive tetanic stimuli (180 Hz stimulation frequency, 200 ms duration, 0.2 ms pulse width, 2 min rest intervals). Specific maximal isometric tetanic force was calculated by dividing the maximal isometric tetanic force with the muscle cross-sectional area. Additional information is provided in Additional file
7.
Tissue analyses
For practical reasons, tibialis anterior (TA) muscle was used for histology and muscle mass assessment, whereas the larger gastrocnemius muscle was homogenized and used for gene, protein, and metabolite analyses.
Tissue composition
To eliminate potential bias from illness- or resuscitation-related changes in fluid content, dry weight of isolated tissues was obtained by a freeze-drying process. Triglyceride and glycogen content was measured with commercially available kits (triglyceride quantification kit Ab65336, glycogen assay kit Ab65620, Abcam, Cambridge, UK).
Lipolysis
Glycerol release was assessed in epididymal adipose tissue explants with a commercially available kit (Glycerol Assay Kit MAK117, Sigma-Aldrich, Saint Louis, MO, USA).
Gene expression
Messenger RNA was isolated, and cDNA was quantified in real time as previously documented [
38]. Commercial TaqMan® assays (Applied Biosystems, Carlsbad, CA, USA) were used for all gene expression analyses (Additional file
6: Table S1). Data were normalized to
Rn18s or
Hprt and expressed as fold change of the mean of controls.
Protein expression analyses
Protein isolation was executed as previously described [
39]. Immunoblotting was performed with primary antibodies (Additional files
1,
2,
3,
4,
5, and
6) and secondary horseradish peroxidase-conjugated antibodies. Blots were visualized with the G:BOX Chemi XRQ (SynGene, Bangalore, India) and analyzed with SynGene software. Data were normalized to β-actin levels and expressed as fold change of the mean of controls.
Histology
Cross-sectional paraffin sections of TA muscle were stained with a monoclonal antibody against PAX7 (1/100, Mab1675, R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN, USA, RRID:AB_2159833) and a HRP-linked secondary antibody (Additional files
1,
2,
3,
4,
5, and
6). Histological scoring of liver steatosis was performed on hematoxylin and eosin-stained liver sections.
Palmitate oxidation
Oxidation of [1-
14C]-labeled fatty acids was measured in tissue homogenates using a HEPES-fortified modified Krebs-Henseleit buffer [
40]. Oxidation rates are expressed as nmol produced [
14C]CO
2 and [
14C]-labeled acid-soluble metabolites per gram wet weight per minute. Additional information is provided in Additional file
7.
Plasma analyses
Plasma glucose concentrations were measured in whole blood with a glucose meter after cardiac puncture (Accu-check, Roche, Basel, Switzerland). Plasma glycerol, TNF-α, LDL, HDL, triglycerides, free fatty acids, insulin, and 3-HB were measured using commercially available kits: Glycerol Assay Kit (MAK117, Sigma-Aldrich), Mouse TNF-alpha Quantikine HS ELISA Kit (MHSTA50; R&D Systems), LDL-Cholesterol assay (DZ128A-K; Diazyme Laboratories, Poway, CA, USA), HDL-Cholesterol assay (DZ129A-K; Diazyme), triglyceride quantification kit (Ab65336; Abcam), Free Fatty Acid Fluorometric Assay Kit (7010310; Cayman Chemical Company, Ann Arbor, MI, USA), Insulin Mouse Ultra Sensitive ELISA (90080, Crystal Chem, Downers Grove, IL, USA), and EnzyChrom™ Ketone Body Assay Kit (EKBD-100; Bioassay Systems, Hayward, CA, USA).
Statistics
Normally distributed data were compared with one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with post hoc Fisher’s LSD test (Student’s t test) for multiple comparisons, where necessary, after log- or (double) square root-transformation to obtain a near-normal distribution (JMP® Pro 12, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). Not-normally distributed data were analyzed with non-parametric Wilcoxon tests. Two-sided p values ≤ 0.05 (α-level of 5%) were considered statistically significant in all analyses. Data are presented as bars with whiskers, showing means and standard error of the mean (SEM). Post hoc p values are plotted on the figures as § p ≤ 0.05, §§ p ≤ 0.01, §§§ p ≤ 0.001, between septic and healthy control mice, and * p ≤ 0.05, ** p ≤ 0.01, *** p ≤ 0.001 between groups of septic mice.
Discussion
We here showed that overweight/obese septic mice had more pronounced lipolysis, peripheral fatty acid oxidation, and ketogenesis than did lean mice. Blocking lipolysis abolished the overweight/obesity-induced protection of the muscle, whereas high intravenous doses of lipids attenuated muscle weakness in lean septic mice. Although this nutritional strategy enhanced fatty acid oxidation and ketogenesis, it also caused adverse liver steatosis and a deranged lipid profile. Ketone body supplementation to PN in lean septic mice also attenuated muscle weakness and improved muscle regeneration without such adverse effects.
Critical illness in lean patients is characterized by impaired ketogenesis and reduced hepatic and muscular fatty acid metabolism [
41‐
43]. Remarkably, overweight/obese septic mice did not display such impairment but maintained the typical metabolic profile present with diet-induced obesity (enhanced lipolysis and elevated hepatic fatty acid metabolism) [
16‐
20,
22,
23]. Furthermore, this obesity-induced enhanced lipolysis appears crucial during sepsis. Indeed, blocking lipolysis in overweight/obese septic mice profoundly aggravated muscle wasting and weakness. Also in healthy non-obese mice, insufficient availability of adipose tissue-derived fatty acids via AAKO caused reduced exercise performance [
44]. This demonstrates an important role of lipid availability for normal muscle function.
With these four consecutive animal studies, we have identified the mechanisms underlying the protection against sepsis-induced muscle wasting and weakness in overweight/obese mice. Whether a similar mechanism holds true for human patients requires further investigation. We previously demonstrated that after 1 week of critical illness, overweight/obese patients showed better preservation of myofiber size and suffered less from ICU-acquired weakness [
15]. A small pilot feasibility study did confirm larger initial muscle depth in obese critically ill patients but failed to demonstrate a difference over time [
45]. In general, the potential benefit of overweight/obesity in critically ill patients has mainly been investigated in relation to mortality. Better ICU survival has been observed in overweight/obese patients compared to those who are underweight, have a normal weight, or are morbidly obese [
46‐
49]. As ICU-acquired weakness is an independent risk factor for death in the ICU [
2,
50], the overweight/obesity-induced protection of the muscle may, to a certain extent, contribute to the observed survival benefit.
Both premorbid overweight/obesity and treatment with high lipid doses enhanced ketogenesis and resulted in elevated plasma 3-HB concentrations. Furthermore, 3-HB supplementation to PN in lean ill septic mice could mimic the protective effect of giving high lipid doses and of overweight/obesity on muscle weakness. This suggests that ketogenesis is key in protecting against sepsis-induced muscle weakness. In line with our findings, exogenous supplementation of ketone bodies has been shown to improve physical endurance performance in both rats and elite athletes [
25,
51]. In contrast, other supplementation studies did not show enhanced physical performances in trained men [
52‐
54].
Neither the supplementation of PN with 3-HB nor the infusion of high lipid doses in lean septic mice could replicate the observed overweight/obesity-induced protection against muscle wasting [
15]. This suggests that the preservation of muscle mass in the overweight/obese is likely related to other pathways. Possibly, the adipokine leptin could be implicated. Indeed, leptin has been shown to increase muscle mass and to reduce muscle atrophy [
55‐
57]. Leptin concentrations also strongly correlate with adiposity, resulting in higher concentrations in obesity [
58]. Of note, in other neuromuscular disorders such as cancer cachexia, increasing plasma ketone body concentrations did have an effect on muscle mass [
24,
59]. Furthermore, 3-HB infusion decreased whole-body phenylalanine-to-tyrosine degradation in LPS-induced inflammation in humans, but had no beneficial effect on protein metabolism in septic patients [
60,
61]. Hence, the exact effect of 3-HB on muscle mass in critically ill patients should also be further investigated.
Nevertheless, the observation that PN+3-HB during sepsis directly reduced muscle weakness has clear clinical potential. Whereas a beneficial effect on muscle force was also observed with high lipid doses, the observed side effects limit the therapeutic potential of this type of nutrition. Furthermore, the skeletal muscle appears to be bio-energetically inert for delivered lipids during chronic critical illness [
43]. This observation further argues for a direct effect of ketones on muscle weakness, rather than of increased lipid availability.
The muscle protection of PN+3-HB during sepsis does not appear to be related to its use as an energy substrate, but rather by its effects as a signaling molecule [
28,
29,
62]. In contrast to cerebral or active muscle 3-HB uptake and oxidation, 3-HB uptake in the resting skeletal muscle of healthy individuals displays saturation kinetics [
63]. This may explain why supplemented ketones appeared to function as signaling molecules rather than energy substrates in our sick mice. Indeed, 3-HB clearly increased markers of early muscle regeneration and decreased the expression of class IIa HDACs. These deacetylases are known suppressors of the regeneration pathway through suppression of MEF2 [
64‐
67]. Further research is needed to evaluate a direct link between improved muscle regeneration and muscle function by 3-HB. It is also unclear whether 3-HB supplementation of PN in lean septic mice does not only prevent but also restore muscle function when weakness is present. Given that muscle regeneration is impaired in the human critically ill and hampers longer-term recovery [
12], the observed effect of 3-HB on muscle regeneration may hold great promise also for optimizing longer-term recovery of patients.
An important limitation of our study is the use of a mouse model to study ICU-acquired weakness. Hence, translation to the human patient should be done with caution, given several species-specific differences [
68]. Nevertheless, the model of sepsis-induced muscle wasting and weakness resembles human ICU-acquired weakness. The septic mice were also fluid-resuscitated and received antibiotics, analgesia, and nutritional support. However, they were not mechanically ventilated nor did they receive other routinely used pharmacological agents that may contribute to the development of ICU-acquired weakness in patients [
4]. Second, for certain pathways, we could rely on gene expression data alone, which might not always be reflected in protein changes as well. Third, we did not assess whether specific macronutrients of the standard PN played either a synergistic or antagonistic role in the observed protection with 3-HB supplementation. Indeed, it was demonstrated earlier that early provision of PN worsened weakness and slowed down recovery [
9,
69,
70], which was largely attributable to the administered proteins [
71,
72].
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.